2. Parameters for Rating Municipal Councillors ParameterMarks Past 1 (Education qualification, PAN Card, Criminal cases)7 Present 2 (Attendance, No. of Question, Participation in Discussions (GBM), Questions compared to Citizen's Complaints & Importance of questions asked by issues raised, Usage of Area Development Fund 4 ) 63 Perception (through an citizen survey of 22,850 people for their perception on their Councillor’s accessibility/availability, performance, corruption, and satisfaction with quality of life, services provided by government) 30 Negative for new FIR cases till December 2014 post elections 3 Minus 5 Negative for pending Charge Sheet 3 Minus 5 Total100 2 RTI Data Source: 1 Municipal Secretary, MCGM (MCGM Head Office and BEST) and Assistant Engineer (Maintenance), MCGM (from all the 24 Administrative Wards of MCGM); 2 Election Commission Department, MCGM; 3 Mumbai Police. 4 Area Development Fund relates to the period April’14 to March’15 (Rs.60 lakhs).

3. Mumbai Report Card Municipal Councillors 2015 3 Grade A – Between 100% to 80% Grade B – Less than 80% to 70% Grade C – Less than 70% to 60% Grade D – Less than 60% to 50% Grade E – Less than 50% to 35% Grade F – Less than 35% (Period under consideration – April 2014 to March 2015. Ranking of 220 councillors)

4. 4

5. TOP 10 COUNCILLORS by RANK 5 Ward Constituen cy No. Political PartyCouncillor name Score (out of 100) Rank 2014 2015 R/S22 BJPSunita Ramnagina Yadav80.87 6 1 D210 INCNoshir Rusi Mehta76.98 9 2 R/S25 INCAjanta Rajpati Yadav76.57 29 3 G/S188 SSHemangi Hareshwar Worlikar76.18 2 4 P/N40 BJPGyanmurti Ramchandra Sharma75.73 3 5 L160 SSSanjana Kishor Mungekar75.65 22 6 K/W60 SSSanjay Kashinath Pawar75.02 5 7 F/S199 SS Hemangi Hemantkumar Chemburkar74.55 51 8 E208 INCManoj Pandurang Jamsutkar74.33 106 9 F/N169 SSShradha Shridhar Jadhav74.26 116 10

6. 6 BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS by RANK Ward Constituency No. Political PartyCouncillor name Score (out of 100) Rank 2014 2015 S116MNSAvinash Bhaskar Sawant25.37 225220 K/W53INDChangez Jamal Multani27.88 217219 H/W97INC Mohammed Tanveer Mohammed Ali Patel30.73 168218 H/E82MNSSukhada Rahul Pawar30.76 138217 M/E139SSDinesh Harishchandra Panchal30.79 204216 F/S198SSSanjay (Nana) Gajanan Ambole31.20 222215 P/N37SSManisha Sadashiv Patil32.87 209214 M/W142INCSeema Rajendra Mahulkar32.99 191213 F/N172IND Manojkumar Martandrao Sansare33.70 218212 N128MNSMangal Prameshwar Kadam34.05 223211

7. TOP 10 COUNCILLORS for MOVEMENT 7 WardC.No.PartyCounciilor name Score 2015 (out of 100) Rank Move mentReasons 20142015 H/W94INCSunita Wavekar65.3819563132 No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance K/W57NC Devendra Amberkar71.6615224128 No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance P/S47SSJitendra Valvi70.8215132119 No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance F/S195INCSunil More67.6717051119 No. of questions, Quality of questions; Perceived Performance R/C13MNSChetan Kadam66.3017658118 Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance K/E80INDJyoti Alavani65.3518064116 Quality of questions; Perceived Performance F/N174INCNayna Sheth72.9012514111 Quality of questions; Perceived Performance P/S51SSPramila Shinde72.4412417107 Attendance; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance F/N169SSShradha Jadhav74.2611610106 Quality of questions; Perceived Performance A225INC Sushama Salunkhe61.6720096104 No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance

8. 8 BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS for MOVEMENT WardC. No.PartyCounciilor name Score 2015 (out of 100) Rank Move mentReasons 20142015 G/N181MNSShraddha Patil50.2563171-108 Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance A224SSGanesh Sanap49.6068175-107No. of questions; Quality of questions P/N42MNSDeepak Pawar50.6767170-103 Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions; Perceived Performance K/W62BJPAmeet Satam53.3461154-93Attendance; No. of questions P/S45INCSneha Zagade57.9925115-90 Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions D213SSAnil Singh60.971199-88No. of questions K/E67SSManjiri Parab47.9996181-85 Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions F/N168BJPSelvan R. Tamil56.7443123-80 Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of questions H/E82MNSSukhada Pawar30.76138217-79 Attendance; No. of Question; Quality of questions H/E87BJPKrishna Parkar57.3241119-78Attendance; No. of Question

9. TOP 10 COUNCILLORS for Participation in Discussion(GBM) 9 Ward Constituency No. Political PartyCouncillor nameNos. F/N170SSTrushna Chandrakant Vishwasrao27 K/W61INCMohsin Haji Haider25 S110NCPDhananjay Sadashiv Pisal20 K/W57INCDevendra Shridhar Amberkar19 M/E132SPRais Kasam Shaikh18 G/N185MNSSandeep Sudhakar Deshpande16 C220SPYaqoob Janmohammed Memon16 L159SPAshraf Azmi Aslam Ansari15 B222INCWaqarunnisa Ansari15 T103BJPManoj Kishorbhai Kotak14

10. Spread of Participation in Discussion(GBM) 10 CategoryNo. of councillors 0107 145 2 to 537 6 to 1017 11 to 157 Above 167

11. Highlights (1/2) 11 For the first time ‘A’ grade has been assigned to a councillor Average committee meeting attendance down to 68% in 2014-15 from 81% in 2012-13 Proportion of questions asked compared to civic complaint's just 29.1%. Awareness and accessibility scores have increased from 35% in 2013-14 to 52% in 2014-15 58% have asked less than 10 questions in 2014-15

12. 12 Highlights (2/2) Ward Constituency No. Political PartyCouncillor name No. of question asked Rank 2014 2015 P/N37SSManisha Sadashiv Patil0 209 214 K/W53INDChangez Jamal Multani0 217 219 K/E73INCKesarben Murji Patel0 212 206 H/E82MNSSukhada Rahul Pawar0 138 217 H/W97INC Mohammed Tanveer Mohammed Ali Patel0 168 218 S116MNSAvinash Bhaskar Sawant0 225 220 N120NCPPratiksha Raju Ghuge0 192 210 N128MNSMangal Prameshwar Kadam0 223 211 M/E136SSManju Bholeshankar Kumare0 174 203 9 Councillors haven’t asked a single question this year (FY 2014-15)

13. FIRs registered against counicllors as of 31 st December 2014 13 CategoryNo. of councillorsNo. of FIRs 01630 131 2 to 51949 6 to 10533 Above 10223 Total220136 Total of current municipal councillors who have FIRs registered: 57 Councillors with most FIRs: Raju Shripad Pednekar(12), Anant Bhiku Nar(11) and Ramesh Gajanan Korgaonkar(8)

14. Committee wise data 14 Note: (*) Only those who were present form April 2014 to March 2015 have been taken, also former Mayor and current Mayor have been excluded No. of members* No. of meeting Attendance in (%) No. of question asked No. of councillor have not single asked question Avg. question per meeting General Body Meeting (GBM) 220797286578 11 Ward Committee2203017196532 3 BEST Committee73563302 1 Education Committee243065508 2 Improvements Committee264169847 2 Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee 3534592922 1 Markets and Gardens Committee 3621555914 3 Public Health Committee3424611235 5 Standing Committee27147661195 1 Tree Committee172367315 1 Women and Child Welfare Committee 3619603920 2 Works Committee (City)3641624013 1 Works Committee (Suburbs) 3722579911 5

15. 15 THANK YOU!!!