1. Zilnamaya’s Matton Future A Multi-Stakeholder Problem Formulation and Options Assessment Process

2. Where we’ve been Agreement that we have a problem of matton pests Agreement that we have a problem of matton pests Affects our ability to feed our people and profit from farming Affects our ability to feed our people and profit from farming GMO matton appears promising GMO matton appears promising We agree to reflect on the options together We agree to reflect on the options together

3. How we work Listen with respect Listen with respect Ask clarifying questions Ask clarifying questions Work to understand others’ ideas Work to understand others’ ideas Consider how to best explain our own ideas Consider how to best explain our own ideas Value diversity Value diversity Agree that we all have Sustainablandia’s future at heart Agree that we all have Sustainablandia’s future at heart

4. First Please review your stakeholder perspectives regarding Steps 6 and 8 Please review your stakeholder perspectives regarding Steps 6 and 8 Identify a spokesperson to present your views Identify a spokesperson to present your views Each group will present their ideas about the risks, benefits, advantages, disadvantages associated with Bt corn Each group will present their ideas about the risks, benefits, advantages, disadvantages associated with Bt corn

5. During presentations Please listen to the variety of views and consider Please listen to the variety of views and consider What other options might achieve similar goals What other options might achieve similar goals How can we reduce uncertainty How can we reduce uncertainty What else should be considered What else should be considered

6. In stakeholder groups Count off Count off Reconvene in new groups by number Reconvene in new groups by number In these diverse groups, please consider your responses to Step 7. In these diverse groups, please consider your responses to Step 7.

7. Discussion What insights do you have about Matton in Zilnamaya? What insights do you have about Matton in Zilnamaya? What other options deserve consideration? What other options deserve consideration? What additional data do you need? What additional data do you need? How is the process working? How is the process working?

8. And now to return to class…