1. Working group on Quality Assessment Steps done and plans for the future

2. Working group on Quality Assessment Working group leaders –Ljerka Crnković –Trajko Spasovski –Svilena Simeonova –Maksym Tymokhin

3. Working group on Quality Assessment Objectives This workshop intends to help internal auditors to: –Understand how to apply the IPPF of the IIA and International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing on quality assessment review case study. –Develop a solid understanding of the process used to complete a periodic internal assessment or external quality assessment of an internal audit activity. –Discover proven quality assessment tools and techniques. –Explore the recommended internal and external quality assessment approaches and identify the best approach for their own organization.

4. Working group on Quality Assessment Work done in Budapest –Overview of the results of the IA CoP meeting in Ohrid –Survey results on Quality Assurance –Presentation on IPPF standards on QC and QA by Jean-Pierre Garitte –Country examples and QA and QC Template (Hungary, Poland)

5. Working group on Quality assessment The result from Budapest workshop –Start to develop in detail part 4 Quality control from PEM PAL Good Practice Internal Audit Manual Template The quality control measures during the individual audit assignment – ongoing supervision

6. Working group on Quality assessment Work planned to be done between two sessions –Working group leaders should consolidate the results of the Budapest workshop on the Ongoing supervision –Working group leaders to add comments and proposals on draft template

7. What has been done –Introductory test and part about ongoing supervision –Template –Questionnaires

8. Working group on Quality Assessment Svilena Simeonova-ongoing supervision Intrductory text.docSvilena Simeonova-ongoing supervision Intrductory text.doc

9. Working group on Quality Assessment Objectives of on going supervision The supervision over the engagement implementation should ensure: –Performance of the engagement only by auditors who have the necessary knowledge, skills and other qualifications therefor; –Drawing up working documents corresponding to the checks planned; –Appropriate instruction during engagement planning and approval of the working documents for its implementation; –Implementation of the engagement audit plan and working programme(s);

10. Working group on Quality Assessment Cont. –Adequate support of the findings, conclusions and recommendations made during the engagement by working documents containing sufficiently reliable, appropriate and useful information; –Ensuring the accuracy, objectivity, clarity, precision, constructiveness and timeliness of the information provided relevant to the engagement; –Ensuring the achievement of the engagement objectives; –Creating conditions for improving the internal auditors’ knowledge, skills and competences.

11. Working group on Quality Assessment Ongoing Quality Control Guidelines, v.1..docOngoing Quality Control Guidelines, v.1..doc

12. Working group on Quality Assessment Questionnaires Svilena's questionnaire.doc Trajko's questionnaire.doc

13. Working group on Quality assessment Our task –Discussion on elaborated draft content on Ongoing supervision during the audit assignment –Prepare the final document as an Guideline to IA Manual –Discussion on the next steps

14. Working group on Quality assessment Our proposal –Working group should continue its work –All the subchapters on Quality control in the IA manual should be further elaborated in the future –Plan will be further elaborated at the end of the meeting

15. 4. QUALITY CONTROL 4.1. Quality Program 4.2. Audit Entity Survay 4.3. Ongoing Supervision 4.4. Key Performance Indicator 4.5. Internal Quality assessment 4.6. External Quality Assessment

16. Thank you!