1. Final Study Report on ROR May 2010 SC32WG2 Kunming, China Hajime Horiuchi SC32WG2-N1423

2. Background The study period project was initiated at the SC32 Sydney Meeting (May 2008) and extended one year at the SC32 Jeju Meeting (Jun 2009). The project was being in charge of the investigation of many possibilities of “Registry Interoperability” In term of ROR (Registry of Registries). The final conclusion was made as a standard by which any heterogeneous registries could be described as simple profiles. The standard for the registry profile could be a part of the MFI-6 (Registration procedure).

3. Objectives of the study Heterogeneous Registries Registry Interoperation Registry ROR ManufacturingLogisticRetails Registry ROR: Registry of Registry SC32 Seoul 020506 4 PDES/STEP Registry Manufacturing ebXML Registry UDDI Component Registry GCI Registry EAN Registry CPFR Registry RosettaNet Registry Business Negotiation Vender Catalog Shipper Catalog Business Category Shipping Customer Support Consumer Profile CALS Production Planning & Procurement System Development 11179 Registry Originally, ISO/IEC 19763 (MFI: Metamodel Framework for Interoperability) in SC32 was addressing the ROR concept.

4. Cases investigated Case-1: Registry Integration Service Case-2: Hierarchical Registry Connection Case-3: Registry Interface Virtualization Case-4: Registry Profile

5. Case-1: ROR as a Registry Service Integrator User Catalogue Information Service Interface Specification Metadata used by Service RaaS Registry Service Service Platform (J-SaaS) Service Platform (SFDC) S1S1 S2S2 S4S4 S3S3 Reference Registry Service Service enjoy Service lookup ★ :Targets to be standardized ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Service Integrator Service Platform ★ S n : Service Registry Service Federation Service Profile Specification in the Registry Interface Specification between Service Integrator and Platform Interface Specification between Service Registry and Service Integrator 2010/05/17 13th Open Forum for Metadata Registry, Kunming, China Cloud ROR

6. Experimental trials on RaaS RaaS Client Browser SOAP http://mr-devel.tiu.ac.jp http://modelregistry.tiu.ac.jp http://serviceregistry.tiu.ac.jp/WS/mdr ROR Service Registry SOAP WSDL http://serviceregistry.tiu.ac.jp/WS/mfi MDR Registries MFI Registries (Registry Service Integration) 2010/05/1713th Open Forum for Metadata Registry, Kunming, China

7. Case-2 : Service Hierarchy SaaS vender SaaS vender SaaS vender Service Integrator Service Integrator Tier-1 Service User Tier-2 Tier-3 Service User RaaS Vender Service Registry Service Integration Registry Service Registry as a Service

8. ebXML RR Case-3: Registry Service Virtualization PLIB XML base Registry MFI Registry MDR Registry Unique independent Interface Registry Integration Service Standard Interface Web SErvice 2010/05/1713th Open Forum for Metadata Registry, Kunming, China

9. Might invite Confusions Registry Service = Service Registry ?

10. Case-4: Registry Profile Only collection of Registry Profiles Everybody can collect and store a set of profiles Change will be informed by Notification(RSS) 10 MFI Registry Registry Profile MDR Registry ebXML Registry ROR

11. 11 Metamodel for Registry Profile Information of RA and owner of this registry system. Information of Registry system. Information of access interfaces to registry system.

12. 12 Metamodel for Registry Profile Data Type: Core Component Data Type.

13. Registry Profile 13 Any Provider Registry Profile M2 M1 UN/CFACT CCL Registry Registry Profile M2 PLIB Registry M1 XXX Registry ROR Registry Profile Collection of profile

14. Service Registry(UDDI) Difference between ROR and UDDI Find Service Establish collaboration Use Service (Interchange ) Service Provider Service Provider Service Provider Service Provider Data/Model /Semantic Registry Service Provider Service Provider ROR Automobile Electronics Parts 12 3 4 Data/Model /Semantic Registry

15. Final Decision Let the Registry Profile be a part of MFI-6 (ISO/IEC19763-6: Registration procedure) ROR Study Project Registry Profile Metamodel Registration Process Core Registration package MFI-6 MDR/MFI Harmonization Project

16. 16 Relationship among MFI & MDR Packages MDR/MFI Registration Core Package Registered Item Instances MFI-6 Registration Process Model Model Constructs Service Service Constructs RGPS RGPS Constructs Registration Record MDR-6 Registration Process MFI -2 Metamodel (Model ) MFI -3 Metamodel (Ontology) MFI -5 Metamodel (Process Model) MFI-7 Metamodel (Service ) MFI-8 Metamodel (Service ) Registration Process Specify

17. MDR/MFI Registration Common Core Package 17 Namespace Registry Authority Registrar Administered_Item Stewardship_Record Submission_Record Registration _Record Registration Identification Designation & Definition MDR/MFI Registration Core Package Contact Date-and Time Individual Language_Id Organization Phone_Number Postal_address Registration A_ID Basic Registry profile From ISO/IEC 11179 ED3 ISO/IEC 11179-3 Ed3 use

18. MFI-6 package (Registration) 18 Namespace Registry Authority Registrar Administered_Item Stewardship_Record Submission_Record Registration _Record Registration Identification Designation & Definition > MDR/MFI Registration Core Package Contact Date-and Time Individual Language_Id Organization Phone_Number Postal_address Registration A_ID Basic MDR-6 (ISO/IEC11179-6) MFI Registration Process Registry Profile Lifecycle Process (Service) Registration of Model (Service) Registration of Ontology (S) Registration of Service (S) Registration of Goal & Role (S) Registry Common Process Out of scope of this document

19. Namespace Registry Authority Registrar Administered_Item Stewardship_Record Submission_Record Registration _Record Registration Identification Designation & Definition MDR/MFI Registration Core Package Contact Date-and Time Individual Language_Id Organization Phone_Number Postal_address Registration A_ID Basic How MFI metamodels to be used in the Registration 19 MFI Registration Processes MFI-6 (ISO/IEC19763-6) Registration of Model Proc. Registration of Ontology Registration of Service Lifecycle Process (Service) Registry Profile MFI Registry Service MFI Metamodel MFI Metamodels Specify RA, Registrar, Stewards, Submitters register Registry Common process Registration of Role & Goal