From information, knowledge Paragon Economics, Inc. Steve R. Meyer, Ph.D. Paragon Economics, Inc. PPIC/RAC – Spring 2011 Wholesale Pork Cuts - Mandatory Price Reporting
From information, knowledge Paragon Economics, Inc. Why, How, What, etc Only 3-5% of pork is reported – cutout? MPR for pork was added when MPR was reauthorized in 2010 Language required Negotiated Rulemaking -Not often used by USDA -Involves affected parties in writing the Proposed Rule Committee representing various groups -12 members including NPPC, AMI, NAMP, GMA and FMI
From information, knowledge Paragon Economics, Inc. Process so far 2 meetings to date – Last one scheduled for May Cooperation has been good and consensus has been reached on several items Some key items remain, including -FOB plant vs. FOB Omaha -Transition period during which both voluntary and mandatory run -Offal/variety meats
From information, knowledge Paragon Economics, Inc. Pork MPR Ground Rules Packers report ALL sales of “wholesale pork” Packer: 100,000 head or more/year Not everything “reported” to USDA will be “published” by USDA in a report – wording Confidentiality rules (3/70/20) will apply since reporting is mandatory
From information, knowledge Paragon Economics, Inc. Current wholesale pork definition " Fresh and frozen primals, sub-primals, cuts fabricated from sub-primals, pork trimmings, pork for processing, pork offal, and variety meats, excluding portion- control cuts, flavored, tray pack, cured, smoked, cooked, ground and diced pork products” Some questioning of including of “pork offal and variety meats”
From information, knowledge Paragon Economics, Inc. Types of sales and delivery windows 4 categories/windows -Negotiated spot (0-14 boxed, 0-10 combos) -Forward contract (15-90 boxed, combos) -Forward contract (90 days and more) -Formula marketing agreement NOTE – Day 0 is the production day at the plant Packer-packer sales included, intra- company sales are NOT
From information, knowledge Paragon Economics, Inc. Several other items have been agreed to Fresh vs. distressed vs. frozen Domestic, NAFTA, non-NAFTA A brand does not exclude a product from negotiated spot or put in a separate spec Any marketing funds will be deducted Brokerage fees are a sales expense and will not be deducted Specialty products Enhanced product
From information, knowledge Paragon Economics, Inc. Big Issue 1: FOB Omaha vs. FOB Plant USDA opposes FOB Omaha -Does not want to adjust prices -Uses current beef system as an example Overwhelming majority of the committee supports FOB Omaha -Current prices are FOB Omaha -More price stability – removes transport Going to FOB Plant will make 2 BIG shifts -Voluntary to mandatory – include all cuts -FOB Omaha to FOB Plant
From information, knowledge Paragon Economics, Inc. Big Issue 2: Transition/overlap period Almost unanimous support for 12 months Mandatory running behind the scenes as a “beta” test -Work out any bugs (remember beef?) -Build 12 months of data to compare PROVIDES RELATIONSHIPS TO ADJUST PRICING AGREEMENTS TO MANDATORY USDA seems resistant – cost is an issue Letter to Craig Morris – not signed by FMI