1. Striving for Voice: Thoughts on language acquisition and integration offered by women who do not yet speak English Striving for Voice: Thoughts on language acquisition and integration offered by women who do not yet speak English Kenise Murphy Kilbride, Ph.D Ryerson University Toronto, Ontario October 22, 2009

2. Who are the women speaking to us? Women who entered Canada: Women who entered Canada: speaking Cantonese (8), Mandarin (8), Urdu (8), Punjabi (6) speaking Cantonese (8), Mandarin (8), Urdu (8), Punjabi (6) as wives of independent, skilled immigrant males as wives of independent, skilled immigrant males not fluent in English not fluent in English

3. Differences between 24 women of similar backgrounds who are now proficient and these 30 women who are not : Level of education Level of education Presence of pre-schoolers Presence of pre-schoolers (4 among the English-fluent Punjabi and Urdu speakers; 11 among the same language groups without English) Length of time in Canada Length of time in Canada

4. Differences in language learning in countries of origin Cantonese and Mandarin speakers said their English teachers had had insufficient experience in English prior to teaching them Cantonese and Mandarin speakers said their English teachers had had insufficient experience in English prior to teaching them Punjabi and Urdu speakers never mentioned this Punjabi and Urdu speakers never mentioned this

5. Differences in goals expressed at landing: Women from Mandarin- and Cantonese- speaking communities usually expect to work and contribute financially to their families Women from Mandarin- and Cantonese- speaking communities usually expect to work and contribute financially to their families Women from Punjabi- and Urdu-speaking communities overwhelmingly expect to have their husbands support their families, and that their roles would be domestic Women from Punjabi- and Urdu-speaking communities overwhelmingly expect to have their husbands support their families, and that their roles would be domestic

6. Experiences in their attempts to learn English Unanimous conviction of importance of learning English Unanimous conviction of importance of learning English Common motivation: Common motivation: to get better jobs; to get better jobs; to be able to deal with doctors for their own and their familys health, to be able to deal with doctors for their own and their familys health, to deal with teachers to support their childrens progress, to deal with teachers to support their childrens progress, to deal with the government regarding their own needs and obligations and the immigration needs of family members; and to deal with the government regarding their own needs and obligations and the immigration needs of family members; and for everyday living as well as emergencies for everyday living as well as emergencies

7. Common challenges to learning English: Financial struggles Financial struggles Differences and similarities among groups Differences and similarities among groups Transportation to classes that arent within walking distance Transportation to classes that arent within walking distance Inconvenient scheduling Inconvenient scheduling Eligibility requirements as obstacles Eligibility requirements as obstacles Teachers they didnt understand Teachers they didnt understand Concern about accents Concern about accents

8. Challenges differing by ethnic group: Familys lack of support or active opposition Familys lack of support or active opposition --husbands, extended familys, and childrens Role in family Role in family Responsibilities for extended family members Responsibilities for extended family members Need for sex-segregated classes Need for sex-segregated classes Ranking in family (daughter-in-law vs daughter) Ranking in family (daughter-in-law vs daughter) Racism Racism Finances Finances

9. Results of not being able to speak English Health Health Lack of confidence in health dealings Lack of confidence in health dealings Problems handling emergencies Problems handling emergencies Inability to meet older family members health needs Inability to meet older family members health needs Mental health effects of stress Mental health effects of stress

10. Education Education Inability to support children in their studies Inability to support children in their studies Inability to advocate for children Inability to advocate for children Family relations suffer from their incompetence in communication Family relations suffer from their incompetence in communication Inability to pursue higher studies themselves Inability to pursue higher studies themselves

11. Workplace - Need for: Advocating for oneself Understanding instructions Communicating difficulties Dealing with injustices

12. Daily life Shopping Banking Dealing with government services Relating to neighbours Overcoming powerlessness

13. On teaching and teachers: Desire for assistance in learning in their own language, whether through teachers or teachers aides, and in a kindly and respectful manner Desire for assistance in learning in their own language, whether through teachers or teachers aides, and in a kindly and respectful manner Desire for instruction in an accent that is Canadian rather than from someone with an accent from another place Desire for instruction in an accent that is Canadian rather than from someone with an accent from another place Desire to acquire a Canadian accent rather than an accent that is a hybrid of the teachers origin and place of education and the students place of origin Desire to acquire a Canadian accent rather than an accent that is a hybrid of the teachers origin and place of education and the students place of origin Desire to progress quickly to mastery of spoken English, with instruction at a more sophisticated level reserved for those going on for higher education or more professional jobs Desire to progress quickly to mastery of spoken English, with instruction at a more sophisticated level reserved for those going on for higher education or more professional jobs

14. Conclusions and Recommendations Subsidies for newcomers to be able to take classes Subsidies for newcomers to be able to take classes Classes on weekends Classes on weekends Classes in local schools, in normal school hours Classes in local schools, in normal school hours Public education on the value to each family & the whole community of women learning English Public education on the value to each family & the whole community of women learning English Free language instruction to newcomers for as long as they need it Free language instruction to newcomers for as long as they need it Emphasis on clarity, not type, of accent in class: There are many types of Canadian accents now! Emphasis on clarity, not type, of accent in class: There are many types of Canadian accents now! Teachers Aides to interpret for students who do not speak English Teachers Aides to interpret for students who do not speak English Good screening & training for teachers to eliminate racism and promote anti-bias teaching Good screening & training for teachers to eliminate racism and promote anti-bias teaching

15. Thank you!