1. BMT Designers & Planners 1 Pollution Prevention Metrics Promoting Activity Accountability and Managing Environmental Improvements at CNRSW National Defense Industrial Association (NDIA) 30 th Environmental and Energy Symposium & Exhibition April 7, 2004 Delphine Lee, BMT Designers & Planners Ed Bonnes, CNRSW Environmental

2. BMT Designers & Planners 2 Naval Base Point Loma, San Diego, CA Activity Name 710 th Army EOD ARCO Dry Dock CDU CSS-11 EODTEU-1 FCTC PAC FISC Fuel Farm FASW Training Center HAZMAT Facility NWS SB SD Det. Magnetic Silencing Facility MK-7 MWR Auto Hobby Shop Navy Construction Battalion NEX Autoport SUBASE NEX Autoport – Nimitz NHRC SUBTRAFAC Pistol Range PSNS NRMD PSNS Projects Group NBPL Env. Site Team Port Operations PWC Recurring Maint. PWC Asbestos & Lead PWC Technical Services PWC Electrical Utilities PWC Civil Utilities BOWTS SIMA SSMD SUBASE Ops USCG Cutters US Navy Sailing Center Hazardous Waste Generation (Shore Activities) in 2001 ~ 327,000 lbs Naval Weapons Station Seal Beach SD Det. Puget Sound Naval Shipyard SD Det.

3. BMT Designers & Planners 3 Traditional P2 Review, Example #1 Puget Sound Naval Shipyard, San Diego Detachment Battery Well Cleaning Pipe / Heat Exchanger Flushing Radiological Testing Sand Blasting Blast Booth Possible PPEP Equipment Hazardous Waste Reduction 0 lbs Processes Total Hazardous Waste Reduction = 0 lbs

4. BMT Designers & Planners 4 Traditional P2 Review, Example #2 Naval Weapons Station Seal Beach San Diego Detachment Torpedo Flushing Touchup Painting Parts Cleaning Aqueous Parts Washer 1,800 lbs Total Hazardous Waste Reduction = 1,800 lbs Possible PPEP Equipment Hazardous Waste Reduction Processes

5. BMT Designers & Planners 5 Pollution Prevention Metrics Activity Waste Description Quantity of Waste Disposed EPA and State Waste Codes Waste Pickup Date Unit Cost for Disposal Method of Disposal

6. BMT Designers & Planners 6 Prioritizing P2 Efforts by Waste Stream

7. BMT Designers & Planners 7 Targeting the Largest Hazardous Waste Stream Labor Savings 50 hours 10 peo / crew $80 / person $40 K / sub $80 K / year Wate r Heat Exchanger Current Process Acid Water Tank Hazardous Waste Disposal 15,000 gal / sub $32 K / year Acid, Heavy Metals and Scale Proposed Process Heat Exchanger Acid Water Recycling System Hazardous Waste Reduction: 160,000 lbs/yr Savings: $100 K / yr

8. BMT Designers & Planners 8 Prioritizing P2 Efforts by Waste Stream

9. BMT Designers & Planners 9 Targeting the Second Largest Waste Stream Oils with sludge and metals 10% Oils Sludge HCN gas Metals Water 33% Seawater Otto Fuel 10% Seawater 6% Transducer Underground Storage Tank Ullage Engine Parts Drain Water with alcohol, detergent and oils 43% Current Process Hazardous Waste Disposal 6000 gal $30 K / year

10. BMT Designers & Planners 10 Targeting the Second Largest Waste Stream (Con’t) Water with sludge and metals 10% Oils Sludge HCN gas Metals Water 33% Seawater Otto Fuel 10% Seawater 6% Transducer Underground Storage Tank Ullage Engine Parts Drain Water with alcohol, detergent and oils 43% Sewer NUWC Keyport BOWTS Proposed Process BOWTS Savings: $20 K / yr Hazardous Waste Reduction: 33,000 lbs

11. BMT Designers & Planners 11 Results of P2 Efforts 70% Hazardous Waste Reduction

12. BMT Designers & Planners 12 Making Activities Accountable Activity Waste Description Quantity of Waste Disposed EPA and State Waste Codes Waste Pickup Date Unit Cost for Disposal Method of Disposal

13. BMT Designers & Planners 13 Making Activities Accountable

14. BMT Designers & Planners 14 Tracking Pollution Prevention Efforts Activity Waste Description Quantity of Waste Disposed EPA and State Waste Codes Waste Pickup Date Unit Cost for Disposal Method of Disposal

15. BMT Designers & Planners 15 Tracking Pollution Prevention Efforts

16. BMT Designers & Planners 16 Summary P2 data were organized in 2 main ways at NBPL: By Waste Stream By Activity Developing P2 metrics helped NBPL: Focus its efforts on its top 10 waste streams Make activities accountable for implementing P2 recommendations Track progress towards P2