Resisting Regulatory Rigidities: Lessons from Front-line Care Work Donna Baines & Tamara Daly

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Nurses as Power Brokers: Changing Roles and Culture Change in Nursing Homes Dana Beth Weinberg, PhD Rebekah Zincavage, MA Almas Dossa, MPH, MS Sue Pfefferle,

Advertisements

Local Public Health System Assessment

Customised training: Learner Voice and Post-16 Citizenship.

Center for Leadership and Involvement Presented by: Donna Freitag & Charlie Cahill.

PHARMACIST CODE OF ETHICS

Can FBOs Reshape the Rights-based Approach to Poverty Reduction? An example from Egypt.

November 1, 2011 Modernization, Human Development.

Sexual Ethics from a Virtue Ethics Perspective Applied to issues of: Adultery: sex outside Marriage. Polygamy.Contraception.Homosexuality.

Companion Lectures For Progressive Community Organizing in a Globalizing World By Loretta Pyles Copyright © 2014, Loretta Pyles. From Progressive Community.

A Good Place to Do Science: A Case Study of an Academic Science Department Diana Bilimoria C. Greer Jordan Department of Organizational Behavior Case Western.

RECAP…. MEST 3 This is the exam unit for your A2 year and accounts for 50% of your A2 grade (25% of your overall qualification). As with the AS exam, this.

MCH Leadership Competencies CityMatCH August 27, 2007 Laura Kavanagh, MPP Department of Health and Human Services Health Resources and Services Administration.

GIPA/MIPA SOUTH AFRICA WORKPLACE MODEL. OUTLINE Background The GIPA principle: definition Why the GIPA principle? General lessons learned How far have.

 What is the main difference between psychology and sociology?

University of Portsmouth students Communicating with you Student support services Course representatives A shared commitment Safer students.

Understand your role 1 Standard.

World development report 2004 Making Services Work for Poor People.

Distribution and recognition Nancy Fraser – claims for social justice/equality based on  socio-economic redistribution  legal or cultural recognition.

How to combine Integration and Diversities ? The Challenge of a European Union Multicultural Citizenship. by Marco Martiniello FNRS and CEDEM-ULg.

MENTORING STUDENTS FOR PROFESSIONAL SOCIAL WORK PRACTICE Pamela Long, ACSW, LCSW Director of Field Education St. Ambrose University School of Social Work.

Unions and the Environment Generation Zero. Climate Change: A Global Issue - Been on the agenda since the 1980s, with little action occurring until quite.

Promoting a Culture of Respect for Children’s Rights The Roles of the State, the Family, Civil Society and the Media Ana Teresa León.

Donna Baines Labour Studies & Social Work McMaster University Emotional Labour in the Nonprofit Social Services: An Australian-Canadian Exploration Donna.

Political right’s “30 Years War” on government. Only 6.6 % of private sector workers now belong to unions. Local, county, and state governments face.

General Consideration of Culturally Responsive Instruction Culture Ethnicity Culture is best explained as the ways in which we perceive, believe, evaluate,

*(Or Evidence at the Frontline’ We will vote on this and other suggestions!) “ Action at the Frontline : Unlocking local level learning”*

7 th European Feminist Research Conference Utrecht, 4-7 June 2009 GEMIC: A project on Gender, Migration and Intercultural Interactions in the Mediterranean.

Leadership Certificate Program Fall 2009 Center for Leadership & Involvement.

Personal data protection in criminal procedure International collaboration and principle of proportionality LEFIS ROVANIEMI MEETING 19TH 20TH JANUARY 2007.

Women with dependent children - their journeys through a primary teacher training programme and the impact on their families. Stephanie White.

A Major Collaborative Research Initiative funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada Pat Armstrong, PhD, Principal Investigator,

A Major Collaborative Research Initiative funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada Pat Armstrong, PhD, FRSC Principal Investigator,

Ethics in pharmacy practice

Intercultural Dialogue and the European Higher Education Area The People’s Friendship University Sochi, May 2010.

Introductions: Tell us your name, year, major and why you are here today!

Locating the ‘Arab Spring’ Lived Experiences of Contemporary Politics among Arabs in Malta Nathalie Grima M.A. in Sociology Faculty of Arts University.

World development report 2004 Making Services Work for Poor People.

Money, Sex and Power Equality and the politics of redistribution: is money enough? Week

International Baccalaureate GLOBAL CONTEXTS. What are Global Contexts? You learn best when your learning experiences have context and are connected to.

Jalongo & Isenberg, Exploring Your Role, 3e Copyright © 2008 by Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved. 3.1 Chapter 3: Exploring Your Role in Respecting.

Collective Behavior, Social Movements, and Social Change

Oranje is an organisation that offers an answer to a need, where people with and without disability do activities together and where family’s get support.

Introduction to process documentation for learning alliances and action research Based on background paper SWITCH Briefing No 6 Ton Schouten.

Health Inequalities: What’s that got to do with CLD? Community Learning and Development Annual Conference 30 th Oct 2015 Clare Beeston: Principal Public.

PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP WITHIN THE SOCIAL PROTECTION SYSTEMS FRAMEWORK.

MULTICULTURAL EDUCATION A Social Justice Approach.

Role of Communities in Inclusive Education: The Case of Roma Communities Alexandre Marc Roma Education Fund.

Challenges for Contemporary Ethics Cultural diversity Technological innovation Globalization.

A Place at the Table Building Community A Step Beyond Advocacy Prepared by Nancy Bolt Nancy Bolt & Associates Based on the work of Kathleen de la pena.

Feminist and virtue perspectives on the ethics of public health research Wendy Rogers Associate Professor Medical Ethics and Health Law Flinders University.

TEACHER LIVES AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT Dr. James Ko Teachers and Teaching in Context 2014.

History of Ethnographic Research and Its Uses Part II.

Transforming Government, Transforming Communities Strengthening the Federal Workforce to Help Communities Implement Place-Based Initiatives Transforming.

Barleti School of Public Affairs. Public service in all countries of the Western Balkans (WB) faces many challenges and weaknesses in regards to public.

Responding to the presence of marginalised groups in public spaces: is well-balanced collaboration possible? Lessons learned from Downtown Montreal, Qc,

Centre-based training Citizenship learning through Diplomas Citizenship learning through Diplomas.

Teacher lives and professional development

19th Asia Pacific Regional Conference of ADI

Marriage and Parenting

Classification of Research

The erasure of gender Fiona Webster, Kathleen Rice, Jennifer Christian, Natashia Seemann, Nancy Baxter, Carol-Anne Moulton, Tulin Cil University of.

Ethics in pharmacy practice

Department of Technology and Society

AAHRPP Accreditation Welcome to the University of Georgia’s presentation for accreditation of the human research protection program (HRPP). This presentation.

PROFESSIONAL BUSINESS PRACTICE

Safety Culture Self-Assessment Methodology

Comm. Dev : A review.

Feminist and Cultural Competence: Ethics of Practice

Organizations, Power, and Empowerment

Decision Criteria Used In Assessing Alternatives

Presentation transcript:

Resisting Regulatory Rigidities: Lessons from Front-line Care Work Donna Baines & Tamara Daly

Many have argued that ethical practice is not possible within current management + regulatory models. How do we best foster ethical, social justice-linked care?

Care, feminist and virtue ethics Ethical care does not happen in a vacuum. Requires a link to wider debates within society about social justice and applied- ethics (social movements + community). Foster conditions under which good care decisions are easy to make – where it is “good to be good”.

Certain populations are constructed as needing care rather than recognizing care as something we all do and receive across a lifetime. –De-universalizes + individualizes care –Remakes care as a private “problem”, requiring private solutions –Depoliticizes care: making it a medical issue rather than a struggle for dignity, resources and power

Linking power, care and social justice (Nancy Fraser 2010) 1.Redistribution of resources and power 2.Recognition (access to affirming identities and culture) 3.Representation (fair and equitable processes of political representation and voice)

Despite regulatory rigidity: Promising Practices *Leaky boundaries/ interconnection/ subsidy *Altruism/ solidarity

Recap of our methods METHODS: Rapid ethnography Intensive case studies in nonprofit social services agencies - 2 completed to date Fieldwork – interviews (+50), observations (+36), document review (Baines + Cunningham, 2013) Research question: seeking promising practices in long term care

Leaky boundaries/interconnection/subsidy 1.Work extra, unpaid hours 2.Bring goods from home 3.Take on extra events and responsibilities beyond the job description

2. Altruism/ Solidarity Care as resistance to larger uncaring society and highly regulated workplace Care mobilized not just to “help” but to empower self and others = solidarity

Conclusions Ways to foster spaces in which it is good to be good in care work warrants further investigation Our data is replete with examples of staff behaving in virtuous ways despite the tight quantification and regulation of practice However, this is not inevitable and may survive because staff are resisting “uncaring” rather than because they are following regulations.