Presentation on theme: "An Intro to FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards"— Presentation transcript:
1 An Intro to FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards ODOT Survey Leadership TeamJune 15, 2006Salem, ORKen Bays, Geodesist Control SpecialistODOT Geometronics
2 Why Adopt an Accuracy Standard? Provide direction for testing and reporting accuracy of geospatial data.Provide direction on matching equipment and field procedures to various geospatial data accuracy requirements.Match the accuracy requirement to the job need, and not allow technology to dictate the accuracy.
3 What is the FGDC?The Federal Geographic Data Committee (FGDC) is an interagency committee that promotes the coordinated development, use, sharing, and dissemination of geospatial data on a national basis. This nationwide data publishing effort is known as the National Spatial Data Infrastructure (NSDI).
4 What is the NSDI?The NSDI is a physical, organizational, and virtual network designed to enable the development and sharing of this nation's digital geographic information resources.NSDI includes the National Spatial Reference System (NSRS), a data base of geodetic control maintained by the National Geodetic Survey.
5 Why Model Standards to Comply with FGDC Standards? Executive Order 12906, Coordinating Geographic Data Acquisition and Access: the National Spatial Data Infrastructure: “Federal agencies collecting or producing geospatial data, …. shall ensure, …., that data will be collected in a manner that meets all relevant standards adopted through the FGDC process.”
6 Why Model State Standards to be FGDC Compatible? Building an effective NSDI requires a well-coordinated effort among Federal, tribal, State, local government, and academic institutions, as well as a broad array of private sector geographic, statistical, demographic, and other business information providers and users.Involving these stakeholders in the development of the NSDI addresses nationwide data needs of end-users.FGDC standards have been accepted by many state and local agencies and private firms.Provides more efficiency and confidence when exchanging geospatial data.
9 Overview of FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards Part 1: Reporting Methodology: common accuracy reporting for all geodata types.Part 2: Geodetic NetworksPart 3: National Standard Spatial Data Accuracy: for digital geospatial data that is not constrained by scale.Part 4: Architecture, Engineering, Construction, and Facilities ManagementPart 5: Navigation Charts and Hydrographic Surveys
10 Part 1:Reporting Methodology, FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards OBJECTIVE: To provide consistency in reporting the accuracy of point geospatial data collected by different activities (e.g., geodetic surveying, topographic mapping, bathymetric mapping, facilities management, mapping, cadastral surveying, etc.)OBJECTIVE: Develop a FGDC document with a single methodology that defines how to report the positional accuracy for all point geospatial data collected, produced, or disseminated by the Federal government and the Nation.Accuracy reporting for all geospatial data is required to be reported at the 95% confidence level.
11 Part 1: Accuracy Standard Horizontal: radius of a circle of uncertainty, such that the true or theoretical location of the point falls within that circle 95-percent of the time.Vertical: linear uncertainty value, such that the true or theoretical location of the point falls within +/- of that linear uncertainty value 95-percent of the time.
12 Expression of Precision (CEP= 50%) CEP = 5 meters
13 Expression of Precision (ss = 68.3%) ss = 7.4 meters
15 Expression of Precision (2ss = 95.5%) NSSDA requires reporting accuracy at the 95% accuracy level.2ss = 14.8 meters
16 Part 2, Geodetic Networks, FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards Developed by the FGDC Federal Geodetic Control Subcommittee (FGCS).Objective: provides a common methodology for determining and reporting the accuracy of horizontal coordinate values and vertical coordinate values for geodetic control points
17 FGDC Federal Geodetic Control Subcommittee (FGCS) Provide Leadership in:leadership in coordinating the planning and execution of geodetic surveysdeveloping standards and specifications for these surveysexchange of geodetic survey data and technical information
18 FGCS Work Groups Fixed Reference Stations Work Group Instruments Work GroupMethodology Work GroupWrote Part 2, FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy StandardsSpectrum Issues Work GroupVertical Reference Systems Work Group
20 Many sources were consulted during the preparation of this document. BLM/ Forest Service “Standards and Guidelines for Cadastral Surveys using Global Positioning System Methods”.Compliant with FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards Parts 1 and 2.Many sources were consulted during the preparation of this document.These sources included other GPS survey standards and guidelines, technical reports and manuals.These standards and guidelines do not require that cadastral surveys be performed to the higher accuracy and methodology requirements of geodetic control surveys.They are intended to provide sufficient observational and occupational redundancy to detect blunders and quantitatively demonstrate the stated accuracy of a survey has been achieved.
21 Part 2, Geodetic Networks, FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards Old vs newProportional 1:100,0001st orderNew :positioanl toleraance95 % confidence accuracy bandsNetwork vs local error
22 Part 3: FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards: The National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy (NSSDA)FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards Part 3, NATIONAL STANDARD FOR SPATIAL DATA ACCURACY, FGDC-STD , (NSSDA) implements a testing and statistical methodology for positional accuracy of fully georeferenced maps and digital geospatial data, in either raster, point, or vector format, derived from sources such as aerial photographs, satellite imagery, and ground surveys.“The NSSDA is intended to replace the 1947 National Map Accuracy Standard.” (source: “A proposal for a National Spatial Data Infrastructure Standards Project”: )NSSDA written by the FGDC Subcommittee for Base Cartographic Data
23 Why a GIS accuracy standard should is based on the NSSDA GIS data is fully georeferenced digital geospatial data, which is the type of data addressed by the NSSDA.Many Federal agency legacy GIS themes are referenced to NMAS requirements, and NSSDA is intended to replace NMAS.
24 National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy NSSDA Statistics95% confidence level requiredHorizontal circular error
25 National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy Comparison of NSSDA with NMAS
26 Existing OR/WA BLM Accuracy Attributes Some BLM GIS Data Standards refer to NMAS. The NMAS has a 90% confidence level specified, and this can easily be converted to the NSSDA 95% confidence level.Other themes have accuracy reporting attributes, but do not require that a confidence level be stated about the accuracy.
27 Grazing Allotment Spatial Data Standard GRAZING_ALLOTMENT_BOUNDARY_LINE_ACCURACY_CD (ACCURACY)Description[Required] Locational accuracy code which indicates how close to the true geographic location on the ground a GIS entity has been recorded. There are two aspects to accuracy: the tools used to get spatial entities into a GIS (turned into digital representations), and the actual accuracy - how far off (+ or - feet) is the digital product. Three types of tools are recognized: GPS (global positioning system), manuscripting onto a map or photo, and legal descriptions using Township, Range, and Section. FOIA Category = PublicAllowable Codes :GPS GPS1 = within 3 feet.GPS2 = within 30 feet.GPS3 = within 300 feetNo confidence level stated.
28 Noxious Weeds Spatial Data Standard LOCATIONS_ACCURACY_CODE (ACC)Description[Required]Locational accuracy code which indicates how close to the true geographic location on the ground a GIS entity has been recorded. There are two aspects to accuracy: the tools used to get spatial entities into a GIS (turned into digital representations), and the actual accuracy -- how far off (+ or _ feet) is the digital product. Three types of tools are recognized: GPS (global positioning system), Manuscripting onto a map or photo, and legal descriptions using Township, Range, and Section.Also note that ACC is NOT a source for polygon overlap. If there is a change in accuracy, the old region is replaced by the new. Only the most accurate regions are maintained on these coverages.FOIA Category = PublicAnnotationLocational Accuracy Codes:GPSGPS1 = within 3 feet.GPS2 = within 30 feet.GPS3 = within 300 feet.No confidence level stated.
29 Fire Water Source Data Standard CodesThe purpose of noting spacial accuracy is to give the potential user an idea of the reliability of finding the water source in the location as depicted in the theme. The methods of capturing the information and placing the location on the theme will effect the accuracy of the point. The code values represented here are an attempt to express what is the reasonable expectation of finding the water source within the given parameters as coded.One of the following codes must be used:1 - Within 10 feet of the actual location.2 - Within 100 feet of the actual location.3 - Within 1000 feet of the actual location Not accurate within 1000 feet of the actual location.No confidence level stated.
30 Wildlife Observation Sites Data Standard Name: LOCATION_ACCURACY_CODEDescription[Required]Attachment 1-15Locational accuracy code which indicates how close to the true geographic location on the ground a GIS entity has been recorded. There are two aspects to accuracy: the tools used to get spatial entities into a GIS (turned into digital representations), and the actual accuracy - how far off (+ or - feet) is the digital product. Three types of tools are recognized: GPS (global positioning system), Manuscripting onto a map or photo, and legal descriptions using Township, Range, and Section. Also note that ACC is NOT a source for polygon overlap. If there is a change in accuracy, the old region is replaced by the new. Only the most accurate regions are maintained on these coverages. FOIA Category = PublicCodesLocational Accuracy Codes:GPS GPS1 = within 3 feet.GPS2 = within 30 feet.GPS3 = within 300 feet.No confidence level stated.
31 Interim Ground Transportation Data Standard 43, Spatial Data Source:Resource Grade GPS 3-7 meters (differential correction)Submeter Grade GPS (differential correction)No confidence level stated.
32 Geographic Coordinates Data Standard (GCDB) Point Reliablility Code attribute with a list of values allowable including the following:0 = Default/unknown1 = 1 foot or less2 = 3 feet or less3 = 10 feet or less4 = 40 feet or less5 = 100 feet or less6 = 200 feet or lessNo ____?______ __?__ stated.
33 Recommendation in the Draft BLM Standard In order to be in compliance with FGDC Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards, it is recommended that the accuracy attribute fields of BLM GIS Data Standards be revised and updated to eliminate outdated GPS accuracy references and to require reporting of accuracy at the 95% confidence level.
34 The Standard Provides Two Ways to Document the Accuracy of GPS data: 1. Test your own data set per procedures outlined in the Standard, and then report the actual “tested accuracy”,or,2. Report the “expected accuracy” of your GPS based on test results published in the standard of the same equipment used under similar conditions.
35 1. Testing Your Own DataA detailed explanation of how to test and report the accuracy of your GPS data set is provided in the Standard.
36 Metadata when you test your data Report accuracy at the 95% confidence level for data tested for horizontal accuracy as:Tested ____ meters/feet accuracy (horizontal) at 95% confidence level
37 2. Reporting “Expected Accuracy” Based on Published Tests in the Standard This Table will be updated frequently with new test results.
38 Metadata when you use Table Report accuracy at the 95% confidence level for data produced according to established procedures to comply with intended horizontal accuracy values as:Compiled to meet ____ meters/feet accuracy (horizontal) at 95% confidence level
39 Why test GPS accuracy? Manufacturers specifications are for open sites and long data sets What the GPS salesman said.1 meterForested Sites:What can really happen in forested sites with short data sets.13 meters
40 Forest Service GPS Test Networks (Appendix 4) www. fs. fed Forest Service GPS Test Networks (Appendix 4)Networks of stations with known locations in various canopy types.Powell, Idaho: old growth cedar and spruce treesLubrecht, Montana: mixed lodgepole and ponderosa pineClackamas, Oregon: heavy second growth Douglas-fir and western hemlockBedford, Indiana: dense canopy eastern hardwoodNewtown Square, PA: heavy deciduous canopy
45 Clackamas Network Summary of Accuracy Performance* * “Your mileage may vary.”
46 Test Results Published in the “Table of Expected Accuracies” in the Standard. This Table will be updated frequently with new test results.
47 What this Standard does NOT do Does not define threshold accuracy values.Does not dictate the minimum accuracy required for a given GIS theme.The GIS specialist and data steward are responsible for deciding the accuracy values that are required on a theme-by-theme basis.
48 RecommendationsAll Federal Accuracy Standards should be compliant with FGDC requirements.The FGDC National Spatial Data Accuracy Standard it the FGDC Standard that is relevant to fully-georeferenced data.The accuracy attributes of existing BLM GIS Data Standards should be updated to eliminate outdated GPS accuracy references and to require reporting of accuracy per NSSDA requirements at the 95% confidence level
49 Geospatial Positioning Accuracy Standards, Part 4: Architecture, Engineering, Construction, and Facilities ManagementPART 4 provides accuracy standards for engineering drawings, maps, and surveys used to support planning, design, construction, operation, maintenance, and management of facilities, installations, structures, transportation systems, and related projects. It is intended to support geospatial mapping data used in various engineering documents, such as architectural, engineering, and construction (A/E/C) drawings, site plans, regional master planning maps, and related Geographical Information System (GIS), Computer-Aided Drafting and Design (CADD), and Automated Mapping/Facility Management (AM/FM) products. These products are typically created from terrestrial, satellite, acoustic, or aerial mapping techniques that output planimetric, topographic, hydrographic, or feature attribute dataResponsible FGDC Group: Facilities Work Group (Corp of Engineers)
52 Reporting: National Standard for Spatial Data Accuracy Reporting accuracy of a dataset with data of varying accuracies:If data of varying accuracies can be identified separately in a dataset, compute and report separate accuracy values. (for example GPS data)If data of varying accuracies are composited and cannot be separately identified AND the dataset is tested, report the accuracy value for the composite data.If a composited dataset is not tested, report the accuracy value for the least accurate dataset component.