1. Recognition by ENQA of the results of national reviews Peter Williams President, ENQA

2. ENQA membership criteria Conformity with ESG Five-yearly reviews National or ENQA-co-ordinated reviews Guidelines for National reviews Review process Review outcomes

3. Guidelines for national reviews 2 types of review ENQA membership criteria only Multi-purpose reviews Key features of national reviews Independence of review process Transparent process Sufficiently detailed report for ENQA Board Clear evidence relating to ENQA membership criteria

4. Six phases of review Notification to ENQA Terms of reference and process Nomination and appointment of panel Self-evaluation Site visit Production and publication of final report

5. Required reporting outcomes for ENQA purposes Specified information about the agency and the review process For each membership criterion Summary of evidence Analysis of evidence in respect of the criterion Judgement of the extent that the criterion is met (fully compliant; substantially compliant; partially compliant; non-compliant)

6. Consideration by ENQA Membership Reviews Committee Satisfactory review process? Satisfactory review outcome? 3 possible recommendations Full membership confirmed Further information needed Membership not confirmed Action plan agreed with ENQA Board Membership terminated