Chapter 12: Supreme Court Decision Making

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chapter 12: Supreme Court Decision Making
Advertisements

Supreme Court Decision Making
Splash Screen Contents Chapter Focus Section 1Section 1The Supreme Court at Work Section 2Section 2Shaping Public Policy Section 3Section 3Influencing.
The Supreme Court/ The Supreme Court at Work
The National Judiciary
Supreme Court Decision Making
The Supreme Court at Work. Basic Facts About the Supreme Court 9 Justices on the Court Each “term” begins first Monday in October and lasts until they.
Supreme Court American Government. The Court  The Supreme Court is the ultimate court of the land  There are 9 judges that make up the Supreme Court.
Describe how the Supreme Court has power over the other branches of government through the process of checks and balances. Warm-Up.
THE SUPREME COURT AT WORK PROCEDURES, HOW CASES REACH THE COURT & STEPS IN DECIDING CASES.
Ch. 12 The Supreme Court. Petitions Stage: by what Routes can Cases Reach the Supreme Court? 1)Petition for Writ of Certiorari – most common Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court at Work
Chapter 11- The Supreme Court of the United States.
The Judicial Branch Chapters 11 & 12. GPS: SSGC 16  Students will demonstrate knowledge of the operation of the federal judiciary. –Explain the jurisdiction.
T HE C OURT ’ S P ROCEDURES Submitting Briefs − Legal arguments on the case − Parties not directly involved may submit amicus curiae Oral Arguments The.
The Judicial Branch The Supreme Court Decision Making.
Section 1: The Supreme Court at Work Section 2: Shaping Public Policy Section 3: Influencing Court Decisions.
Questions What are three types of jurisdiction? What are two types of juries? When is each used? What is senatorial courtesy and when is it used? How many.
Government, Chapters 11 and 12 The Judicial Branch.
The United States Supreme Court Part 1. Main Job The main job of the Justices is to hear and rule on cases to decide whether laws are allowable under.
8.4 The Supreme Court at Work. Court Procedures The Supreme Court meets about 9 months each year, each term begins the first Monday in October and runs.
CHAPTER 11 AND 12 SUMMARY. Essential Question How does the Constitution define the powers of the federal courts, and how are the various courts related.
Ch 8 The Judicial Branch 8.4 Deciding Cases at the Supreme Court.
Supreme Court In a flash. Justices of the Court Supreme Court Justices Composed of 9 justices – Chief Justice and 8 Associate Justices Duties have developed.
Section 1 Getting Cases to the Court Most cases reach the Supreme Court as appeals from lower court decisions. They come to the courts in one of two ways:
UNIT 4: SECTION 1 JUDICIAL BRANCH: ROLES, RESPONSIBILITIES, AND POWERS Essential Questions: How are Supreme Court justices appointed and confirmed by the.
The U.S. Supreme Court. The Supreme Court Justices.
CH 12 SEC 1 THE SUPREME COURT AT WORK I. THE COURT’S PROCEDURES A.During two-week sessions, justices hear oral arguments on cases from Mondays through.
FEDERAL COURT SYSTEM Chapter 16 p I.DUAL COURT SYSTEM 51 Courts Virginia State Courts 1.General District Cts. a. misdemeanors small crimes 2.Circuit.
Mock Supreme Court Assignment, Discussion & Activity with 8.3 & 8.4.
 Where would we find the specific functions of this branch?  Article III  What is the difference between state and federal courts? (Think about Federalism)
Chapter 18: The Federal Court System Section 3. Copyright © Pearson Education, Inc.Slide 2 Chapter 18, Section 3 Objectives 1.Define the concept of judicial.
The Supreme Court The court’s procedures – During two – week sessions, justices hear oral arguments on cases and then meet to make decisions on them. –
The Function of the Supreme Court
Splash Screen.
Chapter 12: Supreme Court Decision Making
The Judicial Branch.
The Federal Court System
The Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court.
T.L.O. vs. New Jersey Read the background summary of the case
Government, Chapters 11 and 12
The Federal Court System
The Courts & the Judicial Branch
The Federal Court System
Supreme Court Decision Making
Chapter 18 “The Federal Court System”
Chapter 8 Section 3 Mr. Gordon.
The Federal Court System Chapter 11
Ch Influencing Court Decisions
The Judicial Branch Review
Warmup What kind of judgments do you have to make in your daily life?
Chapter 14 The US Supreme Court.
Chapter 8 Section 3 Mr. Plude.
Judicial Branch.
SC Decision Making.
AP U.S. Government Chapter 14
Judicial Branch.
Judicial Branch.
Unit 2 Chapter 12 Supreme Court Decision Making
Unit 2: Interactions Among Branches of Government
Bell Ringer: Write five questions you think may be on the test for chapter 7 Include the test question and the answer The questions can be ABC choice,
The Courts AP US Government.
The Supreme Court at Work
Influencing Court Decisions
Primary function is to resolve disputes over the meaning of
Chapter 12 Notes Macdonald Government.
8.4 The Supreme Court at Work
Unit 3 Chapter 12 Supreme Court Decision Making
Article III of the US Constitution
Presentation transcript:

Chapter 12: Supreme Court Decision Making Section 1: The Supreme Court at Work Section 2: Shaping Public Policy Section 3: Influencing Court Decisions

Section 1: The Supreme Court @ Work I: The Court’s Procedures A. During two week sessions, justices hear oral arguments on cases and then meet in secret to make decisions. B. The justices consider arguments in cases they have heard and petitions from plaintiffs and then write opinions for cases they have decided. C. Justices’ written opinions interpret the law and help shape public policy.

II: How Cases Reach the Court The majority of referred cases concern appeals from lower courts. Most appeals concern cases in which a lower state or federal court has ruled laws unconstitutional. Cases the court chooses not to hear are dismissed, and the ruling of the lower court becomes final. Most cases reach the court by writ of certiorari, in which either side petitions that a lower court’s decision involved an error raising a serious constitutional issue. The solicitor general is appointed by the president and acts as the government’s lawyer.

How Does the Court Choose Cases? The chief justice puts worthy certiorari cases on a list for discussion; 2/3 of all appealed cases never make it to this list. 4 of the 9 justices have to agree to hear a case from the list. Some cases are decided by a brief, unsigned per curiam opinion; the rest are given the court’s full consideration.

III: Steps in Deciding Major Cases Each side submits a brief outlining its legal arguments, the facts in the case, the history of the case in lower courts and relevant precedents. People and groups may submit amicus curiae briefs Lawyers for each side make oral arguments during which justices may ask them questions. On Wednesdays & Fridays, the chief justice presides over a closed conference, in which each single case is summarized and recommendations for handling it are made

Steps Continued The justices spend about 30 minutes debating each case. Each justice has one vote; a majority vote is needed to decide a case. The justices then issue one of four kinds of opinions: A unanimous opinion A majority opinion A concurring opinion A dissenting opinion If the chief justice votes with the majority, s/he assigns a justice in the majority to write the Court’s opinion. Otherwise, the most senior justice with the majority assigns a justice to write the opinion.

Section 2: Shaping Public Policy The Court makes policy in three ways: Using judicial review Interpreting laws Overruling or reversing its previous decisions Using its power of judicial review, the Court may examine laws and actions at all levels of government and cancel them if they violate the Constitution. The Court uses its power of judicial review more often at the state level than the national level (as in Brown & Miranda)

Shaping Policy continued The Court’s interpretation of the very general language of laws allows it to decide how the law applies to specific situations. The Court’s rulings become precedents on which to base other, similar decisions; but the Court may overturn or reverse its earlier decisions (Dred Scott & Plessy) Remember the idea of keeping the Constitution a “living document”?

Limits on the Court Major topics the Court concerns itself with include: civil liberties, econ. Issues, federal laws, due process and suits against govt. officials. The Court plays a minor role in foreign policy. (why?) Civil liberties cases make up the largest # of Court cases (appeals from prisoners make up about 1/4 of all its cases) The Court won’t take a case simply to decide a point of law: What’s the constitutional question at stake? Has the plaintiff suffered real harm? Is there a federal issue that needs resolution?

Limits continued The Court does not have original jurisdiction over most cases that it hears, so it hears cases that come to it from other places in the legal system. This means that events beyond the Court’s control shape its agenda. The Court signals its interest in an area by agreeing to hear a specific case. Remember that the court has no power to enforce its decisions. It doesn’t really have a way to monitor compliance by lower courts.

Section 3: What Influences Court Decisions? Basing decisions on the law Justices must be guided by the law, not their personal opinions. Decisions reflect the court’s interpretation of a law based on The Constitution Relevant statutes Legal precedents

Views of the Justices Justices monitor important issues; some become identified with a particular issue. As justices leave the court, the majority voting blocs on certain issues may change. Many now regard Justice Kennedy as a swing vote Do justices always get along? On the modern court, they meet for discussion, but often communicate in writing. Personal relations among the justices can play a role in the Court’s decisions The chief justice needs to be skilled in promoting harmony

The Court & Society The Court is largely free from public opinion and political pressures. Why did the Framers set it up this way? Justices are influenced by the values and beliefs of society; their opinions reflect major changes in society. This is why so many of their cases are controversial--not everyone likes the change the ruling represents. This is where the pejorative term “activist” court comes into play, but “activist” is largely a matter of opinion. For example, people may view the Roe decision as overly activist, but be comfortable with the Brown decision. One person’s view of the court taking corrective action is another person’s view of the justices “making law from the bench.”

Balancing the Court’s Power The Supreme Court is subject to checks and balances just like the other two branches of government. The president appoints members to the court. (every full-term president but Carter has done this). Thus, the president has an influence over the makeup of the court. As the head of the executive branch, it is the responsibility of the president to enforce the court’s decisions, which may be done vigorously or not at all. Congress controls the Court’s jurisdiction. So it could choose to limit the court’s ability to hear certain types of cases. Congress could also “overrule “ the court by passing a Constitutional amendment. The Senate confirms justices’ appointments to the court, thereby shaping the Courts’ position on social issues. Congress also can set, but not lower the salaries of the justices.