3. Hegemony in practice? Despite Vichy’s intention to break with the Republican precedent, the everyday reality during the Occupation was far more complex.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
PHILOSOPHY AND IDEOLOGY Dr Nash Popovic
Advertisements

The Great Globalization Debate PS 314 Spring 2006.
Critical Theory: Other Perspectives Michel Foucault “It’s not a matter of emancipating truth from every system of power (which would be a chimera, for.
Socialism, Communism, Fascism. Let’s Review… Liberalism was a reaction to feudal society, involving:  focus on the individual, idea of responsible gov’t,
Marxist theories of International relations
The Goals of Social Research
The Need For Theory in Children’s Studies. Nothing Is As Simple As It Appears From here there is no turning back…
Sociology: Chapter 1 Section 1
Neorealist Assumptions
Fundamentals of Political Science
Marxism The ideology of marxism and how it can be applied to the way we „read“ texts.
Intercultural Market Communication (English) Brief introduction to academic writing 5th semester, BA-SIV.
Fr. Karl Marx’s The German Ideology (also Friedrich Engels)
Marxism and Inequality
overview of the “Introduction” from Film Analysis,
Writing level 3 essays An initial guide. Key principles The key principles of essay writing still apply: Understanding the topic Plan your response Structure.
Tuesday 26 th January 9am Sports Hall. Marxism  Blockbusters Blockbusters  Try to write a paragraph summarising the key aspects of the functionalist.
Chapter 1: Understanding Psychology’s History Chapter 1: Understanding Psychology’s History.
Instructor: D. Roberts. All notes and important information is posted on my wikispace. Please use this site as much as possible: devinroberts.wikispaces.com.
The Sociological Perspective
Marxist Media Theory by Gabor Bohus Course: American Media Today
Reaction and Reform: New Economic Theories
Money, Sex and Power Week 12
THE ARGUMENTATIVE (SYNTHESIS) ESSAY A QUICK GUIDE.
OUTLINE Conditions: Problem(s) we face, relevance of Marxism Marx & Engels: particularly drawing from Theses on Feuerbach, Anti- Duhring, Dialectics of.
Objectivity & Subjectivity
What is Popular Culture?. What is Culture? Raymond Williams (1983) Culture refers to: ◦ “A general process of intellectual, spiritual and aesthetic development”
IR 501 Lecture Notes Marxist theories of IR
CHAPTER ONE THEORY IN SOCIAL WORK PRACTICE The Practice of Generalist Social Work (2 nd ed.)
Traduzione e Ideologia nella comunicazione internazionale Prof. Elena Di Giovanni Corso di Laurea Magistrale in Lingue Moderne per la Comunicazione e Cooperazione.
+ INTRODUCTION TO VCE ART UNIT 2 COURSE BREAKDOWN.
Cultivation Analysis. 1. In 1973, George Gerbner embarked on the Cultural Index Project, conducting regular, periodic examinations of television programming.
Conservative force or initiator of social change? L.O.: Understand that religion has a role in society. It can maintain traditional norms or it can be.
Paper III Qualitative research methodology. Objective 1.3 To what extent can findings be generalized from qualitative studies.
Media and Ideology. What do we mean by ideology in common parlance?
Chapter 6 Lecture/Recap ORGANIZATIONAL THEORY – PART 4.
Chapter Four An Early Communication Theory. General Semantics “The map is not the territory.”
Chapter Five Critical Perspectives on Theory Development Copyright © 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display.
Christopher Hill: Marxist Historian. Background British historian who examined the history of the 17 th C. Born to a middle class Methodist family in.
Some Issues to Consider in thinking about Causes and Explanations.
Presented by : Mrs. Arundhati Dutta Choudhury Asstt. Professor, Department of English Radhamadhab College Silchar
Chapter 4 The Idea of Culture Key Terms. Symbol Something that stands for something else; central to culture. Adaptation Ways that populations relate.
Cultural Hegemony. Antonio Gramsci Like Althusser, he thought ideology was not so directly related to economics but a human process Devised term Hegemony.
Writing a Historical Essay: The Thesis and Introduction A
Cultural Marxism The Theory of Hegemony.
Dr. Meghann Meeusen University of Tennessee at Chattanooga INTRODUCTION TO IDEOLOGY AND BINARIES.
Lecture 1/Term 3: Postmodernity/Postmodernism Dr Claudia Stein.
Broadcasting: Concepts and Contexts Ideology, Discourse, Hegemony and Representation.
In your notebooks: 1.) Write down the following names: 1. Auguste Comte 2. Harriet Martineau 3. Herbert Spencer 4. Emile Durkeim 5. Max Weber 6. Karl Marx.
Some Philosophical Orientations of Educational Research You Do What You Think, I Think.
Authoritarian and Single Party States Introduction.
Academic Writing Fatima AlShaikh. A duty that you are assigned to perform or a task that is assigned or undertaken. For example: Research papers (most.
Representation Ryan, Gemma and Phil. Karl Marx and his ideas “The oppressed are allowed once every few years to decide which particular representatives.
A POST-IDEOLOGICAL AGE?. Endism: An end to ideology? Following the consensus of political thought in the 1950s and 60s, particularly the consensus on.
Representation.
An unequal contest: A comparison of Geertz’ and Roseberry’s analyses of the Balinese Cockfight Susan Vincent My hypothetical paper is based on a comparison.
Key Media theory A2 MEST 3 revision.
Structural theories – conflict theory
Chapter 5: Political Parties Section 1
Sociological Analysis of Culture
Introduction to Asian American Studies
Learning Objective To understand theories associated with the representation by the media.
The study of Modernity: What is the world like TODAY?
The Great Globalization Debate
Marx and Louis Althusser
Media and Collective Identity – Young People
Command terms with definitions.
Marx, Althusser, Gramsci
The study of Modernity: What is the world like TODAY?
Presentation transcript:

3. Hegemony in practice? Despite Vichy’s intention to break with the Republican precedent, the everyday reality during the Occupation was far more complex. Antonio Gramsci’s concept of hegemony can, I argued, be usefully applied to Vichy ideology. Gramsci wrote that in order for hegemony to be successful, ‘account [should] be taken of the be taken of the interests and tendencies of the groups over which hegemony is to be exercised. ’ (Gramsci: 1971) In fact, Vichy did just that. Two important Republican cultural reference points were retained by Vichy for the duration of the Occupation: the Marseillaise and the tricolore. Context This poster is a synopsis of the first chapter of my thesis and outlines some of the central arguments of my doctoral research. In the chapter, I examined how our understanding of ideology has been shaped by theorists, including Marx and Engels, Antonio Gramsci and Louis Althusser. I also investigated how these theories of ideology can be applied to the history of ideology under the Vichy regime. The ideology of the Vichy regime : a history of compromise and adaptation David Lees Supervisors: Professor Nick Hewlett and Dr Jessica Wardhaugh R. Vachet, BDIC AFF (1) This is one of the clearest examples of how Vichy envisioned its ideology as a clean break with the Republican tradition. The two houses depict the Republic (left) and Vichy (right). 1. Ideology: A working definition Before looking closely at the history of ideology during the Occupation, it is important to discuss what the term actually means. There is no over-arching or widely-accepted definition of ideology, so for the purposes of this thesis, ideology refers to: ‘A set of ideas, beliefs, opinions and values. A body of concepts that help to legitimate a dominant power.’ 2. A new ideology? Vichy replaced the values of the Republic–liberté, égalité, fraternité–with travail, famille, patrie, as the regime aimed to create a distinct set of guiding principles and beliefs. Philippe Pétain was revered as the Head of the French State and this extreme devotion, or Pétainisme, was at the forefront of the National Revolution. In effacing the values of the Republic and through its emphasis on exclusion of the ‘anti-France’–Jews, Freemasons and Communists–from French society, Vichy signalled its intention to break with the Republican tradition. Theories of ideology can, I found, be usefully applied to the history of ideology under the Vichy regime. Although there was widespread support for the reform of the Third Republic, Vichy successfully garnered consent through adopting Republican symbols. However, I suggested that the complexities of Vichyisme, or Vichy ideology, mean that it cannot be described as a ‘typical’ ideology. Rather, Vichyisme had numerous competing influences. Unlike ‘macro’ ideologies, like Communism or Socialism, Vichyisme had limited aims beyond France. I argued, finally, that one of the few unifying elements to Vichyisme was its opposition to the Republican tradition. It is thus ironic that the regime retained references to the ideology of the Republic. E. Castel, BDIC AFF 30183(4) This image shows the extent to which Vichy aimed to claim the tricolore for itself. The slogan suggests that the regime saw the flag as a unifying symbol. Key questions Can we apply theories of ideology to the Occupation years? How is Gramsci’s concept of hegemony relevant to Vichy ideology? Was the regime’s ideology ever representative of a clean break with the Republican tradition? Conclusions: a typical ideology?