1. BEAN WARS CLAIM Type of nutrition varies with the size of the beans CLAIM Type of nutrition varies with the size of the beans QUALIFIER Small beans are sweeter, due to more sugars QUALIFIER Small beans are sweeter, due to more sugars REBUTAL Unless infection play a role REBUTAL Unless infection play a role WARRENT To grow they need nutrition & water WARRENT To grow they need nutrition & water BACKING A living things need nutrition & water to grow BACKING A living things need nutrition & water to grow DATA Large beans : 0 cm Medium beans: 12 cm Small beans: 25 cm DATA Large beans : 0 cm Medium beans: 12 cm Small beans: 25 cm

2. CLAIM We can only see the colour red (no other colours) CLAIM We can only see the colour red (no other colours) QUALIFIER Red light filters the red have length. We can only see that frequency QUALIFIER Red light filters the red have length. We can only see that frequency REBUTAL Unless the red light was not working, or you are colour blind. REBUTAL Unless the red light was not working, or you are colour blind. WARRENT We can only see the colours that are reflected WARRENT We can only see the colours that are reflected BACKING Without a light source we cannot see BACKING Without a light source we cannot see DATA Original flower, black box, red light DATA Original flower, black box, red light