Perceptions of the teaching of Pathology amongst Medical Students: A comparison between a Problem-based and Traditional Lecture-based learning Perceptions.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Australian Council of Deans of Information and Communications Technology Annual Council Meeting 23 and 24 July 2009 Swinburne.
Advertisements

C21: Modernising Medical Education in Cardiff Annual Curriculum Away Day Friday 16 th September 2011, All Nations’ Centre Developments so far : the existing.
Medical students’ insight about PBL at Alfaisal University, Riyadh.
Comparison of Osteopathic Medical School Curricula In Teaching Clinical Reasoning Amanda Kocoloski, OMS IV; Gordon Marler, OMS IV; Nicole Wadsworth, D.O.;
The Medical Graduate as Scientist and Scholar: a UK perspective Dr Shelby Webster MBBCh MRCP DipMedEd Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, London Diploma.
National E-learning Survey Among Histopathology ST1 Trainees Ashirwad Merve 1, Nick Griffin 2 1 Royal Liverpool University Hospitals NHS Trust 2 Leeds.
© 2009 NHS National Genetics Education and Development CentreSupporting Genetics Education for Health Developing genetic learning.
R. S. Williams Senior Visiting General Surgeon Modbury Public Hospital Adelaide South Australia.
Australian Medical Education - Is it Good for Our Health? Helen C Beh CEO, Australian Orthopaedic Association Helen C Beh CEO, Australian Orthopaedic Association.
The use of simulation to teach medical students how to recognise and manage a sick child – A cluster randomised trial Results 61 students participated.
Recording Excellence Nicole Duplain School of Humanities.
Curriculum Evaluation Reverend Dr David Taylor Director of Quality Enhancement School of Medical Education University of Liverpool.
Manchester Medical School Clinical Communication in the Undergrad Programme Dr N Barr Co-Lead for Clincial Communication.
“Wardcraft”: Equipping medical students with the procedural knowledge and skills to make them more confident junior doctors Dr Meng Wang (ACF CMT2) and.
Results 1 Introduction In the USA, on-line interactive clinical cases are increasingly being used to support and deliver the undergraduate paediatric curriculum.
The Graduate Medical Program Dr. Chris Roberts and Prof Ann Sefton The Office of Teaching and Learning in Medicine.
Progress in to Medicine Penny Dowell. Selecting a Course.
A PRESCRIBING CURRICULUM FOR AUSTRALIAN MEDICAL STUDENTS Smith AJ, Hill SR,Tasioulas T,Cockayne NL. National Prescribing Service, Sydney & Clinical Pharmacology.
Fitness for Practice: How Can Junior Doctors Ensure They Keep Up To Date? K Knight, R Wright, N Whybra University of Leicester Aim Producing medical students.
Oral pathology in a PBL course Dr Mary Toner School of Dental Science Trinity College, Dublin.
Critical thinking by Students Undertaking a PBL-based Medical Curriculum: What is the Evidence? Dr. Susan Jamieson, Faculty of Medicine.
MEDICAL STUDENTS – POTENTIAL CONTRIBUTORS TO SMOKING CESSATION PROVISION: THE ADDED BENEFITS OF THE ONLINE NCSCT TRAINING King’s Undergraduate Medical.
 This session looks at the effect of real world enterprise projects on graduate employer perceptions  It considers a cross section of the real world.
Skin Week Introduction and General Overview Dr. Mariamma Joseph Course Chair, Professor Dept. of Pathology LHSC, University Campus.
UOW ALTC ICT Grants Philip Ogunbona Dean Faculty of Informatics UOW.
Margaret J. Cox King’s College London
Dr Elena Luchinskaya, Lancaster University/ Leeds Metropolitan University, UK.
Raising quality and safety awareness: Integration of IHI Open School Online Courses in the Nursing Undergraduate Curriculum Eloise Pearson Sandra Hainey.
Welcome to SRFT! Produced by: Elizabeth Stone, Savana Shakir, Thomas Slater, Frances Ugwu.
National Framework for Induction & Introduction to Histopathology (England/Wales) Strand B: Direction and Standardisation of programme for School Leads.
AN EVALUATION OF THE WHO RATIONAL PHARMACOTHERAPY TEACHING PROGRAM The Guide to Good Prescribing (GGP) was first published in 1994, describing a 6-step.
MED 595 Research in Mathematics Education. What you need for this course. You MUST activate your student account. The format is The format for the.
ASSESSMENT OF THE INDEPENDENT STUDY PATHWAY AT LECOM: STUDENT FEEDBACK Mark A.W. Andrews, Ph.D., Professor and Director, The Independent Study Pathway.
NHS Education for Scotland Karen Beggs 1 st July 2009.
NRI Survey on: Cooperation between universities and university hospitals On behalf of NRI: Lars Hvilsted Rasmussen Director of Research Aalborg University.
Design a Fireworks Show! Using Context and Problem Based Learning (CPBL) Dr Gan Shermer Emily M. MacCready.
1 Ideas of Problem-based Learning As a learner-centred process, problem- based learning meets the learners' interests and as such gives room for developing.
Problem-based learning in public health Instruction: a pilot study of an online simulation as a problem-based learning approach Spinello, E., & Fischbach,
Know your audience; the information literacy (IL) levels of medical students arriving at Imperial College London Bethan Adams, 1 Richard Birley, 2 and.
Do Medical Students Understand the Role of a Pathologist? Do Medical Students Understand the Role of a Pathologist? Moreman, C. 1 Shukla, C. 2 Petts, G.
Eliminating Avoidable sight loss and delivering excellent support for people with sight loss Health and Social Care Integration - From Hospital to Community.
Careers in Agriculture By: Dr. Frank Flanders and Jennie Simpson Georgia Agricultural Education Curriculum Office Georgia Department of Education June.
Methods for evaluation of a prescribing curriculum for Australian senior medical students AJ Smith, SR Hill, T Tasioulas, NL Cockayne.
COURSE OR CAREER???? Archana Sharma, Clinical Psychologist.
A survey of Student Engagement SARAH GRETTON DEREK RAINE CENTRE FOR INTERDISCIPLINARY SCIENCE UNIVERSITY OF LEICESTER 1. Background – AUSSE, HEA 2. Our.
Simulated Patients Improve Medical Student Comfort Level with Breaking Bad News and End of Life Issues Skotti Church, MD Carl J Fichtenbaum, MD, FACP University.
Salma Faghri 1, Nitin Aggarwal 1, Kimberly Zeller, MD 1,2, Julie Taylor, MD, MSc 1,2 1 Warren Alpert School of Medicine at Brown University, Providence,
Teaching and Evaluating a Required Course in Career Planning for Psychology Majors b b James H. Thomas b b Cyndi R. McDaniel b b Northern Kentucky University.
WE WANT CHANGE! KEEP YOUR GANG. Anna Kime - Integrated Practice Project Manager Who We Are Russell Gurbutt - Senior Lecturer.
Expanding the Foundation Programme in Psychiatry Michael Maier Head of London Specialty School of Psychiatry.
Undergraduate Students Experiences of Studying Nursing/Midwifery at NUI Galway Evelyn Byrne, Bróna Mooney, Frances Farrelly, Eimear Burke.
+ A Case Study of Teaching Job Interviews in Introductory Public Speaking Chris Cruz-Boone California State University, Bakersfield College to Workplace:
Embedding Careers Education into the Medical Curriculum: An overview of best practice Mike Wilson Health Education England North East Careers Lead Co-Chair.
The Delivery of Pathology Teaching in the Medical Curriculum: How Often are Medical Students Taught and Examined in ‘Pathology’? Petts, G 1. Shukla, C.
Barry Quinn BDS MSc LDS MRD FDS FFD F.H.E.A. Specialist in Periodontics, Endodontics, Prosthodontics and Restorative Dentistry Senior Specialist Clinical.
TUESDAY 19/04/2016 Professional English in Use, Medicine Medical Education 1.
Petra Hanson Tristan Page Associate College Tutors
A novel interdisciplinary model for chronic pain education
Current practice of continence advisors in the UK:
Teaching foundation doctors about tracheostomy management
Title of the Change Project
How ‘work-ready’ do Moulton College final year undergraduates feel?
The future: the full spectrum of simulation
CLICK TO GO BACK TO KIOSK MENU
Raising the profile of Academic General Practice to our medical students Elizabeth I Lamb & Hugh Alberti Introduction General.
Can you bleep the doctor please?
BeTheChange The Problem BeTheChange Results of the scheme Conclusion
Dr S J Lockey Diversity and Drugs Dr S J Lockey
GMC Generic Professional Capabilities framework
GMC Generic Professional Capabilities framework
Presentation transcript:

Perceptions of the teaching of Pathology amongst Medical Students: A comparison between a Problem-based and Traditional Lecture-based learning Perceptions of the teaching of Pathology amongst Medical Students: A comparison between a Problem-based and Traditional Lecture-based learning Shukla, C. 1 Moreman, C. 2 Petts, G. 3 Cossins, S. 1 1 St James University Hospital, Leeds; 2 University Hospitals of Leicester; 3 The Royal London Hospital Conclusions: Pathology underpins the majority of clinical diagnosis and decisions, and as such we feel that it’s understanding (through effective teaching) is paramount to good medical practice. A study by Guy’s, King’s and St Thomas Medical School 1 suggests 1 st year doctors who have completed a new [integrated] final year had greater confidence with clinical skills, but a clear lack of knowledge in pathology and therapeutics 1. Further compounding factors raised by PBL students were the clear lack of provisions for teaching pathology. This undoubtedly having implications in other disciplines for example, in reply to Weedon’s (Ex-president of the Royal College Pathologists, Austalia) article 2 included two from surgeons, who argued that the PBL curricula leads to doctors untrained in ‘the mechanism of disease and understanding physical findings’ There is a slow shift from TLB teaching to a PBL approach, a understanding of Pathology is paramount in the quality of tomorrow's doctors. Pathology teaching arguably IS capable of being delivered to highest quality through other teaching methods but clearly has not, the direct implications of this being a reduced understanding of pathology, reduced understanding of what a Pathologist does and as we are seeing in the UK, a reduced number a applications into Pathology as a career. The reform of undergraduate medical teaching has led to an integrated problem-based learning (PBL) style replacing the traditional lecture-based (TLB or LBT) learning. The Royal College of Pathologists state “the low profile of pathology teaching in the undergraduate medical curriculum has become increasingly damaging to the recruitment of quality UK medical students.” This study evaluated the perceptions of Pathology teaching amongst medical students from both PBL and TLB medical schools. Methods: An on-line survey was sent to medical students from 24 medical schools. They were asked about the quality of Pathology teaching (including what facilities were provided) at their medical schools and their understanding of Pathology. Results: 1126 students from 17 universities responded, with even representation over years 1-5, the data was analysed using the Mann- Whitney-U test. The TLB courses provided far superior teaching facilities – figure 4, compared to PBL, e.g. 63% providing microscopes compared to 11% of PBL courses. Furthermore, 74% (TLB) practiced cadaver dissection compared to only 24% of PBL courses, 34% (TLB) of which had some formal pathology during these sessions compared to only 6% in PBLs – figure 5.. Approximately 75% of students from PBL courses compared to 38% from TLB courses said Pathology teaching was neglected (p<0.001) on their curriculum - figure 1, and only 20% (PBL) versus 52% (TLB) felt they had a good understanding of Pathology (p<0.001) – figure 2. Approximately 10% (PBL) and 17% (TLB) said they were specifically examined on Pathology during their end-of-year/final exams – figure 3. References 1 (Lempp H, Med Teach May;26(3):276-8). 2 (Weedon D, Med J Aus (5): ). Figure 1: Figure 2: Figure 3: Figure 4:Figure 5: