by N. T. Nassar, T. E. Graedel, and E. M. Harper

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
B a c kn e x t h o m e Frequency Distributions frequency distribution A frequency distribution is a table used to organize data. The left column (called.
Advertisements

B a c kn e x t h o m e Classification of Variables Discrete Numerical Variable A variable that produces a response that comes from a counting process.
Chapter 2 Describing Data.
Section 2.1 Review and Preview. Copyright © 2010, 2007, 2004 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 1. Center: A representative or average value.
Section 2.1 Review and Preview.
Journal of Vision. 2008;8(11):18. doi: / Figure Legend:
Michael R. Bristow et al. BTS 2018;3:1-8
Velocity of hygrobots. Velocity of hygrobots. (A) The difference between l and lp corresponds to a distance that a hygrobot advances a period. (B) Velocity.
Kazuya Hasegawa, Ichiro Yamashita, Keiichi Namba  Biophysical Journal 
Fig. 4 Pupil shape and image quality in the model sheep eye.
Fig. 4 3D reconfiguration of liquid metals for electronics.
Fig. 2 CFD results. CFD results. Results of CFD simulations in horizontal (left column) and vertical (right column) cross-sections. All models oriented.
Fig. 3 Nonenzymatic reactions in the presence of as-prepared FeS (blue) and the FeS electrochemically reduced at −0.7 V (versus SHE) for 7 days (FeS_PERM)
Fig. 4 Power and wavelet spectra of benthic δ18O.
Fig. 3 Projected gains in MCP.
Fig. 1 Demographic shifts in knowledge producers.
Fig. 3 Oil, gas, and FP water variations with time.
Fig. 3 Critical pressure analysis for reentrant and doubly reentrant geometries. Critical pressure analysis for reentrant and doubly reentrant geometries.
Fig. 3 Near-field maps of a multiply cracked α-(BEDT-TTF)2I3 crystal.
Fig. 2 Meta-analysis: Country-specific effects on vote choice.
Fig. 1 Map of Atlantic cod (G
Fig. 6 Comparison of properties of water models.
Fig. 3 Faculty placement distributions.
Fig. 2 Reference-fixing experiment, results.
Fig. 1 Crystal structure and calculated band structure.
Fig. 3 TESC spectra with increasing coupling strength and plexciton energy diagram with QD detuning. TESC spectra with increasing coupling strength and.
Fig. 1 Mean swarm response to an oscillating swarm marker.
Fig. 2 Full-frame images recording the violation of a Bell inequality in four images. Full-frame images recording the violation of a Bell inequality in.
Fig. 4 Visualization of the 20 occipital lobe models, trained to predict EmoNet categories from brain responses to emotional images. Visualization of the.
Fig. 1 Proportions of normative beliefs by exchange condition, level of redistribution (0 = random, one-card, and two-card exchange), and outcome as winner.
Fig. 2 Four types of MJO propagation patterns along the equator.
Fig. 1 Phase diagram and FS topologies.
Fig. 2 Expressions of cll, abd-A, and Abd-B by qRT-PCR.
Intensified vegetation water use under acid deposition
Electronic structure of the oligomer (n = 8) at the UB3LYP/6-31G
Fig. 2 Variation of the SHC with carrier lifetime.
Fig. 2 EUV TG signal. EUV TG signal. Black lines in (A), (B), and (C) are the EUV TG signals from Si3N4 membranes at LTG = 110, 85, and 28 nm, respectively,
Fig. 3 Load dependence of friction force and corresponding COF.
Fig. 3 ET dynamics on the control and treatment watersheds during the pretreatment and treatment periods. ET dynamics on the control and treatment watersheds.
Fig. 2 Nanoparticle logic gates.
Fig. 2 Year-to-year changes in the number of tornadoes, low-level jet, and moisture flux convergence over the SGP. Year-to-year changes in the number of.
Fig. 1 Average contribution (million metric tons) of seafood-producing sectors, 2009–2014. Average contribution (million metric tons) of seafood-producing.
Fig. 3 Characterization of the current-induced effective fields.
Fig. 4 In vivo FF results for MMA mice.
by Hiro Nimiya, Tatsunori Ikeda, and Takeshi Tsuji
by Patrick Francois, Thomas Fujiwara, and Tanguy van Ypersele
Relative impacts of mitigation, temperature, and precipitation on 21st-century megadrought risk in the American Southwest by Toby R. Ault, Justin S. Mankin,
Fig. 4 Relationships between light and economic parameters.
Fig. 3 Evaluating the accuracy of speech separation and attention decoding methods. Evaluating the accuracy of speech separation and attention decoding.
Relationships between species richness and temperature or latitude
Fig. 3 Relationships between Q10 and C distribution in aggregates.
Fig. 1 Global distribution of surface DIP.
Fig. 7 Global change in the collective mass for wild mammals, humans, cattle, and all livestock for the years 1900–2050. Global change in the collective.
Urban scaling and the regional divide
Fig. 1 The s-s/w-w H-bond pairing principle and the effect of protein-ligand H-bonds on protein-ligand binding. The s-s/w-w H-bond pairing principle and.
Fig. 3 Maximal energy intake.
Fig. 2 Comparison of the observed DRs and the estimates by the VR model and FL. Comparison of the observed DRs and the estimates by the VR model and FL.
Fig. 1 Global primate species richness, distributions, and the percentage of species threatened and with declining populations. Global primate species.
Fig. 1 Area and carbon distributions in SFs in the lowland Neotropics.
Fig. 3 Effects of plant species identity, plant traits, and soil properties on plant-soil feedbacks. Effects of plant species identity, plant traits, and.
Fig. 4 Imaged polarization effects.
Fig. 2 Finite element method (FEM) simulations of the photonic synapse with different structures. Finite element method (FEM) simulations of the photonic.
Fig. 1 Prestige hierarchies in faculty hiring networks.
Distribution of applications from AA/B scientists across topics
Fig. 2 Spatial distribution of five city groups.
Fig. 3 Supercurrents in various conductance plateau regions.
Fig. 1 Ecological and evolutionary change of coevolving host and virus populations. Ecological and evolutionary change of coevolving host and virus populations.
Fig. 1 Transformation from coupling to decoupling.
Fig. 2 Imaging blood vessel before and after closure.
Fig. 1 Uplift of the Isthmus of Panama and global sea levels over the last 20 My. Uplift of the Isthmus of Panama and global sea levels over the last 20.
Presentation transcript:

by N. T. Nassar, T. E. Graedel, and E. M. Harper By-product metals are technologically essential but have problematic supply by N. T. Nassar, T. E. Graedel, and E. M. Harper Science Volume 1(3):e1400180 April 3, 2015 Copyright © 2015, The Authors

Fig. 1 The periodic table of companionality on a global basis for 2008. The periodic table of companionality on a global basis for 2008. Metals that are mainly produced as hosts appear in blue, and those that are mainly produced as companions are in red. Details regarding data sources and assumptions are presented in the Supplementary Materials. N. T. Nassar et al. Sci Adv 2015;1:e1400180 Copyright © 2015, The Authors

Fig. 2 The wheel of metal companionality. The wheel of metal companionality. The principal host metals form the inner circle. Companion elements appear in the outer circle at distances proportional to the percentage of their primary production (from 100 to 0%) that originates with the host metal indicated. The companion elements in the white region of the outer circle are elements for which the percentage of their production that originates with the host metal indicated has not been determined. Data sources and assumptions for the assessment are given in the Supplementary Materials. Inspired by a diagram developed by (10). N. T. Nassar et al. Sci Adv 2015;1:e1400180 Copyright © 2015, The Authors

Fig. 3 Companionality dynamics. Companionality dynamics. (A to H) Variations in host metal contributions (vertical axis) for cobalt (A), nickel (B), copper (C), molybdenum (D), silver (E), platinum (F), rhenium (G), and gold (H) as a percentage of total primary production over several years (horizontal axis). Data are from (5, 37–39). N. T. Nassar et al. Sci Adv 2015;1:e1400180 Copyright © 2015, The Authors

Fig. 4 Companionality, primary production concentration, and end-of-life recycling for 62 metals. Companionality, primary production concentration, and end-of-life recycling for 62 metals. Primary production concentration is measured by the HHI, which is calculated as the sum of the squares of the individual country production shares. Where data for multiple production stages (for example, mining, smelting, and refining) are reported, the production stage that yields the largest HHI value is used. Top and side inserts indicate distributions along respective axis. Data sources and assumptions for the assessment of companionality and production concentration are given in the Supplementary Materials (tables S1 and S2). End-of-life recycling rate ranges are obtained from (24). N. T. Nassar et al. Sci Adv 2015;1:e1400180 Copyright © 2015, The Authors

Fig. 5 Revenue contribution by metal (in descending order) for five mines producing platinum group elements. Revenue contribution by metal (in descending order) for five mines producing platinum group elements. The red line marks the point at which revenues cover the cost of sales, thus defining dependency of the metals. For the Canadian and U.S. mines, costs of sales exceed revenues, as indicated by the red number at the right. Details regarding data sources (that is, company annual reports) and assumptions are noted in the Supplementary Materials. N. T. Nassar et al. Sci Adv 2015;1:e1400180 Copyright © 2015, The Authors

Fig. 6 Economic companionality assessment. Economic companionality assessment. (A to E) 2008 companionality of platinum (A), palladium (B), rhodium (C), ruthenium (D), and iridium (E) calculated on the basis of each metal’s revenue contribution relative to the cost of sales on an operation-by-operation basis for 36 operations (column height) displayed in ascending order. Column widths are proportional to each operation’s sales contribution as percent of global sales. Sales-weighted averages for each metal are represented by horizontal lines. N. T. Nassar et al. Sci Adv 2015;1:e1400180 Copyright © 2015, The Authors