1. Principal Observation May 2014 Copyright © 2014 American Institutes for Research. All rights reserved. Growing Leadership to Provide Teacher Feedback Matthew Clifford, Principal Researcher National Summit for Principal Supervisors, May 2016

2. A national leader in teaching and learning improvement, AIR provides research, assessment, evaluation, and technical assistance to ensure that all students—particularly those facing historical disadvantages— have access to a high-quality, effective education. American Institutes for Research 2

3. 3 What We Do Evidence-based coaching Principal supervisor support Leadership measure design Principal evaluation support Leadership studies

4. The Performance Equation 4 We all need people who will give us feedback. That’s how we improve. - Bill Gates

5. 5 The Improvement Cycle Improvement Cycle StudyFeedback Planned Support Improvement

6. 6 Even if ratings are accurate, teacher evaluation will be ineffective if feedback is poorly delivered. Principals struggle to Accurately rate practice Make sense of scores Facilitate feedback Connect results to learning plans What we’ve learned from studies

7. 7 What we know (and research confirms) Delivered well, feedback motivates, builds trust, improves relationships. Strong feedback qualities: Evidence use Professional interactions Differentiated questions Two-way conversation Feedback is an evidence- based conversation about practice quality that leads to a plan for improvement.

8. 8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fj4m6qnSnSc Strong feedback qualities: Evidence use Professional interactions Differentiated questions Two-way conversation

9. No problem can be solved with the same level of consciousness that created it. -Albert Einstein Pair up … Was this an example of a good postobservation conference? Is this conference representative of conversations occurring in your district or state?

10. 10 Principals do receive training on delivering feedback and do not experience systematic performance feedback themselves Clifford & Mason (2015) NAESP & NASSP (2013) Goldring and associates (2011)

11. 11 Improvement Cycle StudyFeedback Planned Support Improvement Experience is the best teacher

12. 12 Instructional Feedback Observation 1of 3 principal supervisor tools 3 years in development Input from 200 educators Literature review Used in 41 districts

13. 13 What Principal Supervisors Do Engage principals in the observation process Step 1: Preobservation Step 2: Collect evidence (video & written) Step 3: Analyze via rubric Step 4: Discuss Step 5: Rate and Plan.

14. 14 What Principal Supervisors Do Five Ratings Evidence use Professional interactions Differentiated questioning Leading conversations Written feedback review

15. 15 Strong alignment with Professional Standards for Educational Leaders (2015) for… Standard 4: Curriculum, Instruction and Assessment Standard 5: Professional Capacity of School Personnel Also contributes to judgements about… Standard 7: Professional Community for Teachers and Staff Standard 10: School Improvement Aligns with several frameworks and standards

16. Pair up … Review sample tools Read the “quick form” and consider what evidence will be used for ratings Raise questions/concerns Learners need endless feedback more than they need endless teaching. -Grant Wiggins

17. 17 Evidence types Speech Time allocation Frequency count Written word http://tpep-wa.org/trainingpd/pre-and-post-observation- examples/

18. Debrief What were the areas of strength for the principal? What evidence did you use? What were areas of weakness for the principal? What evidence did you use? What would be the focus of your feedback to the principal?

19. 19 Using the process Supervisors need training and support to observe accurately Initial training (7 hours) Online coaching (2 hours) Making sense of data (1 hour) Targeted feedback rapidly improves principal feedback quality and teacher evaluation practice

20. 20 Closing What questions do you have? What concerns do you have? What strengths do you see in the tool?

21. Final Thoughts and Questions 21

22. Matthew Clifford 630-689-8017 mclifford@air.org American Institutes for Research 1000 Thomas Jefferson Street NW Washington, DC 20007 Phone: 202-403-5000 TTY: 877-334-3499 www.air.org 22