Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Market Trials Weekly Update – Friday Meeting November 15, 2013.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Market Trials Weekly Update – Friday Meeting November 15, 2013."— Presentation transcript:

1 Market Trials Weekly Update – Friday Meeting November 15, 2013

2 Agenda *The weekly Market Trials 9A Meeting was not held on 11/15/13. For MP Reference: Look Ahead Nov 18-24 Preliminary Results Scenario Tracker Slides Settlements Announcements Updates Release Scorecard Migration Report Known Issues Log Parallel Ops Approach for Tagging 2

3 Look-Ahead: Nov 18 – Nov 24 3 Parallel Ops Calendar on spp.org Parallel Ops Calendar spp.org > Integrated Marketplace > Market Trials > Parallel Operations Test> Integrated Marketplace Parallel Operations Project Documents Mon Nov 18: IDT Prep Call 3:00P CPT Known Issues Log Call 9:00A CPT Tues Nov 19: 2 Hour Integrated Deployment Test Bridge Open 8:00A – 12:30P CPT Wed Nov 20: IDT Prep Call & Debrief 3:00P CPT Tues Nov 21: 2 Hour Integrated Deployment Test Bridge Open 8:30A – 12:30P CPT Fri Nov 22: IDT Debrief & Market Trials Call 9:00A CPT For Reference Only

4 IDT Tuesday Nov 19 Mon Nov 18: Pre-Test Call at 3P CPT Tues Nov 19: Open MP Conference Call 8A -12:30P CPT Dial-In: 866-614-3718 Participant: 2388781 2 nd Separate conference bridge for current EIS BA Real-Time operations personnel 3 rd Separate conference bridge for SPP Vendors and SPP Internal IT –7:30A – 9:30A: Prepare for IDT  Join IDT Call. Participate in Roll Call  Match IM and EIS offers as close to exact as possible starting 2 hrs prior to the test  Verify IM deployments are being received –9:30A – 11:30A: Respond to SPP IM Deployment Instructions  Provide and request IDT status updates every 15 minutes  Participate in Roll Call to ensure exit is on schedule –11:30A – 12:30P: Participate in preliminary debrief Wed Nov 20: Post-Test Call at 3P CPT 4 For Reference Only

5 IDT Thursday Nov 21 Wed Nov 20: Pre-Test Call at 3P CPT Thurs Nov 21: Open MP Conference Call 8:30A -12:30P CPT Dial-In: 866-614-3718 Participant: 2388781 2 nd Separate conference bridge for current EIS BA Real-Time operations personnel 3 rd Separate conference bridge for SPP Vendors and SPP Internal IT –7:30A – 9:30A: Prepare for IDT  Join IDT Call. Participate in Roll Call  Match IM and EIS offers as close to exact as possible starting 2 hrs prior to the test  Verify IM deployments are being received –9:30A – 11:30A: Respond to SPP IM Deployment Instructions  Provide and request IDT status updates every 15 minutes  Participate in Roll Call to ensure exit is on schedule –11:30A – 12:30P: Participate in preliminary debrief Fri Nov 22: Post-Test Call and Market Trials Call at 9A 5 For Reference Only

6 IDT Reminders BA / Reliability Call: Please ensure your BA is represented 6 BA Reliability Attendance: Begin IDT Go/No-Go End IDT Go/No-Go AEP (CSWS) – American Electric Power Service Corp. NPPD – Nebraska Public Power District SPS (XCEL) – Southwestern Public Service Company CUS (SPRM) – City Utilities of Springfield OKGE – Oklahoma Gas and Electric WFEC – Western Farmers WR – Westar Energy SECI – Sunflower Electric Power Corp. LES – Lincoln Electric System Marketing KBPU (KACY) – Kansas City Board of Public Utilities EDE – Empire District Electric INDN – City of Independence KCPL – Kansas City Power and Light MPS – Missouri Public Services (KCPL) OPPD – Omaha Public Power District (On MP Call) GRDA – Grand River Dam Authority (On MP Call) For Reference Only

7 IDT Reminders MP / Open Market Call: The Marketing representative for the EIS BAs should be on this call 7 BA Marketing Attendance: Begin IDT Go/No-Go End IDT Go/No-Go OPPD – Omaha Public Power District – Reliability GRDA – Grand River Dam Authority – Reliability AEP (CSWS) Marketing – American Electric Power Service Corp. NPPD – Nebraska Public Power District (TEA) CUS (SPRM) – City Utilities of Springfield (TEA) SPS (XCEL) – Southwestern Public Service Company OKGE – Oklahoma Gas and Electric WFEC – Western Farmers (ACES) SECI – Sunflower Electric Power Corp. (ACES) WR – Westar Energy LES – Lincoln Electric System Marketing OPPD – Omaha Public Power District – Reliability KBPU (KACY) – Kansas City Board of Public Utilities EDE – Empire District Electric INDN – City of Independence KCPL – Kansas City Power and Light MPS – Missouri Public Services (KCPL) For Reference Only

8 IDT Reminders MP / Open Market Call: MPs with Resources should be represented 8 MP Attendance: Begin IDT Go/No-Go End IDT Go/No-Go AECC - Arkansas Electric Cooperative Corp. BCV - Blue Canyon Wind Power BUFF - Buffalo Dunes Wind Project (ENEL) CALP - Calpine Energy Services CHSM - Chisholm View Wind Project (ENEL) CMRN - Cimarron Wind Energy CHAN - City of Chanute FREM - City of Fremont DRDG - Dempsey Ridge Wind Farm DGPM - Dogwood Power Management EXGN - Exelon Generation Company FR2W - Flat Ridge Wind Energy GSEC - Golden Spread Electric Cooperative (ACES) GOOG - Google Energy MJST - High Majestic Wind KMEA - Kansas Municipal Energy Agency For Reference Only

9 IDT Reminders MP / Open Market Call: MPs with Resources should be represented 9 MP Attendance: Begin IDT Go/No-Go End IDT Go/No-Go KPP - Kansas Power Pool MLCI - Merrill Lynch Commodities MIDW - Midwest Energy MNCO - Minco Wind MEUC - Missouri Joint Municipal Electric Commission MEAN - Municipal Energy Agency of Nebraska FPLP - Nextera Energy Power Marketing NGP1 - Noble Great Plains Windpark OMPA - Oklahoma Municipal Power Authority CORP - Shell Energy North America SHWF - Smoky Hills Wind Project SWE - Southern Company Services SUSP - Sustaining Power Solutions TPS - Tenaska Power Services BEPM - Basin Electric Power Cooperative (Load Only) REMC - Rainbow Energy Marketing Corp. (Load Only) For Reference Only

10 IDT Reminders MPs are encouraged to exercise end-to-end Market processes –However, MPs are not required to bring Resources online solely for testing purposes. Echo Process: If a small MP or BA that represents Resources is unable to follow IM set-point instructions, but still able to disable ACE control then the IDT can still move forward if it is determined that reliability will not be adversely affected. These MPs will control their resources in manual mode. Importance of Control Status –If 1-2 Resources send the wrong control status, a mismatch will cause unnecessary discrepancies in solutions –Please remind your staff:  0: Resource is offline  1: Resources is online, dispatchable and able to provide contingency reserves  2: Resources is online, dispatchable and able to provide operating reserves (including Reg)  3: Resource is not dispatchable (coming online, going offline, test, or having issues that cannot follow dispatch) 10 For Reference Only

11 IDT Reminders EIS Market will continue to operate in parallel –LIPs will continue to be calculated normally based upon EIS Resource Offers –LIPs will be used for all Energy Settlement during IDTs –During IDTs, Unstructured Resource Deviation penalties will not apply in EIS Market Settlements Commit Resources as if the IDT was not occurring –MP should notify SPP that their Resource is coming online or offline and update the commit status in IM  For instance, self commit a resource coming on Submit Resource offers for use in RTBM to minimize mismatches –Resource offers should be consistent with operational parameters in EIS –Reg Ramp Rate curves and Contingency Reserve Ramp Rate curves should be set equal to the Ramp Rate Curve submitted for use in the Up direction in the EIS Market 11 For Reference Only

12 IDT Reminders COP populated using Resource and Ancillary Service Plans in the EIS –Resources should self commit in real time based on actual commitment –Resources identified in the EIS Ancillary Service Plans as providing Reg will be selected to provide Reg in the COP  MPs should submit a fixed amount for Reg-Up and Reg-Down with a zero Offer price so RTBM will allow clearing of Reg-Up and Reg-Down on the selected resources identified in the COP MP should set themselves to Fixed for Reserves (SPP will not do this for you) Operating Reserve Reqs set at the same level as those in the EIS Market –Reg-Up Dispatch Status: set to “Fixed” at specified MW –Reg-Down Dispatch Status: set to “Fixed” at specified MW – SPIN Dispatch Status: set to “Fixed” at specified MW –Online Supp: submit zero Supp Reserve Offer and zero price –Offline Supp: submit “Fixed” Offer at zero price –Not supplying ORs: submit reasonable offers based on actual current capability 12 For Reference Only

13 IDT Reminders Always follow IM Setpoints –Going into and coming out of IDTs, SPP wants MPs to be as close to EIS dispatches as possible RTBM Dispatch Instructions and cleared Operating Reserve will be sent to RTGEN system every 5 min –RTGEN will create Setpoint Instructions that will consist of the sum of the RTBM Dispatch Instruction, Reg Deployment and CRD –LMPs and MCPs will be generated for information purposes and will not be used for Settlement during IDTs Test Schedules should not be submitted during IDTs 13 For Reference Only

14 IDT Reference Documents Integrated Deployment Test (as part of Parallel Ops) spp.org > Integrated Marketplace > Market Trials > Integrated Deployment Test –Deployment Script –SPP IDT Activities –IDT MP Guide –IM BA Cutover Activities 14 For Reference Only

15 Schedule 15 Nov 18 - 24 Nov 18: Known Issues Log Call 9-10A Nov 18: IDT Prep Call 3:00P Nov 19: IDT 8:00A (test begins at 9:30A) Nov 20: IDT Debrief and Prep Call 3:00P Nov 21: IDT 8:30A (test begins at 9:30A) Nov 22: IDT Debrief and Market Trials Call 9:00A Nov 25 – Dec 1 Nov 26: Scenario 15 Commitment Mismatch Part 2 Nov 28: SPP Holiday Nov 29: SPP Holiday For Reference Only

16 Preliminary Results 16 Scenario 7 Must Offer From initial analysis it appears that most MPs were short of their demand bids and were in emergency conditions that should trigger Must Offer penalties From here, it is a manual process for the Market Monitor to determine if they were actually short and send out all of the notifications For Reference Only

17 Preliminary Results 17 Scenario 28a Nonfunctional Testing: CMS Outage  CMS was disabled for about 15 or 20 minutes while the MPs continued to submit virtual transactions from the Markets User Interface.  When CMS was disabled, the credit check from Markets was disabled.  When the scenario was over, SPP brought CMS back online, and the DA Markets Desk approved the pending transactions and re-enabled the credit check from the Markets side. That triggered the auto-approve and re-synch process between Markets and CMS, and all processed successfully.  9 virtual transactions were pending credit approval for 6 asset owners. All 9 transactions approved with the operator manual approval action.  The manual notifications were sent successfully  There is a known defect with Enable Link button command. SPP believes this should be corrected with the next PRD release. For Reference Only

18 Scenario Tracker as of Nov 14 page 1 of 2 18 Scenario ID Scenario Title SPP Successful SPP Unsuccessful MP StatusCommentsMP Fail Details 1Delay MarketX Insufficient MP Response 2Failure to Publish ORX Fail3 MPs requested retest 3Violate Credit LimitX Insufficient MP Response1 MP requested retest 3ADon't Violate CreditX Insufficient MP Response 4Outage SimulationX Pass 5.1DA Capacity ShortagePending R1.8. SPP will work with MPs to address concerns. 5.2RUC Cap ShortageXPending R1.8. SPP will work with MPs to address concerns. 6.1DA Capacity ExcessPending R1.8. SPP will work with MPs to address concerns. 6.2RUC Capacity ExcessPending R1.8. SPP will work with MPs to address concerns. 8DA Scarcity PricingX Insufficient MP Response 11EDR Deployment XTo be retested in P OpsRescheduled ?? 12OOMEX Fail2 MPs requested retestMPs did not have ICCP working 13Demand ResponseX Pass 14.1Low Load High WindX Pass 14.2Low Load High WindX Pass 15 Commitment Mismatch p1 X Insufficient MP Response 15Commit Mismatch p2 XTo be retested in P OpsRescheduled 11/26 16.1DA MitigationMPs can retest independently after R1.9 16.2RUC MitigationX Insufficient MP Response 16.3RTBM MitigationMPs can retest independently after R1.9 17.3Reserve Cap TestingX Fail1 MP retesting 11/25 18Failure ModesX Pass 19Emergency LogicX Insufficient MP Response 20CRD EventX Insufficient MP Response 21RTBM Scarcity #1, 3-8X Insufficient MP Response 21RTBM Scarcity #2X N/A 22Manual RUC X Insufficient MP Response For Reference Only

19 Scenario Tracker as of Nov 14 page 2 of 2 19 Scenario ID Scenario Title SPP Successful SPP Unsuccessful MP StatusCommentsMP Fail Details 23.1Spring Load ProfileRemoved from scope 23.2Spring Load ProfileRemoved from scope 24Re-Pricing X Insufficient MP Response 25.1Fall Load Profile X Pass 25.2Fall Load ProfileX Pass 26.1Winter Load ProfileX Pass 26.2Winter Load ProfileX Pass 27.1Summer Load ProfileX Pass 27.2Summer Load ProfileX Pass 28Non-Funct Test. b,c,d,eX Insufficient MP Response 30Loss of ICCPX Insufficient MP Response 31 Block Demand Response X Pass 32Day Before DA RUCX Fail1 MP retesting 11/16 33Ramp ReservationsX Fail1 MP requested retestMP system not ready 34Off Supp DeploymentX Fail6 MPs requested retest 35Daylight Savings Time Defects will be fixed and tested in Alstom DST environment. No pass/fail emails sent. For Reference Only

20 Scenario Tracker as of Nov 14 20 Summary - Successful: –30 Scenarios Successful –2 partial Scenarios (15 part 1 and 28b-e) Successful Summary - Retests: –15 individual retest requests pending –1 entire Scenario (11) and 1 partial Scenario (15 part 2) applicable MPs will retest during Parallel Ops –2 Scenarios (16.1 and 16.3) will be available for MP Unstructured testing after R1.9 –SPP will work with MPs on 3 Scenarios (5.1, 6.1, 6.2) in Parallel Ops to address concerns after R1.8 is installed in SPP lower environments –Scenario 35 (DST) defects will be fixed and tested in the Alstom DST environment For Reference Only

21 Scenario Tracker Metrics page 1 of 2 21 Scenario # Emails Sent # Responses Received % Responses Received # No Response % No Response# Passed % Passed (of Resp. Rec'd)# Fail % Fail (of Resp. Rec'd) 1 - Delay Market563766%1934%37100%00% 2 - Failure to Publish OR503468%1632%3191%39% 3 - Violate Credit Limit1016362%3838%6298%12% 3a - Don't Violate Credit Limit1026160%4140%61100%00% 4 - Outage Simulation513569%1631%35100%00% 5.1 - Day Ahead Capacity ShortageN/A 5.2 - RUC Capacity Shortage403485%615%3191%39% 6.1 - DA Capacity ExcessN/A 6.2 - RUC Capacity ExcessN/A 8 - Day Ahead Scarcity Pricing423686%614%36100%00% 11 - EDR DeploymentN/A 12 - OOME323094%26%2893%27% 13 - Demand Response11100%00%1100%00% 14.1 - Low load High Wind513671%1529%36100%00% 14.2 - Low Load High Wind363392%38%33100%00% 15 - Commitment Mismatch p1232191%29%21100%00% 15 - Commitment Mismatch p2N/A 16.1 - DA Offer Curve MitigationN/A 16.2 - RUC Offer Curve262492%28%2396%14% 16.3 - RTBM MitigationN/A 17.3 - Reserve Cap testing22 100%00%2195%15% 18 - Failure Modes0N/A 19 - Emergency Logic262492%28%24100%00% 20 - CRD Event212095%15%20100%00% For Reference Only

22 Scenario Tracker Metrics page 2 of 2 22 Scenario # Emails Sent # Responses Received % Responses Received # No Response % No Response# Passed % Passed (of Resp. Rec'd)# Fail % Fail (of Resp. Rec'd) 21 - RTBM Scarcity #1, 3-8332164%1236%21100%00% 22 - Manual and ID RUC commitment402153%1230%21100%00 21 - RTBM Scarcity Shortages #2N/A 22 - Manual RUC171376%424%13100%00% 23.1 - Spring Load ProfileN/A 23.2 - Spring Load ProfileN/A 24 - LMP Repricing442250%2250%2091%29% 25.1 - Fall Load Profile503468%1632%34100%00% 25.2 - Fall Load Profile503468%1632%34100%00% 26.1 - Winter Load Profile513569%1631%35100%00% 26.2 - Winter Load Profile513569%1631%35100%00% 27.1 - Summer Load Profile513569%1631%35100%00% 27.2 - Summer Load Profile513569%1631%35100%00% 28b, c, d, e - Non-Functional Test87 28 32%52 60%28 100%00% 30 - Loss of ICCP25 24 96%1 4%24 100%00% 31 - Block Demand Response 10 0%1 100%0 0%0 32 -Day before DA RUC251560%1040%1493%17% 33 - Ramp Reservation System532038%3362%1995%15% 34 - Off Supp Deployment141286%214%758%542% 35 - Daylight Savings TimeN/A For Reference Only

23 Settlements - Parallel Operations Accelerated posting schedule for Finals (OD+14) still being discussed. –Discussed at CWG this week. –Will be discussed with SUG November 19. Settlement system brought back up 11/14 as planned. No new Known Issues. Throughout Nov Settlements will continue to use OD+2 Data. Starting Dec 1 transition will be made to OD+4. 23 For Reference Only

24 Announcements 24 Modeling Reports The following reports were available on spp.org during SMT and have been moved permanently to the Marketplace portal: marketplace.spp.org > Public > Marketplace > Modeling Reports SL to Pnode to Zone Mapping SL EIR Mapping SMT FAQ SMT Quick Facts Scheduling Changes 3 Hour IDT Thursday, Dec 12 5:30 – 10:30A CPT (IDT Test 6:30 – 9:30A) Actual test is now 3 hours instead of 4 hours Web mirroring turns off Dec 16 Originally scheduled to turn off mid-January. Detailed slides follow. For Reference Only

25 Migration and Maintenance Report 25 Migration and Maintenance Report Migration and Maintenance Report posted to spp.org spp.org > Integrated Marketplace > Market Trials > Parallel Operations Test> Integrated Marketplace Parallel Operations Project Documents For Reference Only

26 26 Release Scorecard Release Scorecard posted to spp.org: spp.org > Integrated Marketplace > Market Trials > Parallel Operations Test> Integrated Marketplace Parallel Operations Project Documents Release Scorecard For Reference Only

27 Known Issues Log 27 Please review the Market Trials Known Issues Log on spp.org Market Trials Known Issues Log spp.org > Integrated Marketplace > Market Trials > Parallel Operations Test> Integrated Marketplace Parallel Operations Project Documents For Reference Only

28 Market Trials Useful Resources Integrated Marketplace Parallel Operations Project Documents spp.org > Integrated Marketplace > Market Trials > Parallel Operations Test> Integrated Marketplace Parallel Operations Project Documents Parallel Ops Presentations, Statistics, MP Meetings Folder Parallel Ops Reference Documents Folder Scenarios in Parallel Ops Folder > Scenarios Schedule Scenarios in Parallel Ops Folder Scenarios Schedule Parallel Ops Communication Plan Parallel Ops MP Guide Parallel Ops Calendar Known Issues Log Release Scorecard Migration Report Integrated Deployment Test (as part of Parallel Ops) spp.org > Integrated Marketplace > Market Trials > Integrated Deployment Test IDT MP Guide Parallel Ops Calendar Additional documents: Settlements Calendar marketplace.spp.org > Public > Settlements > Calendars Settlements Calendar Change Tracker spp.org > Integrated Marketplace > Marketplace Documents Change Tracker Integrated Marketplace Structured/Unstructured Test Project Documents spp.org > Integrated Marketplace > Market Trials > Structured / Unstructured Test> Integrated Marketplace Structured / Unstructured Test Project Documents 28

29 Tag Mirror/Replicate Process SPP is currently mirroring (copying) Production Tags from the EIS Market into the Integrated Marketplace Systems Process also modifies the tags to allow them to pass certain Marketplace Business Rules Copied tags are used to calculate the SPP CBA Net Scheduled Interchange (NSI) for use in the ACE equation Copied tags are used in RTBM to simulate activity from the current Balancing Authority activities 29 For Reference Only

30 Tag Mirror/Replicate Process Benefits The NSI calculated by the copied tags closely matches the aggregate 16 BA NSI for the current SPP EIS footprint Allows the SPP Engineers to study the Balancing Activities and compare those against the overall CBA NSI during the testing processes Important tool for Inadvertent verification purposes during deployment testing Lessened burden on MP not required to create tags 30 For Reference Only

31 Tag Mirror/Replicate Process - Costs Small number of MP have created test tags Tag Mirror Process renders Tariff validations invalid Test tags were approved regardless of tagging errors or failed evaluations necessary for CBA MP were trained on new Business Rules but have not been able to practice these new rules Errors and confusion for hundreds of tags for Go-live if MP do not begin the real tag submission process well in advance of Go-live 31 For Reference Only

32 Tag Mirror Process - Changes SPP will continue to Copy Tags for the first part of Parallel Operations –Tags Mirrored/copied – Nov. 12 thru Dec. 16 –Tag Mirror/copy will be turned off December 16 –Tag Mirror/copy will take days to wind down –Tag Mirror/Copy will not be reinstated for remainder of time to Go-live MP will enter tags January/February 2014 32 For Reference Only

33 IM Tagged Transaction entered by MP Import Tags into the SPP CBA (Required) –Consist of Load Serving Contractual obligations for SPP BA –Necessary for accurate NSI Export Tags out of the SPP CBA (Required) –Consist of Load Serving Contractual obligations for neighboring BA –Necessary for accurate NSI Internal SPP CBA tags (not allowed) Wheel/Through (not required/optional) 33 For Reference Only

34 IM Tagged Transactions - BP for approval SPP Operators will evaluate for new Business Practices: –Accurate Transmission Service –Accurate GCA and LCA for “SWPP” BA –Accurate Marketplace Protocols evaluation –Ramp Availability –Accurate Physical Path –Must include SWPP Transmission Service MP were previously trained on the new rules Operators will deny tags that do not pass 34 For Reference Only

35 IM Tagged Transaction Process – Getting Started MP will begin entering “Daily and Monthly” Import and Export tags for January Operating Month –Entry of tags between December 23 rd and December 31 –MP Will see evaluation failures to be remedied to gain approval –SPP Operators will assist MP/PSE with modifying tags for entry errors –When Tag is accurate SPP Operator will approve Optional - PSE adjust tags throughout January for Real Time Same process for month of February 35 For Reference Only

36 Impacts on Market Participants For the months of January and February MP will be required to “dual” enter. One tag in EIS Real time and an additional tag in IM Training Tag entered for Training will not need to be updated for real time. An average contractual mw profile will be adequate. Additional Tags are encouraged for Financial Market MP encouraged to compare EIS and IM settlement statements for strategy planning 36 For Reference Only

37 Impacts on Market Participants Required Tagged Transactions have been identified –Current EIS Tagged Transactions – 600 to 800 –Required Tagged Transactions – approximately 75 Impacted CPSE have been identified - CPSE involved in required transactions – approximately 12 CPSE are being contacted by SPP staff to communicate requirements for tag entry Tag entry also being coordinated with GP and LSE associated with required tags 37 For Reference Only


Download ppt "Market Trials Weekly Update – Friday Meeting November 15, 2013."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google