Teaching Procedural Skills UCSF Faculty Development Workshop January 21, 2014 Diane Sliwka, MD Kirsten Greene, MD Darren Fiore, MD.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Providing Effective Feedback

Advertisements

Feedback in Clinical Skills Session in Pre-clinical Years Dr. Steve Martin Island Medical Program.

Providing Performance Feedback to Trainees Mary M. Moran, MD Associate Dean for Faculty Affairs & Professional Development.

Objectives Explain the purpose of the RIME feedback method.

Teaching Strategies Gold

Meeting the needs of all learners.  Is differentiated instruction new? ◦ Think of the one room school house. ◦ Can you remember how your elementary teachers.

Materials and Lesson Planning

Session 5-8. Objectives for the session To revisit general themes and considerations when delivering the intervention. To consider sessions 5-8 and familiarise.

Workplace-based Assessment. Overview Types of assessment Assessment for learning Assessment of learning Purpose of WBA Benefits of WBA Miller’s Pyramid.

Welcome to.. Coaching Classroom Management: District Systems of Support 2013 National PBIS Leadership Forum October 10, 2013 Rosemont, Illinois Susan Gasber,

People skills Having people skills is a key requirement in most organisations today. You cannot choose your colleagues.

Instructional Methods Secondary Learners. Factors that limit the extent of acquisition of secondary curriculum  Information and skills acquired at a.

Clinical Teaching Tricks and Tips Julie Story Byerley, MD, MPH.

UCD School of Medicine “Criterion Based” vs. “Norm-Based” Evaluation David L Gaspar MD October 18, 2008.

DED 101 Educational Psychology, Guidance And Counseling

You watch one of your interns go in to interview and examine the patient. The patient is having difficulty understanding the questions that the intern.

7/14/20151 Effective Teaching and Evaluation The Pathwise System By David M. Agnew Associate Professor Agricultural Education.

Lesson planning? It can’t be that difficult! Svetla Tashevska, NBU.

Delegation: An Art of Professional Practice

Hannah Guldin Chrystol White Aimee Kanemori.  Form an alliance between the teacher and parent “Above all parents need to know that their child’s teacher.

Assignment Thank you for participating in the On-Line Learning Mastery Series. The knowledge you gain and the application of the skills you’ve acquired.

Holland Central School District New Teacher Mentoring Program Introduction.

Last time, we asked you to... Bring an ‘live’ issue or concern for which you would like some coaching! Could also be an issue sensitively presented in.

Teaching Tip Series Day One: The First Meeting with a Student.

Dealing with Professionalism Lapses: Beyond “he said, she said” Catherine Lucey MD UCSF December 18, 2012.

Retention. Numbers that Matter 3476= total number of women enrolled at least 95% retention at each visit, at each study site 100% attention to data quality,

Motivation Dr. K. A. Korb University of Jos. Overview Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Overview of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation – Behavioral Approach.

Thinking Actively in a Social Context T A S C.

Guidelines for Developing Lesson Plans EX

1 Rachel Yudkowsky MD MHPE Simulation for Patient Safety Slideset 2 Designing instructional programs with simulation.

Preventing behavior problems Rules – did you cover everything? Consequences – did you ever talk to the student? Include the parents? Communicating rules.

THE ACADEMIC DEMANDS OF COLLEGE REQUIRES THAT STUDENTS CHANGE HOW THEY LEARN. SUCCESS ON COLLEGE TESTS REQUIRES THAT STUDENTS LEARN FROM TESTS, SO THEY.

Objectives understand the feedback process and its’ importance to learning understand the feedback process and its’ importance to learning know factors.

Welcome Back O.

Conducting Scenario-based Simulations Sandrijn van Schaik, MD PhD Jenna Shaw-Batista, CNM PhD Cynthia Belew, CNM MS UCSF Center for Faculty Educators &

Planning and Designing Scenario-based Simulations

@sparqs_scotland Course Rep Training name of trainer associate trainer | sparqs.

1 Reading Assessments. 2 EAs often assist with student assessments by conducting ______________________ assessments of language skills.

Spectrum of styles Based on who makes decisions  Pre-impact: who makes decisions about the content preparation  Impact: who makes decisions about the.

School Connectedness: Obstacles and Solutions (Willmar Workshop) Robert Wm. Blum, MD, MPH, PhD William H. Gates Sr. Professor and Chair Population, Family.

English Only. What is English Only A style of immersion In the Korean Context All classroom instruction takes place in English All response takes place.

Planning for Equity Laura Maly Astrid Fossum Lee Ann Pruske Cynthia Cuellar Rodriguez Math Teacher Leader Training January 2011.

Patient Education. Educational Domains Cognitive: information area (teaching joint protection principles to patient with Rheumatoid Arthritis Psychomotor:

Slide B-1 Case 1 You have just received surprising information that requires your group to take a new approach right away. You know the group members are.

Giving and Receiving Constructive Feedback

Practical Coach Discussion Session #60. Learning Objectives To understand the value of coaching in a manager’s work To learn how to determine when to.

The qualities of an effective teacher presented by Grema Malam Mamadou—MA in education: Curriculum and Instruction—ELT advisor.

IST_Seminar II CHAPTER 12 Instructional Methods. Objectives: Students will: Explain the role of all teachers in the development of critical thinking skills.

Promoting Quality Care Dr. Gwen Hollaar. Introduction We all want quality in health care –Communities –Patients –Health Care Workers –Managers –MOH /

Improving Medical Education Skills. Many Family Medicine graduates teach… D6 students New doctors who do not have post-graduate training Other healthcare.

Delivering Effective Feedback A Faculty Development Program for Teachers of International Medical Graduates.

Differentiating Your Instruction Through Guided Reading.

Marking and Feedback CPD Student approach to marking.

Educational Outcomes Service Group: Overview of Year One Lynne Tomasa, PhD May 15, 2003.

School of something FACULTY OF OTHER Leeds Institute of Medical Education School of Medicine Mentoring for Teaching Support Workshop at Supporting Medical.

Teaching Strategies and Teaching Styles. Introduction How can we keep or more children motivated to become and remain involved in practice that.

C. Jessica Dine, MD MSHPR ASH Training Program Directors’ Workshop December 4, 2015 Diagnosing errors in communication when designing remediation plans.

IDENTIFICATION, DIAGNOSIS & REMEDIATION OF THE STRUGGLING LEARNER Jeannette Guerrasio, MD University of Colorado, SOM Chris Knight, MD University of Washington,

AISI October 27, Essential Questions: What does it mean to be an AISI teacher leader? What does “leading” mean? What is critical thinking?

Curriculum Development: an Overview of 6 Steps MAJ Heather O’Mara, DO, FAAFP Faculty Development Fellow.

Using the ARCH Feedback Model to Facilitate Teacher-Learner Collaboration and Enhance Self- Regulated Learning Skills A Workshop for the STFM Annual Spring.

FACULTY DEVELOPMENT FOR CLINICAL EDUCATORS FEEDBACK SKILLS FOR THE CLINICAL ENVIRONMENT 1 FEEDBACK SKILLS FOR THE CLINICAL ENVIRONMENT.

Adapted from PPT developed by Jhpiego corporation

Workshop for ART mentors

Scaffolding Children’s Learning Differentiate Levels of Support

Planning and Designing Scenario-based Simulations

Effective Techniques and Strategies

Workshop for LME Residents

Adult Learning and Training

Instructional Plan and Presentation Cindy Douglas Cur/516: Curriculum Theory and Instructional Design November 7, 2016 Professor Gary Weiss.

Presentation transcript:

Teaching Procedural Skills UCSF Faculty Development Workshop January 21, 2014 Diane Sliwka, MD Kirsten Greene, MD Darren Fiore, MD

Workshop Objectives Develop a process for teaching a procedure. Describe how the theory of deliberate practice guides the steps for teaching a procedure. Practice providing feedback that will enhance performance. Analyze obstacles to the teaching of procedures.

Small Group Activity 1 Goal: How would you teach someone to make an easy origami heart (procedure)? -4 groups -Practice making a heart -Identify steps for teaching a procedure -Present steps to large group heart.html

Deliberate Practice All practice is not equal Practice makes permanent Deliberate practice makes perfect Unproductive (mindless) practice vs. Deliberate (mindful) practice

Deliberate Practice K. Anders Ericsson Expertise: more to do with how one practices than with performing a skill many times Repetitive, goal-directed practice Targeted feedback Reflection on performance

Practice Observed Performance Targeted Feedback Goals LEADS TO ALLOWS FOR GUIDES FURTHER DIRECT HELP US EVALUATE SHAPE

Framework for Teaching A Procedure Identify a skill Know your learner Define specific goals Devise an exercise Practice the skill Provide feedback Problem Identification Needs Assessment Goals and Objectives Educational Strategies Implementation Evaluation

Steps of Procedural Teaching Preparation Task analysis Conceptualization Visualization Verbalization Guided deliberate practice with feedback

Small Group Activity 2 Goal: Learn and teach a complex origami heart (procedure). -2 groups practice blossom heart -2 groups practice beating heart -Work in pairs to teach each other your heart -Self-assessment of teaching heart.html

Feedback

Be respectful and sensitive Be specific Temporally close to event Optimal Losada ratio reinforcing: corrective 5.6:1

ARTful Feedback Ask Respond Tell

Feedback What do you think you would like to KEEP doing? (reinforce) What do you think you would like to STOP doing? (correct) What do you think you would like to START doing? (next steps)

Feedback What did you do well? What do you think did not go well? What do you want to work on next time?

What is hard about teaching procedures?

Patience Give the learner a set period of TIME Give the learner a set number of TRIALS Give the learner a set number of STEPS

Communication Give clear directions Don’t scare the patient Don’t scare the learner Use similes, think creatively about how to describe things

Safety Do not teach a procedure you can’t do yourself Do not let the learner get into trouble you can’t bail them out of Choose the correct level of learner for your OWN experience level Choose the correct patient for your OWN experience level

Challenging Scenario 1 Chris is a surgery intern who has been having a hard year. His evaluations haven’t been good on any rotation this year. Faculty report that he is lazy, has poor technical skills, lacks time management, and still can’t prioritize what is important vs. what is trivial. You know that he has gotten a lot of negative feedback this year. He seems demoralized and less responsive when attendings point out errors compared to a few months ago. Today you are supervising him placing a central line. In the past, he has had trouble with this according to your colleagues although you have never worked with him. What is your approach?

Challenging Scenario 2 You are supervising a resident doing a lumbar puncture for his 3 rd time. He has been attempting to get the LP for ~20 minutes, and has not been successful despite your attempts to give suggestions. The patient is awake and is becoming increasingly anxious, expressing concerns about how long the procedure is taking. The patient asks whether the resident knows what he’s doing. What do you do as the supervising physician?

Challenging Scenario 3 A new nurse has been training for about 4 weeks to place PICC lines. Her teacher is an experienced PICC nurse. The trainee observed her teacher for a week and has had supervised practice for 3 weeks. She has been successful nearly 80% of the time, but doesn’t know why she’s not yet at 100%. She seems to find and access the vein easily, but sometimes has difficulty using a guide wire and manipulating the equipment. How might her teacher approach this situation?

Summary Teaching a procedure takes time and involves helping learner: prepare, analyze the task, understand, observe, verbalize the steps, then practice with feedback. Deliberate practice is repetitive and goal- directed with targeted feedback and reflection. Procedural teaching parallels the steps of curriculum development. Feedback is critical to improve performance.