Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

An investigation of factors affecting the accuracy of Thies disdrometers TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Graham Upton and Dan.

Published byBonnie Morris Modified over 8 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "An investigation of factors affecting the accuracy of Thies disdrometers TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Graham Upton and Dan."— Presentation transcript:

1 An investigation of factors affecting the accuracy of Thies disdrometers TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Graham Upton and Dan Brawn University of Essex, Colchester, UK

2 Thanks TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton To the UK Met Office (for providing the data) To the EPSRC (Grant:EP/P500214/1) (for the money) To Dan Brawn (for letting me come to St. Petersburg!)

3 The Thies disdrometer TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Uses a 780 nm infrared parallel light-beam with a cross-section of 45.6 cm 2. Particle diameters recorded using 22 bins Fall speeds recorded using 20 bins

4 The test site: Eskdalemuir Under these clouds! TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton

5 Overview of the instruments TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Looking North-West

6 The disdrometers (3 Thies & 1 Parsivel) TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Looking towards the North-West

7 Close up of the three Thies TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Looking towards the West T1 T3 T2

8 Arrangement of the four disdrometers TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton DisdrometerPole Height of disdrometer above ground Orientation (pole end given first) T1A2mNorth-South T2B1.75mNorth-South T3B2mWest-East ParsivelC2mWest-East

9 Restrictions on comparisons TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Counts in lowest Thies size bin ignored (to permit comparison with Parsivel: diameters considered are therefore between 0.25mm and 8mm) 2.Use only hours with complete data (there were some computer problems: this restriction ensures that individual minutes are correctly matched) 3.Use only minutes in which the average Thies count was 50 drops (to eliminate records not caused by rain)

10 Average drop counts (per minute) TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Excellent agreement between the Thies 2.Number of drops recorded by the Parsivel is only about 75% of that recorded by a Thies Rain rateT1T2T3Parsivel < 1 mm/hr286 284212 > 1 mm/hr886898897719

11 Comparison of Thies and Parsivel drop count distributions TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Log scale on vertical axis 2.Parsivel’s consistently higher (though small) counts of larger diameter drops 3.Thies’s much greater count of the smaller drops Notes:

12 Overall equality of counts between the three Thies does not mean that they agree all the time! TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton TimeT1T2T3 12:03161816451290 :::: 12:11222222791879 Total180901804915428 Nine minutes of heavy rain during a storm at midday on June 30th, 2007

13 Overall equality of counts between the three Thies does not mean that they agree all the time! TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton TimeT1T2T3 12:03161816451290 :::: 12:11222222791879 Total180901804915428 North-South North-South West-East Pole A Pole B Pole B 2m 1.75m 2m

14 Shielding: the effect of wind direction TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Wind direction 110°-130°-150°-170°-190°-210°-230°-250°-270°-290°- T1 > T3 (% of minutes with wind in given direction) 85%64%39%27%26%31%48%56%61%50% No. of minutes 7719612621317812322620413265 These are statistically significant variations from 50%

15 Shielding: the effect of wind direction TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Wind direction 110°-130°-150°-170°-190°-210°-230°-250°-270°-290°- T1 > T3 (% of minutes with wind in given direction) 85%64%39%27%26%31%48%56%61%50% No. of minutes 7719612621317812322620413265 The two disdrometers are at the same height above ground

16 Shielding: the effect of wind direction TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Wind direction 110°-130°-150°-170°-190°-210°-230°-250°-270°-290°- With wind in given direction, % of minutes T1 > T3 85%64%39%27%26%31%48%56%61%50% No. of minutes 7719612621317812322620413265 The two disdrometers are at the same height above ground T1 is oriented North-South T3 is oriented West-East

17 Shielding and drop size TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton T3 T2 The next results compare counts for T2 and T3 (very close in space)

18 A useful comparison statistic TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton m ij = Median(Count i / count j ) where count i denotes the one-minute drop count for disdrometer i Only minutes where both disdrometers count at least 50 drops are included

19 Shielding and drop size TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Drop diameter (mm) Wind from the South m 23 Wind from the West m 32 0.125-0.810.85 0.25-0.860.96 0.375-0.990.98 0.5-1.000.98 0.75-0.940.96 1-0.980.96 T2 is oriented North-South (T3 is not) Test statistic is m 23 = Median(count 2 / count 3 )

20 Shielding and drop size TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Drop diameter (mm) Wind from the South m 23 Wind from the West m 32 0.125-0.810.85 0.25-0.860.96 0.375-0.990.98 0.5-1.000.98 0.75-0.940.96 1-0.980.96 T3 is oriented West-East (T2 is not) Test statistic is m 32 = Median(count 3 / count 2 )

21 Shielding and drop size TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Drop diameter (mm) Wind from the South m 23 Wind from the West m 32 0.125-0.810.85 0.25-0.860.96 0.375-0.990.98 0.5-1.000.98 0.75-0.940.96 1-0.980.96 Smallest drops Greatest loss Test statistics are m 23 = Median(count 2 / count 3 ) and m 32 = Median(count 3 / count 2 )

22 Shielding and wind speed TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Wind speed (m/s) Wind from the South m 23 Wind from the West m 32 0-1.00 1-0.97 2-0.920.99 3-0.880.91 4-0.890.92 5-0.860.78 Very light wind No problem Test statistics are m 23 = Median(count 2 / count 3 ) and m 32 = Median(count 3 / count 2 )

23 Shielding and wind speed TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Wind speed (m/s) Wind from the South m 23 Wind from the West m 32 0-1.00 1-0.97 2-0.920.99 3-0.880.91 4-0.890.92 5-0.860.78 Strong wind Serious problem Test statistics are m 23 = Median(count 2 / count 3 ) and m 32 = Median(count 3 / count 2 )

24 The combined effect of drop diameter and wind speed TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton The worst case occurs with small drops in strong winds Drop diameter (mm) Wind speed 3m/s < 0.25 mm0.870.80 > 0.25 mm0.980.93 Entries are m 23 ratio

25 Fall-speed calibration Values of m 21 = Median(count 2 / count 1 ) Values of m 23 = Median(count 2 / count 3 ) TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.230.930.99 > 0.250.951.041.03 All1.161.001.01 Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.550.870.95 > 0.250.951.021.01 All1.330.970.99 First result: All three Thies disdrometers are recording roughly equal numbers of both small drops and large drops

26 Fall-speed calibration Values of m 21 = Median(count 2 / count 1 ) Values of m 23 = Median(count 2 / count 3 ) TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.230.930.99 > 0.250.951.041.03 All1.161.001.01 Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.550.870.95 > 0.250.951.021.01 All1.330.970.99 Second result: All three Thies disdrometers are recording roughly equal numbers of the faster falling drops

27 Fall-speed calibration Values of m 21 = Median(count 2 / count 1 ) Values of m 23 = Median(count 2 / count 3 ) TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.230.930.99 > 0.250.951.041.03 All1.161.001.01 Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.550.870.95 > 0.250.951.021.01 All1.330.970.99 Third result: T2 assigns fewer of the fast-falling drops to the smaller drop-size categories than do either T1 or, particularly, T3

28 Fall-speed calibration Values of m 21 = Median(count 2 / count 1 ) Values of m 23 = Median(count 2 / count 3 ) TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.230.930.99 > 0.250.951.041.03 All1.161.001.01 Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.550.870.95 > 0.250.951.021.01 All1.330.970.99 Fourth result: T2 assigns more drops to the slow-falling speeds than either T1 or, particularly, T3

29 Fall-speed calibration Values of m 21 = Median(count 2 / count 1 ) Values of m 23 = Median(count 2 / count 3 ) TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.230.930.99 > 0.250.951.041.03 All1.161.001.01 Drop diameter (mm) Fall speed (m/s) < 1> 1All < 0.251.550.870.95 > 0.250.951.021.01 All1.330.970.99 Fifth result: T2 assigns more drops to the slow-falling speeds than either T1 or, particularly, T3. This is especially true of the smallest drops.

30 Summary of results TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Overall counts agree well from one Thies to another 2.Thies counts are appreciably greater than those from a Parsivel 3.Drop size distributions agree well from one Thies to another 4.The drop size distributions seen by Thies and Parsivel are markedly different (as are the water volumes) 5.Thies suffer from shielding with counts in the smallest drop sizes reduced by as much as 20% in strong winds 6.Fall speeds can vary appreciably from one Thies to another --- particularly in the case of the smaller drops

31 Summary of results TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Overall counts agree well from one Thies to another 2.Thies counts are appreciably greater than those from a Parsivel 3.Drop size distributions agree well from one Thies to another 4.The drop size distributions seen by Thies and Parsivel are markedly different (as are the water volumes) 5.Thies suffer from shielding with counts in the smallest drop sizes reduced by as much as 20% in strong winds 6.Fall speeds can vary appreciably from one Thies to another --- particularly in the case of the smaller drops

32 Summary of results TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Overall counts agree well from one Thies to another 2.Thies counts are appreciably greater than those from a Parsivel 3.Drop size distributions agree well from one Thies to another 4.The drop size distributions seen by Thies and Parsivel are markedly different (as are the water volumes) 5.Thies suffer from shielding with counts in the smallest drop sizes reduced by as much as 20% in strong winds 6.Fall speeds can vary appreciably from one Thies to another --- particularly in the case of the smaller drops

33 Summary of results TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Overall counts agree well from one Thies to another 2.Thies counts are appreciably greater than those from a Parsivel 3.Drop size distributions agree well from one Thies to another 4.The drop size distributions seen by Thies and Parsivel are markedly different (as are the water volumes) 5.Thies suffer from shielding with counts in the smallest drop sizes reduced by as much as 20% in strong winds 6.Fall speeds can vary appreciably from one Thies to another --- particularly in the case of the smaller drops

34 Summary of results TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Overall counts agree well from one Thies to another 2.Thies counts are appreciably greater than those from a Parsivel 3.Drop size distributions agree well from one Thies to another 4.The drop size distributions seen by Thies and Parsivel are markedly different (as are the water volumes) 5.Thies suffer from shielding with counts in the smallest drop sizes reduced by as much as 20% in strong winds 6.Fall speeds can vary appreciably from one Thies to another --- particularly in the case of the smaller drops

35 Summary of results TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Overall counts agree well from one Thies to another 2.Thies counts are appreciably greater than those from a Parsivel 3.Drop size distributions agree well from one Thies to another 4.The drop size distributions seen by Thies and Parsivel are markedly different (as are the water volumes) 5.Thies suffer from shielding with counts in the smallest drop sizes reduced by as much as 20% in strong winds 6.Fall speeds can vary appreciably from one Thies to another --- particularly in the case of the smaller drops

36 Summary of results TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton 1.Overall counts agree well from one Thies to another 2.Thies counts are appreciably greater than those from a Parsivel 3.Drop size distributions agree well from one Thies to another 4.The drop size distributions seen by Thies and Parsivel are markedly different (as are the water volumes) 5.Thies suffer from shielding with counts in the smallest drop sizes reduced by as much as 20% in strong winds 6.Fall speeds can vary appreciably from one Thies to another --- particularly in the case of the smaller drops Thank you for your attention. Any questions?

Download ppt "An investigation of factors affecting the accuracy of Thies disdrometers TECO-2008 St Petersburg, November 29th, 2008 Graham Upton Graham Upton and Dan."

Similar presentations

© Crown copyright Met Office UK Met Office investigations into laser disdrometers Present Weather Trial at Eskdalemuir, Scotland: Winter 2007/8 Darren.

© Crown copyright Met Office UK Met Office investigations into laser disdrometers Present Weather Trial at Eskdalemuir, Scotland: Winter 2007/8 Darren.
The use of dual-frequency microwave links for the detection of sleet Background to the research A NERC-funded research project centred on Bolton in the.

The use of dual-frequency microwave links for the detection of sleet Background to the research A NERC-funded research project centred on Bolton in the.
Chapter 23 Mirrors and Lenses.

Chapter 23 Mirrors and Lenses.
WORLD CLIMATE PATTERNS

WORLD CLIMATE PATTERNS
1 1 Slide © 2003 South-Western/Thomson Learning TM Slides Prepared by JOHN S. LOUCKS St. Edward’s University.

1 1 Slide © 2003 South-Western/Thomson Learning TM Slides Prepared by JOHN S. LOUCKS St. Edward’s University.
Long-Term Ambient Noise Statistics in the Gulf of Mexico Mark A. Snyder & Peter A. Orlin Naval Oceanographic Office Stennis Space Center, MS Anthony I.

Long-Term Ambient Noise Statistics in the Gulf of Mexico Mark A. Snyder & Peter A. Orlin Naval Oceanographic Office Stennis Space Center, MS Anthony I.
12.3 – Measures of Dispersion

12.3 – Measures of Dispersion
Pressure Chapter 44 What is Pressure? Pressure is the Force per unit Area Pressure = Force(N) Area(m 2 ) The unit of pressure is N/m 2 or the Pascal.

Pressure Chapter 44 What is Pressure? Pressure is the Force per unit Area Pressure = Force(N) Area(m 2 ) The unit of pressure is N/m 2 or the Pascal.
1 1 Slide © 2003 South-Western/Thomson Learning TM Slides Prepared by JOHN S. LOUCKS St. Edward’s University.

1 1 Slide © 2003 South-Western/Thomson Learning TM Slides Prepared by JOHN S. LOUCKS St. Edward’s University.
TRENDS IN MARINE WINDS ADJUSTED FOR CHANGES IN OBSERVATION METHOD, 1980-2002 Bridget R. Thomas 1, Elizabeth C. Kent 2, Val R. Swail 3 and David I. Berry.

TRENDS IN MARINE WINDS ADJUSTED FOR CHANGES IN OBSERVATION METHOD, Bridget R. Thomas 1, Elizabeth C. Kent 2, Val R. Swail 3 and David I. Berry.
WORLD CLIMATE PATTERNS

WORLD CLIMATE PATTERNS
Leading Cadet Training

Leading Cadet Training
AP Statistics Chapters 0 & 1 Review. Variables fall into two main categories: A categorical, or qualitative, variable places an individual into one of.

AP Statistics Chapters 0 & 1 Review. Variables fall into two main categories: A categorical, or qualitative, variable places an individual into one of.
12.4 – Measures of Position In some cases, the analysis of certain individual items in the data set is of more interest rather than the entire set. It.

12.4 – Measures of Position In some cases, the analysis of certain individual items in the data set is of more interest rather than the entire set. It.
Key Concepts What are solar and lunar eclipses? What causes the tides?

Key Concepts What are solar and lunar eclipses? What causes the tides?
Using NPOL (the NASA S-band polarimetric radar), and a network of 2D video disdrometers for external radar calibration and rain rate estimation, and to.

Using NPOL (the NASA S-band polarimetric radar), and a network of 2D video disdrometers for external radar calibration and rain rate estimation, and to.
CHAPTER SIX FUNCTIONS OF RANDOM VARIABLES SAMPLING DISTRIBUTIONS.

CHAPTER SIX FUNCTIONS OF RANDOM VARIABLES SAMPLING DISTRIBUTIONS.
SWTJC STEM – ENGR 1201 Content Goal 13 Quality Factors 1.Accuracy refers to how close the reported value comes to the true value. 2.Precision refers to.

SWTJC STEM – ENGR 1201 Content Goal 13 Quality Factors 1.Accuracy refers to how close the reported value comes to the true value. 2.Precision refers to.
Chapter 2 Measurement & Problem Solving. Uncertainty There is a certain amount of doubt in every measurement – It is important to know the uncertainty.

Chapter 2 Measurement & Problem Solving. Uncertainty There is a certain amount of doubt in every measurement – It is important to know the uncertainty.
Section 3.1 Measures of Center. Mean (Average) Sample Mean.

Section 3.1 Measures of Center. Mean (Average) Sample Mean.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google