Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Brenda J. Stutsky RN, PhD Development and Testing of a Conceptual Framework for Interprofessional Collaborative Practice.

Published byPriscilla Shepherd Modified over 8 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Brenda J. Stutsky RN, PhD Development and Testing of a Conceptual Framework for Interprofessional Collaborative Practice."— Presentation transcript:

1 Brenda J. Stutsky RN, PhD Development and Testing of a Conceptual Framework for Interprofessional Collaborative Practice

2 Outline Project Background Literature Review Methods/Procedure Instrument Results Conceptual Framework 77 Discussion

3 Project Background Post-doctoral work in Health Human Resource Optimization at UWO September 2011 – December 2012 Advisor: Dr. Heather Laschinger

4 Project Background Special thanks to: –Carol Cooke, Associate Librarian, University of Manitoba –Catherine Hynes, Regional Manager Decision Support, Northern RHA

5 Literature Review Extensive review of the interprofessional literature –Antecedents/consequences of: Interprofessional education (IPE) Interprofessional collaborative practice (ICP)

6 Literature Review Problem –Interprofessional literature: Atheoretical –Terms are poorly conceptualized –Consistent framework for research is missing (Reeves et al., 2011)

7 Literature Review Collaborative Practice “When multiple health workers from different professional backgrounds provide comprehensive services by working with patients, their families, carers and communities to deliver the highest quality of care across settings.” (WHO, 2010)

8 Literature Review Relationship-Centered Collaborative Care –Model developed by Tresolini & Pew-Fetzer Task Force (1994) –3 key relationships 1.Patient-practitioner 2.Community-practitioner 3.Practitioner-practitioner –Used by researchers to guide ICP studies (Dix et al., 2008; Gaboury et al., 2011)

9 Consequences Interprofessional Collaborative Practice Conceptual Framework Antecedents Personal Factors Interprofessional Insight Beliefs in IPC Flexibility Relational Skills Trust Cooperation Communication Skills Situational Factors Leadership Empowerment Support Structures Interprofessional Collaborative Practice Collective Ownership of Goals Understanding of Roles Interdependence Knowledge Exchange Work Behaviours & Attitudes Personal Work Satisfaction Intent to Stay Team Perceived Team Effectiveness Conflict Organizational Outcomes Patient Safety Quality of Patient Care Patient Outcomes Patient Biopsychosocial Outcomes Patient Satisfaction Patient Empowerment Length of Stay

10 Methods/Procedure Exploratory design Regulated healthcare providers in Northern RHA –Involved in direct patient care planning or team decision making 3 hospitals, 3 long-term care facilities, 4 primary healthcare centres Manager in RHA assisted with distribution of packages –Information sheet –Informed consent –$2.00 gift card & draw ballot

11 Instrument Interprofessional Collaborative Practice Survey (Stutsky & Laschinger, 2012) –Constructed from existing standardized measures –55 items with 9 demographic items –5-point scale of strongly disagree to strongly agree (1-2=low level, 3=moderate, 4-5=high level) –Pt. safety, quality, degree of collaboration (5-point scale from low to high) –2 items measuring degree of collaboration used to validate ICP measure (r=.60 and r=.48)

12 Instrument Exploratory Factor Analysis (Construct Validity) –ICP –Personal Antecedents –Situational Antecedents –Consequences: Work Behaviours and Attitudes Reliability was adequate (.67 to.88)

13 Rotated Factor Loadings for Interprofessional Collaborative Practice Scales/Question #Ownership of Goals Understanding of Roles InterdependenceKnowledge Exchange Goals 37.880 Goals 39.789 Goals 40.674 Goals 38.522.451 Roles 32.794 Roles 35.744 Roles 33.623 Interdependence 31.788 Interdependence 34.633 Interdependence 30.475.584 Knowledge 44.828 Knowledge 41.705 Knowledge 43.466.473 4 factors with Eigenvalues greater than 1.00, explaining 59.73% of the cumulative variance

14 Rotated Factor Loadings for Antecedents: Personal Factors Interprofessional Insight Relational Skills Scales/Question #Beliefs in ICPTrustCommunicationFlexibilityCooperation Belief 2.903 Belief 4.859 Belief 3.830 Belief 1.760 Trust 10.795 Trust 11.782 Trust 9.770 Trust 8.756 Trust 14.563.470 Communication 15.825 Communication 16.706.329 Communication 17.381.634 Flexibility 5.856 Flexibility 6.737.324 Cooperation 12.865 Cooperation 13.321.346.628 5 factors with Eigenvalues greater than 1.00, explaining 71.44% of the cumulative variance

15 Rotated Factor Loadings for Antecedents: Situational Factors Situational Factors Scales/Question #SupportLeadershipEmpowerment Support 24.763 Support 25.708 Support 23.659.425 Support 27.557.370 Support 26.398.599 Leadership 21.876 Leadership 20.799 Leadership 22.359.702 Empowerment 29.880 Empowerment 28.315.858 3 factors explained 67.50% of the cumulative variance

16 Rotated Factor Loadings for Consequences: Work Behaviours and Attitudes Work Behaviours & Attitudes: Team Work Behaviours & Attitudes: Team Scales/Question #ConflictTeam Effectiveness Intent to StayWork Satisfaction Conflict 59.767 Conflict 57.722.475 Conflict 60.715 Conflict 58.691.378 Team Effectiveness 55.870 Team Effectiveness 54.768.364 Team Effectiveness 56.728.356 Stay 49.884 Stay 51.870 Stay 50.306.587.581 Work Satisfaction 52.783 Work Satisfaction 53.363.369.681 4 factors explained 74.71% of the cumulative variance

17 Results Demographics Response rate 32% (N=117) 95 females, 21 males, 1 not indicated 23-68 yrs. of age (M=43.30, SD=11.77) 0.5-40 yrs. of experience (M=15.51, SD=12.45) 75% nurses, 17% allied health, 8% physicians 59% acute care, 34% community care, 7% long-term care 72% full-time, 24% part-time, 4% casual 78% direct patient care

18 Results Subscale Scores Means ranged 3.25 (SD=.81) to 4.41 (SD=.63) Conflict 3.05 (SD=.73) –Only 34% did not have frequent conflicts over sharing of responsibilities (M=2.97, SD=1.03) –Only 25% did not believe that interprofessional relationships had winners and losers (M=3.27, SD=1.05)

19 Results Correlations Correlations between ICP and its antecedents and consequences All factors were significantly correlated with overall ICP (r=.33-.65, p<.01) except for flexibility

20 Results Hierarchical Multiple Regression Influence of personal and situational antecedents on overall ICP 37% of the variance of ICP was attributed to personal factors with an additional 12% being explained by situational factors Hierarchical Multiple Regression for Personal and Situational Factors on ICP R2R2 ∆R2∆R2 BSEβP Personal Factors.366**.400.076.405.000** Situational Factors.123**.250.048.403.000** Total ICP R 2.489** **p<.001

21 Results Hierarchical Multiple Regression Influence of individual components of subscales of personal and situational antecedents on overall ICP 49% of the variance of ICP was explained by personal factors with an additional 10% being attributed to situational factors

22 Hierarchical Multiple Regression for Personal and Situational Subscales on ICP R2R2 ∆R2∆R2 BSEβP Personal Factors.485** Beliefs in IPC.029.047.043.542 Flexibility -.051.043-.078.242 Trust.091.044.165.043* Cooperation.151.052.207.005* Communication.205.049.333.000** Situational Factors.098** Leadership.004.048.006.942 Empowerment.013.037.032.723 Support Structures.174.043.330.000** Total ICP R 2.583** *p<.05, **p<.001

23 Results Series of Regression Analyses Combined effect of personal and situational antecedents and overall ICP on consequences Combination of predictors explained a significant variance in all six consequences of ICP

24 Hierarchical Multiple Regression for the Entire Model Work Behaviours & Attitudes: Personal Work Behaviours & Attitudes: Team Organizational Outcomes Work Satisfaction Intent to Stay Team Effectiveness Conflict Patient Safety Quality Patient Care Standard Coefficients Beta Personal Factors Beliefs in IPC.068-.008.018.279*.120.024 Flexibility-.055.061-.152-.073-.113-.103 Trust-.049.055.100.357**.087-.018 Cooperation.087-.073-.092*-.049-.038-.075 Communication-.080.033.171-.002-.018.230* Situational Factors Leadership.050.127.050.092-.025.015 Empowerment.570**.364*.144-.040.091.195 Support Structures-.131-.235*.078-.076.020.064 ICP ICP Overall.305*.405**.329*.450**.283* R 2 and ∆R 2 Personal Factors R 2.200**.178**.377**.417**.207**.270** Situational Factors ∆R 2.232**.096*.090**.007.042.076* ICP ∆R2.039*.069**.045*.085**.033* Total Model R 2.472*.313*.537**.469*.334**.380* *p<.05, **p<.001

25 Discussion Encouraging preliminary empirical support for the conceptual framework Results were consistent with findings in the literature including the importance of relationship-centered collaborative care Limitations include small sample size and response rate Limited power prevented more sophisticated analyses (SEM) Psychometric properties of the ICPS are promising but continual refinement and validation is needed Patient outcomes need to be captured in future studies

26 Discussion Use of the framework –Healthcare leaders: Guide for facilitating ICP to enhance patient safety and quality of care –Educators: Strengthen IPE curricula –Healthcare professionals: Evidence linking personal attitudes and behaviours to effective ICP and patient safety and quality may motivate them to reflect on own behaviours and make a commitment to ICP Further research to validate the framework

27

Download ppt "Brenda J. Stutsky RN, PhD Development and Testing of a Conceptual Framework for Interprofessional Collaborative Practice."

Similar presentations

Interprofessional Education Building from the Bottom Out

Interprofessional Education Building from the Bottom Out
Is There a Relationship Between Hospital Safety Culture and Safety Outcomes in VA Hospitals? Amy K. Rosen, Ph.D. 1,2, Sara Singer, Ph.D. 3,Christine Hartmann,

Is There a Relationship Between Hospital Safety Culture and Safety Outcomes in VA Hospitals? Amy K. Rosen, Ph.D. 1,2, Sara Singer, Ph.D. 3,Christine Hartmann,
Principles & Framework

Principles & Framework
Predicting Youth Engagement: The Role of Initiating and Sustaining Factors Linda Rose-Krasnor 1, Kelly Campbell 1, Lisa Loiselle 2, Mark Pancer 3, Michael.

Predicting Youth Engagement: The Role of Initiating and Sustaining Factors Linda Rose-Krasnor 1, Kelly Campbell 1, Lisa Loiselle 2, Mark Pancer 3, Michael.
Interprofessional Education and Practice: Creating Leaders and Opportunities for Clinical Learning MODULE 2 Setting the Scene Setting the Scene Funded.

Interprofessional Education and Practice: Creating Leaders and Opportunities for Clinical Learning MODULE 2 Setting the Scene Setting the Scene Funded.
Assessing the Unmet Needs of Health Care Providers Using a Web-Based Survey Ruth McCorkle, PhD, FAAN Connecticut Coalition to Improve End-of-Life Care.

Assessing the Unmet Needs of Health Care Providers Using a Web-Based Survey Ruth McCorkle, PhD, FAAN Connecticut Coalition to Improve End-of-Life Care.
Improving health outcomes across England by providing improvement and change expertise How to Measure Patient Activation Measuring Patient Activation In.

Improving health outcomes across England by providing improvement and change expertise How to Measure Patient Activation Measuring Patient Activation In.
Temporal Intelligence and Time Management 14 th European Congress of Work and Organizational Psychology 15 th May 2009 Andrew Doyle and Dr Jan Francis-Smythe.

Temporal Intelligence and Time Management 14 th European Congress of Work and Organizational Psychology 15 th May 2009 Andrew Doyle and Dr Jan Francis-Smythe.
Measuring the quality of staff-family relationships in residential aged care Dr Michael Bauer Dr Deirdre Fetherstonhaugh Dr Virginia Lewis.

Measuring the quality of staff-family relationships in residential aged care Dr Michael Bauer Dr Deirdre Fetherstonhaugh Dr Virginia Lewis.
Comparing Job Demands, Coping Resources and Well-being Across Different Health Care Providers Working Together Jane B Lemaire MD, Jean E Wallace PhD, Janet.

Comparing Job Demands, Coping Resources and Well-being Across Different Health Care Providers Working Together Jane B Lemaire MD, Jean E Wallace PhD, Janet.
The Influence of Parent Education on Child Outcomes: The Mediating Role of Parents Beliefs and Behaviors Pamela E. Davis-Kean University of Michigan This.

The Influence of Parent Education on Child Outcomes: The Mediating Role of Parents Beliefs and Behaviors Pamela E. Davis-Kean University of Michigan This.
Stage One: Registrant, (N.M.C., 2006). Student Handout. (May, 2008).

Stage One: Registrant, (N.M.C., 2006). Student Handout. (May, 2008).
Dr. Dalal AL-Matrouk KBA Farwaniya Hospital

Dr. Dalal AL-Matrouk KBA Farwaniya Hospital
Maria Cristina Matteucci, Dina Guglielmi

Maria Cristina Matteucci, Dina Guglielmi
Human Resource Development in Healthcare Organizations

Human Resource Development in Healthcare Organizations
An Acute Care World without Registered Nurses Kathleen Gallo, PhD, MBA, RN, FAAN Senior Vice President & Chief Learning Officer.

An Acute Care World without Registered Nurses Kathleen Gallo, PhD, MBA, RN, FAAN Senior Vice President & Chief Learning Officer.
Weighting CanMEDS Roles & Competencies Marilyn Singer MD, FCFP Director, Clinician Assessment Programs Brenda Stutsky RN, PhD, Program Advisor, Manitoba.

Weighting CanMEDS Roles & Competencies Marilyn Singer MD, FCFP Director, Clinician Assessment Programs Brenda Stutsky RN, PhD, Program Advisor, Manitoba.
Motivation to Lead Layla Qaabidh, RN, MSN, (PhD candidate)

Motivation to Lead Layla Qaabidh, RN, MSN, (PhD candidate)
Parental Satisfaction: The Effects of Perceived Parental Self Efficacy, Care-Giving Role and Child Age Hamill, N. R., Fleming, M. J., (University of Canberra)

Parental Satisfaction: The Effects of Perceived Parental Self Efficacy, Care-Giving Role and Child Age Hamill, N. R., Fleming, M. J., (University of Canberra)
Reliability and factorial structure of a Portuguese version of the Children’s Hope Scale José Tomás da Silva Maria Paula Paixão Catarina Carvalho dos Santos.

Reliability and factorial structure of a Portuguese version of the Children’s Hope Scale José Tomás da Silva Maria Paula Paixão Catarina Carvalho dos Santos.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google