Post-It Notes to Improve Questionnaire Response Rates in RCTs Findings from a Randomised Sub-Study Ada Keding 1, Helen Lewis 2, Kate Bosanquet 2, Simon.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The CAREDEM feasibility study Joint CIs: Iliffe (UCL) & Robinson (Newcastle University) PIs: Robinson (North east), Livingston (London), Fox (Kent)
Advertisements

Patient experience of smoking lapse and relapse back to smoking Dr Caitlin Notley SSA Research Fellow, Norwich Medical School, University of East Anglia.
Implementation of new technologies Dr Keith Cooper Southampton Health Technology Assessments Centre University of Southampton.
A feasibility study to explore patient, clinician and GP decision making of acute recurrent tonsillitis for NATTINA: The NAtional Trial of Tonsillectomy.
BACKGROUND AND AIM Website: Challenges in conducting a systematic review of the diagnostic accuracy of genetic tests: an example.
Launch Event – 6 th November 2014 Trial Information and Design Isabel Rubie – Trial Manager The NAtional Trial of Tonsillectomy IN Adults: a clinical and.
Aftercare Attendance Partially Moderated by History of Physical Abuse and Gender Louise F. Haynes 1 ; Amy E. Herrin 1 ; Rickey E. Carter 1 ; Sudie E. Back.
Accounting for Psychological Determinants of Treatment Response in Health Economic Simulation Models of Behavioural Interventions A Case Study in Type.
? This project was funded by the National Institute for Health Research Health Technology Assessment (NIHR HTA) Programme (project number 06/301/233) and.
The Cost-Effectiveness of Providing DAFNE to Subgroups of Predicted Responders J Kruger 1, A Brennan 1, P Thokala 1, S Heller 2 on behalf of the DAFNE.
Systematic review of the ‘added value’ for well-being of physical activity in outdoor natural environments Ruth Garside Senior Lecturer in Evidence Synthesis.
Journal Club Alcohol, Other Drugs, and Health: Current Evidence May–June 2013.
John Cape Elizabeth Hancock Colleen Roach Miranda Heneghan Lucy Palmer Lorna Farquharson.
Effect of Physician Asthma Education on Health Care Utilization of Children at Different Income Levels Randall Brown, Noreen Clark, Niko Kaciroti, Molly.
ESH 2004 Paris1 Blood Pressure Control by Home Monitoring A Meta-Analysis of Randomised Trials FP Cappuccio, SM Kerry, L Forbes, A Donald Published in:
Longer term outcomes & Stop smoking services. Study TeamStop Smoking Service Sites Linda Bauld Fiona Dobbie Rosemary Hiscock Jo Leonardi – Bee Andy McEwen.
Journal Club Alcohol, Other Drugs, and Health: Current Evidence January–February 2010.
® Introduction Mental Health Predictors of Pain and Function in Patients with Chronic Low Back Pain Olivia D. Lara, K. Ashok Kumar MD FRCS Sandra Burge,
® Introduction Low Back Pain Remedies and Procedures: Helpful or Harmful? Lauren Lyons, Terrell Benold, MD, Sandra Burge, PhD The University of Texas Health.
MAPPING THE DIABETES HEALTH PROFILE (DHP-18) ONTO THE EQ-5D AND SF-6D GENERIC PREFERENCE BASED MEASURES OF HEALTH Brendan Mulhern 1, Keith Meadows 2, Donna.
Factors that Associated with Stress in Nursing Faculty in Thailand
Description of fracture with endocrine therapy use in older breast cancer survivors in a population-based setting Taryn Becker 123, Geoff Anderson 123,
The cost-effectiveness of providing a DAFNE follow- up intervention to predicted non-responders J Kruger 1, A Brennan 1, P Thokala 1, S Heller 2 on behalf.
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ADOLESCENT/YOUNG ADULT BMI AND SUBSEQUENT NON- PROBLEM AND PROBLEM ALCOHOL USE Alexis E. Duncan, Kathleen Keenan Bucholz, Pamela.
Frequency and type of adverse events associated with treating women with trauma in community substance abuse treatment programs T. KIlleen 1, C. Brown.
A systematic review of school-based skills building behavioural interventions for preventing sexually transmitted infections in young people Jonathan Shepherd.
Severity assessment for lower respiratory tract infections: potential use and validity of CRB-65 in primary care N. Francis, J. Cals, C. Butler, K. Hood,
Complete Recovery of Renal Function After Acute Kidney Injury is Associated with Long-Term All-Cause Mortality In a Large Managed Care Organization Jennifer.
Real-world effectiveness of nicotine replacement therapy in pregnancy Leonie S. Brose, PhD Andy McEwen, PhD & Robert West, PhD University College London.
Norwich Medical School Faculty of Medicine and Health Science Longer-Term Smoking Abstinence after treatment by specialist or non-specialist advisors:
ARROW Trial Design Professor Greg Brooks, Sheffield University, Ed Studies Dr Jeremy Miles York University, Trials Unit Carole Torgerson, York University,
How to Analyze Systematic Reviews: practical session Akbar Soltani.MD. Tehran University of Medical Sciences (TUMS) Shariati Hospital
Core Outcome Domains for Eczema – Results of a Delphi Consensus Project Introduction Eczema is a chronic, relapsing, inflammatory skin disorder that affects.
Evaluation of a web-based educational model to improve nurse recognition of delirium: An RCT McCrow J 1, Beattie E 1, Sullivan K.A. 1, Fick D 2 & Park.
The SCIN (Skin care intervention in nurses) Trial: A Cluster Randomised Trial Dr I. Madan (Guy’s & St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust), Dr V. Parsons (King’s.
Communicating Statistics What is the message? Philip Sedgwick St. George’s, University of London Burwalls: King’s College London. UK Annual Meeting for.
Influence of Comorbid Depression and Antidepressant Treatment on Mortality for Medicare Beneficiaries with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease by SSDI-eligibility.
Hazel Gilbert Research Department of Primary Care and Population Health UCL Medical School Can we involve smokers who are unmotivated to quit in quitting.
“The Effect of Patient Complexity on Treatment Outcomes for Patients Enrolled in an Integrated Depression Treatment Program- a Pilot Study” Ryan Miller,
Pre-notification increases uptake in colorectal cancer screening: a randomised controlled trial Gillian Libby, Jane Bray, Jennifer Champion, Linda Brownlee,
E of computer-tailored S moking C essation A dvice in P rimary car E A Randomised Controlled Trial ffectiveness Hazel Gilbert Department of Primary Care.
The (ab)use of symptom scores in asthma clinical trials: a systematic review Geoff Frampton & Jonathan Shepherd Southampton Health Technology Assessments.
A prevalence study of alcohol amongst offenders in the probation and prison services in North East England Dr. Dorothy Newbury-Birch Senior Research Associate.
Lecture 9: Analysis of intervention studies Randomized trial - categorical outcome Measures of risk: –incidence rate of an adverse event (death, etc) It.
1 Centre for Sport and Exercise Science, Sheffield Hallam University, U. K. 2 York Trials Unit, Department of Health Sciences, University of York, U. K.
[this box will not print/ display] Please note: NIHR Brand Guidance requires you to use their logo as follows: Slides that are:  Introductory should use.
F UNCTIONAL L IMITATIONS IN C ANCER S URVIVORS A MONG E LDERLY M EDICARE B ENEFICIARIES Prachi P. Chavan, MD, MPH Epidemiology PhD Student Xinhua Yu MD.
Multifaceted intervention to improve health worker adherence to Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI) guidelines in Benin* * Published in American.
E of computer-tailored S moking C essation A dvice in P rimary car E ffectiveness Hazel Gilbert, Irwin Nazareth and Richard Morris Department of Primary.
Development and preliminary validation of a dynamic, patient-tailored method to detect abnormal laboratory test results PhD Student: Paolo Fraccaro MEng.
Introduction Results and Conclusions Comparisons of psychiatric hospitalization rates in the 12 months prior to and after baseline assessment revealed.
The authors would like to acknowledge the families at the Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin Jane P. Pettit Pain and Palliative Care Center. For more information,
Janet H. Van Cleave PhD, RN1 Brian Egleston PhD2
Technology to the rescue: A pilot RCT to examine the impact of computerised therapy for long-standing aphasia R Palmer, P Enderby, G Paterson, NIHR CLAHRC.
Correlates of the use of urgent care (UC) and quality of life in patients with 4 long-term physical conditions (CHD, asthma, diabetes and/or COPD). Authors:
Association of Cognitive Outcomes and Response Status in Late Life Depression: A 12 Month Longitudinal Study David Bickford B.A., Alana Kivowitz B.A.,
Fibromyalgia Impact Questionnaire McGill Pain Questionnaire
The DEPression in Visual Impairment Trial:
The use of regular text messaging over one year to collect primary outcome data in an RCT Reuben Ogollah1,2, Martyn Lewis1,2, Kika Konstantinou1 Sarah.
Training package is appropriate
Dr Kerry Woolfall Kerry_woolfall
Preliminary analysis of a new measure of quality of patient decision making about research participation Peter Knapp, Jonathan Graffy, Peter Bower, Jo.
Jessica Wood, Graeme MacLennan & Jemma Hudson
SCIMITAR+: a definitive RCT of a smoking cessation intervention for people with severe mental ill health Emily Peckham.
Quantifying the magnitude and the overlap between frailty, multimorbidity and disability in the very old – results from the Newcastle 85+ Study Michael.
Exercise / Physical Activity as Medicine Special interest group
Helen Barraclough, MSc, Ramaswamy Govindan, MD 
This study/project is funded by/ supported by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) [name of NIHR programme (Grant Reference Number XXX)/name.
This study/project is funded by/ supported by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) [name of NIHR programme (Grant Reference Number XXX)/name.
This study/project is funded by/ supported by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) [name of NIHR programme (Grant Reference Number XXX)/name.
Presentation transcript:

Post-It Notes to Improve Questionnaire Response Rates in RCTs Findings from a Randomised Sub-Study Ada Keding 1, Helen Lewis 2, Kate Bosanquet 2, Simon Gilbody 2, David Torgerson 1 1 York Trials Unit, University of York, UK; 2 Department of Health Sciences, University of York, UK Background Valid treatment effect estimates in the analysis of RCTs using patient reported outcomes depend on adequate response rates. Evidence from non-RCT surveys suggests that inexpensive post-it notes may improve response rates. Introduction Methods Aim To assess the effectiveness of a Post-it® note attached to questionnaires on patient response rate and time to response in an elderly mental health study population. Results Post-it® notes were not found to be effective in improving retention in the elderly population of this trial. However, beneficial effects for sub-groups of clinical populations may exist. Conclusions Design A two-arm RCT (CASPER PiN trial) was embedded into the follow-up of older adults as part of the UK Casper + trial and Casper Shard trial At 4 months follow-up of both trials, participants were randomised 1:1 to receive their follow-up questionnaire with or without a post-it note requesting completion Main Analyses Adjusting for age, gender, main trail treatment allocations and depression at baseline, analyses revealed no statistically significant effect of having received a Post-it® note on response rates, time to return or the need for a reminder at three weeks following the initial questionnaire posting. 817 Casper + and Casper Shard Participants in study time window 4-Month Follow-Up 611 Randomised 314 Follow-up questionnaire without post-it note 297 Follow-up questionnaire with post-it note 206 Withdrawn before 4-Month Follow-up Contact Ada Keding  York Trials Unit StatisticianDepartment of Health Sciences University of York, York, YO10 5DD, UK Funding: The CASPER+ trial was funded by the National Institute for Health Research HTA programme (project number 10/57/43). This ‘trial within a trial’ was funded by the York Trials Unit. Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed therein are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the HTA programme, NIHR, NHS or the Department of Health. Post-it® Note ControlStatisticP-Value Questionnaire Return 89.6%89.8%OR=0.97p=0.913 Median time to return 14 days15 daysHR=1.04p=0.611 Reminder required 30.0%30.9%OR=0.97p=0.875 The Intervention A printed yellow Post-it® note, 3 inches square, attached to the top half of the front page of the questionnaire Signed with the first name of the researcher contact Analysis Questionnaire Return and Need for a Reminder: Logistic regression; Time to Return: Cox proportional hazard model All analyses tested the effect of the intervention while adjusting for treatment arm of the two main Casper trials, depression at baseline, age and gender (interactions with post-it® notes were also explored) Participants Please take a few minutes to complete this for us. Thank you. Jane Post-it® Note Control Mean Age (SD)74.3 (6.83)73.8 (6.27) Female176 (59%)188 (60%) Major Depressive Episode 134 (45%)167 (53%) Subthreshold Depression 163 (55%)147 (47%) Sub-group Analyses An exploratory analysis showed that participants with major depression were more likely, and participants with sub-threshold depression less likely to respond to post-it® notes (p-value of interaction = 0.019). p=0.019 Source Trials Casper + trial: RCT of Collaborative Care versus Usual Care in people aged 65 and over with major depressive episode symptoms Casper Shard trial: RCT of a Guided Self-Help Booklet versus Usual Care in people aged 65 and over with sub-threshold depressive symptoms Table 2: Effect of post-it note allocation on trial outcomes Figure 2: Questionnaire Return by Baseline Depression Table 1: Baseline characteristics Figure 1: Kaplan-Meier plot for time to return