Patrick Corrigan Illinois Institute of Technology WHAT SAYS THE DODO BIRD?
STOP
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES Everybody has won and all must have prizes!
“THE POOR!” “THE WEAK!” “THE LEAST IMPORTANT!” “Whatsoever you did to the least of my brethren, that you do unto me!” Matthew 25
“THE POOR!” “THE WEAK!” “ THE LEAST IMPORTANT! ” “Whatsoever you do to the least of my brethren, that you do unto me!” John BESTOW EMPOWER
Stigma is Bad ◦ Public stigma ◦ Self-stigma Not all ways to address stigma work! ◦ Unintended consequences GOALS 7
9
10
12 People with mental illness are homicidal maniacs In the movies
13
14
18 Benevolence stigma
19
20
Trenton State Hospital has fire.
22 Roasted Nuts
STOP
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES Everybody has won and all must have prizes!
BEWARE easy answers and easy remedies
Has Stigma Changed? DANGER Phelan, Link et al 26
Has Stigma Changed? DANGER Phelan, Link et al 27
Has Stigma Changed? DANGER Phelan, Link et al 28
Has Stigma Changed? DANGER Phelan, Link et al 29
EASY STUFF: Just change the words! Just cure the disease!
Leprosy to Hansen’s Disease Dementia to Alzheimer’s Mental Retardation to Intellectual Disability Leprosy to Hansen’s Disease Mania to Bipolar Illness seishin bunretsu to togo shitco sho “mind split disease” “integration disorder”
The Data ◦ Japan: mixed findings (Takashi et al., 2009, 2011) ◦ Hansen’s Disease (Oliveria et al., 2003; Van Brakel et al., in press) Perpetuates the difference Prejudice and discrimination more than words. ◦ MODERN RACISM
Stigma is deserved ◦ Because symptoms are abnormal (Gove, 1975) ◦ People with mental illness are dangerous (Torrey) WRONG! ◦ Link’s research program on the effects of label Breast cancer HIV-AIDS STIGMA CURE Corrigan, (in press) Stigma, Disease, and Disability Washington, DC: APA
EASY STUFF: Just change the words! Just cure the disease! CRITICAL UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES
35 Framing Stigma Change Protest Education Contact Media- based In vivo vehiclevehicle processes
KNOWLEDGE IS GOLD: Educate stigma away!
37 Framing Stigma Change Protest Education Contact Media- based In vivo vehiclevehicle processes EDUCATION
RECOVERY
HIRE THEM? RENT TO THEM? EQUAL HEALTH CARE?
41 Framing Stigma Change Protest Education Contact Media- based In vivo vehiclevehicle processes MEDIA
MEDIA: Problem or Solution
NEWS HEADLINES
2003., SOMETIMES THE STATE’S DEAD MUST TEACH Landauer …the tragic story of Billy Owens, a convict with mental illness who stabbed himself to death in an Oregon prison cell surrounded by guards untrained to address his symptoms , BEAUTIFUL MINDS CAN BE RECOVERED Harding …combining the story of Nobel Laureate John Nash with the empirical evidence from long- term follow-up research that people with serious mental illness recover. Fellowships for Mental Health Journalism Control: Dental Health
COERCION Corrigan, Powell, & Michaels in press
COERCION
RECOVERY
Is not always to reduce stigma. Dead Must Teach ◦ Major Overhauls to Oregon’s Mental Health System
HEADLINES RECOVERY… Is boring.
A High-Profile Executive Job as Defense Against Mental Illness Keris Myrick, Oct 22, 2011
SOCIAL MEDIA Its Promise and Limitations
What a DIFFERENCE a friend makes!
Real Warriors + Real Battles Real Strengths
Connecting Veterans and their friends and family members with information, resources, and solutions to issues affecting their health, well- being, and everyday lives. MAKETHECONNECTION.NET
What a DIFFERENCE a friend makes!
57
58 Website visits
59 Odds Ratio 2.81***
60 Effect Size MILLIONS thousands
61 Effect Size MILLIONS thousands Just going to the site is not enough 88% left after one minute!
The possibilities of the population
The age of social media
The possibilities of the population The need for the grassroots
GOAL: Get into treatment. Get rightful opportunity: work, housing.
Penetration and Impact Jorm - Griffiths - Highet Christensen
Penetration 44-60%
Impact MH literacy Stigma
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES Brain Disease Benevolence Stigma
Patrick Corrigan Illinois Institute of Technology WHAT MIGHT WE DO?
BEWARE easy answers and easy remedies
Clifford Beers
“Nothing about us without us!” Judi Chamberlin
78 Framing Stigma Change Protest Education Contact Media- based In vivo vehiclevehicle processes CONTACT
79 Contact “Meet Bob Lundin”
80 Bob’s story ◦ My name is ______ and I have a severe mental illness called schizo-affective disorder ◦ My childhood was not unusual… ◦ Unfortunately, my mental illness was traumatic. It did not go away quickly… ◦ Despite these problems, I have achieved several accomplishments.
Contact vs Education DV’s ◦ Overall ◦ Attitudes ◦ Behavior > 38,000 Ss 79 studies; 13 RCTs Corrigan, Michaels et al., 2012
p<.05
TLC 3
Targeted Local Credible Continuous Contact TLC3 84 Corrigan, 2011
Targets Landlords Health care professionals Teachers Legislators Employers
x CHICAGO: the heart and brains of Illinois ILLINOIS Does it play in PEORIA?
City Office Church, synagogue, mosque School 90 Local
91 Good stigma change credible continuous
Contact with whom? Example ◦ Military (PTSD) ◦ Other enlisted members Marines from marines Sailors from sailors Credible 92
Once is not enough And cannot be carbon copies Continuous 93
Targeted Local Credible Continuous Contact TLC3 94
The GRAND PLAN
Come out everyone Come out everywhere
the Grand Plan Come out Mad Come out Proud
DON’T BE A MENTAL PATIENT
EMBRACE WHO YOU ARE
Accomplishment ◦ Overcoming disability Who I am ◦ Ethnic pride Authenticity
Three Lessons ◦ Consider the pros and cons of disclosing ◦ There are different ways to disclose ◦ Telling your story
Clifford Beers
National Center on Stigma and Empowerment