1. Texas’ New Business Tax Credits: Something for Everyone Craig Daugherty Texas Comptroller’s Office

2. $4.4 billion Budget Period 2000-01 Beginning Balance Uneven Regional Economic Development Regional Technology Booms Legislative Policy Environment Texas’ New Business Tax Credits

3. Tax Relief Package Summary n Legislative leaders allot $500 million over two years to sales and franchise tax relief n Final tax relief package more or less evenly split between sales tax and franchise tax n Bipartisan support in the legislature

4. Franchise Tax Relief Package n Three economic development credits n Two child care credits n Small business exemption n Rejected the “mega-credit”

5. Economic Development Credits n Research credit based on federal credit n Targeted job creation credit n Targeted investment credit

6. Economic Development vs Child Care

7. Revenue Impacts of Credits

8. Job Creation Credit n 25 percent of wages in first year n Minimum threshold—10 new jobs n Credit installments spread over 5 years n Excludes lower-than-average-paying jobs n Limited to 50 percent of tax liability

9. Investment Credit n 7.5 percent of investment amount n Minimum investment of $500,000 n Credit installments spread over 5 years n Excludes buildings and structures n Limited to 50 percent of tax liability

10. Research Credit n 5 percent of “new” research spending n Based on federal research credit n Credit may be taken immediately n Limited to 50 percent of tax liability

11. Targeting Credits Reflect Legislative Sensibilities n A “Strategic Investment Area” directs tax concessions to impoverished counties n Industry limitations focus tax benefits on high-wage industries n Performance requirements reinforce the high-wage-job bias of the credits

12. Selection of Strategic Investment Area County unemployment rate > state unemployment rate + County per-capita income < state per-capita income = Strategic Investment Area

13. manufacturing wholesale warehousing computer services research labs Industries Qualified for Targeted Credits

14. Indirect Credit Limitations n Job creation credit only covers jobs that pay more than 110 percent of county average wage n Investment credit only covers companies that pay, on average, 110 percent of county average wage

15. Credit Performance Standards n Job credit takers are required to maintain employment levels throughout the five-year credit installment period. n Investment credit takers are required to retain the capital equipment throughout the five-year credit installment period.

16. Policy Goals n Grant the credits only for high-wage jobs n Steer economic growth to impoverished areas n Require minimum performance standards

17. Future Considerations n SICs vs NAICS n Urban county lock-out? n Legislative review n Taxpayer uncertainty

18. Credits for Child Care n Child Care Credit: business-sponsored child care for employees’ pre-school children n After-School Credit: business donations to accredited schools for before- and after- school care

19. Child Care Credit n Companies that provide child care on premises or pay costs for off-site care n Only for pre-school children n Credit is 50 percent of expenses, limited to $50,000 and 90 percent of tax liability

20. After-School Credit n Companies that donate cash to accredited schools (public or private) n Only for school-age children n Credit is 30 percent of donation

21. Texas’ New Business Tax Credits: Something for Everyone Craig Daugherty Texas Comptroller’s Office