1. EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE and gLite are registered trademarks Migration to the GLUE 2.0 information schema in the LCG/EGEE/EGI production Grid Stephen Burke (RAL), Laurence Field (CERN) and David Horat (CERN) CHEP2010, Taipei

2. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 2 Overview Implementation plan The GLUE 2.0 schema –Structure –LDAP rendering Implementation and use in the LCG/EGEE/EGI Grid –BDII rollout –Service publication –Clients –Implementation timeline Outlook This presentation follows on from a talk about The impact and adoption of GLUE 2.0 in the LCG/EGEE production Grid at CHEP09The impact and adoption of GLUE 2.0 in the LCG/EGEE production Grid

3. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 3 Implementation plan Schema migration is a complex process: 1)Define the abstract schema 2)Define the LDAP rendering 3)Implement the schema in the BDII and roll out 4)Write and deploy information providers You are here! 5)Update client tools to understand GLUE 2 6)(Retire GLUE 1) The schema interacts with everything, so the rollout must be a gradual process without breaking anything

4. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 4 GLUE 2.0 timeline January 2007: First working group meeting June 2008: Draft specification opened to public comment January 2009: Final specification ready March 2009: GLUE 2.0 becomes an official OGF standard –http://www.ogf.org/documents/GFD.147.pdfhttp://www.ogf.org/documents/GFD.147.pdf April 2009: Start work on implementation …

5. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 5 Glue 2.0 key concepts User Domain Admin Domain Resource Manager ShareEnd Point Activity Access Policy Mapping Policy Negotiates Share with Provides Manages Runs Defined on Contacts Maps User to Has Service Has

6. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 6 Glue 2.0 computing schema Computing Service Execution Environment Computing Manager Computing Share Computing End Point Computing Activity Manages Runs Defined onMaps User to Application Environment Can use Has

7. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 7 Glue 2.0 storage schema Storage Service Data Store Storage Manager Storage Share Storage End Point Storage Share Capacity Defined onMaps User to Storage Capacity Has Storage Access Protocol Offers Manages Has

8. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 8 LDAP rendering Needs some basic decisions about how to map the abstract schema to LDAP We designed the schema knowing that LDAP was a target technology, so many things have a natural implementation –GLUE entities mapped directly to LDAP object classes –Multivalued and optional attributes supported directly  Unlike e.g. a relational database –Not much support for data types, basically just string and integer  Type conformance must largely be checked externally Try to optimise to make the most likely queries efficient Defined in ~ 6 phone meetings in May/June 2009 Generally follows GLUE 1 practice, but some changes –Case sensitivity –Some attributes are mandatory –Strings changed from 7-bit ASCII to UTF-8 –The naming and usage of foreign keys are somewhat different

9. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 9 Object classes Object classes are the basic structural unit of an LDAP schema –Basically maps to a defined list of attributes –One LDAP object may include attributes from many object classes An LDAP schema has a global namespace, so useful to have a naming convention –Prefix schema entity names with “GLUE2”  e.g. GLUE2ComputingShare –No clashes with GLUE 1.x (prefix “Glue”) Natural mapping: –One object class per schema entity –Objects representing specialised entities inherit attributes from parent object classes objectclass: GLUE2Entity objectclass: GLUE2Share objectclass: GLUE2ComputingShare

10. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 10 LDAP attributes Attribute naming –Follows the object class naming scheme –“GLUE2” + +  GLUE2ComputingShareRunningJobs –Exception for unique ID  Could be confusing for all object IDs to have the same name dn: GLUE2EntityID=x, GLUE2EntityID=y, GLUE2EntityID=z  Named for the first derived entity instead  GLUE2ShareID not GLUE2EntityID (or GLUE2ComputingShareID ) Foreign key attributes –Representation of relations between entities –All schema relations have a corresponding key attribute  Even when the relation is also implied by the DN  Multiplicity (optional/mandatory, single/multivalued) follows the schema like other attributes  Inherited in the same way as other attributes –Only needed at one end of a relation  Decided case-by-case, but generally point logically “up” (child points to parent) –Named specifically for the relation they represent  Long but unambiguous  GLUE2ComputingShareComputingServiceForeignKey –Attribute value is the ID of the target entity

11. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 11 DN construction (LDAP tree) LDAP objects are arranged in a hierarchical tree Each object has a unique Distinguished Name (DN) representing its location in the tree The DN is constructed as a series of components, each of which gives the name and value of an identifying object attribute –For GLUE the natural attribute is the ID Attach objects in the tree according to a natural hierarchy –The GLUE schema relations are more complex than a tree can represent, so this is only indicative –subcomponent -> component -> Service -> AdminDomain -> Root  GLUE2PolicyID=xxx, GLUE2ShareID=xxy, GLUE2ServiceID=xxz, GLUE2DomainID=zyx, GLUE2DomainID=xyz –Extension objects must be directly below the object they extend –Dummy grouping object to insert GLUE2GroupID anywhere in the DN  No semantics, just makes the tree easier to follow, e.g. in an LDAP browser  c.f. mds-vo-name –Should navigate using foreign keys, not DNs

12. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 12 BDII implementation Merged LDAP schema, GLUE 1.3 + GLUE 2 Single LDAP server, on port 2170 as usual Separate root DNs – o=glue vs o=grid –Should be no crosstalk other than data volume Resource BDII: GLUE2GroupID=resource, o=glue Site BDII: GLUE2DomainID=, o=glue Top BDII: GLUE2DomainID=, [GLUE2DomainID=,] GLUE2GroupID=grid, o=glue Roll out –Only implemented for SL5 (gLite 3.2) –Resource BDII in production since September 2009 –Site BDII in production since August 2010 –Top-level BDII in production in October 2010

13. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 13 Information providers Generic Service publisher exists –Drop-in replacement for the existing generic GlueService provider for GLUE 1.3 Currently supports one Endpoint per Service (plus the corresponding AccessPolicy) –Easy to extend for multiple Endpoints (VOMS) Supports all relevant attributes Being rolled out as new versions of services are released –Already have CREAM, LB, bdii_site, bdii_top, VOBOX in production –In work for WMS, MyProxy, AMGA, VOMS, Frontier/squid (!), …  Easy to add publication for any service –FTS and LFC currently have their own providers for GLUE 1.3, so may need more work Computing and Storage providers will be more complex –CREAM will be incremental  Endpoint publisher already exists, ExecutionEnvironment (Cluster) in work  Need to re-use GLUE 1.3 code where possible Particularly for the batch system interfaces –Storage publishers will be needed for each SRM type  Not yet started  Expected to have a first version in the first EMI release (April)

14. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 14 Clients All clients need to become GLUE2-aware –Must be backward-compatible –Can happen gradually –Mostly not yet started WMS: JDL Storage: lcg-utils/GFAL/FTS Service discovery: lcg-info(sites), glite-sd-query –First version of OGF/SAGA service discovery tool available Monitoring: gstat –Will be used to follow GLUE 2 deployment Accounting: resource accounting, not APEL User tools …

15. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 15 Summary Define LDAP schema and deploy in BDIIs –1.3 and 2.0 together in parallel –Now deployed in production  But sites are slow to upgrade! Write and deploy information providers to populate the new objects –Generic Service publisher available  Being rolled out progressively –ComputingService publication (for CREAM) coming incrementally  Full version by mid-2011? –StorageService more complex, many different providers  Timescale unclear Update clients to look at the new information –Workload management, data management, service discovery, monitoring, accounting, user, … –Upgrades should be backward-compatible –Aim for the end of 2011?? Switch off GLUE 1 publishing –Only when everything has been upgraded –>2012??? NB EGI/EMI will bring new middleware distributions into the fold –ARC is committed to implementing GLUE 2

16. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 16 Outlook The GLUE schema has developed over 9 years of practical use GLUE 2 is a major new version of the schema –Incorporates all our experience, and input from many other Grids –OGF backing makes this a worldwide Grid standard  EGI/EMI are committed to adopting it –Uniform structure for any service  CE, SE, WMS, VOMS, MyProxy, LFC, FTS, … –Much more expandable  All objects can be extended –Fixes many long-standing problems  StorageService designed for SRM 2!  ComputingService has a better separation of Grid endpoint, LRMS and queue/fairshare information GLUE 2.0 should cover all current use cases for WLCG/EGI –And allow things we can’t do at the moment –And be much more flexible for the cases we still haven’t anticipated Roll out has started, but the transition process will take several years

17. Enabling Grids for E-sciencE EGEE-III INFSO-RI-222667 GLUE 2.0 migration - CHEP10 17 References OGF GLUE working group home page –http://forge.ogf.org/sf/projects/glue-wghttp://forge.ogf.org/sf/projects/glue-wg GLUE 2.0 specification –http://www.ogf.org/documents/GFD.147.pdfhttp://www.ogf.org/documents/GFD.147.pdf LDAP rendering specification (draft) –http://forge.ogf.org/sf/go/doc15518?nav=1http://forge.ogf.org/sf/go/doc15518?nav=1