Guy, Guys, and Gender Neutrality Sean McLennan Indiana University CLS 40 April 15, 2004
Sean McLennan - CLS 40 Introduction A server in a restaurant: Good evening! Can I get you guys something to drink?
Sean McLennan - CLS 40 Corpus Analysis chosen for colloquial nature static community restricted demographics known community where referents are more clearly interpretable computational tractability
Sean McLennan - CLS 40 Corpus Analysis messages sent to a closed list approx. 70 participants (primarily Canadian undergraduate students) nearly equal gender ratio November October 2002
Sean McLennan - CLS 40 Corpus Analysis Factors examined: number: singular vs. plural grammatical position: subject, object, indirect object, vocative phrasal co-occurrence: determiners, you, hey/hi etc. gender composition of referent: male, female, mixed, unknown, genderless
Sean McLennan - CLS 40 Corpus Analysis: Results 73% total = %
Sean McLennan - CLS 40 Corpus Analysis: Results NumberGram. Pos.Phrase Co-occ. 98% you 3% you
Sean McLennan - CLS 40 Corpus Analysis: Results Accounts for 98% of the recorded instances
Sean McLennan - CLS 40 Discussion guymanhe high freq (73%)* low freq (5%)* low freq (3%) highly pred. by gram. context marginally pred. by gram. context not pred. by gram. context shift in dir. of neutrality shift in dir. of gender specificity prescriptivist imposition non-gendered imagery(?) gendered imagery balances lexical paradigms in conflict with existing paradigm used as a generic: * current study Graham (1975)