1. The Changing Role of Intangibles over the Crisis Intangibles & Economic Crisis & Company’s Value : the Analysis using Scientometric Instruments Anna Bykova Perm 25th March 2013

2. The objects of Scientometrics Analysis 1 What is the University’s research performance 2 How competitive is our research compared to peers? 3 How can the University forecast growth? 4 What are the Uni’s centres of excellence? 5 What is our citation ranking 6 How can we demonstrate the relevance of our research?

3. Scientometrics: basic points Different Data Bases for conducting research (next slide) Derek de Solla Price and Vasilij Nalimov were the originators of the discipline, which they developed for the purpose of providing research tools to historians and sociologists of science. Scientometrics are a set of methods for measuring the production and dissemination of scientific knowledge for conducting quantitative analysis of science

5. Main Indicators of the Scientometrics The number of articles published in learned journals during a specific time frame is an indicator of the output of a set or subset within the science system. It is also possible to compare numbers in order to gauge output intensity in specific fields (specialization index). Publication count Number of citations can be used to evaluate the scientific impact of research. The number of citations received by learned journals is systematically compiled by Thomson ISI and sold under the trademark Journal Citation Reports (JCI). This product includes a number of indicators related to citations received by journals, and the impact factor is probably the one most commonly applied. Citations and impact factor Many co-citation-based indicators are used to map research activity. Mapping is a means of studying the development of emerging fields using time as a variable. Co- citation and co-word indicators can be combined with publication and citation counts to build multifaceted representations of research fields, linkages among them, and the actors who are shaping them. Co-citation and co-word analysis

6. Main Indicators of the Scientometrics: Absolute and Relative measures

7. Methodology was almost taken from…. Jeevan V. K.J, and Sen B.K.. 2007. A scientometric analysis of publications on accelerator- based research from nuclear science centre and Tata institute of fundamental research India, Malaysian Journal of Library &Information Science, Vol. 12, no. 2, Dec. 2007: 89-97 Jeevan V.K.J., and Gupta B.M. 2001. R&D performance of different departments of IIT, Kharagpur: a scientometric study based on publications, (Delhi University) Journal of Library & Information Science, Vol. 26, no. 2: 129-143. Pandalai T.A., Karanjai A., and Sen B.K. 1996. Bibliometrics in the evaluation of science. Handbook of Libraries, Archives & Information Centres in India, Vol 13: 99-108.

8. Steps Paper and citation countsThe place of publication of the journal papersThe key authors, institutions, and journalsThe Subject of publicationsMapping

9. Key Words for the Research Key words Intangibles Economic Crisis Company Value

10. Intangibles: incredible growth of publications during last 10 years

11. More or less the same situation for Intellectual Capital….

12. Economic Crisis: peaks of surge of interest

13. Company’s Value: could be just one of outputs

14. When we overlap all key words:

16. Countries: the Leadership of USA Intangibles Economic Crisis Company's Value

17. Subject of the papers Intangibles Economic Crisis Company's Value

18. Citation counts (absolute metrics!) Intangibles Total number of documents: 6664 H-index: 97 Total number of citations: 55397 Journal with max score: Journal of Marketing (2019) Paper with max score: Evolving to a New Dominant Logic for Marketing by Vargo S.L., Lusch R.F. Time period: 1923-2013 Top 3 journals: Journal of Marketing Academy of Management Journal International Journal of Production Economics Economic Crisis Total number of documents: > 20 000 from 2000 to 2013 H-index: 59 Total number of citations: 48909 Journal with max score: the Lancet Paper with max score: Adaptive governance of social-ecological systems by Folke C., Hahn T., Olsson P., Norberg J. Top 3 Journals: Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews Economy and Society Annual Review of Environment and Resource Company’s Value Total number of documents: > 20 000 from 2000 to 2013 H-index: 45 Total number of citations: 38904 Journal with max score: Paper with max score: Managing the co-creation of value by Payne A.F., Storbacka K., Frow P. Top 5 Journals: Journal of Financial Economics Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science Harvard Business Review

19. Further Steps….. 1. To finish the analysis Proportion of papers published in SCI journals Proportion of papers published in non-SCI journals Impact rate, measured in terms of normalized impact factor (NIF) per paper for papers in SCI journals Number of papers above the average NIF and total NIF of each institution Number of papers in the different NIF ranges and the proportion of high NIF papers, above a particular threshold Publication effectiveness index (PEI) as a measure of the impact of research of a particular institution in tune with the papers produced

20. Further Steps….. 2. To calculate the Relative measures citations per paper compared with citations per paper in the field over the same period citations vs. expected (baseline) citations percent papers cited vs. uncited compared to field average rank within field or among peer group by papers, citations, or citations per paper

21. Further Steps….. 3. Research field Mapping