1. Interpretations and Code Cases

2. Topics Covered
Interpretations
Intent Interpretations
Code Cases

3. Interpretations: Routine and Always Acceptable
Traditional Inquiries:
A simple clarification or restatement of code requirements that may be considered vague, inconsistent or slightly difficult to apply. These interpretations do not amount to changes to the Code requirements, therefore a simplified approval process is permitted.

4. Intent Interpretations: Routine and Always Acceptable
Intent Inquiries:
Used when Code text does not adequately convey the intention of the Standards Committee.
An intent interpretation provides a statement of the Standards Committee’s intent and simultaneously corrects the requirements to reflect the stated intent.
As a result , Code requirements must be revised, therefore the full consensus process must be employed for approval.

5. Committee Process for Interpretations
Assigned to subcommittee to develop a response
Presented at an A17 Standards Committee meeting
For Intent Interpretation both response and revision simultaneously presented and voted upon.
Approved by A17 Standards Committee
Requires 2/3 approval of members present at meeting

6. Receiving Inquiries Requests must be submitted through ASME website:
go.asme.inquiry
Staff reviews requests for interpretation for formatting and nature of questions
If acceptable open a record and submit to the committee

7. Question and Reply
Interpretations are written as a question about a requirement and then the answer
The answer is in Yes/No format

8. Inquiries Typically Not Accommodated
Consultation (“How do I…”?):
ASME committees traditionally decline to provide technical consultation to code users on successful implementation of the Code.
Is it NOT demonstrated that the Code rules are vague or inconsistent?
Does the inquiry ask “why” (the philosophy or basis of the Code)?

9. Inquiries Typically Not Accommodated
Training:
ASME committees traditionally decline to address inquiries based solely on an inadequate understanding of the Code.
There exists an opportunity for code users to improve their general understanding of ASME Codes through ASME’s Training and Development products.

10. Code Cases

11. Cases Cases represent alternatives or additions to existing rules
Written in question and reply format
Intended for incorporation into the next edition
Typically requires a separate revision to be opened

12. Approval Process
Ballot using the method described for technical revisions
Requires ASME Public Review
Cases may be used once Board Approved
Do not require ANSI Approval