1. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Effects of Early Stimulation and Deprivation Chapter 5

2. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. The general philosophical trend has been that stimulation is always “good” and deprivation is always “bad.”

3. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Objectives Describe some effects of early stimulation Describe some programs to enhance early motor development Describe McGraw’s famous twin study involving early stimulation and deprivation Describe some effects of early deprivation Explain the major concepts concerning stimulation and deprivation

4. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Questions Can overstimulation occur? Is deprivation ever in the child’s best interest? When are the best times for stimulation or the worst times for deprivation? Is stimulation worthwhile for the acquisition of all human behaviors? Are there some behaviors that cannot be facilitated by early exposure to stimulating experiences?

5. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Effects of Early Stimulation In 1983, 70% of 4-year-olds from families with incomes higher that $25,000 per year attended preschool Parents believe early educational stimulation is valuable Some experts believe that too much early stimulation toward a skill, like reading, may actually cause difficulties later in reading

6. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Effects of Early Stimulation Many parents –Believe that kindergarten is “too late” –Begin to “teach” their children at birth –Believe that early educational stimulation is valuable

7. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Programs to Enhance Early Motor Development Programs designed to stimulate early motor development fall into two categories –No programming –Programming

8. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Programs to Enhance Early Motor Development No programming –These programs do not emphasize specific practice of future motor skills –Instruction should be withheld until the infant learns body control –Infants are to be left on their back until they are capable of changing the position –Nonrestrictive clothing advocated –Hard-soled shoes are discouraged

9. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Programs to Enhance Early Motor Development Programming –Parent takes an active role in moving the baby or limbs of the infant during activity –Infant walkers, bouncers, etc., are encouraged –Specialized equipment is available –Manual manipulation for infant fitness and flexibility

10. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Programs to Enhance Early Motor Development Little research is available to substantiate either “no-programming” or “programming” American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that structured programs not be “promoted as being therapeutically beneficial for the development of healthy infants” “parents are encouraged to provide a safe, nurturing, and minimally structured play environment for their infant”

11. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Gymboree Philosophy: preschool years may be the most critical part of education Preschoolers need to be provided with certain types of play activities that are essential in development but not available at home –Safe and noncompetitive

12. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Gymboree Program includes 7 levels designed to enhance motor skills, social skills, and self-esteem –Physical fitness –Arts –International play –Music and dance –Yoga

13. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Gymboree Lofty claims are not made, but there is no controlled research to suggest that this program is superior to “no program” Parents claim the programs are beneficial for both child and parent Consumers should be cautious

14. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Swim Programs The American Academy of Pediatrics, American Red Cross, and YMCA state that –Infant and toddler aquatic programs DO NOT decrease the risk of drowning

15. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Swim Programs Children are not ready for swimming lessons until their 4 th birthday Drownproofing programs may give parents a false sense of security –Child may be at greater risk of drowning

16. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Swim Programs Hyponatremia –Water intoxication –Occurs when an individual ingests too much water The body’s electrolytes are reduced and kidneys cannot filter excess fluid Sodium levels reduced Symptoms of restlessness, disorientation, weakness, and death –Common in those who practice forced or frequent submersion

17. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Swim Programs How could an infant develop hyponatremia during a swim program?

18. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Swim Programs Giardia –A parasitic condition which develops due to cyst growth in the digestion tract –Causes diarrhea and is easily transmitted to others in a pool Safety in the pool –Shower after class (wash off Giardia) –Wear tight legged diapers/pants –Children who are ill or with diarrhea should not participate in swim lessons

19. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Swim Program Guidelines Children are not ready for formal swim lessons until their 4 th birthday Avoid total submersion Provide measure for avoiding fecal contamination in the pool Children should never be dropped or pushed into water Babies chill easily; limit exposure

20. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Suzuki Method of Violin Playing Begin at birth –Infant listens to violin music –Child watches musicians play violin The child begins lessons at 2 to 2 ½ years The child’s motivation is important

21. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Suzuki Method of Violin Playing Child should not be forced into taking lessons A properly sized violin is used Little is known about the residual effects of such early programming

22. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Suzuki method of learning to play the violin emphasizes listening and playing

23. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Head Start Programs Designed to give financially disadvantaged children a “head start” in education The major goal of Head Start is to “enhance the social competence of children from lower income families” Social competence = ability to deal with the present environment in school and for life

24. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Head Start Programs Children of Head Start programs were 10 times more likely to complete a high school education without failure compared to their socioeconomic counterparts The D.C. Study reported that programs like Head Start and other preschool programs affected children’s long-term performance positively

25. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Head Start Programs Head Start Family and Child Experience Survey (FACES) –Surveyed the cognitive, social, emotional, and physical development of Head Start children –Generally, Head Start children were found to “very often” use their free time in acceptable ways,” “follow the teacher’s directions,” and “help in putting things away”

26. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Head Start Programs Head Start Family and Child Experience Survey (FACES) –The children COULD NOT Identify or write the letters of the alphabet Copy complex geometric figures Demonstrate “right from left” or “top from bottom” in reading

27. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Head Start Programs Head Start Family and Child Experience Survey (FACES) –Overall conclusion was that Head Start children are ready for school on the basis of how much they had learned by the end of kindergarten

28. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Infant Walkers Designed to support babies who cannot yet walk independently There are many questions about safety and efficacy of the device to promote early walking

29. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Infant Walkers Due to risk and lack of clear benefit, the sale and manufacture of infant walkers should be banned in the US Injuries are common –Head injuries –Falling down stairs Parents need to be informed of the dangers of a walker Childcare centers should not allow the use of walkers Recommendation of the American Academy of Pediatrics (1995)

30. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Johnny and Jimmy In 1935, two twin brothers were observed for 22 months to determine a normal progression in motor development Johnny was given toys and stimulation, practice, and experience in movement activities Jimmy was given few toys and had minimal movement experience

31. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Johnny and Jimmy The researcher concluded that readiness, practice, attitude, and physical growth were all particularly important factors influencing human movement at an early age

33. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Effects of Early Deprivation Difficult to study the effects of early deprivation –It is unethical and inhumane to place children in an deprived environment Animal models have provided important information Tragic human cases in society provide additional insight

34. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Effects of Early Deprivation Hopi cradleboards –A subject of research in the 1930s –Up until 1 year of age, Hopi babies may be swaddled and tied to a board –Legs are extended, arms free –Although, these babies were not permitted typical “infant” movements, when free of the board, these infants exhibited the expected movement sequences of noncradled infants

35. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Early Deprivation Deprivation Dwarfism –A disorder resulting in reduced or failed growth –An emotional disturbance that is registered in the higher centers of the brain –Information is conveyed to hypothalamus where growth hormone and somatotropin are released –When growth is affected, motor development may also be affected

36. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Early Deprivation Deprivation Dwarfism –Infants who are hospitalized for extended periods fail to gain weight and develop respiratory infections –Symptoms disappear when infant is returned home to a more stimulating environment

37. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Early Deprivation Deprivation Dwarfism –Also occurs in situations where children are not nurtured in a loving and caring environment despite proper and plentiful nutrition

38. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Early Deprivation Anna –A victim of severe deprivation due to isolation (1946) –Left in an attic room until six years of age –When discovered she showed signs of minimal intelligence, could not walk or talk, and was extremely malnourished

39. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Early Deprivation Anna –By the age of 10 years, Anna was able to walk and run clumsily, string beads, but did not speak in complete sentences –Died at age 11 years

40. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Early Deprivation Young Savage of Abeyron –Victor, a young boy found in the woods of France in 1799 at 11-12 years of age –He could not talk, trotted rather than walk, chewed like a rodent, and was intellectually delayed –Despite attempts to remediate, he showed little improvement intellectually and died at 40 years of age

41. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Stimulation and Deprivation Concepts Critical period –A time of particular or maximum sensitivity to environmental –If a child is stimulated during the sensitive period, the associated behavior is likely to occur

42. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Stimulation and Deprivation Concepts Critical periods –Specific time in a person’s life –For many skills, if critical period bypassed, skill may be learned, but will never be developed at master level If the left hemisphere of brain is damaged during critical period for language –Right hemisphere substitutes If the left hemisphere of brain damaged after language is developed –Person will never be able to speak fluently –Critical period for right hemisphere substitution passed

43. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Stimulation and Deprivation Concepts Four essential elements of a critical period –State of readiness must be attained by the individual in order for the environmental stimulation to be effective –There is a specific time limit Appropriate stimulation must occur during a specific time for optimal development

44. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Stimulation and Deprivation Concepts Four essential elements of a critical period –The effects of the stimulation during the critical period create a permanent and durable imprint –There are critical periods for all aspects of human behavior Animals imprint on parents and will follow them. Here is Konrad Z. Lorenz who demonstrated that incubator-hatched geese would follow the first moving stimulus within the critical period http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imprinting_(psychology)

45. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Stimulation and Deprivation Concepts Readiness –The establishment of the minimum characteristics necessary for a particular human behavior to be acquired –Depends on an adequate level of physical growth, associated neurological patterns, and sufficient motivation Tri-cycling skill in the twins Johnny and Jimmy

46. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Stimulation and Deprivation Concepts Readiness –Early experience with a particular skill before a child is “ready” may not be valuable –Signs for readiness are unrecognizable at present Maybe the signs never exist

47. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Stimulation and Deprivation Concepts Catch-up –The human power “to stabilize and return” to a genetically determined growth path “after being pushed off trajectory” –Associated with physical growth and motor development –Children can also catch-up intellectually, socially, emotionally, and developmentally –Severity of the deprivation determines the degree of catch-up

48. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved. Stimulation and Deprivation Concepts Example of a child’s catch-up growth following a period of anorexia

49. © 2007 McGraw-Hill Higher Education. All rights reserved.