# Division of Economic Statistics and Advice SCAF WORKSHOP ON INVESTMENT APPRAISAL – CURRENT POLICY AND PRACTICE IN MOD 9 FEBRUARY 2010 NEIL V DAVIES, JOHN.

## Presentation on theme: "Division of Economic Statistics and Advice SCAF WORKSHOP ON INVESTMENT APPRAISAL – CURRENT POLICY AND PRACTICE IN MOD 9 FEBRUARY 2010 NEIL V DAVIES, JOHN."— Presentation transcript:

Division of Economic Statistics and Advice SCAF WORKSHOP ON INVESTMENT APPRAISAL – CURRENT POLICY AND PRACTICE IN MOD 9 FEBRUARY 2010 NEIL V DAVIES, JOHN OGILVIE, PRABHAT VAZE MINISTRY OF DEFENCE

 Value for Money (vfm) is optimal combination of  Economy – ie Cost of Inputs ( 1 / M ):Inputs/Money)  Efficiency – ie Ratio of Output to Inputs ( O / I :Outputs/Inputs)  Effectiveness – ie Value of Outcomes from Outputs ( V / O :Value/Outputs  Hence vfm =  Vfm is a relative not absolute construct SLIDE 1 VALUE FOR MONEY

 Responsible for MOD policy on Investment Appraisal (IA) and Project Evaluation (PE) and ensuring MOD compliance with HM Treasury’s “Green Book” guidance  Provide advice and guidance on IAs and PEs eg JSP507  Scrutinise IAs/COEIAs, OBCs for all projects subject to Central Approval (eg Ministers, IAB, DEC)  Review sample of TLB IAs/PEs for Health of Financial Systems Review SLIDE 2 OUR ROLES IN MOD INVESTMENT APPRAISAL AND EVALUATION

 To ensure Value for Money is obtained from investment decisions  Effective appraisal and evaluation are fundamental requirements of Treasury delegations SLIDE 3 PURPOSE OF IA

 Compares the costs of alternative ways of producing the same or similar outputs, which are not given a monetary value  While every effort should be made to quantify benefits, cost benefit analysis is not appropriate or feasible for most defence projects SLIDE 4 MAIN FORM OF IA IN MOD: COST EFFECTIVENESS OF ANALYSIS

Military or Business Effectiveness Whole Life Cost A OptionsC B E F D SLIDE 5 COMBINED OPERATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS & INVESTMENT APPRAISAL (COEIA) 45º

 Why is it necessary to commit resources?  What do we want to achieve?  What options are available?  How much will they cost? SLIDE 6 BASIC QUESTIONS FOR IA

 establish requirement  define objectives  identify options  quantify costs and benefits of (shortlisted) options  compare these in NPV terms  evaluate risks and uncertainties  consider unquantifiable factors  present results and make recommendation  plan for Project Evaluation SLIDE 7 MODEL OUTLINE OF MOD IA

SLIDE 8 QUALITY OF TLB IAs  Quality improving from a low base  Numbers of IAs declining

 We have around 180-200 live projects at any time  Most IAs at a high standard by the time they go to IAB  But at draft stage main problems vague/uncertain specification of requirement limited consideration of alternative options/case written around preferred option particular challenges with partnering affordability often uncertain SLIDE 9 PRACTICAL ISSUES WITH IAs/COEIAs SUPPORTING CENTRALLY APPROVED PROJECTS

1.Increasing competition for resources - Fiscal position means next comprehensive Spending Review will bring severe squeeze on spending - Defence will need to compete with other spending priorities 2.Strategic Defence Review - This will provide long-term direction - Need for evidence on VFM to support direction - Can appraisal provide more for strategic decisions? 3.Gray Review findings and appraisal - Highlights problems of Entryism and Optimism Bias - Findings include skills gaps and technical shortcomings - Poor information mixes with competing interests and incentives SLIDE 10 CHALLENGES

SLIDE 11 WHERE WE MIGHT FOCUS: Training & Guidance Requirements & options identification Optimism bias Integrate supplementary guidance Examples & better presentation Training for managers & practitioners

SLIDE 11 WHERE WE MIGHT FOCUS: Training & Guidance Requirements & options identification Optimism bias Integrate supplementary guidance Examples & better presentation Training for managers & practitioners Evaluation Encourage more evaluation Share best practise on IA evaluation Highlight feedback role into appraisal Use existing evaluative results: optimism bias

SLIDE 11 WHERE WE MIGHT FOCUS: Training & Guidance Requirements & options identification Optimism bias Integrate supplementary guidance Examples & better presentation Training for managers & practitioners Evaluation Encourage more evaluation Share best practise on IA evaluation Highlight feedback role into appraisal Use existing evaluative results: optimism bias Wider applications Could appraisal help at concept level? What role in planning round? What IA evidence can be used for prioritisation?

SLIDE 12 ANY QUESTIONS?

Download ppt "Division of Economic Statistics and Advice SCAF WORKSHOP ON INVESTMENT APPRAISAL – CURRENT POLICY AND PRACTICE IN MOD 9 FEBRUARY 2010 NEIL V DAVIES, JOHN."

Similar presentations