Standards and Certification Training Module B – Process B5AStandards & Certification Project Management

Page © ASME 2013 ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management REVISIONS CHANGEDATE 3/14/13 1 First edition

Page © ASME 2013 Module B Course Outline B1. ASME Organizational Structure B2. Standards Development: Staff and Volunteer Roles and Responsibilities B3.Conformity Assessment: Staff and Volunteer Roles and Responsibilities B4.Initiating and Terminating Standards Projects B5.Consensus Process for Standards Development B5A. Standards & Certification Project Management B6.The Basics of Parliamentary Procedure B7.The Appeals Process B8.International Standards Development B9.ASME Conformity Assessment Programs B10.Performance Based Standards B11. Consensus Process for Standards Interpretation and Code Cases (under development) ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management 2

Page © ASME 2013 Learning Objectives At the end of this module, you will be able to: –Understand the responsibilities of S&C Project Management –Understand the roles and responsibilities of the Project Technical Manager –Learn how to prepare and submit proposals for approval –Understand the various options for the committee approval process ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management 3

Page © ASME 2013 Standards & Certification Project Management Each standards action is assigned to a Project Team The Project Team is appointed by the standards committee. Depending on the committee, a subcommittee or the standards committee itself could act as the Project Team. Project Team Membership: Project Technical Manager; Project Administrative Manager; additional members, as necessary, including those requesting the action Project Team membership is approved by consensus committee Tasks of Project Team are to develop one or more proposals and to consider, and respond to, comments ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management 4

Page © ASME 2013 Responsible for managing the work – setting a schedule, arranging for conferences, consulting with specialists, and working with staff to submit proposal for review and comment or ballot Responsible for moving proposal through multiple levels of balloting with potentially multiple sets of comments for consideration and response by Project Team Should determine which groups will need to approve the item, then develop a plan to move the item through the process Controls the pace the item is moved through the approval process, including timely responses to comments and communication with committee members Learns about committee rules and customs for preparation, submission, and the approval process, which may be more restrictive than those described on the following slides ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management Standards & Certification Project Technical Manager (PTM) 5

Page © ASME 2013 ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management Standards & Certification Proposal Development Revisions to existing standard: relevant existing material should be shown along with a clear indication of what is to be changed. Refer to Guide for Presenting Proposed Revisions New standard or case: the complete document should be included in the proposal. Refer to the C&S Writing and Style Guides 2010 when developing proposed items An explanation describing the rationale behind the proposal may be helpful and should be included as part of the explanation field in the record, in the proposal file or as background material Proposal should contain the C&S Connect record number and revision date in the header 6

Page © ASME 2013 ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management Submitting the Proposal on C&S Connect –Subject should not be more than one sentence that describes the area being addressed by the proposal –Proposal should be not more than one sentence that describes what is being changed –Explanation should be not more than one paragraph explaining why the proposal is being presented. If longer explanation needed, should be referenced and included as part of background material Standards & Certification Proposal Submittal 7

Page © ASME 2013 Submitting the Proposal on C&S Connect, C&S Connect Upload Fields –Proposal File - shall contain most recent (latest) version of proposal/document/revision to be reviewed during the consensus process. –Background Material should contain a file providing background information. –Committee Correspondence should contain any information that is generated as part of the project attached for future or historical purposes Additional Instructions and Guidance can be found online through the C&S Connect Help tab. ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management 8 Standards & Certification Proposal Submittal

Page © ASME 2013 ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management Potential Options for Approval Process –Broad Review and Comment Process: Proposal sent out for review and comment to all groups that will ultimately have to vote on the item. Comments addressed, then the item is balloted using either one of processes below –Tiered Approval Process: Proposal reviewed and approved by each group, one group one group at a time. Can be a slow process –Simultaneous Approval Process: Proposal reviewed and approved by all groups at the same time. Approach more appropriate for simple items or items that are urgent –Concurrent Voting Process: Proposal is submitted for ballot of two tiers at once; some committees may ballot one tier for approval and submit the proposal to the upper tier for review and comment Standards & Certification Approval Process 9

Page © ASME Ballot is opened by Staff Secretary or Project Technical Manager 2.Upon closure of a ballot the PTM shall post a response to all comments. 3.Negative voters should be asked if they are willing to withdraw their negatives in light of the response posted. 4.The proposal is then revised to include all changes agreed to in their responses. 5.The proposal is then posted to the Record’s Proposal uploaded field or submitted to the ASME Staff Secretary to upload. ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management 10 Standards & Certification Proposal Ballot Process

Page © ASME If the proposal requires no additional changes after the ballot comments have responded to, then the PM should inform the ASME Staff Secretary. 7.No further ballots may be issued until all comments from the previous ballot have been given a response. 8.PTM does not have to wait until a ballot is closed to respond to comments online. If a comment is addressed and the concerns have been satisfied before ballot closure, the voter can revisit the ballot and change their vote. 9.The ASME Staff Secretary in conjunction with committee officers (or PTM) decides what the next level ballot is for the proposal. (e.g. recirculation, first consideration, or ballot at subcommittee or Board level). ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management 11 Standards & Certification Proposal Ballot Process

Page © ASME 2013 ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management After standards committee approval, the ASME Staff Secretary and PTM work together to complete the standards development steps noted in Module B5 Consensus Process for Standard Development including: –Public Review –Supervisory Board Approval –Appeals Hearings (if any) –ANSI Approval –Publication Standards & Certification Proposal Consensus Process 12

Page © ASME 2013 Verifying Publishing of Approved Proposal –If PTM has opportunity to review manuscript to be presented to ASME Publishing, s/he should verify that the manuscript accurately reflects the approved proposal –PTM should verify that published version of the proposal is correct and notify appropriate committee officers of any deviations ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management 13 Standards & Certification Project Management

Page © ASME 2013 ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management All standards-related proposals are managed by an assigned Project Team, the standards committee or subcommittee. The Project Technical Manager is vital in ensuring timely preparation and submittal of the proposal to the relevant technical groups and in the timely consideration and response to comments submitted. It is important that Project Technical Manager establish a plan for driving proposals through the approval process, taking into account the nature of the proposal. Module Summary 14

Page © ASME 2013 REFERENCES Guide for Presenting Proposed Revisions C&S Writing and Style Guide uide.htm uide.htm Instructions for New Component Record Form Instructions for Updating a Component Record Form S&C Module B5 Consensus Process for Standard Development ASME S&C Training Module B5A Standards & Certification Project Management 15