1. Twice/Multi-Exceptional Students
Teacher Update
WKU, Bowling Green
August 28, 2010
Leah M. Ellis
Gifted & Talented Educational Consultant

2. Overview What is a twice or multi-exceptional child?
Challenges of the issue
Identification & Characteristics
Programming/Services
Recommendations/Strategies
Responsibilities/Attitudes

3. What is a Twice or Multi-Exceptional student?
Twice Exceptional students have gifts/talents with a specific disability.
Multi-Exceptional students have gifts/talents and have more than one disability.
behavioral, social, physical and/or learning challenges

4. More Specifically…
The educational term "exceptional" can be applied to gifted children because of their above-average cognitive ability.  When gifted children are also "exceptional" because of a learning disability (a disorder that adversely impacts their learning) they may be referred to as "twice exceptional" ("2E" or 2X"), or as gifted/learning disabled (gifted/LD), or simply "multi-exceptional" a term which acknowledges that a person may have more than one disability.
Julie Shepherd Knapp, 2006

5. Who are the Twice or Multi-exceptional?
The one common trait is that they possess giftedness as well as a deficit.
The largest group of twice exceptional students are those who have a disability & are academically gifted.
They are found within every socioeconomic, cultural, racial, & ethnic population.
They are present in almost every classroom.
They are students at risk of not achieving their potential.
They are the most frequently under-identified population in our schools.
A group of educationally vulnerable pupils whose profiles are often underrepresented in gifted/talented populations.

6. The Big Challenges: Appropriate services are not provided
Underserved students
Difficulty in meeting the unique needs
Not much research in the area of Multi-exceptional
Although there is evidence that students can be both gifted and disabled simultaneously, limited awareness causes school systems
Lack of access to appropriate educational experiences results in …. often having to choose between services that address one exceptionality or the other.

7. Identification Challenges
Inadequate procedures resulting in under-representation.
Labeled first as “disabled”, remediation is the primary concern, not in GT ID.
Few Special education teachers have been exposed to GT characteristics and may observe deviations from the norm as being unique to the disabling condition. (B. Clark)
Some tests that diagnose hyperactivity, withdrawal or disruptive behavior are often tests that spot GT ability.
These children are often put in classrooms with LD children.
self-concept is such an important factor in the success of this student.

8. Identification Considerations
Identification is Complicated: the necessary knowledge of both giftedness & special education and the awareness of the relationship between the two areas of exceptionality.
Hidden disabilities/abilities that complicate the assessment & identification process (ADHD, LD, AS).
Procedures must consider assessments in both giftedness and disabilities.
Actively seek GT students among the students with disabilities population

9. Suggested ID Considerations
Use culturally sensitive assessment processes to prevent cultural bias.
Look for subtle indicators of exceptionality in students, remembering that ones abilities are often masked by disability and vice/versa.
Look for discrepancies in performance including passing hard tasks and failing easy ones.
Assess & compare oral vs. read materials, math analysis vs. computation, timed vs. untimed.
Look for unusual abilities.
Observe adaptations children make; note special strengths & difficulties
Selection committee to include special educators, counselors and GT

10. ID Considerations cont.
Use multiple data sources:
Both Formal & Informal data: Tests of intellectual ability, achievement tests, creativity tests, student work/portfolio, recommendations
Teacher Report of student Functioning: observations, recommendations
Family History/Student Background: Conference with families about student performance outside of school, student interviews, parent surveys
Nominations/Formal recommendations: Teachers, parents, peers, self, psychologists, community members
Student Inventory to include interests, strengths, learning styles, values, etc.
Awards & Achievements
Behavioral Checklists of specific characteristics of GT students with disabilities

11. 3 Main Categories (Baum, 1990)
Formally identified GT, but not identified as having a disability (Giftedness masks the disability)
- Goes unnoticed for possible special education.
- May be considered an underachiever, lazy, or unmotivated.
- Maintains grade-level expectations until difficulty increases (middle & high school).
Formally identified disability, but not identified as GT (Disability masks giftedness)
- May be in special education focused solely on remediation or compensation of the disability.
- Significantly underestimated intellectual abilities due to inadequate assessment that yielded depressed IQ scores.
- Bored in special programs if services do not match challenge level.
- Often misdiagnosed as having an emotional disability.
Experts suggest students fall within one of these three categories:

12. Categories continued:
Not formally identified as either GT or having a disability (Components mask each other)
- Achieving at grade level and assumed to have average ability.
- Show signs of difficulty as curriculum becomes more challenging.
- Perceived as performing within expectations and therefore never referred for special education evaluation.
- Deflated achievement and test scores due to disability and not qualifying for gifted education services.

13. Characteristics of Gifted Students with Disability
Impaired long & short-term memory
Visual or auditory processing difficulties
Visual motor integration problems
Poor self-concepts
High levels of self-criticism, withdrawal, or aggressive behaviors
Short attention spans
Difficulty following directions
Poor peer relations
(Suter & Wolf 1987)

14. Twice Exceptional Learner Profile
Decent grades, grade-level district assessments, well above average IQ, reading decoding skills below average.
Having a combination of some gifted abilities and areas that require intensive interventions

15. Multi-Exceptional Learner Profile
Well above grade level reading skills, creative thinker, gifted athlete & artist, grade level testing is slightly above average, A’s in classes she likes and F’s in classes (or with teachers) she dislikes, behavioral, emotional & social disabilities (Bi-Polar, anxiety, ADD, OCD).
The unique combination of needs requires intensive interventions for both giftedness and exceptionalities. Because of her behavioral difficulties, she drops out of school.

16. Underachieving GT & LD/GT Compared (Silverman 1989)
Key Characteristics
Lack of social skills
Social isolation
Unrealistic self-expectations
Perfectionist tendencies
Distractibility
Frustration in response to school demands
Low self-esteem
Failure to complete assignments
Both populations are usually identified by the discrepancy between aptitude and achievement
Is this a student who wont do the work or cant do the work?

17. Gifted Regulation Support for ID & Services
Section 3. Identification and Diagnosis of Gifted Characteristics, Behaviors, and Talent and Determination of Eligibility for Services.
(3) A local school district shall provide a system for diagnostic screening and identification of strengths, gifted behaviors and talents which provides equal access for racial and ethnic minority children, disadvantaged children, and children with disabilities.
704 KAR 3:285

18. Section 4. Procedure for Determining Eligibility for Services.
(2) Exceptions and special considerations for eligibility. School personnel shall take into consideration environmental, cultural, and disabling conditions which may mask a child's true abilities that lead to exclusion of otherwise eligible students, such as a student who qualifies as:
(a) An exceptional child as defined in KRS ;
(b) Disadvantaged; or
(c) Underachieving.

19. Addressing the Needs
Students require a combination of gifted and special education services.
Teach the whole child, not just a part of the child.
The general classroom teacher has responsibilities to this population.

20. Classroom Teacher Responsibilities
When teaching twice-exceptional students in their area of strength, offer them the same compacting and differentiation opportunities available to other students.
When teaching in the area of challenge, teach them directly whatever strategies they need to increase success.
Never take time away from their strength to create more time on their deficiencies.
Winebrenner, 2003

21. Effective Practices:
Gather info to identify student needs and strengths.
Develop and implement IEPs that have GT strategies and GSSPs that have special education strategies.
Collaboration/ Expert Consultation.
Meet individual needs (May need use of special ed or gifted services, after school activities, clubs, independent study, arts programs, etc.).
Example: IEP can include enrichment or additional PD for classroom teacher
Experts include: GT specialist, special Education specialist, counselors, psychologists
Example: Independent projects or oral execution of creative ideas and help with getting ideas into complete sentences and on paper

22. In the Classroom:
Simultaneous provision of gifted instruction & specialized instruction, adaptations & accommodations.
Make students an active part of the class.
Hold high expectations for these students as well.

23. Key Issues to Consider in the Classroom :
Accommodate Academic Strengths/Giftedness
Accommodate Academic Weaknesses/Disabilities
Provide Direct Instruction to Support Classroom success
Address Social & Emotional Issues
Address Behavioral Issues
Overview: 5 key issues
(Detailed on the next 5 slides)

24. Accommodating Academic Strengths/Giftedness
Focus on developing personal strengths.
Focus on higher order thinking & reasoning skills to include student inquiry & questioning.
Find students strongest Learning Style.
Incorporate instruction with in-depth lessons & concept development in student interest & passion areas.
Use an interdisciplinary curriculum to allow for connectedness between topics.
Use alternate ways to demonstrate understanding (CRUCIAL).
Where appropriate, provide compacting, differentiation, acceleration.
Explore multiple avenues to meets needs: after school activities, clubs, related arts-programs, mentoring, online learning, independent studies.
Do not use gifted services as an incentive for addressing behavioral problems or academic weaknesses.
Allow students to participate in enrichment experiences.

25. Accommodating Academic Weaknesses/Disabilities
Hands-on Activities
Graphic Organizers
Differentiation (Adjust content, process & product/assessment)
Direct instruction in skills that affect disability
Allow Assistive Technology where appropriate
Make modifications (keyboarding, spell check)
Necessary accommodations: extended test/work time, quiet/less distracting environment, etc.
Direct instruction in study skills & learning strategies
Promote student self-determination by developing self-understanding, goal setting, self-advocacy

26. Provide Direct Instruction to Support Classroom success
May include Content &/or Direct Instruction in:
- Writing
- Organization
- Reading
- Mathematical Calculations
- Test Taking Strategies

27. Additional Comments This special population:
may have extremes of ability existing in one student (disabilities & giftedness).
may underestimate their own capabilities and choose not to pursue post-secondary education.
when needs are met, has shown growth in closing achievement gaps.
is more likely to drop out of school possibly adding to homelessness, low-income housing, criminal activity.
represents unrealized potential such as inspiring leaders who are never elected, cures for diseases never discovered, revolutionary inventions never patented, thrilling novels that are never written, groundbreaking theories never conceived.

28. Closing Comments
Do you know of students not performing up to expectations?
Do you think you might have a twice/multi-exceptional student in your schools?
Do you feel you have some tools for helping them achieve their potential?

29. References/ Additional Resources
The Twice-Exceptional Dilemma, National Education Association,
Supporting Emotional Needs of the Gifted,
National Association for Gifted Children,
Council for Exceptional Children
Hoagies Gifted / Twice Exceptional
Uniquely Gifted
2E Newsletter
Clark, Barbara. Growing Up Gifted. Merrill, Prentice Hall
Some references