1. Presentation by Tom Hummel OverSoC: A Framework for the Exploration of RTOS for RSoC Platforms

2. Background Complexity of Systems Parallelism Memory Management Concurrency Design Exploration Testing Validation Experimentation 2

3. Motivation Prior Works Do not consider dynamic reconfiguration Do not provide OS-like resources and programming model Framework must provide exploration of Spatiotemporal Scheduling Reconfiguration and Resource Management Task Pre-emption and migration Inter-process communication 3

4. Platform Exploration Hierarchal Top down design Evaluation at each level Performance Metrics User Defined SystemC Simulation Model 4

5. System Description 3 Elements Operating System Communication Memories and resources Processing GPU’s and DRA’s (Reconfig Blocks) Abstraction Layers are separated via API’s Evaluation and exploration at each level SystemC based simulation 5

6. Refinement Process Element Refinement Virtual Nodes Functional Simulation Annotated Nodes Functional with timing constraints Cycle Accurate Nodes GPU and DRA simulations RTL Nodes Bit level accuracy 6

7. Refinement 7

8. RTOS Integration SystemC OS Highly Abstract Designed to be service and time accurate Test various scheduling algorithms and resource sharing methods Communications Proxy like resource access Does not distinguish between HW/SW Instantaneous Communication 8

9. Reconfiguration DRA Portioning Re-active Components Active Components Task Parameters Multilevel Allocation problem defined as 3 levels for verification Provides determinism in case HW version of task cannot run, software can take over 9

10. Reconfiguration 10

11. DOGME Tool Design Exploration Tool Platform Design SystemC Code Generation Compilation and Simulation Analysis 11

12. Processor Modeling Instruction Set Simulator AVR Instruction Set Easy to model and many compilers SystemC Based Cycle accurate exploration Predictable Execution Code broken into blocks which encapsulate system call free code Improves simulation performance 12

13. Validation Application Robotic Vision (Object Recognition) Nios-II on Cyclone-II SoC Platform uC/OS-II style services Ability of Framework Optimal number of CPU’s determined Task timing versus size of reconfigurable blocks Occupation rate of reconfigurable blocks Simulation time proportional to number of OS in system 13

14. 14

15. 15

16. 16

17. Opinion Long Paper Could be divided into 2-3 papers Poor Flow Description of DOGME platform is begun in middle of paper, yet most of its features are elaborated in the experimental section Vague Descriptions Explanation of inter-OS communication not well described Communication Elements were not elaborated on ISS Architecture vs. Experimentation ISS Simulator uses AVR IS, however simulation was performed on a NIOS-II. This discrepancy was not addressed 17

18. References Miramond, B., Huck, E., Verdier, F., Benkhelifa, M. E. A., Granado, B., Aichouch, M., et al. (2009). OveRSoC : A framework for the exploration of RTOS for RSoC platforms. International Journal on Reconfigurable Computing, 2009(450607), 1-18. 18