Showing the Value of Procurement: The Sequel
Showing the Value of Procurement: The Sequel
Showing the Value of Procurement: The Sequel
NIGP Research Purpose of Reporting Savings Communicate the Value of Procurement Evaluate Performance Justify Budget
What is Measured? Non-ROI ROI
New Trends in Non-ROI Spend
New Trends in Non-ROI Spend
New Trends in Non-ROI Spend
New Trends in Non-ROI Customer Focus
Showing Value - ROI Competitive Sealed Bidding Competitive Negotiations Revenue-Generating Contracts Other Activities
Budget - 45% Highest Bid - 36% Previous Price - 17% Average Bids - 31% GSA, etc. - 15%
Other Methods IFB Savings Award Price v. Retail or wholesale price Independent estimate Price submitted by requestor Price paid by other governments
Award Price v. Market Price Award Price v. Initial Proposed Price Added Value - i.e. Warranties
Recovery for Non-Performance Negotiating Contract Increases Specs / Scope Review Negotiating Non-Competitive Contracts Negotiating Renewals / Extensions
Recovery for Non-Performance Negotiating Contract Increases Specs / Scope Review Negotiating Non-Competitive Contracts Negotiating Renewals / Extensions
“The CFO’s View of Procurement” Aberdeen Group November 2007
“The CFO’s View of Procurement” Aberdeen Group November 2007
3 Tiers of Savings IDENTIFIED IMPLEMENTED BOOKED
11.9% 9.4% 3.2%
Collaboration Automation Spend data
Collaboration Automation Spend data
> 70% 30-70% < 30%
Best-in-Class - > 70% Industry Average % Laggard - Less than 30%
Best-in-Class Excellent process and Efficiency Superior process innovation aptitude Superior negotiation and contracting skills Superior general business acumen Superior supply market knowledge Strong technology acumen
Best-in-Class Excellent process and Efficiency Superior process innovation aptitude Superior negotiation and contracting skills Superior general business acumen Superior supply market knowledge Strong technology acumen
Top 10 Private Sector Procurement Measures
A Case Study
13 Agreed-Upon Measures 1.Additional Value Received 2.Improved Terms 3.Audit Savings 4.Price Reductions – Contract to Contract 5.Buyer Innovation / New Ideas 6.Price Reductions – Requisition to PO 7.Cost Avoidance – Contract CPI Increases
13 Agreed-Upon Measures 8.Revised Specification Initiatives 9.Elimination of Purchase Requests 10.Revenue Increases 11.Energy Contract Savings 12.Rebates Negotiated and Received 13.Improved Business Processes
$1,170,555
Action Steps