Check your answers. 1a) The Framers wanted the Legislative branch to dominate as: They feared Executive tyrannyThey feared Executive tyranny They wanted.

Check your answers

1a) The Framers wanted the Legislative branch to dominate as: They feared Executive tyrannyThey feared Executive tyranny They wanted an elected and representative Congress to be the voice of ‘the people’ and therefore dominantThey wanted an elected and representative Congress to be the voice of ‘the people’ and therefore dominant 1b) The Executive has dominated recently due to: The growth of America and therefore Federal governmentThe growth of America and therefore Federal government The growth of responsibilitiesThe growth of responsibilities The nature of challenges – Great depression ; World war; Cold War ; Superpower status; 9/11; Credit crunchThe nature of challenges – Great depression ; World war; Cold War ; Superpower status; 9/11; Credit crunch 2. A Congressman: Is a member of the House of Representatives

Checks and Balances Separation of Powers Codified Constitution Bill of Rights This is known as LIMITED GOVERNMENT

It is Representative with a mandate It is not Party dominated like in the UK Separation of powers mean it is independent from the other branches and cannot be controlled by them It has enumerated and entrenched powers in the Constitution

1 The US has a BICAMERAL system because: It creates the most representative government – Pop/stateIt creates the most representative government – Pop/state It would check and balance each other ensuring fairness and good legislationIt would check and balance each other ensuring fairness and good legislation 2 The largest chamber is the House of Representatives 3 It has 435 members 4 Its constituencies are called: Congressional districts 5 They are elected every 2 years 6 The Framers wanted to ensure The representatives would be highly responsive to their districts and more respected as they were legitimate & representative 7 The largest representation according to population is California

8 California has 55 seats 9 Small population states include: Wyoming, Delaware, North Dakota 10 Every 10 years there are Possible changes due to census change 11 The important set of elections are Mid Terms 12 These elections are important because: They can bring about divided government or can affirm the Presidential mandateThey can bring about divided government or can affirm the Presidential mandate They can act as a ‘bell weather’ to the Presidents progress after two yearsThey can act as a ‘bell weather’ to the Presidents progress after two years They can kick start an election campaign for PresidentThey can kick start an election campaign for President

1 The Senate has : 100 seats excluding VP 2 The Senate represents the States – equally 3 Senators are elected Every 6 years 4 The 2 houses are elected differently.. To allow for more long term careful thinking in the SenateTo allow for more long term careful thinking in the Senate To allow for experience and added debate in SenateTo allow for experience and added debate in Senate To merge representative ‘folks back home’ HOR to be tempered by diverse State wide thinking from SenateTo merge representative ‘folks back home’ HOR to be tempered by diverse State wide thinking from Senate 5 The President of the Senate is : Senate is : The Vice President – Joe Biden- They can vote when a tied vote Biden (never) Cheney (6 times)

6 Two exclusive powers to Senate are : Confirmation of Federal AppointmentsConfirmation of Federal Appointments Ratification of Foreign TreatiesRatification of Foreign Treaties CONFIRMATION OF FEDERAL APPOINTMENTS Gives the Senate the power to control, if need be, the Presidents appointments. Senators must approve their appointment by a simple majority vote. It is unusual for Presidential appointments to be blocked but is a political negotiating tool when in divided government. It has been used to block appointment of George Bush Snr’s choice of John Tower as defence secretary (1989) RATIFICATION OF TREATIES This gives the Senate power of oversight into Foreign policy – a very Presidential domain. The Senate has to ratify foreign treaties made by Presidents to make them binding. Several have been rejected including Treaty of Versailles and nuclear limiting SALT treaty- Presidents now tend to pass treaties by Executive order to bypass this threat

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES 113 th Congress113 th Congress 435 Members435 Members Represent by PopulationRepresent by Population REPUBLICANS control HORREPUBLICANS control HOR Elected every TWO yearsElected every TWO years Candidates must be over 25Candidates must be over 25 Be US citizen for at least 7 yearsBe US citizen for at least 7 years Have lived in the State for 7 yearsHave lived in the State for 7 years Under 20%Under 20% 44 Black ; 25 Hispanic ; 7 Asian ; 1 Native American (19%)44 Black ; 25 Hispanic ; 7 Asian ; 1 Native American (19%) Average age 56.7 Average age 56.7 Professional background: business / public service /politics / law Professional background: business / public service /politics / law POWERS EXCLUSIVE TO HOR To consider money bills FIRSTTo consider money bills FIRST To begin impeachmentTo begin impeachment To choose President in event of a tieTo choose President in event of a tie

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES 1.MAJORITY LEADER Key Party kingpin and ‘leader’ of largest party in houseKey Party kingpin and ‘leader’ of largest party in house Crucial in coalition building / log rolling / legislationCrucial in coalition building / log rolling / legislation 2.MINORITY LEADER Key Party kingpin and ‘leader’ of minority party in houseKey Party kingpin and ‘leader’ of minority party in house Still crucial in coalition building / log rolling / legislation as the majorities in the House are usually not very bigStill crucial in coalition building / log rolling / legislation as the majorities in the House are usually not very big 3.SPEAKER Unlike the UK the Speaker is PARTISAN (Newt Gingrich)Unlike the UK the Speaker is PARTISAN (Newt Gingrich) Roles  Refers bills to Committees, appoints select committee and conference committee chairs while influencing the appointment of standing committee chairs, Appoints majority party contingent on House rules committee, and presides over the House enforcing its rules.

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES To pass laws To pass laws To pass the budget To pass the budget To undertake investigations into the actions of the executive branch To undertake investigations into the actions of the executive branch To start constitutional amendments by a 2/3rds majority in both houses To start constitutional amendments by a 2/3rds majority in both houses To declare war To declare war To confirm the appointment of a newly elected vice President To confirm the appointment of a newly elected vice President

SENATE 100 Members100 Members Represent by STATERepresent by STATE DEMOCRATS control SenateDEMOCRATS control Senate Elected every SIX yearsElected every SIX years Candidates must be over 30Candidates must be over 30 Be US citizen for at least 9 yearsBe US citizen for at least 9 years Have lived in the State for 9 yearsHave lived in the State for 9 years 20% most ever20% most ever 1 Black ; 2 Hispanic ; 1 Asian1 Black ; 2 Hispanic ; 1 Asian Average age 62 Average age 62 Professional background: Law / business / public service /politics Professional background: Law / business / public service /politics POWERS EXCLUSIVE TO SENATE ConfirmationConfirmation RatificationRatification To try impeachmentTo try impeachment To choose Vice President in event of a tieTo choose Vice President in event of a tie

SENATE 1.MAJORITY LEADER Key Party kingpin and ‘leader’ of largest party in SenateKey Party kingpin and ‘leader’ of largest party in Senate Crucial in coalition building / log rolling / legislationCrucial in coalition building / log rolling / legislation 2.MINORITY LEADER Key Party kingpin and ‘leader’ of minority party in SenateKey Party kingpin and ‘leader’ of minority party in Senate Still crucial in coalition building / log rolling / legislation as the majorities in the House are usually not very bigStill crucial in coalition building / log rolling / legislation as the majorities in the House are usually not very big 3.VICE PRESIDENT Holds the casting vote – can be important in building coalitionsHolds the casting vote – can be important in building coalitions Timetables bills in absence of House rules committeeTimetables bills in absence of House rules committee Can take over from President when incapacitatedCan take over from President when incapacitated

AGREE Senators represent an entire State not a small part of it. Senators represent an entire State not a small part of it. Senators serve 6 years—x3 Representatives Senators serve 6 years—x3 Representatives Senators are 1 out of 100 compared with 1 out of 435 in the House Senators are 1 out of 100 compared with 1 out of 435 in the House Senators are much more likely to chair a committee than those in the House. Senators are much more likely to chair a committee than those in the House. Senators have greater name recognition—due to their smaller number and more prestigious nature of the Senate. Senators have greater name recognition—due to their smaller number and more prestigious nature of the Senate. House members frequently seek election to the Senate which speaks volumes. House members frequently seek election to the Senate which speaks volumes. It is the ideal starting point to the Presidency and has been successful for Obama, Kennedy, Johnston etc It is the ideal starting point to the Presidency and has been successful for Obama, Kennedy, Johnston etc Senators are also frequently chosen as Vice Presidential running mates Senators are also frequently chosen as Vice Presidential running mates Senators have EXCLUSIVE POWERS—to ratify treaties / confirm Presidential appointments which gives it a say in holding the Executive to account—much more so than the House powers. Senators have EXCLUSIVE POWERS—to ratify treaties / confirm Presidential appointments which gives it a say in holding the Executive to account—much more so than the House powers.

DISAGREE It requires BOTH Chambers to compromise in order to achieve effective legislation and policy. It requires BOTH Chambers to compromise in order to achieve effective legislation and policy. All bills must go through BOTH houses—none can pass without the agreement of the other. All bills must go through BOTH houses—none can pass without the agreement of the other. BOTH houses have powerful Standing committees—which can conduct investigative hearings at the committee stage BOTH houses have powerful Standing committees—which can conduct investigative hearings at the committee stage At conference committee stage members of BOTH houses are represented. At conference committee stage members of BOTH houses are represented. BOTH houses must agree to the compromise bill agreed in conference committee BOTH houses must agree to the compromise bill agreed in conference committee To introduce a Constitutional Amendment both are required To introduce a Constitutional Amendment both are required To override a Presidential veto a 2/3rds majority in both chambers is needed. To override a Presidential veto a 2/3rds majority in both chambers is needed.

A FILIBUSTER is a Senate tactic of TALKING OUT A BILL. Tradition allows for Senators to have unlimited debate. This gives them the powers to simply talk a bill out of legislative time forcing its death through delay To prevent this there is the power of CLOTURE whereby 60 Senators are needed to vote a filibuster down This is increasingly hard to do. It requires at least 60% support for all legislation Filibusters are much more common in a partisan chamber with divided government in operation It has been called the ‘Soul of the Senate’ by defenders

HOUSE OF LORDS SENATE REPRESENTATION It is unrepresentative with NO mandate.It is unrepresentative with NO mandate. It still has hereditary peers.It still has hereditary peers. It has a political tinge to its make up through political appointmentsIt has a political tinge to its make up through political appointments It maintains 26 COE archbishops!It maintains 26 COE archbishops! It has underwent a very slow period of reforms to try and democratise it with very little progressIt has underwent a very slow period of reforms to try and democratise it with very little progress REPRESENTATION It has a mandate – being elected every 6 years.It has a mandate – being elected every 6 years. It is representative of a State – however may favour smaller States unequally – Wyoming has same say as California for exampleIt is representative of a State – however may favour smaller States unequally – Wyoming has same say as California for example It is politically tainted unlike Peers in the HOL who are not under Party control per seIt is politically tainted unlike Peers in the HOL who are not under Party control per se

HOUSE OF LORDS SENATE POWERS Necessary as a check on the Commons—the government dominated lower chamber. It shares the Parliamentary workload (provides much needed scrutiny of bills by often expert eyes) It has the power to delay legislation for up to 1 year using the Parliament Act—This is rarely used but may force the Government to compromise. IT CANNOT DELAY Legislation for more than 1 year. Provides expertise and advice on public policy by experts in their field. Peers have little Party control and no constituency to consider allowing Peers greater freedom of expression Non controversial legislation can be initiated in the Lords. POWERS In theory the two Houses have equal powers—however the Senate is now considered more important than the House.In theory the two Houses have equal powers—however the Senate is now considered more important than the House. EXCLUSIVE POWERS— The power to CONFIRM Presidential appointments and RATIFY treaties EXCLUSIVE POWERS— The power to CONFIRM Presidential appointments and RATIFY treaties Senate Committees play a key role in the legislative process in the US and are essential to producing legislation Senate Committees play a key role in the legislative process in the US and are essential to producing legislation The Senate also plays a key role in the budgetary process. The Senate also plays a key role in the budgetary process. It CHECKS Executive power through the ratification and confirmation process mentioned above. It CHECKS Executive power through the ratification and confirmation process mentioned above. It would also be responsible for conducting trials for impeachment It would also be responsible for conducting trials for impeachment

HOUSE OF LORDS SENATE ESTEEM The reputation of the Lords has been enhanced over the past few years. The reputation of the Lords has been enhanced over the past few years. The introduction of LIFE PEERS has created a much more diverse and representative Lords— (in terms of age ; background, Race, Gender and political persuasion)The introduction of LIFE PEERS has created a much more diverse and representative Lords— (in terms of age ; background, Race, Gender and political persuasion) This has also helped boost its activity as Peers are encouraged to actively challenge the Government. This has also helped boost its activity as Peers are encouraged to actively challenge the Government. The House of Lords now sits for longer and is one of the busiest legislative chambers in the world. The House of Lords now sits for longer and is one of the busiest legislative chambers in the world. Of the 350 Peers who attend daily, many exhibit a greater degree of independence—free from the ties of Party or constituency. Blair’s powerful government suffered badly from defeats from a united Lords. Of the 350 Peers who attend daily, many exhibit a greater degree of independence—free from the ties of Party or constituency. Blair’s powerful government suffered badly from defeats from a united Lords. ESTEEM Direct elections and TV coverage have both altered the nature of Congress “from old fashioned clubby enclave to springboard to Presidency” Direct elections and TV coverage have both altered the nature of Congress “from old fashioned clubby enclave to springboard to Presidency” Senators tend to build their political reputation and gain media coverage from serving as Senators (Kennedy, Nixon, Bush Senior, Obama) Senators tend to build their political reputation and gain media coverage from serving as Senators (Kennedy, Nixon, Bush Senior, Obama) It is regarded as the more prestigious House. It is regarded as the more prestigious House.

Candidates also have to represent vital interests such as business to maintain war chest Folks back home are much more important than party in America and vital for re election Constant election campaigns mean it is vital to keep voters happy Locality rule Have to bring home the bacon: Pork Barrel politics

Town hall meetings Emails; phone calls Investigate infringements for constituents Bring home the pork Committee memberships All politics is local

This form of politics is both common and controversial in the US Political system.This form of politics is both common and controversial in the US Political system. It refers to the process of adding EARMARKS (or Pet projects) on to Appropriations bills in return for Political supportIt refers to the process of adding EARMARKS (or Pet projects) on to Appropriations bills in return for Political support

Congressmen rely on their constituents to vote them in every TWO yearsCongressmen rely on their constituents to vote them in every TWO years Constituents want their congressmen to prove their worth by ‘bringing home the pork’ This simply means getting their Congressional district a share of Federal schemesConstituents want their congressmen to prove their worth by ‘bringing home the pork’ This simply means getting their Congressional district a share of Federal schemes Alaskan Bridge to nowhere EXAMPLES: Mississippi railroad to nowhere

Earmarks have boomed in recent years as the Federal government has increased.Earmarks have boomed in recent years as the Federal government has increased. This has caused a great deal of concern particularly with the huge US deficitThis has caused a great deal of concern particularly with the huge US deficit

Earmarks have been highly criticised: They balloon the Federal budgetThey balloon the Federal budget Some schemes seem deeply flawedSome schemes seem deeply flawed Federal projects may be unfairly distributedFederal projects may be unfairly distributed They can lead to corruptionThey can lead to corruption In response the Office of management and Budget now openly publishes all earmarks

Opportunities to bring home the bacon ‘ credit claiming Constant media coverage provides free publicity They have access to HUGE staff – District/State/ DCThey have access to HUGE staff – District/State/ DC Free postageFree postage Huge campaign war chests from PACs Political action committees or special interests to protect or fight for certain policies Gerrymandering in favour of incumbent Uphill struggle of new candidate to prove they can do better

7 Are there any challenges to this dominance? The rise of the TEA PARTY has provided strong opposition to some candidates – Anti Washington – kick the bums out – 1994, 2008, 2010The rise of the TEA PARTY has provided strong opposition to some candidates – Anti Washington – kick the bums out – 1994, 2008, 2010 Unpopular incumbents can be targeted particularly over a scandalUnpopular incumbents can be targeted particularly over a scandal Smaller war chest than opponentsSmaller war chest than opponents 8 TERM LIMITS: Have been suggested for years as a way of keeping congressional terms limited to certain time frames thereby keeping Congress fresh and proactive

1.Typical representative: White, Male, Professional, Well educated, Wealthy, Law, politics, business background, 50’ish 2. Why is Congress Socially unrepresentative? a) ‘Ordinary people’ do not put themselves forward b) Perception that education/money is required- built on by media c) The need for a large ‘War chest to fund the campaigns d) An occupation for the rich – Kennedys, Bush dynasty, Romney e) Progress is glacial in US. The re-election rate is such that change to the status quo will always be very slow and unlikely

3.The House is more representative than the Senate due to: Constant reelection every 2 yearsConstant reelection every 2 years Locality rule links congressman/woman to districtLocality rule links congressman/woman to district Senator is in charge of diverse State / Congressmen are in charge of less diverse more unified districtsSenator is in charge of diverse State / Congressmen are in charge of less diverse more unified districts Congressmans role is to bring back the porkCongressmans role is to bring back the pork 4.Signs of Greater representation: More women than ever before (20%) Use of Emilys list to promote women candidates in politicsMore women than ever before (20%) Use of Emilys list to promote women candidates in politics Growth of PAC’s Political Action Committees to push forward candidates. NAACPGrowth of PAC’s Political Action Committees to push forward candidates. NAACP Growing black/hispanic activism (Bush campaigned strongly in Cuban America)Growing black/hispanic activism (Bush campaigned strongly in Cuban America) Majority Minority districts – districts with heavy minority influenceMajority Minority districts – districts with heavy minority influence

M.Ps Congressmen Congressmen LIMITED power as legislators. The Executive initiates and pushes through most legislation in UKLIMITED power as legislators. The Executive initiates and pushes through most legislation in UK Fusion of Powers in UK allows the Executive to dominate the political process. How?Fusion of Powers in UK allows the Executive to dominate the political process. How? Cabinet is controlled through patronage / collective responsibilityCabinet is controlled through patronage / collective responsibility Backbenchers are controlled through patronage / strong party control and whips. They have limited power to impactBackbenchers are controlled through patronage / strong party control and whips. They have limited power to impact PMB’s are limited in scope due to lottery naturePMB’s are limited in scope due to lottery nature Early day motions also need Government support to start or pass legislationEarly day motions also need Government support to start or pass legislation Congressmen have a great deal more power in legislation. They can initiate constitutional amendments and laws.Congressmen have a great deal more power in legislation. They can initiate constitutional amendments and laws. They can all be part of very powerful committees with wide investigative and scrutinising powers with the ability to make or break billsThey can all be part of very powerful committees with wide investigative and scrutinising powers with the ability to make or break bills Separation of powers ensures compromise with other powerful branches. Congressmen can override a veto or a constitutional amendment. Committees can pigeonhole bills. Earmarks may be added to influence the legislation. Lobby groups play an influential role. NRASeparation of powers ensures compromise with other powerful branches. Congressmen can override a veto or a constitutional amendment. Committees can pigeonhole bills. Earmarks may be added to influence the legislation. Lobby groups play an influential role. NRA

M.Ps Congressmen Congressmen MP’s can have power under the right circumstances. Low government majority (Major) Leadership challenge (Thatcher)MP’s can have power under the right circumstances. Low government majority (Major) Leadership challenge (Thatcher) Rebellions against government policy have been relatively common even in powerful governments like Blair (University fees; anti terror laws)Rebellions against government policy have been relatively common even in powerful governments like Blair (University fees; anti terror laws) MP’s can produce legislation with the right support. Some of the biggest pieces of modern legislation have been PMB’s abolition of death penalty; legalisation of divorce abortion and homosexualityMP’s can produce legislation with the right support. Some of the biggest pieces of modern legislation have been PMB’s abolition of death penalty; legalisation of divorce abortion and homosexuality MP’s have growing power in select committees and the ability to AMEND and VOTEMP’s have growing power in select committees and the ability to AMEND and VOTE Weaker party ties allow for more freedom of conscience in USAWeaker party ties allow for more freedom of conscience in USA Powerful committees have huge powers to pigeonhole bills undermining a Congressmans power of influence.Powerful committees have huge powers to pigeonhole bills undermining a Congressmans power of influence. Constant compromising to gain pork can lead to major problems and obstacles to progressConstant compromising to gain pork can lead to major problems and obstacles to progress Divided government and gridlock can overcome any benefit as legislators – delaying and often killing much needed legislationDivided government and gridlock can overcome any benefit as legislators – delaying and often killing much needed legislation Power of lobby groups – interest groups vs votersPower of lobby groups – interest groups vs voters

M.Ps Congressmen Congressmen REPRESENTING VOTERS COMES 1st? Constant re-election campaigns – every 2 years in HOR – They have to deliver the goods (or the bacon)Constant re-election campaigns – every 2 years in HOR – They have to deliver the goods (or the bacon) Much greater link to district – locality ruleMuch greater link to district – locality rule Scrutinised by local media – effectiveness in Congress and committeesScrutinised by local media – effectiveness in Congress and committees Importance of town hall meetings lobby groupsImportance of town hall meetings lobby groups The folks back home – keeping them happyThe folks back home – keeping them happy Party ties not as strong therefore more room to work of constituencyParty ties not as strong therefore more room to work of constituency REPRESENTING VOTERS COMES 2 nd ? Elections only every 5 yearsElections only every 5 years Party ties are strong and locality rule is not in place in UKParty ties are strong and locality rule is not in place in UK MP’s have limited ability to influence in UK and this is recognisedMP’s have limited ability to influence in UK and this is recognised Safe seats cultureSafe seats culture Loyalty to party will ensure promotion and patronage is much used to control along with role of whips. Careers therefore will be short if they do not toe the line.Loyalty to party will ensure promotion and patronage is much used to control along with role of whips. Careers therefore will be short if they do not toe the line. Executive dominates in UK unlike US. Fusion of powers places much power in Executive handsExecutive dominates in UK unlike US. Fusion of powers places much power in Executive hands

M.Ps Congressmen Congressmen REPRESENTING VOTERS DOES NOT ALWAYS COME 1st? The power of the war chest and interest groups often speaks louder than constituents needsThe power of the war chest and interest groups often speaks louder than constituents needs Huge funding lobby groups like the NRA can have a massive influence on Congressmen and prevent truly popular and needed legislation like Gun ControlHuge funding lobby groups like the NRA can have a massive influence on Congressmen and prevent truly popular and needed legislation like Gun Control Delicate balancing act between sponsors and votersDelicate balancing act between sponsors and voters Increasing partisan politics and increase in power of partyIncreasing partisan politics and increase in power of party REPRESENTING VOTERS CAN COME 1st ? MP’s are constantly looking for reelection too and will aim to please constituentsMP’s are constantly looking for reelection too and will aim to please constituents More volatile and tactical voting reduces the amount of truly safe seats – Hamiltons and Tatton in 1997 (Martin Bell)More volatile and tactical voting reduces the amount of truly safe seats – Hamiltons and Tatton in 1997 (Martin Bell) Backbench revolts show that MP’s do not always toe the party line. Resignations by Clare Short and Robin Cook in Blairs cabinet show that even he was vulnerableBackbench revolts show that MP’s do not always toe the party line. Resignations by Clare Short and Robin Cook in Blairs cabinet show that even he was vulnerable

UK US US THE BEST CONGRESS MONEY CAN BUY’ There is a simple feeling that money talks in Washington and the peoples real concerns are left behind. There is a real perception that Congressmen don't act in the national interest. This has led to anti government independent candidates such as ROSS PEROT in 1992. LOBBYISTS V’s CITIZENS There is real concern that congress acts more to please powerful lobbies than its own citizens. BIG ISSUES LEFT UNTOUCHED The nature of US politics means that huge and important issues such as dealing with the massive national debt are left and not dealt with EXPENSES SCANDAL A massive expenses scandal rocked Westminster in 2006 when it was discovered by a newspaper just what expenses M.Ps were claiming—often illegally. CONTROVERSIAL ISSUES Britain’s slide to war in Iraq against a huge tide of public opinion rocked public confidence in MP’s, Tony Blair, New Labour and Politics CASH FOR QUESTIONS In the last 15 years several scandals have emerged over M.Ps actually being paid to ask questions for wealthy clients or organisations (this was illegal) OUTSIDE INTERESTS There is a widespread distrust that politicians are in the pocket of powerful organisations and lobby groups (The Tory link to Rupert Murdoch and SKY is a case to mention

UK US US SLOW AND CUMBERSOME The legislative process in the US appears both slow and cumbersome. Congressional turnover of legislation is low. FAILURE TO WORK TOGETHER There has been criticism that Congress fails to work together as a collective entity. While Congressmen may represent their states adequately. They cannot seem to cooperate as a legislative two Congress theory’ GRIDLOCK Congressional petulance leads to Gridlock—such as the US budget FEAR OF BAD LEGISLATION There is a fear that UK legislative proposals are inherently weak due to the nature of the system. The majority party for example can rely on the support of its backbenchers (usually) This it is argued can lead to bad legislation (eg Child Support Agency ; Criminal Justice Act) GENERAL DISLIKE OF POLITICIANS There is a dislike of Yaboo politics— the dramatic but seemingly ineffective politics of debate in the Commons MALAISE There is a general dissatisfaction with Politics across the Western world perhaps due to the economic downturn too

The reasons are that Congress is actually DESIGNED NOT TO WORK. The system of CHECKS AND BALANCES is such that the only way anything can be done is through a very rigorous set of COMPROMISES Between institutions Between institutions Between Parties Between Parties AND often Within Parties AND often Within Parties There are 7 factors that have been considered by Anthony Bennett as to why legislation is so difficult to pass:

There are a great deal of hurdles to overcome in the US system “It is stacked against the enactment of Law” In UK, there are 3 readings and a committee stage. The Committee stage comes after the 2 nd reading and is carried out by a non specialist and partisan committee Remember how much control the Government / party has in these areas. In the US the COMMITTEE STAGE is fundamental and comes BEFORE the Second reading It is carried out by a permanent and SPECIALIST Policy committee It is carried out by a permanent and SPECIALIST Policy committee They have life or death say over bills AND are deferred to by other members due to their status as Specialist.They have life or death say over bills AND are deferred to by other members due to their status as Specialist.

Any bill must have a MAJORITY in BOTH HOUSES Any bill must have a MAJORITY in BOTH HOUSES Any bill must have a MAJORITY of 3/5ths in the SENATE Any bill must have a MAJORITY of 3/5ths in the SENATE (To end a FILIBUSTER requires 60 members) (To end a FILIBUSTER requires 60 members) Any bill VETOED by the President must have a MAJORITY of Any bill VETOED by the President must have a MAJORITY of 2/3rds in BOTH HOUSES 2/3rds in BOTH HOUSES Supporters in this case have an uphill struggle. EXAMPLE: Clinton vetoed the LATE TERM ABORTION BAN BILL The House voted over 2/3rds to overrule the veto The House voted over 2/3rds to overrule the veto The Senate however were 3 votes short of the 2/3rds required The Senate however were 3 votes short of the 2/3rds required THEREFORE: despite the fact that the majority overall wanted the ban the President (and minority supporters) still won the dayTHEREFORE: despite the fact that the majority overall wanted the ban the President (and minority supporters) still won the day

The UK has only one real chamber to deal with when it comes to legislation. The Lords can only delay bills The US has a bicameral system where BOTH houses share equal power necessitating compromise and negotiation It also leads to the potential problem of DIVIDED GOVERNMENT & GRIDLOCK. BILLS MUST BE APPROVED BY THE STANDING COMMITTEES OF BOTH CHAMBERS

The separation of powers can lead to partisan chambers and often has done. This adds to complications. Although some may say it increases the scrutiny given to laws and appointments. During periods of divided government the House and Senate may be working towards different agendas and their committees chaired by people of very different ideologies. It can lead to GRIDLOCK in some circumstances

Again the separation of powers can lead to divided Government between President and Congress. This adds to complications. Between 1969 and 2001 for only 6 years did the President remain the same party as the Congress The use of the Presidential veto is greatest during a period of divided Government. (7 per year as opposed to an average of 2 per year) Divided government can cause a President a great deal of problems as Clinton found out. Clinton (Dem) wanted an increase in the minimum wage Congress (Rep) wanted cuts in Federal programmes!

A Presidential majority is no guarantee of success. Of Clintons 6 legislative proposals in 1993 only 2 were passed (even with majority’s in the House and Senate Most votes in Congress are BIPARTISAN – One group of Democrats AND Republicans voting against another group of Dems and Reps. Check the example of No Child Left Behind

Previously there was a set of key players called ‘ the Kings of the Hill’ -Speaker ; majority leader and Committee chairmen -Over time however power moved from very powerful committee chairmen to subcommittee chairmen. -The powerful FEW became the considerably less powerful MANY Piecing together coalions therefore is notoriously difficult now “LIKE SEWING BUTTONS ON TO CUSTARD”

1.Wilson was trying to show that the main business of government in the US was based in the Committee. The debate and work in the chamber was merely the outer workings of the work of governing 2. Why are Congressional committees so powerful? a) Key legislative role. Power to pigeon hole and kill a bill as well as amend/block b) They are permanent with large staff. They are also specialist which gives their views gravitas c) They conduct public hearings with extensive powers to call for witnesses or papers (Subpoena) d) Very close links with pressure groups/trade bodies – Iron triangles – Military industrial complex e) Blue ribbon committees like Ways and Means / appropriations/ Senate Foreign affairs has powerful roles – budget/legislation/FP and Confirmations

1.Most important committees- House Rules / Ways and Means/ Senate Foreign affairs / Senate Judicial 2.16 in each House 3.Divided into Subcommittees 4.House committee: approx45-50 5.Senate committee: approx: 18 6.Committee members used to be decided by seniority NOW chosen to mirror party strength and chosen by party committee – Chairs always come from majority party. 7.Seniority rule was simply the longest serving member became chair – role reduced in 1970’s 8.POWER to: influence legislative process – amend/block/initiate Control the purse strings ; Senates advice and consent powers ; impeachment process; scrutinise and check the powers of the executive branch 9.IRON TRIANGLES are deep and powerful relationships developed between legislators and industrial or lobby groups which can dominate policy making and lead to unfair influence EXAMPLE: Pentagon; armed forces committee defence industry

1.POWERS OF HOUSE RULES COMMITTEE? One of the Standing committees BUT VERY IMPORTANTOne of the Standing committees BUT VERY IMPORTANT Timetables bills for consideration on floorTimetables bills for consideration on floor Deals with getting bills from committee to 2 nd readingDeals with getting bills from committee to 2 nd reading Prioritises for quick passagePrioritises for quick passage Sets RULES – Sets out the rules of debate and therefore potential for amendmentSets RULES – Sets out the rules of debate and therefore potential for amendment 2.CONFERENCE COMMITTEE? Both houses have EQUAL POWERBoth houses have EQUAL POWER Bills through BOTH houses CONCURRENTLYBills through BOTH houses CONCURRENTLY Therefore there may have to be compromises negotiated after 3 rd readingTherefore there may have to be compromises negotiated after 3 rd reading They are AD HOC and contain members from both housesThey are AD HOC and contain members from both houses They aim to RECONCILE THE DIFFERENCES IN BILLSThey aim to RECONCILE THE DIFFERENCES IN BILLS The final version is then voted onThe final version is then voted on

YESNO ‘ Damn your Party and stick to your district’ Traditional view‘ Damn your Party and stick to your district’ Traditional view Campaign finance will generally be organised individually at district level.Campaign finance will generally be organised individually at district level. Election campaigns are also highly individual with personal views not party views – Independent Political entrepreneurs-Election campaigns are also highly individual with personal views not party views – Independent Political entrepreneurs- They are more attuned to their constituents wishes – Pork barrel politics etcThey are more attuned to their constituents wishes – Pork barrel politics etc Very few independents in Congress.Very few independents in Congress. The Party machine is required to organise elections (constant) to give ideological backboneThe Party machine is required to organise elections (constant) to give ideological backbone IDEOLOGY is becoming increasingly important over the last few years – Much more solid partisan voting and signs of sophisticated voting operations – Tom DeLay tried to create a very strong cohesive Republican vote. Issues such as healthcare reform galvanise ideologiesIDEOLOGY is becoming increasingly important over the last few years – Much more solid partisan voting and signs of sophisticated voting operations – Tom DeLay tried to create a very strong cohesive Republican vote. Issues such as healthcare reform galvanise ideologies Strong Presidents or controversial Presidents can also divide- Clinton ; ReaganStrong Presidents or controversial Presidents can also divide- Clinton ; Reagan

YESNO ‘ Many congressmen and Senators are given a double barrelled label such as a liberal Republican or even Tea Party – The parties are so diverse that they are hard to be cohesive‘ Many congressmen and Senators are given a double barrelled label such as a liberal Republican or even Tea Party – The parties are so diverse that they are hard to be cohesive Voting does not always coincide with the PartyVoting does not always coincide with the Party No equivalent to manifestos or party programmesNo equivalent to manifestos or party programmes Contract with america damp squibContract with america damp squib Whips lack the carrots on offer in UK (ie office) or discipline withdrawing whip.Whips lack the carrots on offer in UK (ie office) or discipline withdrawing whip. Shifting coalitions of votesShifting coalitions of votes Strong regional cohesion in recent decades with Republicans controlling South and mid west and Democrats North and coastal statesStrong regional cohesion in recent decades with Republicans controlling South and mid west and Democrats North and coastal states Ideological cohesion Democrats now known to be liberal Republicans more Right wing.Ideological cohesion Democrats now known to be liberal Republicans more Right wing. 1994 Contract with America – manifesto setting out reform programme – conservative1994 Contract with America – manifesto setting out reform programme – conservative Party votes are now much more controlled than ever beforeParty votes are now much more controlled than ever before Party leaders in houses are important- trying to form some form of party unityParty leaders in houses are important- trying to form some form of party unity

UKNO EFFECTIVE ‘ Separation of Powers gives the committees a key role in legislating and scrutinising- Executive is a separate institution and it is the duty of Committees to hold it to account RATIFICATION: Senate Foreign Affairs committee. Holds President to account over Foreign policy – can reject foreign treaties- VersaillesRATIFICATION: Senate Foreign Affairs committee. Holds President to account over Foreign policy – can reject foreign treaties- Versailles CONFIRMATION- Judicial committee can reject Presidential appointees – Cabinet members can also be rejectedCONFIRMATION- Judicial committee can reject Presidential appointees – Cabinet members can also be rejected EFFECTIVEEFFECTIVE Stronger Select Committees have been very prominent in recent months in holding the government to account – Credit Crunch. Levenson enquiry; OlympicsStronger Select Committees have been very prominent in recent months in holding the government to account – Credit Crunch. Levenson enquiry; Olympics Power to call Persons and papersPower to call Persons and papers Hutton Enquiry into Iraq war and weapons kept scrutiny on governmentHutton Enquiry into Iraq war and weapons kept scrutiny on government

UKNO EFFECTIVE Impeachment powers – wide investigative powers including power to impeach a PresidentImpeachment powers – wide investigative powers including power to impeach a President Investigative powers Iran Contra scandal Powers to subpoena etcInvestigative powers Iran Contra scandal Powers to subpoena etc EFFECTIVEEFFECTIVE

UKNO INEFFECTIVE Gridlock can result from divided government – Clinton and shut down of federal government- highly unpopularGridlock can result from divided government – Clinton and shut down of federal government- highly unpopular RATIFICATION: President can now use Executive orders to override this powerRATIFICATION: President can now use Executive orders to override this power CONFIRMATION- This is only used sparingly and tends to be a political tool in times of divided government.CONFIRMATION- This is only used sparingly and tends to be a political tool in times of divided government. INEFFECTIVEINEFFECTIVE Committee powers in the UK are usually dampened by Political patronage and controlCommittee powers in the UK are usually dampened by Political patronage and control Power to call Persons and papers is limited legallyPower to call Persons and papers is limited legally A strong governmentA strong government

Check your answers. 1a) The Framers wanted the Legislative branch to dominate as: They feared Executive tyrannyThey feared Executive tyranny They wanted.

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Check your answers. 1a) The Framers wanted the Legislative branch to dominate as: They feared Executive tyrannyThey feared Executive tyranny They wanted."— Presentation transcript:

Similar presentations

About project

Feedback

Log in

Auth with social network:

Check your answers. 1a) The Framers wanted the Legislative branch to dominate as: They feared Executive tyrannyThey feared Executive tyranny They wanted.

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Check your answers. 1a) The Framers wanted the Legislative branch to dominate as: They feared Executive tyrannyThey feared Executive tyranny They wanted."— Presentation transcript:

Similar presentations

About project

Feedback