Monitoring and Evaluating Scotland’s Alcohol Strategy (MESAS) Using sales and survey data to monitor and evaluate alcohol policy: learning from MESAS Mark.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Public health and licensing workshop Outlet density and cumulative impact Dr James Nicholls Alcohol Research UK.

Advertisements

Tackling Crime – Current Laws on Alcohol, Drugs and Road Traffic Offences.

Working together to help people drink within the guidelines July 2013 DH – Leading the nation’s health and care Jean Nicol.

Evidence into Action (and Action into Evidence) Dr Lesley Graham ISD.

Wine consumption in Spain Rafael del Rey General Manager XVIII Giornata Internazionale Vitivinicola - Siena, 28 maggio 2005.

Alcohol & Health Harm: the Scale of the Problem North-South Alcohol Conference Armagh 26 th January 2012 Ian Gilmore, University of Liverpool, Chair, UK.

Alcohol in Scotland a public health perspective Dr Lesley Graham Public Health Lead, Information Services Division, National Services Scotland Alcohol.

Alcohol-Related Harm and Unmet Need Amongst Older Drinkers S Wadd, R Driver, D Forrester.

Population Health for Health Professionals. Module 2 Epidemiology The Basic Science of Public Health.

Migration, methodologies and health inequality SEED Group

Restricting Access to Alcohol. Background  Injuries  Liver diseases  Cancers  Heart diseases  Premature deaths  Poverty  Family and partner violence.

What is the scale of the alcohol problem in Merseyside? Michela Morleo Alcohol Research Manager June 2009 Centre for Public Health, Liverpool John Moores.

From Evidence to Action: a case study of Minimum Unit Price Dr Lesley Graham Associate Specialist, Public Health ISD, NHSNSS 13 th November 2012 Royal.

The new HBS Chisinau, 26 October Outline 1.How the HBS changed 2.Assessment of data quality 3.Data comparability 4.Conclusions.

Healthy Ireland A framework for improved health and wellbeing Healthy Food for All 20 November 2013 Dr Miriam Owens.

Target population-> Study Population-> Sample 1WWW.HIVHUB.IR Target Population: All homeless in country X Study Population: All homeless in capital shelters.

Role and importance of Distributive Trade Statistics Workshop for African countries on the Implementation of International Recommendations for Distributive.

International Health Policy Program -Thailand Present by : Wittaya Wisutruangdaj Sopit Nasueb Alcohol control policies and alcohol consumption by youth:

Alcohol Availability & Alcohol Consumption: New Evidence from Sunday Sales Restrictions Kitt Carpenter (UC Irvine) & Daniel Eisenberg (University of Michigan)

European Health Forum Gastein, October Avoidable chronic diseases: the neglected global epidemic Corinna Hawkes Visiting Research Fellow International.

International Health Policy Program -Thailand Panatapon Chongprasertying,Kannapon Phakdeesettakun Center for Alcohol Studies, International Health Policy.

Restricting Access to Alcohol. Background  Injuries  Liver cirrhosis  Cancers  Cardiovascular diseases  Premature deaths  Poverty  Family and partner.

How Big is the Alcohol Problem Locally? Jess Mookherjee Consultant in Public Health Kent.

Lesson Starter Health inequalities are result of poor lifestyle CHOICES rather than poor lifestyle CHANCES. Do you agree with this statement? Why/ why.

Workshop on Price Index Compilation Issues February 23-27, 2015 Market Basket Items and Weights Gefinor Rotana Hotel, Beirut, Lebanon.

4TH EUROPEAN ALCOHOL POLICY CONFERENCE Alcohol as a Global Health Concern.

Salford’s Alcohol Strategy Background Salford’s Drug and Alcohol Strategy Safe. Sensible. Social. : next steps in the national alcohol.

Minimum unit pricing for alcohol and the ‘moderate drinker of moderate means’: An analysis of household scanner data Ourega-Zoé Ejebu Lynda McKenzie Anne.

Catherine Millington Scottish Crime and Justice Survey,

7th International Forum on Tourism Statistics Stockholm, Sweden, 9-11 June 2004 NEW RESEARCH LINES ON TOURISM INFORMATION SYSTEMS: POTENTIAL DEMAND ANALYSES.

Household consumption survey

Blackpool Alcohol Strategy Steve Morton, Public Health Practitioner.

Name:_________________________________ Day:____ Period: _____ Do you know how many people drink alcohol? 2 billion people in the world drink alcoholic.

Statistics Division Beijing, China 25 October, 2007 EC-FAO Food Security Information for Action Programme Side Event Food Security Statistics and Information.

ALCOHOL MONITORING SYSTEMS Professor Colin Drummond St George’s University of London.

Monitoring of Alcoholic Beverages Consumption in Thailand Gun Chernrungroj M.D., M.P.H., Ph.D. Non-communicable Disease Information Center, Department.

Today we will… Identify the information handling questions which will be assessed in Higher Modern Studies.

Background information about ESPAD The European School Survey Project on Alcohol and Other Drugs.

L4. Health IssuesAS Geography. L4. Health IssuesAS Geography Lesson Focus: Coronary Heart Disease: Is it really a disease of affluence? Lesson Focus:

Health Statistics and Informatics Non-communicable diseases A global overview.

Alcohol Drugs and Hepatitis C, Brewing up a perfect storm COSLA Haymarket, Edinburgh 24 June 2015 Epidemiological overview Professor David Goldberg, Health.

Alcohol consumption and purchasing by ill drinkers in What might be the effect of a minimum price of 50p per unit? 2. “Strong cider in Scotland.

Introduction to Lifestyle Data Peter Cornish South East Public Health Intelligence Analyst Training Day 2, Session 4 11 th February 2016.

South West Public Health Observatory SOUTH WEST PUBLIC HEALTH SCIENTIFIC CONFERENCE2011 Alcohol Attributable Hospital Admissions in the South West Laura.

Introduction to Lifestyle data Nicola Bowtell

“United Society” Foundation. General characteristics of the alcohol situation in Russia At the official level, alcohol consumption 14,0-14,5 liters per.

1 A investigation of ethnic variations in mortality using the ONS Longitudinal Study Chris White Health Variations Team Office for National Statistics.

1 MONITORING OF THE INDICATORS OF MDG: EXPERIENCE OF THE KYRGYZ REPUBLIC Turdubayeva Chinara Chief of the Division of Consolidated Works and Information.

New Psychoactive Substances: an overview of the evidence Isla Wallace, Social Researcher Drugs Research Team

MRC/CSO Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, University of Glasgow. Quantifying non-response bias in the Scottish Health Surveys by comparison of alcohol-related.

Evaluating imputation of sex and age for substitutes in substitute households Michael Ryan 2008 UNECE Work Session on Statistical Data Editing.

People with alcohol related harm: who else suffers…? Fiona O’May Queen Margaret University Edinburgh

Alcohol a public health issue Day 5 Session 3 Feb 2010.

Alcohol-related mortality in European countries II Working Meeting on Adult Premature Mortality in European Union Warsaw, October 2006.

Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005 Current measures and new proposals Gary Cox Head of Alcohol and Knives Licensing.

MESAS: Evaluation of minimum unit pricing (MUP) for alcohol

Problem alcohol use in the Irish population: review of current data

Monitoring and Evaluating Scotland’s Alcohol Strategy (MESAS)

Trends in the UK Annual Alcohol Consumption per UK Resident

MESAS: Evaluation of minimum unit pricing (MUP) for alcohol

Female heavy drinkers in Glasgow and Edinburgh- similar but different

Problem alcohol use in the Irish population: review of current data

MESAS: Evaluation of minimum unit pricing (MUP) for alcohol

Lesson starter Some people are affected by crime more than others.

Campaign for MUP in Scotland

Lesson Starter Health inequalities are result of poor lifestyle CHOICES rather than poor lifestyle CHANCES. Do you agree with this statement? Why/ why.

Part 3: Weighting Estimation Samples Frank Porell

Volume 393, Issue 10169, Pages (January 2019)

Volume 375, Issue 9723, Pages (April 2010)

An evaluation of the effects of lowering blood alcohol concentration limits for drivers on the rates of road traffic accidents & alcohol consumption A.

Presentation transcript:

Monitoring and Evaluating Scotland’s Alcohol Strategy (MESAS) Using sales and survey data to monitor and evaluate alcohol policy: learning from MESAS Mark Robinson

Alcohol-related mortality rates* updated from Leon and McCambridge, Lancet 367 (2006) *As indicated by chronic liver disease mortality

Source: General Lifestyle Survey (GB) Mean units of alcohol per week among adults in Scotland and England & Wales, by sex, “The absence of high-quality alcohol consumption data, particularly on a regional and national basis, is a profound handicap to further study.” Leon & McCambridge, 2006

Learning point 1 More robust data provides more robust intelligence

Retail sales data On-trade (CGA)Off-trade (Nielsen)

Estimated per adult consumption in Scotland and England & Wales Source: Nielsen/CGA

Estimated per adult consumption in Scotland and England & Wales

Source: Nielsen/CGA Estimated per adult consumption in Scotland and England & Wales, by trade sector

Source: Nielsen Price distribution (L per adult) of spirits sold off-trade in Scotland and England & Wales, 2014

Weekly per adult sales, Scotland and England & Wales Source: Nielsen

Learning point 2 Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of data is crucial

“We should be concentrating on the figures for alcohol consumption, not sales” “It ignores all the alcohol bought and drunk by the 15million tourists who visit our country each year and I imagine also ignores the 700,000 immigrants resident in Scotland.” “Your methodology of taking the total amount of alcohol sold in Scotland and dividing that by the number of Scots is disingenuous and flawed – at best.” “ONS Statistics on Alcohol England 2010 shows that Scots actually drink less than their English counterparts” “The misuse of figures relating to alcohol consumption in Scotland will not cure the social factors which damage our health”

Validity and reliability of alcohol retail sales data Underestimated population denominator Personal exports Stockpiling Wastage/ spillage Food Scots abroad Non-inclusion of some sales outlets Personal imports Illicit alcohol Home brew Substitute alcohol Representativeness of sample frame Non-response bias Measurement error Population estimates Underestimation Overestimation

Validity and reliability of alcohol retail sales data Underestimated population denominator Personal exports Stockpiling Wastage/ spillage Food Scots abroad Non-inclusion of some sales outlets Personal imports Illicit alcohol Home brew Substitute alcohol Representativeness of sample frame Non-response bias Measurement error Population estimates Underestimation Overestimation Underestimate of 0.7L per adult (7% of 2013 estimate)

Learning point 3 Consider all available data

Consumption distribution

Consumption distribution and the alcohol harm paradox Source: Scottish Health Survey (2012/13 combined)

Consumption distribution and the alcohol harm paradox Source: Scottish Health Survey (2012/13 combined)

Thanks to the MESAS project team and to you for listening. Reports, papers and infographics available at healthscotland.com/MESAS

Source: Nielsen Price distribution (%) of alcohol sold off-trade in Scotland, % 52% <50ppu