1. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Friedrich Lachmayer Ljubljana, 15th March 2007 Structural Visualization of the Pure Theory of Law Structural Visualization of the Pure Theory of Law

2. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Historical Position

3. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory 1934 1 1960 2 1934 1 1960 2

4. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules  very relevant Paradigmatical Change of Legal Theory and Juridical Methodology Pure Theory

5. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory  New Juridical Methodology

6. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory  New Terms and Concepts Norm Basic Norm Hierarchy of Norms Legal Act ….

7. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory a great Intensity of the Text

8. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory a great Intensity of the Text combined with a very clear Pre-textual Imagination

9. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory NLD Natural Law Doctrine Natural Law Doctrine  1970 Rene Marcic

10. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory NLD Natural Law Doctrine Natural Law Doctrine  1970 Rene Marcic

11. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory L Log. Legal Logic Legal Logic 1951  Deontic Logic Georg Henrik von Wright Ilmar Tammelo Ota Weinberger Jürgen Rödig Hajime Yoshino

12. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory L Inf. Legal Informatics Legal Informatics 1970  Herbert Fiedler Leo Reisinger Alfred Schramm Erich Schweighofer Roland Traunmüller Maria Wimmer

13. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory of Law

14. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Stage Metalevel Rules „Ought“ (Sollen) „Ought“ (Sollen) Pure Theory

15. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Stage Metalevel Rules „Is“ (Sein) „Is“ (Sein) „Ought“ (Sollen) „Ought“ (Sollen) Pure Theory

16. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Stage Metalevel Rules Stage

17. Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Stage Metalevel Facts Rules

18. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Facts Human Action Rules

19. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Facts Rules Human Action Conditions Behavior Consequences

20. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory

21. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Is (Sein) 3 Kinds of Interpretation: Facts Norms Texts

22. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Is (Sein) 1. Interpretation of Factual Reality

23. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts

24. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Interpretation Situation, Facts

25. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Interpretation

26. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Interpretation Reaction

27. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Interpretation Reaction Norm

28. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation

29. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation

30. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation Terms

31. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation Terms Modal Indifferent Substratum

32. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Imposition of Meaning Deutung

33. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Is/Sein Facts

34. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Is/Sein Legal Interpretation of Facts Legal Interpretation of Facts

35. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Facts not interpreted Facts (only colour, no lines)

36. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules subjective interpreted Facts subjektive Meaning/Sinn subj. Interpretation/ Deutung

37. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules objektive Meaning/Sinn Sein objective interpreted Facts Basic Norm Legal Norm

38. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Facts not interpreted Facts (only colour, no lines) subjective interpreted Facts subjektive Meaning/Sinn subj. Interpretation/ Deutung objektive Meaning/Sinn Sein objective interpreted Facts Basic Norm Legal Norm

39. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Is (Sein) 2. Interpretation of Legal Acts („Container“)

40. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Substratum: Normative Content

41. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Interpretation Substratum: Normative Content

42. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Interpretation Meaning: Valide Legal Act

43. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Interpretation Reaction Meaning: Valide Legal Act

44. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Interpretation Reaction Norm Meaning: Valide Legal Act

45. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation Meaning: Valide Legal Act

46. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Basic Norm Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation Meaning: Valide Legal Act

47. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Basic Hipothesis Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation Concept of Basic Norm Meaning: Valide Legal Act

48. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation 1. Interpretation of Facts

49. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Basic Norm Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation Meaning: Valide Legal Act 2. Interpretation of Norms

50. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Is (Sein) 3. Interpretation of Legal Texts („Content“)

51. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Legal Text §§§§§§§§§

52. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Legal Text §§§§§§§§§ Interpretation of the Content

53. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Legal Text §§§§§§§§§ Interpretation of the Content

54. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Is (Sein) Synthesis of the 3 Kinds of Interpretation: Subsumption

55. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Sein Meaning: Valide Legal Act

56. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Sein Meaning: Valide Legal Act §§§§§§§

57. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Sein Meaning: Valide Legal Act §§§§§§§ Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“)

58. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Sein Subsumption Meaning: Valide Legal Act §§§§§§§ Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“)

59. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Sein Meaning: Valide Legal Act §§§§§§§ Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Decision

60. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory

61. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Concept of Norm Pure Theory

62. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules pre-scriptive Human Being Norm: To Do

63. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Behavior: To Do Norm: To Do

64. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Status: To Be Norm: To Be Giovanni Sartor

65. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory

66. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Double- Norm Pure Theory

67. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Condition

68. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules ReactionCondition Hypothetical Norm if  then

69. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules To Do Kategorical Norm

70. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules FinalityReactionCondition another Concept (Luhmann)

71. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Hierachy of Norms Pure Theory

72. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules ConstitutionLawStatuteDecision

73. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules ConstitutionLawStatuteDecision Basic Norm

74. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules ConstitutionLawStatuteDecisionInternational Law Basic Norm

75. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules ConstitutionLawStatuteDecisionEU Secundary LawEU Primary LawInternational Law Basic Norm

76. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules ConstitutionLawStatuteDecisionPrivate TreatyEU Secundary LawEU Primary LawInternational Law opinio iuris Concept of Basic Norm

77. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules ConstitutionLawStatuteDecisionPrivate TreatyEU Secundary LawEU Primary LawInternational Law Basic Norm Hegemonial Law

78. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory

79. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Norm- Monism Pure Theory

80. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules The legal order exclusively consists of norms Norm

81. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Legal definitions are only part of other norms Norm Definition

82. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules another Concept: it is possible, that there are other Legal Elements too Legal Norm Indicative Legal Sentences Legal Signs

83. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory

84. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Purification (Deconstruction) of Ideology Pure Theory

85. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Situation, Facts Meaning („Sinn“) Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation 1. Interpretation of Facts

86. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Basic Norm Interpretation Reaction Norm Scheme of Interpretation Meaning: Valide Legal Act 2. Interpretation of Norms

87. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Legal Text §§§§§§§§§ Interpretation of the Content 3. Interpretation of Texts

88. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Approach of Purification  Deconstruction Traditional Concepts of Law 4. Critical Interpretation of other Theories

89. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Approach of Purification  deconstructed Traditional Concepts of Law

90. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Traditional Concepts of Personality Person

91. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Approach of Purification Person Person: only a Quantity of Rights and Duties  deconstructed

92. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Traditional Concepts of Institutions

93. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Institutions: only Norms Norm  deconstructed

94. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Traditional Concepts of State

95. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules State Approach of Purification State = Personification  deconstructed

96. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules but on the contrary

97. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory Personification of Jurisprudence Personification of Jurisprudence

98. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Pure Theory Personification of Jurisprudence Personification of Jurisprudence Approach of Purification?

99. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Thank you for your Attention Lachmayer @ chello.at

100. Stage Metalevel Subjekt Mind Rules Lachmayer @ chello.at