Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

The Potter Box Model of Reasoning. British law prohibits reporting the names and family histories of children facing criminal charges until their trials.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "The Potter Box Model of Reasoning. British law prohibits reporting the names and family histories of children facing criminal charges until their trials."— Presentation transcript:

1 The Potter Box Model of Reasoning

2 British law prohibits reporting the names and family histories of children facing criminal charges until their trials are complete. Is the legal standard the only possible one we can use to evaluate this case? Is Britain’s domestic standard compelling for the international media? The above picture taken from a shopping center security camera shows two-year-old Jason Bugler being kidnapped from his mother by two ten-year-olds who would eventually brutally murder the child. The Liverpool Murder Case

3 Ethics and Values Ethics - the discipline dealing with what is morally right or wrong, good or bad. Ethical system describes the critical process of how we work through moral issues Values - the accepted principles or standards of an individual or a group All decision-making involves values which reflect our presuppositions about social life and human nature!

4 Professional Proximity Firstness Impact/magnitude Recency Conflict Human Interest Entertainment Novelty Toughness Thoroughness Immediacy Independence No prior restraint Public’s right to know Watchdog Moral Values Truthtelling Humanness Justice/fairness Freedom Independence Stewardship Honesty Nonviolence Commitment Self-control Aesthetic Harmonious Pleasing Imaginative Logical Consistent Competent Knowledge- able Socio-cultural Thrift Hard work Energy Restraint Heterosexuality Types of Values

5 Values Used by the British Press Legal value: Honor the court restrictions against reporting juvenile names and family background. Principles Used by the British Press Other-regarding care: The privacy of children facing criminal charges must be protected at all costs. Values Used by the American Press Professional value: Do not suppress public information. Principles Used by the American Press Truth-telling: All people have a right to know the truth. The truth must be proclaimed under all conditions.

6 Resulting Action of the British Press Withhold information about the defendants including names and personal histories Resulting Action of the American Press Print names of defendants and information on their personal histories. WE NEED A GUIDELINE OR MODEL FOR ETHICAL DECISIONMAKING!! THE POTTER BOX

7 The “Potter Box” Dr. Ralph Benajah Potter, Jr. Professor of Social Ethics Emeritus BA, Occidental College BD, McCormick Theological Seminary ThD, Harvard University Ralph Benajah Potter, Jr., who retired in July 2003, began teaching at HDS in He is an ordained Presbyterian minister and the author of the book War and Moral Discourse and assorted scholarly articles. He is a founding fellow of the Hastings Center for Bioethics and is a member of the American Academy of Religion, the Society for Christian Ethics, Societe Europeene de Culture, the Society for Values in Higher Education, and, at Harvard, the Senior Common Room of Lowell House. His 1997 HDS Convocation Address was titled "Moralists, Maxims and Formation for Ministry." Source:http://www.hds.harvard.edu/faculty/em/potter.html

8 Definition Values Loyalties Principles → ↓↑ Four Dimensions of Moral Analysis

9 Potter Box Empirical Definition Identifying Values Appeal to Ethical Principles Choosing Loyalties Particular Judgment or Policy Sociological Immediate External Philosophical Reflective Internal both positive & negative Feedback virtue, duty, utility, rights, love Facts

10 Potter Box Applied to the Liverpool Murder Case SITUATION Two ten-year-olds go to trial for kidnapping and brutally murdering two-year-old Jason Bugler VALUES British Television: honor the court restrictions against reporting juvenile names U.S. Newspaper: do not suppress public information PRINCIPLE British Television: other- regarding care U.S. Newspaper: truthtelling is categorical imperative LOYALTIES British Television: to juvenile defendants and their families U.S. Newspaper: to general readership JUDGMENT British Television: withhold broadcasting U.S. Newspaper: publish names and details

11 Is there a universal ground for making ethical decisions, an overarching theory from which we can choose among competing alternatives? Or is ethical decision making simply a process of adjusting to the mores and commitments of a given community? The Potter Box accounts for both. Without an appeal to an explicit ethical principle, a conclusion is not considered morally justified. Determining the Ethical Decision

12 When competing values seem appropriate, resolution usually occurs in step three (ethical principles). When two different ethical theories are relevant, the adequacy of the theories themselves must be evaluated through metaphysics or theology. Occasionally, the ethical choice is not apparent until quadrant four, loyalties, as in the case of the Liverpool murder. Evaluation With the Potter Box ModelPotter Box Model

13 Why We Study the Process By Which Choices Are Made Knowing the elements in moral analysis sharpens our vocabulary and enhances our discussion of media ethics Understanding the logic of social ethics improves the quality of our conceptual work and the validity of the choices we make in media practice. The four dimensions of the Potter Box allow us to develop normative ethics.

14 Potter Box Empirical Definition Identifying Values Appeal to Ethical Principles Choosing Loyalties Particular Judgment or Policy Sociological Immediate External Philosophical Reflective Internal both positive & negative Feedback virtue, duty, utility, rights, love Facts

15 Additional Links Finding a Philosophical PerspectiveFinding a Philosophical Perspective A discussion of different approaches to ethics including the Potter Box The Effects of Journalism Loyalties on the Invasion of PrivacyThe Effects of Journalism Loyalties on the Invasion of Privacy A discussion of the loyalties of the journalist according to the Potter Box. ScenariosScenarios Test yourself in applying the Potter Box model of ethical reasoning to these public relations scenarios. Digital Manipulation: Issues and Ethics in PhotojournalismDigital Manipulation: Issues and Ethics in Photojournalism An actual case of journalistic ethics analyzed according to the Potter Box.

16 Using Ethical Principles

17 Guidelines 1. Always treat specifics very carefully. 2. Values must be isolated and accounted for. 3. Values must be checked, questioned, or corrected using steps three and four of the Potter Box.

18 Use of Ethical Principles Definition Values Principles Loyalties No conclusion can be morally justified without a clear demonstration that an ethical principle shaped the final decision. What Actually HappensWhat Ought to Happen DescriptiveNormative

19 Ethics vs. Values Ethics involves an understanding of theology and philosophy as well as debates in the history of ideas over justice, virtue, the good, etc. Values pervade all dimensions of human experience, even scientific experimentation.

20 Challenging Moral Norms Challenging Moral Norms Our society challenges the practice of searching for moral norms. BUT norms rightly understood are foundational for moral commitment.

21 Purpose of Sound Ethical Reasoning Allows us to draw responsible conclusions that yield justifiable actions Helps us to determine which ethical theory is most powerful under which conditions

22 Five Categories of Ethical Theories 1. Ethical Theories based on Virtue Aristotle’s Mean/Confucius’ Golden Mean 2. Ethical Theories based on Duty Kant’s Categorical Imperative 3. Ethical Theories based on Utility Mill’s Principle of Utility 4. Ethical Theories based on Rights Rawls’s Veil of Ignorance 5. Ethical Theories based on Love Judeo-Christian Persons as Ends

23 Ethical Guidelines Based on Virtue Aristotle’s Mean Confucius’ Golden Mean

24 Aristotle’s Mean “Moral virtue is a middle state determined by practical wisdom”

25 Four Cardinal Virtues TEMPERANCE JUSTICE COURAGE WISDOM

26 Extremes JUSTICE COURAGE WISDOM SpontaneityCaution CowardiceTemerity IndifferenceIndulgence

27 Main Ideas Propriety before duty or love Character over conduct Outer behavior as a reflection of inner disposition Equilibrium and harmony

28 Practical Wisdom Phronesis Moral discernment Knowledge of the proper ends (telos) of conduct and the means of attaining them Distinct from both theoretical knowledge and technical skill

29 Using Practical Wisdom Applied to “individual facts” by locating “the mean between two vices, that which depends on excess and that which depends on defect” Examples –Case 16 –Case 29

30 Exceptions Not all actions or emotions can be justified by a middle state What actions and emotions are intrinsically wicked whether or not they are practiced with temperance? Adultery Theft Murder Spite Shamelessness Envy

31 Summary of Aristotle’s Mean NOT a weak-minded consensus NOT a compromise NOT a mathematically equal distance between two extremes Aristotle’s mean involves the correct quantity, the correct timing, the correct people, the correct motives, and the correct manner

32 Confucius’ Golden Mean “Moral virtue is the appropriate location between two extremes”

33 Main Ideas Rooted in virtue Virtue as benevolence, kindness, generosity, and balance (a mean between two extremes) Excellence dependent on character not social position

34 Equilibrium and Harmony “Equilibrium (chung) is the great root from which grow all human actings in the world. And harmony (yung) is the universal path all should pursue. Let the states of equilibrium and harmony exist in perfection, and happy order will prevail throughout heaven and earth, and all things will be nourished and flourish”

35 Applying Confucius’ Golden Mean 1.Identify all extremes 2.Resolve competing obligations using the Golden Mean 3.Reject any extremes 4.Choose the middle path

36 Additional Links Nicomachean EthicsNicomachean Ethics An online version of Aristotle’s text. Book II, chapter 6 is a good place to start. Aristotle OverviewAristotle Overview This article describes the life, writings, ethics, and politics of Aristotle. Aristotle’s “Doctrine of the Mean”Aristotle’s “Doctrine of the Mean” A chart illustrating Aristotle’s concepts of virtue and vice. ConfuciusConfucius An overview of Confucian beliefs The Doctrine of the MeanThe Doctrine of the Mean An online version of the article by Confucius cited by the text

37 Ethical Guidelines Based on Duty Kant’s Categorical Imperative

38 “Act only on that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law”

39 Main Ideas Ethics are objective Any genuine moral obligation can be universalized Categorical = unconditional What is right must be done regardless of circumstances Existence of higher truths Deontological ethics

40 Higher Truths Noumena Superior to reason Transcend physical universe Innate in human beings Apprehended by conscience NOT reason

41 Deontological Ethics From deon (Greek for duty) Rule determines the result Rule is the basis of the act Rule is good regardless of the act Result always calculated within the rules

42 Application of Kant’s Categorical Imperative Moral law is unconditionally binding on all rational beings. Certain actions are always wrong. Certain actions are always right. Examples

43 Questions to Consider What happens when there is a conflict of duties? (2 rules that are universalized) Is every rule we would universalize a moral duty? Can we truly ignore results in decision- making? Do we really want to make reason the final, sole authority in determining right and wrong?

44 Additional Links Critique of Practical ReasonCritique of Practical Reason The online version of Kant’s writings on epistemology and ethics. Kant’s Argument for the Categorical Imperative Kant’s Argument for the Categorical Imperative An outline of Kant’s reasoning for the categorical imperative Immanuel Kant and the Categorical Imperative Immanuel Kant and the Categorical Imperative A critical evaluation of Kant’s categorical imperative Kant’s Four Examples of How to Apply the Categorical Imperative Kant’s Four Examples of How to Apply the Categorical Imperative Kant’s own application from his work, Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysic of Morals

45 Ethical Guidelines Based on Utility Mill’s Principle of Utility

46 “Seek the greatest happiness for the greatest number”

47 Main Ideas Consider what course will yield the best consequences for the welfare of human beings Ethical choice produces the greatest balance of good over evil Good end must be promoted, bad end must be restrained

48 The Good End Happiness or pleasure To Mill, preventing pain and promoting pleasure are the only desirable ends. Pluralistic utilitarians argue that other values besides happiness possess intrinsic worth (friendship, knowledge, health). –Rightness or wrongness assessed according to total value ultimately produced

49 Application of the Principle of Utility 1.Calculate the consequences of various options. How much benefit and how much harm would result in the lives of everyone affected, including ourselves? 2.Choose the alternative that both A.Produces the greatest possible balance of good over evil B.Distributes this balance as widely as possible

50 Two Types of Utilitarianism 1.Act Utilitarianism: Greatest good in a specific case Will a particular action in a particular situation result in a balance of good over evil? 2. Rule Utilitarianism: Greatest good for general welfare Will a general rule result in a balance of good over evil?

51 Questions to Consider How do we account for the long term consequences of a decision that are not always able to be forseen? What if the majority rejects basic standards of decency? What problems are generated by defining the public good as the sum total of all private goods?

52 Additional Links John Stuart MillJohn Stuart Mill A description of Mill’s life and writings. What Utilitarianism IsWhat Utilitarianism Is John Stuart Mill’s explanation of the principle of utility from his book, Utilitarianism. A Millian Critique of Library CensorshipA Millian Critique of Library Censorship A discussion of utilitarian arguments in favor of and against censorship. Intellectual Property, Innovation, and Social ProgressIntellectual Property, Innovation, and Social Progress Intellectual property is evaluated from the perspective of utilitarianism.

53 Ethical Guidelines Based on Rights Rawls’s Veil of Ignorance

54 “Justice emerges when negotiating without social differentiations”

55 Rawls’s Veil of Ignorance Fairness = Justice (sometimes means quantity) Justice Helps determine what is “right” in any given situation Same reward given to everyone for same work No arbitrary distinctions can determine who receives what; or what is “right” in any situation (although inherent ones may) SO, we set up the “veil” to help eliminate these distinctions This means It functions like a Barrier: keeps out race, class, gender, group interests, sexual orientation, age, occupations, etc. -- puts players on equal playing field -- decisions based on “fairness” This is the veil....we step behind it to make decisions - the other side is “real life” Helps us iron out a “social contract’ that by definition is just Gives the “little guy” a leg up Who you are, what you have shouldn’t determine what you now should get

56 Main Ideas Fairness fundamental to justice Egalitarian perspective Fairness as quantitative in basic cases Elimination of arbitrary distinction Emphasizes the morally appropriate action, not the action that benefits the most people

57 Veil of Ignorance Roles and social differentiations eliminated Race, class, gender, and other personality features suspended behind the veil Equality behind the veil intended to protect the weaker party and minimize risks

58 Two Principles 1. Maximal system of equal basic liberty 2. All social goods other than liberty may be distributed unequally only if distribution favors the least advantaged side

59 Additional Links John RawlsJohn Rawls A biographical sketch of Rawls along with a discussion of his major works. John Rawls and the Social Contract John Rawls and the Social Contract An evaluation of Rawls’s theory of justice as fairness. The Antipolitical Philosophy of John RawlsThe Antipolitical Philosophy of John Rawls This article considers whether Rawls’s idea of justice is applicable in the modern world. A Just ManA Just Man Michael Sandel’s article, referred to in the above link, discussed Rawls’s contributions.

60 Ethical Guidelines Based on Love Judeo-Christian Persons as Ends Noddings’ Relational Ethics

61 Judeo Christian Persons as Ends “Love your neighbor as yourself” “What is the Will of Heaven like? The answer is – To love all men everywhere alike”

62 Main Ideas All moral obligations derived from the command to love God and humankind Love for neighbor as normative Regard for others as personal, not legalistic (as with Rawls’s contract) Humans made in the image of God and with unconditional value apart regardless of circumstances

63 Agape Love Unselfishness, other-regarding care Much more than friendship, charity, or benevolence To love is to accept a person as he or she is with unalterable commitment and permanent loyalty People are never given instrumental value

64 Concerns Failure of adherents to practice agape love Love vs. justice Reason as distinct from discernment Whether agape is universal or had continuity with other alternatives

65 Advantages Practical, gives help to those who need it Avoids discrimination without denying distinctions Does not presume to assign value to an individual

66 Noddings’ Relational Ethics “The ‘one-caring’ attends to the ‘cared-for’ in thought and deeds”

67 Main Ideas Ethics rooted in relationships Emphasizes nurturing and caring for people, not avoiding harm to others Roles of the one-caring and the cared-for Three dimensions: engrossment, motivational displacement, and reciprocity

68 Additional Links Agape in Feminist EthicsAgape in Feminist Ethics This article describes several different approaches to other-regard, contrasting Protestant and feminist appraisals of agape. Can Agape Be Universalized?Can Agape Be Universalized? The test of universalizability is applied to agape. Care Ethics and Virtue EthicsCare Ethics and Virtue Ethics A critical evaluation of Noddings’ care ethics. Longing for the Sacred in Schools: A Conversation with Nel NoddingsLonging for the Sacred in Schools: A Conversation with Nel Noddings Nel Noddings defends the place of spirituality in public education.

69 To Whom Is Moral Duty Owed? Who Ought to Decide?

70 Five Categories of Obligation 1.Duty to ourselves 2.Duty to clients / subscribers / supporters 3.Duty to our organization or firm 4.Duty to professional colleagues 5.Duty to society

71 Loyalties Duty to society is critical Ethical decision-making must be marked by a sincere sense of social responsibility and a genuine concern for the citizenry In the Potter Box the loyalty component necessitates the acknowledgment of the implications of a decision for institutions and social groups before an ethical decision is made.Potter Box

72 Empirical Definition Identifying Values Appeal to Ethical Principles Choosing Loyalties Particular Judgment or Policy Sociological Immediate External Philosophical Reflective Internal both positive & negative Feedback virtue, duty, utility, rights, love Facts

73 Accountability Are parents alone accountable for the programs their children watch, or do advertisers and networks carry responsibility also? Can producers of entertainment dismiss their responsibility for quality programming by arguing that they merely give the public what it wants Requiring accountability across the board preferable to giving absolute authority to one person or group.

74 Individuals The individual is the authentic moral agent. Though corporations are real, they are not concrete enough to be assigned praise or blame in any real sense. Ultimately it is the individual who will be held responsible.

75 Corporate Obligation Corporate obligation still meaningful Ultimate responsibility rests with individuals but must be distributed among the individuals constituting a corporation. Broad attacks on entire media systems are not helpful. Ethics is fundamentally concerned with individual choices.


Download ppt "The Potter Box Model of Reasoning. British law prohibits reporting the names and family histories of children facing criminal charges until their trials."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google