We think you have liked this presentation. If you wish to download it, please recommend it to your friends in any social system. Share buttons are a little bit lower. Thank you!
Presentation is loading. Please wait.
Published byAngelina Farley
Modified over 3 years ago
Designing for Equality Best-fit, medium-fit and non-favourable combinations of electoral systems and gender quotas © International IDEA.
Electoral Systems The way in which votes are translated to seats © International IDEA.
Elements of Electoral Systems The district magnitude – determining how many representatives are elected in one electoral district; The formula – determining how the winner of a seat is choosen; and The ballot structure – determining whether the voter votes for a candidate or a party and whether the voter makes a single choice or expresses a series of preferences. © International IDEA.
Electoral system variables which impact on the representation of women District magnitude – the size of the district determines the number of people a party can nominate – the more people the better chance for gender balance. Party magnitude – the more candidates elected from the same district and the same party, the better chance for gender balance. A formula that leads to greater competition: many parties in the legislature few wasted votes The ballot structure – candidate or party centered? © International IDEA.
Best-fit combinations Systems with a second tier + reserved seats – a tier for women candidates only (example: Pakistan). List PR + »Small districts (Dominican Rep. and Ecuador) or Large districts (Argentina, Belgium, Costa Rica, Iraq) + nominations – percentage regulations with placement mandate/rank-order rules (e.g. Zipper- quotas) »Large districts + nominations – percentage regulations without placement mandate/rank-order rules (e.g. Zipper- quotas) (example: Macedonia) © International IDEA.
Best-fit combinations Block Vote (+ LV and SNTV) + reserved seats – best loser system (example:Jordan) Party Block Vote + nominations- percentage regulations without/with placement (examples: Cameroon & Djibouti) Single Transferable Vote + reserved seats – best loser system Mixed Member Proportional + reserved seats – a tier for women candidates only Borda Count + reserved seats – best loser system © International IDEA.
Medium-fit combinations that can work favourably but will need special attention List PR with large districts without applying any quotas All other systems with reserved seats – certain districts for women candidates only Parallel or MMP system together with nominations – percentage regulations with or without placement mandat/rank-order rules © International IDEA.
Impossible or non-favourable combinations 16 identified combinations of electoral systems with quota types which are either not possible or not likely to be favourable to achieving a higher level of political participation for women. Many times the reason is that candidate centred systems do not allow ranking to be determined beforehand or elected candidates to be changed after the election. © International IDEA.
Other variables affecting the representation of women Enforceability Capacity of the EMB Cultural factors and voter preferences Aspirants Nomination procedures © International IDEA.
Conclusions An electoral system is not neutral. Party-centred electoral systems tend to work well with quotas targeting the nomination of candidates. Candidate-centred electoral systems often need quotas targeting the results. The most effective quotas are likely to also be the most controversial ones. © International IDEA.
Recommendations The electoral system and the quota to be used must be considered together instead of separately. There is no impossible electoral system. Electoral systems and quotas can be modified and adapted to suit the specific context in which they are implemented. When designing electoral institutions it is highly advisable to include as many stakeholders as possible. © International IDEA.
Making your vote count Understanding the different electoral systems Source:
Democratic Electoral Systems Weekend 3 : Session 1.
Electoral Systems Women and Elections
Women’s Participation in Elections: The Impact of Electoral Systems Kristin van der Leest OSCE-ODIHR 30 June 2011.
Plurality Systems Weekend 3 : Session 3. Basic Principles Contestants are individual candidates Contestants are individual candidates Candidates run in.
Marginalization and Exclusion of Women in Elections Julie Ballington.
Electoral System Families The Rockridge Citizens’ Assembly April 21, 2004.
Proportional Representation (PR-List) Systems Weekend 4 : Session 1.
2 systems of voting : Plurality and Proportional representation systems BY: Destiny Cook, Jordan Burke.
Alternative Electoral Systems for BC Deliberative Phase: Weekend 4.
AP Comparative Government and Politics Sachem North High School
Democracy, Elections & Electoral Systems. This week 1.Democracy 2.Electoral systems.
Explaining party systems The role of electoral systems.
Elections, Parties, and the Party System Malcomlson & Myers, Chapter 9 & 10 Elections & the Electoral System Elections, Parties, & Representation Canada’s.
Choice Voting- Proportional Representation
Electoral Systems & Party Systems The causes and consequences of multiparty competition.
The Electoral College and Alternative Voting Systems
PO377 ETHNIC CONFLICT AND POLITICAL VIOLENCE Week 17 Seminar: Institutional Design as Conflict Management: Executive Structures and Electoral Systems in.
Starting to Decide Deliberative Phase: Weekend 1.
Spanish Politics and Society The Institutions of Spanish Democracy: the electoral system. Anthony Gilliland Office
Gender Equality in Elected Office: A Six-Step Action Plan Dr. Marcin Walecki OSCE-ODIHR April 2012 A study by Pippa Norris and Mona Lena Krook.
Voting System Reform in Canada. Fair Vote Canada Multi-partisan Group formed in 2000 People from all regions, all walks of life, all points of view, all.
Designing Alternate Electoral Systems Deliberative Phase: Weekend 3.
Pathways to evolving Ukraine’s parliamentary elections International Centre for Policy Studies Kyiv, 13 February 2008.
Institutions Much of political science is interested in political institutions (institutionalist, neoinstitutionalist, rational choice) Institutions affect.
REP DAY 2014 Our Electoral System. What is an electoral district? An electoral district is a geographical area represented by an elected official, also.
PROPORTIONALITY, DISTRICTING AND OPEN LISTS How to reconcile them? Author: Leon Malazogu.
REP DAY NOVA SCOTIA Our Electoral System. What is an electoral district? An electoral district is a geographical area represented by an elected official,
January 26, In representative democracies, their purpose is to allow voters to express their political preferences Elections provide an opportunity.
Voting systems in elections First past the post system Supplementary vote system Additional vote system Single transferable vote system.
Mixed Systems Weekend 4 : Session 3. Mixed Systems Mix different formula at different stages of the seat allocation process Austria Mix different formula.
Interest Aggregation. Interest aggregation A.The activity in which the political demands of individuals are combined into policy programs Competing demands.
Electoral System How politicians are elected into office. Electoral Systems 1.First-Past-The-Post 2.Proportional Representation 3.Mixed Member Proportional.
Part Three (continued): Electoral Systems & Linkage Institutions “Our political institutions work remarkably well. They are designed to clang against each.
SA1: Living in a Democracy Electoral Systems. Proportional Representation Aims: Define Proportional Representation (PR) Examine different types of PR.
Objective Assess the reasons for the two-party system in the U.S., and decide whether there should be reforms fostering 3 rd parties. Assess various electoral.
Alternative Electoral Systems Read and précis notes will be checked before this Lecture is delivered … 1.
Today we will… Learn to understand the Single Transferable Vote.
Institutional Design: Electoral Systems Plan for Today 1. Understand the characteristics and democratic consequences of three basic types of electoral.
The Central Election Commission 中央選舉委員會 A National Electoral System with Uniqueness: the Legislative Election of Taiwan Dr. Po-ya Chang Chairperson of.
The Single Transferable Vote*: Mechanics and Implications FairVote’s Election Services Group Robert Richie, Executive Director
Topics for Today Civil Society and Institutional Design: Electoral Systems 1.Finish group discussion activity. 2.Characteristics and consequences of three.
The Single Transferable Vote: Workings and Implications
An election held before the general election Voters choose members of their political party to run for public office in the general election Candidates.
Electoral systems used in the UK
Plurality/Majority System vs. Proportional Representation
Consequences of consensus democracy
Electoral systems Lesson Types of electoral systems.
© 2017 SlidePlayer.com Inc. All rights reserved.