1. Tantangan Global Pengembangan Industri Minyak Sawit Indonesia Oleh Duta Besar Dian Triansyah Djani Direktur Jenderal Amerika dan Eropa Konferensi Pengembangan Industri Minyak Sawit Gran Melia Hotel Jakarta, 16 – 17 Oktober 2013 1

2. 1.Preliminary stage 2.Production 3.Output/end product ATTACK ON RI'S PALM OIL

3. ISSUES BROUGHT FORWARD 1.Environment angle  Depletion forest  Green house effect/global warming  Haze  How to count emission Green House Gases, scientific evidence 2.Health angle  Obesity  Saturated vs unsaturated fat  Cancer, heart disease etc  Cholesterol 3.Production method  Chemical usage  Land clearing  Forest fires/haze 4.Energy concerns  oil depleting  renewable sources 5.Animal cruelty  Orang Utan, Sumatran Tiger 6.Trade angle  Dumping, Subsidy, Price fixing (?)  is there unfair trade practice; injury to domestic 7.Food insecurity  changing pattern of production from food to biodiesel  corn, palm oil, etc 8.Social/other issues  movement of community, indigenous people's right, etc; Human Rights, child labor 9.Competitiveness of Market

4. ACTORS/PLAYERS 1.Governments 2.International Organizations 3.Companies 4.Environmental NGOs 5.Scientific Community 6.Communities/peoples

5. HURDLES 1.Entering market  high tariff as result of dumping case/ trade remedy 2.Regulations  rules and standards 3.Public opinion  negative labeling deter consumers 4.Global view 5.Business reluctance  using intermediate product  Ferrerro case 6.NGOs pressure 7.Etc

6. ACTIONS 1.Campaign on creating awareness  media interview, advertising on CNN 2.Rebutting false accusations  health, environment, animal cruelty etc 3.Providing scientific evidence  usage of science publications ( reputable science journal), statement of scientist 4.Negotiating rules and standard in international fora 5.Diplomacy  targeted toward government, business and interest groups 6.Pressure/appeal on business partners to assist 7.Trade dispute in international fora  WTO 8.Legal Discourse  local court  Ivory Coast case

7. FORA 1.Bilateral  government to government approach 2.Multilateral/regional fora 3.Standardization organization 4.Scientific institutions 5.NGOs gathering 6.Regional/Local Court

8. THANK YOU / TERIMA KASIH