1. CLUE Framework Status and Issues IETF89 - London March 5, 2014 Mark Duckworth draft-ietf-clue-framework-14 1

2. Changes in Framework-14 Add Security section Add Participant Information, Participant Type, and Scene Information (was “Role” placeholder) Composition within an MCC doesn’t use spatial information Clean up MCC example Remove editor’s notes, delete unneeded text 2

3. MCC attributes max-captures – add qualifier to say either “=“ or “<=“ add attributes switched and composed – proposed in data model draft Seems to be little support for either change proposal: do neither, don’t make any change 3

4. Global Capture Entry List Proposal – add optional list of “Global Capture Entries” A GCE references a set of media captures of a particular media type. The referenced captures can be from any capture scene in the advertisement. The set of captures included in a GCE are a suggestion from the provider as to which captures would be a good choice for the consumer to request, to represent a good view of the entire advertisement The Provider MUST be capable of encoding and sending all Captures in a single Global Capture Entry simultaneously The Media Consumer can choose to receive all Media Captures from one Global Capture Entry for each media type (e.g. audio and video), or it can pick and choose Media Captures regardless of how the Provider arranges them in Global Capture Entries. 4

5. Switched Capture Example Topo-Mixer – media switching variety – see draft-ietf-clue-rtp-mapping and draft-ietf-avtcore-rtp-topologies-update Mixer (middle box) provides conceptual sources (Media Captures), selecting one source at a time from the original sources Mixer is not doing any video composition 5

6. Example Video Layout This endpoint is receiving 9 video captures. MCC1, MCC2, MCC3 has the current talker MCC11 – MCC23 has other recent talkers MCC1MCC2MCC3 MCC11 MCC12 MCC13MCC21 MCC22 MCC23 Blue person starts talking, mixer switches video London Paris 6 MCC1MCC2MCC3 MCC11 MCC12 MCC13MCC21 MCC22 MCC23

7. Advertisement Approach Advertisement has several scenes, each with spatial information for switched MCC video captures – main scene for dominant talker, plus other scenes for next most recent talkers – consumer doesn’t need to handle changing spatial information on the fly as switches occur, because the MCCs have their own spatial information. This is an advantage over the example in the framework. Each scene has multiple CSEs, with different number of MCCs, to accommodate consumers that want to receive a different number of captures “Global Alternative Capture List” is provider’s suggestion for which captures to choose, across all scenes, again to accommodate consumers that want to receive a different number of captures 7

8. Advertisement 8 Scene1Red Room VC1Left; view=table VC2Center; view=table VC3Right; view=table AC1view=room CSE1(VC1,VC2,VC3) CSE2(AC1) None of these media captures has an encoding group Scene2Green Room VC4Left; view=table VC5Center; view=table VC6Right; view=table AC2view=room CSE3(VC4,VC5,VC6) CSE4(AC2) Scene3Blue Room VC7Left; view=table VC8Right; view=table AC3view=room CSE5(VC7,VC8) CSE6(AC3) Scene4Yellow Room VC9view=table AC4view=room CSE7(VC9) CSE8(AC4)

9. Scene5Main Scene MCC1(VC1,VC4,VC7)Left; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=1; Policy=soundlevel:0; EncodingGroup=1 MCC2(VC2,VC5,VC8)Center; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=1; Policy=soundlevel:0; EncodingGroup=1 MCC3(VC3,VC6,VC9)Right; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=1; Policy=soundlevel:0; EncodingGroup=1 MCC4(VC1,VC4,VC7)Left; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=2; Policy=soundlevel:0; EncodingGroup=1 MCC5(VC2,VC3,VC5,VC6,VC8,VC9)Right; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=2; Policy=soundlevel:0; EncodingGroup=1 MCC6( )maxCaptures=1; Policy=soundlevel:0; EncodingGroup=1 MCC7( )maxCaptures=1; Policy=soundlevel:0; EncodingGroup=2 MCC8( )maxCaptures=1; Policy=soundlevel:1; EncodingGroup=2 MCC9( )maxCaptures=1; Policy=soundlevel:2; EncodingGroup=2 CSE101(MCC1, MCC2, MCC3) CSE102(MCC4, MCC5) CSE103(MCC6) CSE104(MCC7,MCC8,MCC9) CSE105(MCC7,MCC8) CSE106(MCC7) Advertisement 9

10. Scene6PiP Scene 1 MCC11(VC1,VC4,VC7)Left; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=3; Policy=soundlevel:1; EncodingGroup=2 MCC12(VC2,VC5,VC8)Center; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=3; Policy=soundlevel:1; EncodingGroup=2 MCC13(VC3,VC6,VC9)Right; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=3; Policy=soundlevel:1; EncodingGroup=2 MCC14(VC1,VC4,VC7)Left; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=4; Policy=soundlevel:1; EncodingGroup=2 MCC15(VC2,VC3,VC5,VC6,VC8,VC9)Right; maxCaptures=1; SyncID=4; Policy=soundlevel:1; EncodingGroup=2 MCC16( )maxCaptures=1; Policy=soundlevel:1; EncodingGroup=2 CSE111(MCC11, MCC12, MCC13) CSE112(MCC14, MCC15) CSE113(MCC16) Advertisement 10 Scene7, PiP Scene 2, is similar. It uses MCC21 to MCC26, with Policy=soundlevel:2; EncodingGroup=3.

11. Advertisement 11 Global Capture Entry List (MCC1, MCC2, MCC3, MCC11, MCC12, MCC13, MCC21, MCC22, MCC23) (MCC1, MCC2, MCC3, MCC11, MCC12, MCC13, MCC24, MCC25) (MCC1, MCC2, MCC3, MCC11, MCC12, MCC13, MCC26) (MCC1, MCC2, MCC3, MCC11, MCC12, MCC13) (MCC1, MCC2, MCC3, MCC14, MCC15) (MCC1, MCC2, MCC3, MCC16) (MCC1, MCC2, MCC3) (MCC4, MCC5) (MCC6) The provider is suggesting all these to accommodate consumers that want to receive different number of captures. Each entry in the list provides a good view of the entire advertisement, for the given number of captures.

12. Need “active capture” info Signaling the “active video capture”, not using just audio energy in the audio stream. Discussed at October 2011 interim meeting, where the group supported this need, but we never followed up on it. Example: endpoint provider sends 3 video captures, and 1 mono audio – Consumer (MCU topo-mixer) wants to know which video has the loudest talker, so it can send that one to a simple endpoint that just receives one video stream – How does this MCU consumer know which one it is? Provider can signal this somehow, if it knows locally which video is associated with the talker – in RTP? – in CLUE channel? – with separate switched MCC capture for the “active capture”? but don’t want to send duplicate encodings wasting bandwidth 12

13. “active capture” Proposal Use separate switched MCC to represent the active capture Example, endpoint provider advertisement: – VC1 left; VC2 center; VC3 right – MCC1(VC1,VC2,VC3) maxCaptures=1; policy=soundlevel:0 – CSE1(VC1,VC2,VC3) – CSE2(MCC1) MCU receives all four captures, so it has enough information to send the right one(s) to different consumers Desire optimization from RTP Mapping draft, Media-9 requirement: – If a given source is being sent on the same transport flow for more than one reason (e.g. if it corresponds to more than one switched capture at once, or to a static capture), it should be possible for a sender to send only one copy of the source. 13

14. Open Tickets #10 sufficient info for receiver – ready to close this? #19, #26 site switching – we have MCC syncID, can we close this? #32 Roles – Added to framework, can close #33 Security – Added to framework, can close #35 consistency with data model - ongoing 14