1 Market Outlook: Raise Cash, or Put It to Work? × Pat Dorsey, CFA × Director of Equity Research, Morningstar.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chapter 7 Learning Objectives
Advertisements

Chapter 13 Learning Objectives
® 1 Rudiments of Credit Analysis May 18, 2001 Credit for Bluffers – Part I.
Is There More Upside in High Yield? DC Finance Institutional Investor Conference May 24, 2010.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 40 The Stock Market Crashes.
Chapter 19 Financing and Valuation Principles of Corporate Finance
1 1 Presented by: Sara L. Johnson Managing Director Global Macroeconomics Group DRI-WEFA August 7, 2001 The U.S. Economic Outlook: Turbulent Times.
Teacher instructions:
CHAPTER 5 ESSENTIALS OF FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS.
Historical Perspective on British Columbias Credit Rating Presentation to Financial Management Institute June 18, 2008.
6 th International Venture Capital Forum Athens 14 th -15 th June 2005 Private Equity in Europe -Fund Raising and Trends.
Activity 1………………Saving vs. Investing Activity 2……….….Saving for a Rainy Day Activity 3…………………… = Saving Activity 4…..Investing for the Long Term.
Capacity Planning For Products and Services
Uncertainty and Volatility in Global and Domestic Markets Robert B. Engel President & Chief Executive Officer December 6, 2010.
Research Department 1 Global Economic Crisis and the Israeli Economy Herzliya conference Dr. Karnit Flug Research Director, Bank of Israel February 2009.
FI3300 Corporation Finance Spring Semester 2010 Dr. Isabel Tkatch Assistant Professor of Finance 1.
Global Entrepreneurship and Small Business Management
36 Offices in 17 Countries Beyond the Media Stories: What’s Happening in the USA? John Thomas Global Real Estate Practice Group Leader.
2 Economic Activity 2-1 Measuring Economic Activity
Fundraising. Starting and growing a business always require capital. There are a number of alternative methods to fund growth. These include the owner.
Chapter 4: Financial Statement Analysis
1 Financial Markets and Institutions Leng Ling Department of Economics & Finance Georgia College & State University.
Banking and the Management of Financial Institutions
Financial Sector Review Questions
The Global Financial Crisis, in Brief..  The root cause was runaway borrowing and debt based on the inflated value of “assets”  Plus the lending of.
Stock Valuation and Risk
Investing in Stocks Copyright © 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall Learning Objectives 1. Invest in stocks. 2. Read stock.
Norges Bank 1 Executive Board meeting 30 May 2007.
Understanding Financial Management and Securities Markets
Copyright © 2007 Global Insight, Inc. The U.S. Economic Outlook: How Much Fallout from The Housing Meltdown? Nariman Behravesh Chief Economist NAHB April.
Veritas Financial Group Introduction to the Financial Universe Week 4– Hedge Funds.
Economic Outlook William Strauss Senior Economist and Economic Advisor Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago Multi-Chamber Economic Outlook Luncheon Downers.
Coca-Cola Garrett Roberts ACG2021 Sec Executive Summary Coca-Cola was established in 1886 and today has plants in 200 countries world wide. Coca-Cola.
Entrepreneurial Finance in Less than One Hour Michael Dearing Stanford University 2010 Copyright 2008 Michael Dearing.
Copyright © 2012 Pearson Prentice Hall. All rights reserved. CHAPTER 17 Banking and the Management of Financial Institutions.
Finance Issues in the News. Economic Indicators Inflation: Overall rise in prices Inflation: Overall rise in prices -The Consumer Price Index averages.
Economic Outlook for Consumers William Strauss Senior Economist and Economic Advisor Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago University of Illinois Center for.
Economy / Market Analysis
The Great Recession Causes & Prospects
INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT SEMINAR 1 How I Analyze Stocks or, How I Invest Mark Greenberg 1/25/11.
CHAPTER 1 A Tour of The World CHAPTER 1 Prepared by: Fernando Quijano and Yvonn Quijano Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice.
Lazard Ltd (NYSE: LAZ) Closing Price on 12/7: DCF Upside: 24.9%
UNIT 4 – TEST REVIEW PLANNING FOR YOUR FUTURE SAVINGS AND INVESTING
Valuation Terms and Ratios Tanveer Chandok (Director of Mentorship)
FOUNDATION BUSINESS SIMULATION
Investment Basics Clench Fraud Trust Investment Workshop October 24, 2011 Jeff Frketich, CFA.
IBM Chris Driscoll ACG Executive Summary IBM is an IT company that has been around for a long time and will continue to be since they are since.
Security Analysis. Learning Goals Analyzing shares based on Economic, Industry and Fundamental of the company Analyzing shares to determine WHAT shares.
Financial Accounting Dave Ludwick, P.Eng, MBA, PMP, PhD Chapter 20 Ratios Analysis.
CHAPTER 3 Working With Financial Statements. Key Concepts and Skills Know how to standardize financial statements for comparison purposes Know how to.
Highlighting a Few Key Ideas and Issues.  M&M: Equity ≈ Debt  For Corporate Finance: ▪ Value of firm projects (revenue, costs) matters a lot more than.
The Economy and External Environment 10th Annual Georgia Idea Institute August 19, 2015 Bill Hampel, Chief Policy Officer Credit Union National Association.
A Global Reach with a Local Perspective Current Economic Conditions Affecting Your Business.
STAPLES COMPANY VALUATION JACKIE PHAN LATRISHA SEARCY ANNA DAI.
1 "An appetising spread" Corporate bond spreads are now very high Between June 2007 and November 2008, junk issuers spread went from 2.5% to 15% This indicates.
Economic Outlook for 2011 and 2012 William Strauss Senior Economist and Economic Advisor Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago Electronics Representatives Association.
Rhys Johnson Head of Education Asia Pacific
Merrill Lynch Matt Western ACG2021 Section 002. Executive Summary Overall Merrill Lynch had a great year in They increased their revenues 11% from.
The Financial Crisis and the Great Recession 14. Start with the 2001 recession and weak recovery Fed responds by cutting interest rates (FFR = 1%) Since.
Aswath Damodaran1 Financial Statement Analysis “The raw data for investing”
 Fundamental Analysis By Martin Brenner. What is Fundamental Analysis?  A method of evaluating a security that entails attempting to measure its intrinsic.
Class Business Upcoming Debate. Valuation Assignment Free-Cash Flow Valuation of Target (TGT) Graded portions – Pro forma projections (Wednesday, 5/25)
Portfolio Management Unit – III Session No. 22 Topic: Economic Analysis Unit – III Session No. 22 Topic: Economic Analysis.
2015 Investment Outlook Yuntaek Pae, PhD, CFA Associate Professor of Finance, Lewis University.
Choose a country and explain why they may have seen a rise in their fiscal deficit – create a short report on the country.
2016 Market Update and Outlook April 27, 2016 J.P. King Advisors, Inc. is an SEC registered investment advisor. Past performance is no guarantee of future.
Ratio Analysis…. Types of ratios…  Performance Ratios: Return on capital employed. (Income Statement and Balance Sheet) Gross profit margin (Income Statement)
1 Chapter 1 Money, Banking, and Financial Markets --An Overview © Thomson/South-Western 2006.
Mark R. Holloway, C.F.A. Chief Investment Officer March 14, 2019
Economic Outlook EconoSummit 2019 William Strauss Las Vegas, NV
Presentation transcript:

1 Market Outlook: Raise Cash, or Put It to Work? × Pat Dorsey, CFA × Director of Equity Research, Morningstar

2 2 Morningstar Equity Research × One of the largest independent equity research groups in the world. × Broad coverage: 90 analysts covering 1800 companies across the globe × Consistent, disciplined research approach focused on intrinsic values and economic moats.

3 3 Our Approach × We evaluate stocks as small pieces of a business. × We do primary research by reading filings & trade journals, visiting companies, talking to competitors & customers, and attending industry conferences. × We have a long-term perspective. × Our recommendations are driven by valuation, but we are not value investors in the most traditional sense. × We believe that competitive advantages–economic moats–add intrinsic value, and we rigorously assess the competitive position of the companies we cover. × We believe that the ability of a business to generate returns on invested capital (ROIC) above cost of capital is the primary test of shareholder value creation.

4 Morningstar Approach to Equity Research We evaluate stocks as pieces of a business

5 Big Picture: The Bad Stuff × Unemployment will likely take some time to come down × Many of the jobs created during the last expansion are not coming back soon. Construction, finance, real estate, etc. × High U-6 rates (includes people who are involuntarily part-time) mean that employers can increase hours rather than hiring when demand recovers. × Consumer spending is still ugly × Demand for credit has declined considerably – it may stay down for a while. The politicians squawking about the supply of credit are barking up the wrong tree. × Deleveraging will take a long time. × Credit markets are terra incognita × The Fed has never before intervened on this scale in the bond and mortgage markets. What happens as the much-ballyhooed exit strategy goes forth is anyones guess.

6 Big Picture: More Bad Stuff × Washingtons balance sheet is in bad shape × Govt finances were stretched before crisis, and things are much worse now. × There is zero political will to deal with mandatory spending. Unless we raise taxes, cut defense spending, cut Medicare spending, or cut social security benefits, well be living with a lot of debt for a long time. × Dont shoot me – thats the math. 75% of spending is defense + entitlements. × Valuation is no longer compelling in most markets × Tough to make a cheap argument for most assets. Relatively attractive in spots, maybe, but not cheap. × Our median price/fair value for 1800-stock coverage universe is × Our rolled-up FV for the S&P 500 is ~1250.

7 Defense + Entitlements Are The Big Kahunas

8 Not Expensive…But Not Cheap, Either

9

10 Round Trip

11 Big Picture: The Good Stuff × Truly massive global stimulus – liquidity is still flooding the system × Intervention is working. The question is what happens when it stops. × Credit markets have thawed. × Spreads are down across the board, most to normal (pre-Lehman) levels. × Housing market seems to be thawing × Sales volumes up, prices stabilizing. × A big positive for consumers and for banks. × Manufacturing is coming back nicely × Manufacturing jobs are only 15% of the employment base, but they tend to be relatively well-paying, so the knock-on effect is large. × Earnings could surprise on the upside. × The US economy the S&P 500s earnings stream.

12 Big Picture: More Good Stuff × Maybe valuations arent all that bad × Heck, 12x for JNJ is a steal! × Many high-quality mega-cap stocks are pretty reasonably priced. × Massive cost-cutting may mean that high margins are sustainable × Weve done three years of restructuring in the past year. × MMM revenues down 14%, op margins went from 22.8% to 21.7%. (4Q09) × UNP revenues down 25%, op margins went from 25% to 26%. (4Q09) × U.S. productivity growth was excellent in × Retail investors are very skeptical of the rally. × Equity flows have been barely positive, and bond flows are off the charts × Typically, retail fund flows are a great contrarian indicator

13 Sherman, set the WABAC machine to 1999!

14 WABAC Investing × In , money was pouring into equity funds, and out of bond funds. Why? The 90s were better for stocks than for bonds. × Fast-forward 10 years. From , the S&P 500 was basically flat, while Treasuries have returned 6.5% annually. Result? Now everyone is buying bonds! +$15bn 1-Yr +$400bn 1-Yr

15 Investors are skeptical of the rally March 2000 S&P=1500 October 2002 S&P=820 April 2006 S&P=1300 March 2009 S&P=700

16 Valuations are a lot better than ten years ago S&P Weight TTM P/E Div Yield Microsoft4.9%720.0% General Electric4.1%471.0% Cisco3.0%1330.0% Wal-Mart2.5%570.3% ExxonMobil2.3%342.1% Intel2.2%350.2% Lucent1.9%560.2% IBM1.6%290.5% Citigroup1.5%171.1% America Online1.4%1100.0% Total / Average25.5%590.5% S&P Weight TTM P/E Div Yield ExxonMobil3.4%122.3% Microsoft2.6%181.8% Wal-Mart2.0%152.1% Apple1.8%300.0% P&G1.8%162.9% Google1.8%460.0% JPM1.7%140.5% GE1.7%112.5% J&J1.7%133.2% IBM1.7%131.7% Chevron1.6%93.4% AT&T1.6%136.2% Pfizer1.4%154.5% Total / Average24.8%172.4% December 1999December 2009

17 Wild Cards × Inflation / Deflation × Last January, 10-year TIPS were forecasting 0.5% inflation – now over 2%. Over the same time span, 5-year TIPS have gone from deflation to about 2%. × Weve expanded the money supply and the Feds assets big-time…the source of all those scary charts you see. × Long-term disinflationary tailwinds – productivity growth, increased labor supply from China/India – may be waning. × BUT…the velocity of money hasnt increased much. Most of the money thats been printed is sitting in bank accounts. In some ways, the Fed hasnt really printed money – it has created deposits. × Also, the output gap is quite large in the U.S. – in terms of labor and manufacturing – so perhaps we can grow for a little while before pushing up against any capacity limits.

18 Wild Cards × Valuation × Three sources of returns from equities: Dividends, earnings growth, and changes in valuations (earnings multiples.) Dividends are ~2%. × Were somewhat above the mean long-run multiple now, so future returns depend on multiple expansion or earnings growth. Peak earnings for S&P were $92. If the next peak is lower due to de-leveraging and muted growth…well, put a 15 multiple on $80 and you get BUT if the next peak is just 9% higher than the last one, and the S&P 500 earns $100, then the market is worth 1500 before any multiple expansion. × So, substantial upside from here (S&P ~1200) requires that either the next peak in earnings be higher than the peak, or that multiples expand. × My best guess? It will be a tug of war between a weak U.S. consumer (negative), and higher global growth + the sustainability of higher margins (positives.) Stay tuned!

19 Wild Cards × China × All OK for now – after all, when Beijing says jump, Chinese bankers ask, how high? × But never in the history of mankind has credit expanded at the pace it did in China in 2009 without some eventual fallout. Its not humanly possibly to expand your loan book at >50% year-over-year and maintain prudent lending standards. × Longer-term, demography will be a headwind: × Dependency ratio will increase very rapidly for a relatively low-income country that lacks a social safety net. Currently 11 over-65s per 100 working adults -- this ratio will be 38 in (Equals Japan today, or U.S. in 2050.) × One-child policy + female infanticide = tens of millions of young men who cannot marry or start a family. A potential source of social unrest. × When does the bubble burst? Can Beijing sweep things under the rug like the last time it bailed out the banks? What are the external repercussions? How do the demographics play out? Tough questions to answer.

20 So Now What? × Avoid long-dated Treasuries. Unattractive returns from a borrower with a weakening balance sheet. Jim Grant has called them return-free risk – I agree. × Be careful of high-yield as a group – went from a fat pitch to a bubble in < year. Also, HY bond funds have seen massive inflows -- a good contrarian indicator. × Emerging markets no longer look cheap. Some look downright bubbly. Long-term fundamentals are good, but youre paying a high price for a cheery consensus. × Blue chips (wide moats) with strong balance sheets are very attractive. Go for yield. × Large stocks, on balance, are cheaper than small stocks. × Health Care, Financials look cheap, Tech seems pricey.

21 A Few Ideas × Health Care: Thermo Fisher TMO, Novartis NVS, Stryker SYK × Financial Services: J.P. Morgan Chase JPM, Wells Fargo WFC, BofA BAC, Discover DFS, Capital One COF × Consumer: Apollo Group APOL, Lowes LOW, Molson Coors TAP × Energy: Spectra SE, Range RRC, ExxonMobil XOM × Utilities: National Grid NGG, Westar WR, Exelon XC × Tech: KLA-Tencor KLAC, Applied Materials AMAT, France Telecom FTE

22 Accessing Morningstar Equity Research: Analyst Research Center

23 Institutional Service: Access to Analysts and DCF Models

24 Morningstar Corporate Credit Ratings × Issuer ratings: AAA, AA, A, BBB, etc. × Applies to any senior, unsecured debt of the company × Initial coverage list is 100, growing to 700+ in 2010 × Will include roughly 100 non-U.S. companies (mostly European)

25 Four Scores that Determine the Morningstar Credit Rating × Business Risk × Economic Moat, Uncertainty, Stewardship × Size, Concentration, Dependence on Capital Markets × Cash-Flow Cushion × Based on our proprietary cash-flow models. Uses our five-year forecasts of cash flow, and compares that to debt coming due × No one else has systematic cash-flow forecasts that they can compare with debt coming due × Solvency Score × Based on equation we derived from historical backtesting × Four variables: leverage, interest coverage, liquidity, and profitability × Distance to Default × Market-based measure of financial health × Academically tested

26 Morningstars Corporate Credit Rating Process

27 Credit Research and Ratings for Advisors × Analyst commentary covering × Financial Health × Capital Structure × Enterprise Risk × Thesis & Economic Moat × Data on × Four pillars of our framework × Key credit metrics × Annual cash-flow forecasts × Bond issues and related data (prices, yields, maturities) × Related Services × Feed of credit ratings and rating changes × Conference calls with analysts × Access to Research Liaison Desk Advisor