Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX 77843-3116 (USA) Slide — 1/80 Rate-Decline.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Azimuthal Correlation Studies Via Correlation Functions and Cumulants N. N. Ajitanand Nuclear Chemistry, SUNY, Stony Brook.
Advertisements

Analytical Solutions for a Composite, Cylindrical Reservoir with a Power-Law Permeability Distribution in the Inner Cylinder Ryan Sawyer Broussard Department.
Liquid Loading Current Status, New Models and Unresolved Questions
Jan – Dec, 2006 University of Alaska – Fairbanks Pacific Northwest National Laboratory British Petroleum Exploration Alaska Injection of CO 2 for Recovery.
2010 SPWLA Topical Conference
Presentation to Repsol by MYS on 9/13/06 Well Completion Design for Tight-Gas Formations M. Y. Soliman, PhD September 20, 2006 Mendoza, Argentina.
Harold Vance Department of Petroleum Engineering
SPE PP A Method for Probabilistic Forecasting of Oil Rates in Naturally Fractured Reservoirs Julio César Muñoz Blanco y Rafael Paz Palenzuela, CBM.
Reservoir Engineering Aspects of Unconventional Reservoirs
Well Testing — Historical Perspectives
Decline Curve Analysis Using Type Curves —
Imbibition Assisted Recovery
Analysis of Production Data
Analysis of Layered Gas Reservoir Performance Using a Quasi-Analytical Solution for Rate and Pressure Behavior I Nengah Suabdi Department of Petroleum.
Evaluation of Reservoir Performance Using Decline Type Curves Improve Reservoir Description - Area Central Norte (ACN) Region, El Tordillo Field Argentina.
SPE Analysis and Interpretation of
Hydrologic Characterization of Fractured Rocks for DFN Models.
Vivek Muralidharan Simulation and imaging experiments of fluid flow through a fracture surface: a new perspective.
“Don’t Forget Viscosity” Dave Bergman BP America July 28, 2004
Geologic Analysis of Naturally Fractured Reservoirs 2nd Edition, R. A
Chapter 1 RESERVOIR.
Thesis Defense College Station, TX (USA) — 05 September 2013 Landon RISER Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX.
Principal Investigators: Ding Zhu and A. D. Hill
SPE Distinguished Lecturer Program The SPE Distinguished Lecturer Program is funded principally through a grant from the SPE Foundation. The society gratefully.
Option Values of Alternative Completion and Production Strategies in Shale Gas Plays Janie M Chermak, University of New Mexico James Crafton, Performance.
Optimizing In Fill Well Drilling - Wamsutter Field
Semi-Analytical Rate Relations for Oil and Gas Flow
Schlumberger Public Scope and Application of Pressure Transient Tests in CBM and Shale Gas reservoirs Baijayanta Ghosh Reservoir Domain Champion Testing.
1 Study of Pressure Front Propagation in a Reservoir from a Producing Well by Hsieh, B.Z., Chilingar, G.V., Lin, Z.S. May 4, 2007.
07 April 2010 Denver, CO OPTIMIZING DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES TO INCREASE RESERVES IN UNCONVENTIONAL GAS RESERVOIRS Presented to: RPSEA Unconventional Gas.
Pseudopressure Function
OIL RECOVERY MECHANISMS AND THE MATERIAL BALANCE EQUATION
Reserve Evaluation for Enhance Oil Recovery Purposes Using Dynamic Reserve Evaluation Model Woodside Research Facility GPO Box U 1987 Perth West Australia.
Modelling Unconventional Wells with Resolve and Reveal Juan Biörklund (Gauloise Energía) and Georg Ziegler (Wintershall Holding)
Calgary Petroleum Club – February 19, 2013 “Production Performance Unique Type Curve for Horizontal, Multi-Stage Frac'd Gas Wells: WHY, HOW and WHEN!”
Production Analysis of Western Canadian Unconventional Light Oil Plays (SPE ) C.R. Clarkson and P.K. Pedersen T O C © TOC, 2011.
Fluid Saturation Introduction
Integration of Production Analysis and Rate-Time Analysis via Parametric Correlations — Montney Shale Case Histories Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum.
Well Performance Analysis in a Multiwell Gas Condensate Reservoir— Arun Field, Indonesia T. Marhaendrajana, Texas A&M University N.J. Kaczorowski, Mobil.
Michael Fay VP, Software Development. Well Production Forecasting Requirements For efficiency, the method should be simple (e.g. no simulation or complex.
Boyd Russell A Practical Guide to Unconventional Petroleum Evaluation Petroleum Club November 28, 2012 R eservoir E valuation P roduction O ptimization.
Final Presentation College Station, TX (USA) — 11 August 2015 Chulhwan SONG Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX.
Title: SHAPE OPTIMIZATION OF AXISYMMETRIC CAVITATOR IN PARTIALY CAVITATING FLOW Department of Mechanical Engineering Ferdowsi University of Mashhad Presented.
Capillary Pressure Brooks and Corey Type Curve
Produced Water Reinjection Performance Joint Industry Project TerraTek, Inc. Triangle Engineering Taurus Reservoir Solutions (DE&S) E-first Technologies.
A Semianalytical p/z Technique Abnormally Pressured Gas Reservoirs
History Matching Flowmeter Data in the Ghawar Field
Case Study : History Matching of Well by Predictive Material Balance Term Project : Advanced Reservoir Engineering Presented By, Namit J Jaiswal B.E (Chemical)
Abnormally Pressured Gas Reservoirs
27 May, 2011 — College Station, TX Study of Nonideal and Secondary Fractures O.M. Olorode Slide — 1/18 A Numerical Study of Nonideal and Secondary Fractures.
Diffusivity Equations for Flow in Porous Media PETE 613 (2005A) Slide — 1 T.A. Blasingame, Texas A&M U. Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University.
Production Analysis of Eagle Ford Shale Gas Wells using Time-Rate Relations Avery DAVIS Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College.
Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX (USA) Antu Xie Modelling Concepts for Fracture.
SPE What Factors Control Shale Gas Production Decline Trend: A Comprehensive Analysis and Investigation HanYi Wang, The University of Texas at Austin.
Final Presentation College Station, TX (USA) — 11 August 2015 Chulhwan SONG Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX.
APPLICATION OF MULTIPLE WELL DECONVOLUTION METHOD IN A NORTH SEA FIELD EMMA THORNTON 1 SUPERVISORS: ALAIN GRINGARTEN (IMPERIAL COLLEGE) JALAL MAZLOOM,
Chapter 5 Well Testing (III)
Chapter 5 Pressure Transient Testing (I)
Brooks-Corey MICP Model Parameters Determination
SPE DISTINGUISHED LECTURER SERIES
GMS Geostatistical Realizations CMG-STARS Results
Decline Curve Analysis Using Type Curves —
MS Thesis Defense — Fall 2016
Masters of Science Thesis Defense
Upscaling of 4D Seismic Data
Capillary Pressure Brooks and Corey Type Curve
Gas Condensate Blockage
Gas Condensate Blockage
Capillary Pressure: Reservoir Seal Capillary Pressure / Saturation Relationship (Sw* Model) .
SPEGC Northside Study Group “Unconventional Reservoir Horizontal, Multi-Stage Completion Design Optimization” Presented by Stephen Schubarth President.
Presentation transcript:

Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX (USA) Slide — 1/80 Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties

Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX (USA) Slide — 2/80 Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Introduction

● Overview ● Performance Analysis of Time-Rate Models ■ Power-Law Exponential Model (PLE) ■ Duong Model ■ Logistic Growth Model (LGM) ● Rationale ■ Diagnostic Functions for Time-Rate Data Analysis ■ "Continuous EUR" Analysis to Estimate Reserves ● Development of New Time-Rate Relations ■ D-Parameter Modification ■ q/G p versus Time – Diagnostic Plot Analysis ■ K/G p -1 versus Time – Diagnostic Plot Analysis ● Rationale ■ Duong Model: D-parameter Modification (MDNG – 1) ■ LGM Model: D-parameter Modification (MLNG – 1) ■ Duong Model: q/G p Data Analysis (MDNG – 2) ■ LGM Model: K/G p -1 Modification (MLNG – 2) Presentation Outline Slide — 3/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Outline) ●○

● Preliminary study: Integration Of Production Data Analysis And Time-rate Analysis Via Parametric Correlations – Theoretical Consideration ● Rationale ■ Time-Rate Data Analysis of Numerical Simulation Cases ■ Cross-Plot Analysis of Time-Rate Model Parameters and Reservoir Properties (Fracture Conductivity (Fc) and EUR) ■ Development of Parametric Correlation ● Summary, Conclusions and Recommendations Presentation Outline Slide — 4/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Outline) ●●

● Definitions ■ D-parameter: Inverse of "loss-ratio" relation. Definition of "loss-ratio" ■ b-parameter: Derivative of "loss-ratio". ■ b -derivative: Constant pressure production: Diagnostic Functions (Background): Slide — 5/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Background) ●○○○○ Johnson, R.H. and Bollens, A.L The Loss Ratio Method of Extrapolating Oil Well Decline Curves. Trans. AIME: 160, ] Arps J.J Analysis of Decline Curves. Trans. AIME: 160, ] Ilk, D., Currie, S.M., Symmons, D. et al Hybrid Rate-Decline Models for the Analysis of Production Performance in Unconventional Reservoirs. Paper presented at the SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Florence, Italy. Society of Petroleum Engineers

● History: ■ SPE (Ilk et al., 2008) ■ Derived from data D-parameter ■ Analogous to Stretched-Exponential, but derived independently ■ Has a terminal term for boundary-dominated flow (D ∞ ) ● Governing Relations: Time-Rate Relations (Background): Power-Law Exponential Model (PLE) Slide — 6/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties ■ Rate-Time Relation: ■ D-parameter ■ b-parameter ■ b-derivative: (Background) ●●○○○

● History: ■ SPE (Duong, 2011) ■ Based on extended linear/bilinear flow regime ■ Derived from transient behavior of unconventional-fractured reservoirs ■ Relation extracted from straight line behavior of q/G p vs. Time (Log-Log) plot ● Governing Relations: Time-Rate Relations (Background): Duong Model Slide — 7/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Background) ●●●○○ ■ Rate-Time Relation: ■ D-parameter ■ b-parameter ■ b-derivative: ■ Base Relation:

● History ■ SPE (Clark et al., 2011) ■ Adopted from population growth models ■ Modified form of hyperbolic logistic growth models ● Governing Relations: Time-Rate Relations (Background): Logistic Growth Model (LGM) Slide — 8/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Background) ●●●●○ ■ Rate-Time Relation: ■ D-parameter ■ b-parameter ■ b-derivative: ■ Cumulative Production Relation: K = Carrying Capacity

● History ■ SPE (Currie et al., 2010) ■ Continuous Estimation of EUR with Time ■ To Reduce Uncertainty in Reserve Estimation ■ Time-Rate Relations EUR Estimates are Compared ■ Rate of convergence is compared "Continuous EUR" Analysis (Background): Slide — 9/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Background) ●●●●● Cumulative Production versus Production Time

Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX (USA) Slide — 10/80 Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Performance Analysis of Time-Rate Relations

● Performance Study ■ PLE model ■ Duong model ■ Logistic Growth Model (LGM) ● A diagnostic Approach ■ Diagnostic Plots ■ Data Driven matching process Introduction Slide — 11/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties ● Approach ■ Continuous evaluation of D(t), b(t), and b(t) relations provide a diagnostic method for matching time-rate data.

● PLE, LGM and Duong Models. ■ All models match transient flow-regimes very well. ■ In the absence of boundary-dominated flow, all models provide reliable EUR estimate. ● Numerical Simulation Case: k = 50 nD Slide — 12/80 Theoretical Consideration: Time-rate analysis Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties

Slide — 13/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties ● General: ■ 50 nd case. ■ All models shown. ● PLE Model: ■ Very good match. ■ Indistinguishable. ● Doung Model: ■ Very good match. ■ Indistinguishable. ● LGM Model: ■ Very good match. ■ Indistinguishable. 50 nd Simulation Case Time-Rate Analysis: PLE, Duong, and LGM Models

● PLE Model ■ Transient ■ Transitional and ■ boundary-dominated flow regimes. ● LGM Model ■ Transient and ■ Transitional flow regimes. ● Duong Model ■ Transient flow regimes. ● Numerical Simulation Case: k = 2,000 nD Slide — 14/80 Theoretical Consideration: Time-rate analysis Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties

Slide — 15/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties ● General: ■ 2,000 nd case. ■ G p,30yr = 14.2 BSCF ■ All models shown. ● PLE Model: ■ Very good match. ■ Matches BDF regime. ■ G p,30yr = 14.7 BSCF (3.5%) ● Doung Model: ■ Very good match. ■ Does NOT match BDF. ■ G p,30yr = 19.5 BSCF (37.3%) ● LGM Model: ■ Very good match. ■ Fair match of BDF. ■ G p,30yr = 17.5 BSCF (23.2%) 2000 nd Simulation Case Time-Rate Analysis: PLE, Duong, and LGM Models

Slide — 16/80 "Continuous EUR" Analysis: ● EUR is estimated as a function of time. ● Continuous EUR approach: ■ To compare performance of PLE, LGM and Duong time-rate relations at estimating reserves. ■ To compare rate of convergence of EUR. ● 30 year reserve estimates are determined. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties

Slide — 17/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Power-Law Exponential Model Numerical Simulation Case – Numerical Simulation Case ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● D ∞ -parameter used once boundary- dominated flow regime is attained. ● PLE model results in quality match at all intervals. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Numerical Simulation Case ) ●○○○

Slide — 18/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Duong Model Numerical Simulation Case – Numerical Simulation Case Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Numerical Simulation Case ) ●●○○ ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● Lacks boundary behavior. ● Good match in early transient periods. ● Data match is forced.

Slide — 19/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Logistic Growth Model Numerical Simulation Case – Numerical Simulation Case Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Numerical Simulation Case ) ●●●○ ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● Excellent match during transient and transition flow periods. ● Lacks boundary characteristics. ● Data match is forced.

Slide — 20/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Numerical Simulation Case – 30 year EUR estimate Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● PLE model EUR values have converged to a reliable reserve estimate. ● Duong and LGM models have converged at a higher reserve estimate. ● LGM and PLE converge faster. (Numerical Simulation Case ) ●●●● ● Model 30 year reserve estimate: ■ PLE= BSCF ■ Duong model= 16.1 BSCF ■ LGM model= 15.6 BSCF

● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● Very good match during transient and transition flow periods. ● Boundary-dominated flow regime is not observed. ● D ∞ -parameter is not used. Slide — 21/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Power-Law Exponential Model East Texas Gas Well Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Tx Tight Gas Well) ●○○○

Slide — 22/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Duong Model East Texas Tight Gas Well Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Tx Tight Gas Well) ●●○○ ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● Very good match during transient and transition flow periods. ● Boundary-dominated flow regime is not observed.

Slide — 23/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Logistic Growth Model East Texas Tight Gas Well Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Tx Tight Gas Well) ●●●○ ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● Very good match during transient and transition flow periods. ● Boundary-dominated flow regime is not observed.

Slide — 24/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: East Texas Tight Gas Well – 30 year EUR Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Tx Tight Gas Well) ●●●● ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● PLE model has converged faster ● All models result in a similar reserve estimates. ● Model reserve esimates are similar when boundary- dominated flow regime is not observed. ● Model 30 year reserve estimate: ■ PLE= 2.98 BSCF ■ Duong model= 3.15 BSCF ■ LGM model= 2.95 BSCF

Slide — 25/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Power-Law Exponential Model East Texas Tight Gas Well – Numerical Simulation Case Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Tx Tight Gas Well – Num. Sim) ●○○○ ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● Very good match during transient, transition and boundary-dominated flow periods. ● Boundary-dominated flow regime is observed. ● D ∞ -parameter used.

Slide — 26/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Duong Model East Texas Tight Gas Well – Numerical Simulation Case Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Tx Tight Gas Well – Num. Sim) ●●○○ ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● Very good match during early transient flow periods. ● Poor match quality during boundary flow periods. ● Model match is forced.

Slide — 27/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: Logistic Growth Model East Texas Tight Gas Well – Numerical Simulation Case Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Tx Tight Gas Well – Num. Sim) ●●●○ ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● Very good match during transient and transition flow periods. ● Poor match quality during boundary flow periods. ● Model match is forced.

Slide — 28/80 Continuous EUR Analysis: East Texas Tight Gas Well – Numerical Simulation Case Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Tx Tight Gas Well – Num. Sim) ●●●● ● EUR is estimated every 60 days. ● Simulation data is projected to 30 years. ● PLE model has converged faster. ● PLE model D ∞ -parameter provides a hard constraint. ● Duong and LGM model overestimate reserves and converge slowly. ● Time-rate models 30 year reserve estimate: ■ PLE= 2.32 BSCF ■ Duong model= 3.30 BSCF ■ LGM model= 2.61 BSCF

Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX (USA) Slide — 29/80 Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties New Time-Rate Relations

● Modified Duong Model ■ With boundary parameter, D DNG ■ Boundary-dominated flow can be modeled. ■ Derivation is based on loss-ratio definition (similar to PLE). The modified form of D-parameter is given by: ■ It is derived by assuming constant loss-ratio during boundary- dominated flow regimes. ■ New time-rate relation can be derived from the loss-ratio relation. It is given by: ■ Cumulative production relation can not be derived. Numerical methods are necessary. Slide — 30/80 Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified Duong Model – 1 (MDNG 1) Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (New-Relations – MDNG – 1) ●○○

● MDNG – 1 ■ The b-parameter is given by: ● MDNG – 1 ■ Boundary-dominated flows can be modeled EUR estimates are constrained. ■ Exponential decline characterizes boundary-dominated flow. Slide — 31/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified Duong Model – 1 (MDNG – 1) (New-Relations – MDNG – 1) ●●○

● Derived based on loss-ratio derivation of Duong Model. ● Modified Duong Model ■ Boundary-dominated flows can be modeled. ■ EUR estimates are constrained. ■ Exponential decline characterizes boundary- dominated flow. Slide — 32/80 Added Constant Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (New-Relations – MDNG – 1) ●●● Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified Duong Model – 1 (MDNG 1)

● MDNG – 2 ■ With boundary parameter D DNG ■ Boundary-dominated flow can be modeled. ■ Based on q/G p Vs. time diagnostic plot. ■ New q/Gp model-relation: ■ New time-rate relation: ■ New Cumulative production relation: Slide — 33/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (New-Relations – MDNG – 2) ●○○○ Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified Duong Model – 2 (MDNG – 2)

Slide — 34/80 ● q/G p vs. Time — Diagnostic Plot ● On log-log plot of q/Gp vs. time: ■ Transient flow can be characterized by a power- law relation, and ■ Boundary-dominated flow can be characterized by an exponential decline relation. ■ q/Gp data can be matched with the following relation: Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified Duong Model – 2 (MDNG 2) (New-Relations – MDNG – 2) ●●○○

● Modified Duong Model – 2 (MDNG – 2) ■ The D-parameter is given by: ■ The b-parameter is given by: Slide — 35/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified Duong Model – 2 (MDNG 2) (New-Relations – MDNG – 2) ●●●○

Slide — 36/80 ● Model schematics ■ Duong Model ■ MDNG – 1 ■ MDNG – 2 ● New relations show boundary characteristics to model boundary- dominated flow regimes. ● EUR is constrained. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Modified Time-Rate Models: Duong and Modified Duong Models ( ) (New-Relations) ●●●●

Slide — 37/80 ● Modified Logistic Growth Model ■ With boundary parameter D LGM ■ Boundary-dominated flow can be modeled. ■ Derivation is based on loss-ratio definition. The modified form of D-parameter is given by: ■ New time-rate relation can be derived from the loss-ratio relation. It is given by: ■ Cumulative production relation can not be derived. Numerical methods are necessary. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (New-Relations – MLGM – 1) ●○○○ Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified LGM Model – 1 (MLGM – 1)

Slide — 38/80 ● MLGM – 1 ■ The b-parameter is given by: ● MLGM – 1 ■ Boundary-dominated flows can be modeled. ■ EUR estimates are constrained. ■ Exponential decline characterizes boundary-dominated flow. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (New-Relations – MLGM – 1) ●●○○ Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified LGM Model – 1 (MLGM – 1)

Slide — 39/80 ● Modified Logistic Growth Model: ■ Boundary-dominated flows can be modeled accurately. ■ EUR estimates are constrained. ■ Exponential decline characterizes boundary-dominated flow. ● Prior knowledge of gas in place (K) is required. ● Direct formulation of Gp is not possible. Numerical methods are necessary. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (New-Relations – MLGM – 1) ●●●○ Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified LGM Model – 1 (MLGM – 1)

Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified LGM Model – 2 (MLGM – 2) Slide — 40/80 ● Using Diagnostic plot of [K/Q g – 1] vs. time From LGM Model we have ● The last relation suggests that a log-log plot of K/Q g – 1 versus time shows a power-law relation for transient flow regimes. ● Now, we can suggest the following relation with modification for boundary dominated flow regimes. Where K = Initial Gas in Place. R = Remaining Gas Reserve at t ∞. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (New-Relations – MLGM – 2) ●○○○

Slide — 41/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties ● If K is known, we can estimate parameters a and n from the transient flow regime. ●.D LGM can be modified based on boundary behaviors. a= 161 n= 0.79 K= 20,219, D lgm = R= Modified Logistic Growth Model: Diagnostic Plot Corrected K/Q-1 Relation (MODEL 4)

Slide — 42/80 ● Now, we can derive the associated modified relations. R = Remaining Gas Reserve at t ∞ ● Cumulative Production [G p (t)] relation can be derived for MLGM – 2. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (New-Relations – MLGM – 2) ●●●○ Modified Time-Rate Models: Modified LGM Model – 2 (MLGM – 2)

Slide — 43/80 ● Model schematics ■ LGM ■ MLGM – 1 ■ MLGM – 2 ● New relations show boundary characteristics to model boundary- dominated flow regimes. ● EUR is constrained. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Modified Time-Rate Models: LGM and Modified LGM Models ( ) (New-Relations) ●●●●

Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX (USA) Slide — 44/80 Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties New Time-Rate Relations Validation

Slide — 45/80 ■ Numerical Simulation Model – East Texas Tight Gas Well ● Hydraulically fractured vertical well in a tight gas reservoir. ● About 6 years of production data is available. ● Boundary-dominated flow regime is established. ● k = md ● G p,max = 1.82 BSCF Numerical Simulation Case: East Texas Tight Gas Well – MDNG – 2 Model Analysis Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Texas Tight Gas Well) ●○○○○

Slide — 46/80 ● MDNG-2 model parameters are estimated on a log-log plot of q/G p versus time plot. ● q t1 is estimated from the rate data at t = t 1. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (East Texas Tight Gas Well) ●●○○○ ■ q/G p versus time Plot Analysis Numerical Simulation Case: East Texas Tight Gas Well – MDNG – 2 Model Analysis

Slide — 47/80 ● MLGM-2 model parameters are estimated on a log-log plot of K/Q(t)-1 versus time plot. ● A prior estimate of initial gas in place (K) is required ● Gas in Place (K) = 2.65 BSCF (numerical simulation input) Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties ■ K/Q(t)-1 versus time Plot Analysis Numerical Simulation Case: East Texas Tight Gas Well – MLGM – 2 Model Analysis (East Texas Tight Gas Well) ●●●○○

Slide — 48/80 ● Model Match on q, D-,b- parameter and b-derivative versus time Log-Log plot ● All models match transient flow regimes. ● PLE and the new models match the transient and the boundary-dominated flow regimes. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Numerical Simulation Case: East Texas Tight Gas Well – PLE, Duong, LGM, MDNG – 1, MDNG – 2, MLGM – 1, and MLGM – 1 models (East Texas Tight Gas Well) ●●●●○

Slide — 49/80 ● PLE and New time-rate relations result in excellent match to the boundary conditions. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Numerical Simulation Case: East Texas Tight Gas Well – PLE, Duong, LGM, MDNG – 1, MDNG – 2, MLGM – 1, and MLGM – 2 models (East Texas Tight Gas Well) ●●●●● Numerical Simulation Case Gp,max = 1.82 BSCF ■Duong Model= 2.37 BSCF ■LGM= 1.95 BSCF ■PLE= 1.84 BSCF ■MDNG – 1 = 1.80 BSCF ■MDNG – 2 = 1.79 BSCF ■MLGM – 1 = 1.77 BSCF ■MLGM – 2 = 1.78 BSCF

Slide — 50/80 ■ Numerical Simulation Model – Barnet Shale Gas Well ● Hydraulically fractured well in a shale gas reservoir. ● About 10 years of production data is available. ● Boundary-dominated flow regime is established. ● G p,max = 0.84 BSCF Field Case: Barnet Shale Gas Well Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Barnet Shale Gas Well) ●○○○○

Slide — 51/80 ● MDNG-2 model parameters are estimated on a log-log plot of q/G p versus time plot. ● q t1 is estimated from the rate data at t = t 1. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Barnet Shale Gas Well) ●●○○○ ■ q/G p versus time Plot Analysis Field Case: Barnet Shale Gas Well – MDNG – 2 Model Analysis

Slide — 52/80 ● MLGM-2 model parameters are estimated on a log-log plot of K/Q(t)-1 versus time plot. ● A prior estimate of initial gas in place (K) is required ● Gas in Place (K) (estimate)= 1.31 BSCF Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties ■ K/Q(t)-1 versus time Plot Analysis Field Case: Barnet Shale Gas Well – MLGM – 2 Model Analysis (Barnet Shale Gas Well) ●●●○○

Slide — 53/80 ● Model Match on q, D-,b- parameter and b-derivative versus time Log-Log plot ● All models match transient flow regimes. ● PLE and the new models match the transient and the boundary-dominated flow regimes. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Field Case: Barnet Shale Gas Well – PLE, Duong, LGM, MDNG – 1, MDNG – 2, MLGM – 1, and MLGM – 1 models (Barnet Shale Gas Well) ●●●●○

Slide — 54/80 ● PLE and New time-rate relations result in excellent match to the boundary conditions. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Field Case: Barnet Shale Gas Well– PLE, Duong, LGM, MDNG – 1, MDNG – 2, MLGM – 1, and MLGM – 2 models (Barnet Shale Gas Well) ●●●●● Barnet Shale Gas Well Gp,max = 0.84 BSCF ■Duong Model= 1.20 BSCF ■LGM= 1.10 BSCF ■PLE= 0.79 BSCF ■MDNG – 1 = 0.78 BSCF ■MDNG – 2 = 0.82 BSCF ■MLGM – 1 = 0.80 BSCF ■MLGM – 2 = 0.78 BSCF

Slide — 55/80 ■ Numerical Simulation Model – Mexico Tight Gas Well ● Hydraulically fractured vertical well in a tight gas reservoir. ● k < md ● About 40 years of production data is available. ● Boundary-dominated flow regime is established. ● G p,max = BSCF Field Case: Mexico Tight Gas Well Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Mexico Tight Gas Well) ●○○○○

Slide — 56/80 ● MDNG-2 model parameters are estimated on a log-log plot of q/G p versus time plot. ● q t1 is estimated from the rate data at t = t 1. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties (Mexico Tight Gas Well) ●●○○○ ■ q/G p versus time Plot Analysis Field Case: Mexico Tight Gas Well – MDNG – 2 Model Analysis

Slide — 57/80 ● MLGM-2 model parameters are estimated on a log-log plot of K/Q(t)-1 versus time plot. ● A prior estimate of initial gas in place (K) is required ● Gas in Place (K) =22.96 BSCF Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties ■ K/Q(t)-1 versus time Plot Analysis Field Case: Mexico Tight Gas Well – MLGM – 2 Model Analysis (Mexico Tight Gas Well) ●●●○○

Slide — 58/80 ● Model Match on q, D-,b- parameter and b-derivative versus time Log-Log plot ● All models match transient flow regimes. ● PLE and the new models match the transient and the boundary-dominated flow regimes. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Field Case: Mexico Tight Gas Well – PLE, Duong, LGM, MDNG – 1, MDNG – 2, MLGM – 1, and MLGM – 1 models (Mexico Tight Gas Well) ●●●●○

Slide — 59/80 ● PLE and New time-rate relations result in excellent match to the boundary conditions. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Field Case: Mexico Tight Gas Well– PLE, Duong, LGM, MDNG – 1, MDNG – 2, MLGM – 1, and MLGM – 2 models (Mexico Tight Gas Well) ●●●●● Mexico Tight Gas Well Gp,max = BSCF ■Duong Model= BSCF ■LGM= BSCF ■PLE= BSCF ■MDNG – 1 = BSCF ■MDNG – 2 = BSCF ■MLGM – 1 = BSCF ■MLGM – 2 = BSCF

Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX (USA) Slide — 60/80 Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Development of Parametric Correlation

■ Ilk et al., (2011) have demonstrated that rate-time parameters can be correlated with reservoir/well parameters using limited well data from unconventional reservoirs. ■ Theoretical Consideration (Preliminary Study) is presented using production data generated from unconventional reservoirs. Objectives/ Problem Statement: Slide — 61/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Ilk, D., Rushing, J.A., and Blasingame, T.A Integration of Production Analysis and Rate-Time Analysis Via Parametric Correlations -- Theoretical Considerations and Practical Applications. Paper presented at the SPE Hydraulic Fracturing Technology Conference, The Woodlands, Texas, USA

Reservoir Properties Net pay thickness, h=160 ft Formation permeability, k=0.5 µD Fracture conductivity=0.005 – 0.7 md-ft Wellbore Radius, r w =0.1 ft Formation compressibility, c f =3 x psi -1 Porosity, f=0.05 (fraction) Initial reservoir pressure, p i =5000 psi Gas saturation, s g =1.0 fraction Skin factor, s=-5 (dimensionless) Reservoir temperature, T r =212 °F Fluid properties: Gas specific gravity, γ g =0.7 (air = 1) Hydraulically fractured well model parameters: Fracture half-length, x f =164.0 ft Number of fractures=15 Horizontal well length= ft Production parameters: Flowing pressure, p wf =500 psia Production time, t=10,958 days (30 years) ■ A horizontal well with multiple transverse fractures is modeled. ■ The model inputs are as follows: Transverse Fractures Horizontal well with multiple transverse fractures Slide — 62/80 ● Synthetic Examples ■ 15 Models with F c ranging from md-ft. ■ All other reservoir/well and fluid parameters are identical. Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: Synthetic Case Example ● Time-rate models ■ PLE model ■ Duong model ■ LGM model

Slide — 63/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: PLE model analysis (PLE model Analysis) ●○○○○ β-parameter b-parameter Rate

Slide — 64/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: PLE model analysis Cross-Plot Analysis – Fracture Conductivity (F c ) (PLE model Analysis) ●●○○○ F c vs. n ● Discussion: ■ Fracture conductivity is correlated with PLE model parameters for: ■ Constant (slowly changing) bottomhole pressure. ■ Constant (slowly changing) completion parameters (well length, number of fractures…).

Slide — 65/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: PLE model analysis Cross-Plot Analysis – 30 year EUR (EUR 30yr ) (PLE model Analysis) ●●●○○ EUR 30yr vs. n ● Discussion: ■ EUR is correlated with PLE model parameters for: ■ Constant (slowly changing) bottomhole pressure. ■ Constant (slowly changing) completion parameters (well length, number of fractures…).

Slide — 66/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: PLE model analysis F c and EUR 30yr Correlation (PLE model Analysis) ●●●●○ Calculated F c vs. Model F c ● Discussion: ■ EUR 30yr and Fc can be estimated using PLE model parameters: Calculated EUR 30yr vs. Model EUR 30yr

Slide — 67/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: Duong model analysis (Duong model Analysis) ●○○○○ β-parameter b-parameter Rate

Slide — 68/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: Duong model analysis Cross-Plot Analysis – Fracture Conductivity (F c ) (Duong model Analysis) ●●○○○ F c vs. m ● Discussion: ■ Fracture conductivity is correlated with Duong model parameters for: ■ Constant (slowly changing) bottomhole pressure. ■ Constant (slowly changing) completion parameters (well length, number of fractures…).

Slide — 69/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: Duong model analysis Cross-Plot Analysis – 30 year EUR (EUR 30yr ) (Duong model Analysis) ●●●○○ EUR 30yr vs. m ● Discussion: ■ EUR is correlated with Duong model parameters for: ■ Constant (slowly changing) bottomhole pressure. ■ Constant (slowly changing) completion parameters (well length, number of fractures…).

Slide — 70/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: Duong model analysis F c and EUR 30yr Correlation (Duong model Analysis) ●●●●○ Calculated F c vs. Model F c ● Discussion: ■ EUR 30yr and Fc can be estimated using Duong model parameters: Calculated EUR 30yr vs. Model EUR 30yr

Slide — 71/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: LGM model analysis (LGM model Analysis) ●○○○○ β-parameter b-parameter Rate

Slide — 72/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: LGM model analysis Cross-Plot Analysis – Fracture Conductivity (F c ) (LGM model Analysis) ●●○○○ ● Discussion: ■ Fracture conductivity is correlated with Lgm model parameters for: ■ Constant (slowly changing) bottomhole pressure. ■ Constant (slowly changing) completion parameters (well length, number of fractures…).

Slide — 73/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: Duong model analysis Cross-Plot Analysis – 30 year EUR (EUR 30yr ) (LGM model Analysis) ●●●○○ ● Discussion: ■ EUR is correlated with LGM model parameters for: ■ Constant (slowly changing) bottomhole pressure. ■ Constant (slowly changing) completion parameters (well length, number of fractures…).

Slide — 74/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Theoretical Consideration: LGM model analysis F c and EUR 30yr Correlation (LGM model Analysis) ●●●●○ Calculated F c vs. Model F c ● Discussion: ■ EUR 30yr and Fc can be estimated using LGM model parameters: Calculated EUR 30yr vs. Model EUR 30yr

Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX (USA) Slide — 75/80 Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Summary and Conclusions

Slide — 76/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Summary: (Summary and Conclusions) ●○○ ● Duong Model ■ Very good data match in transient flow regimes. ■ Reliable reserve estimates in transient flow regimes. ■ Very Poor data match for boundary-dominated flow regimes. ■ Reserves are significantly overestimated beyond transient flow regime. ■ Do not conform to diagnostic functions (D-,b-parameter and b-derivative) during boundary conditions. ● Logistic Growth Model (LGM) ■ Very good data match in transient and transition flow regimes. ■ Reliable reserve estimates in transient and transition flow regimes. ■ Poor data match for boundary-dominated flow regimes. ■ Reserves are overestimated beyond transient/tranistion flow regimes.

Slide — 77/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Summary: ● MDNG – 1 and MLGM – 1 flow regime ■ Based on the "loss-ratio" relation. ■ Similar to PLE model. ■ Excellent match for Transient, transition and boundary- dominated flow regimes. ● MDNG – 2 and MLGM – 2 models ■ Based on data Diagnostic Functions. ■ Excellent match for transient, transition and boundary- dominated flow regimes. ■ Very flexible. ● It is possible to integrate time-rate model parameters with reservoir/well parameters using parametric correlations when production and completion strategies remain constant (fairly changing). (Summary and Conclusions) ●●○

Slide — 78/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Conclusion: (Summary and Conclusions) ●●● ● The limitations of Duong and LGM models is investigated. ● Duong and LGM models overestimate reserves. ● Diagnostic Functions can be used to generate representative time-rate relations. ● New time-rate relations match all flow regimes observed from production data of unconventional reservoirs. ● New time-rate relations provide constrained reliable reserve estimates. ● The preliminary investigation to use parametric correlations for estimation of reservoir properties can be applied to field cases.

Slide — 79/80 Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Recommendation for Future Work: (Recommendation) ● ● Identification of other diagnostic function will allow accurate model parameter estimation and assists in the derivation of reliable models. ● The newly derived relations should be tested using production data from other reservoir systems to check their flexibility/accuracy. ● The developed parametric correlations methodology should be applied to field cases.

Yohanes ASKABE Department of Petroleum Engineering Texas A&M University College Station, TX (USA) Slide — 80/80 Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties Yohanes Askabe — MS Thesis Defense — October 12, 2012 Department of Petroleum Engineering — Texas A&M University Rate-Decline Relations for Unconventional Reservoirs and Development of Parametric Correlations for Estimation of Reservoir Properties End of Presentation