Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

W. A. Horowitz The Ohio State University June 19, 2010

Published byMaija-Leena Virtanen Modified over 5 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "W. A. Horowitz The Ohio State University June 19, 2010"— Presentation transcript:

1 W. A. Horowitz The Ohio State University June 19, 2010
Theory Comparisons W. A. Horowitz The Ohio State University June 19, 2010 With many thanks to Brian Cole, Miklos Gyulassy, Ulrich Heinz, Jiangyong Jia, and Yuri Kovchegov 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

2 Motivation for pQCD Theory Comparison?
Death of fragility: Density extracted (assuming infinite thy prec) to w/i 20-30% Proof of Principle What about other observables? Falsify before we quantify PHENIX PRL101 (2008) 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

3 Uncertainty in Medium Extraction?
Is this a sys. th. unc. on a medium parameter? No! Experimentally all these models are falsified by data v2, IAA, NPE, ... No! Known important physics is missing Elastic E-loss (dyn sc cent, vacuum rad, ...) What is the qhat from fully strongly coupled AdS? AdS is at least as right/wrong as pQCD Apples to oranges comparison 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

4 Irony of Multiple Observables
v2 too small NPE supp. too large p0 v2 C. Vale for PHENIX, QM09 Plenary (analysis by R. Wei) WHDG Wicks, WAH, Gyulassy, Djordjevic, NPA784 (2007) NPE v2 IAA, B/M, g-h, ... Pert. at LHC? PHENIX, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, (2007) 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

5 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL
Comments on v2 CGC, fluctuations not enough for pQCD AdS/CFT: DE ~ L3 Better job? Glauber KLN CGC Solid: rotated Dashed: not rotated PHENIX p0 WAH and J Jia, in preparation Marquet and Renk, PLB685 (2010) Largest medium density w/i unc. from RAA 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

6 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL
Comments on NPE Exp. converge in pp NB: pQCD calculations so far assume M << E b corrections likely large c and b separation Success of AdS/CFT? dpT/dt = - m pT m = pl1/2 T2/2Mq WAH, PhD Thesis 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

7 Uncertainties in Wide Angle Radiation
UV What about IR? WAH and B Cole, PRC81, 2010 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

8 Collinearity and Gluon Mass
Massless gluons: Large IR cutoff sensitivity Gluons with thermal mass ~ BDMS, JHEP 0109 (2001) Larger x better respects kT << xE 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL WAH and B Cole, PRC81, 2010

9 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL
Results Quantitatively compare to PHENIX data Assumed infinite Elastic precision WAH and B Cole, PRC81, 2010 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

10 Parton Energy Dependence
Dependence on parton energy Uncertainty on qhat Assume all formalisms equally affected WAH and B Cole, PRC81, 2010 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

11 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL
v2: “Collinearly Safe” Fix dNg/dy from RAA, calculate v2 Expect larger v2 for smaller opening angle ( tcoh ~ 1/kT2 ) IAA: coming soon Rad Only Rad + El v2 pT 20-30% p0 20-30% p0 v2 pT Data Data WAH, in preparation 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

12 Comments/Conclusions
These should be addressed in general (JET) and in TECHQM report in particular Consensus on missing & important physics? Wide angle radiation, dyn vs. static sc. cent., Poisson vs. Fokker-Planck, vacuum radiation,... NB: Elastic loss not yet addressed at all Importance/uncertainties? Falsify first, then quantify Consensus that pQCD HI picture is in serious trouble? v2, IAA, NPE, ... Sim. mult. obs. description not possible, even with large unc. from wide angle radiation Future work: Include missing physics Sim. remove collinear and small mass approx? Calculate more observables in pQCD and AdS/CFT: IAA, etc. 7/27/2019 JET Collaboration Meeting at LBL

Download ppt "W. A. Horowitz The Ohio State University June 19, 2010"

Similar presentations

21/05/07 William Horowitz CERN Heavy Ion Forum 1 Possible String Theoretic Deviations from pQCD in Heavy Quark Energy Loss at LHC William Horowitz Columbia.

21/05/07 William Horowitz CERN Heavy Ion Forum 1 Possible String Theoretic Deviations from pQCD in Heavy Quark Energy Loss at LHC William Horowitz Columbia.
The EIC, Heavy Quarks, and QGP Phenomenology W. A. Horowitz University of Cape Town October 4, 2010 6/22/20151EIC at the INT With many thanks to Brian.

The EIC, Heavy Quarks, and QGP Phenomenology W. A. Horowitz University of Cape Town October 4, /22/20151EIC at the INT With many thanks to Brian.
Single & Dihadron Suppression at RHIC and LHC Xin-Nian Wang Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Last call for prediction for LHC, CERN, May 29-June 2,2007.

Single & Dihadron Suppression at RHIC and LHC Xin-Nian Wang Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Last call for prediction for LHC, CERN, May 29-June 2,2007.
1 Heavy Quark Energy Loss Tatia Engelmore Journal Club 7/21.

1 Heavy Quark Energy Loss Tatia Engelmore Journal Club 7/21.
Cold nuclear matter effects on dilepton and photon production Zhong-Bo Kang Los Alamos National Laboratory Thermal Radiation Workshop RBRC, Brookhaven.

Cold nuclear matter effects on dilepton and photon production Zhong-Bo Kang Los Alamos National Laboratory Thermal Radiation Workshop RBRC, Brookhaven.
Status of the TECHQM ‘brick problem’ Marco van Leeuwen, Utrecht University.

Status of the TECHQM ‘brick problem’ Marco van Leeuwen, Utrecht University.
M. Djordjevic 1 Heavy quark energy loss in a dynamical QCD medium Magdalena Djordjevic The Ohio State University M. Djordjevic and U. Heinz, arXiv:0705.3439.

M. Djordjevic 1 Heavy quark energy loss in a dynamical QCD medium Magdalena Djordjevic The Ohio State University M. Djordjevic and U. Heinz, arXiv:
Marco van Leeuwen, Marta Verweij, Utrecht University Energy loss in a realistic geometry.

Marco van Leeuwen, Marta Verweij, Utrecht University Energy loss in a realistic geometry.
Identified Particle Ratios at large p T in Au+Au collisions at  s NN = 200 GeV Matthew A. C. Lamont for the STAR Collaboration - Talk Outline - Physics.

Identified Particle Ratios at large p T in Au+Au collisions at  s NN = 200 GeV Matthew A. C. Lamont for the STAR Collaboration - Talk Outline - Physics.
7/7/09 William Horowitz WHDG Brick and Comparing WHDG to ASW-SH William Horowitz The Ohio State University July 7, 2009 With many thanks to Brian Cole,

7/7/09 William Horowitz WHDG Brick and Comparing WHDG to ASW-SH William Horowitz The Ohio State University July 7, 2009 With many thanks to Brian Cole,
11/15/06 William Horowitz 1 LHC Predictions 1 from an extended theory 2 with Elastic, Inelastic, and Path Length Fluctuating Jet Energy Loss William Horowitz.

11/15/06 William Horowitz 1 LHC Predictions 1 from an extended theory 2 with Elastic, Inelastic, and Path Length Fluctuating Jet Energy Loss William Horowitz.
6/6/06William Horowitz Hard Probes 2006 1 Overcoming Fragility William Horowitz Columbia University June 14, 2006 With many thanks to Simon Wicks, Azfar.

6/6/06William Horowitz Hard Probes Overcoming Fragility William Horowitz Columbia University June 14, 2006 With many thanks to Simon Wicks, Azfar.
6/6/06William Horowitz RHIC & AGS Annual Users’ Meeting ‘06 1 Heavy Quark Energy Loss William Horowitz Columbia University June 6, 2006 With many thanks.

6/6/06William Horowitz RHIC & AGS Annual Users’ Meeting ‘06 1 Heavy Quark Energy Loss William Horowitz Columbia University June 6, 2006 With many thanks.
11/1/06William Horowitz 1 Jet Quenching at RHIC and the LHC William Horowitz Columbia University November 1, 2006 With many thanks to Simon Wicks, Azfar.

11/1/06William Horowitz 1 Jet Quenching at RHIC and the LHC William Horowitz Columbia University November 1, 2006 With many thanks to Simon Wicks, Azfar.
Jet energy loss at RHIC and LHC including collisional and radiative and geometric fluctuations Simon Wicks, QM2006 Work done with Miklos Gyulassy, William.

Jet energy loss at RHIC and LHC including collisional and radiative and geometric fluctuations Simon Wicks, QM2006 Work done with Miklos Gyulassy, William.
Comparing energy loss models Marco van Leeuwen Utrecht University What have we learned from the TECHQM brick problem? With many contributions from TEHCQM.

Comparing energy loss models Marco van Leeuwen Utrecht University What have we learned from the TECHQM brick problem? With many contributions from TEHCQM.
M. Djordjevic 1 Theoretical predictions of jet suppression: a systematic comparison with RHIC and LHC data Magdalena Djordjevic Institute of Physics Belgrade,

M. Djordjevic 1 Theoretical predictions of jet suppression: a systematic comparison with RHIC and LHC data Magdalena Djordjevic Institute of Physics Belgrade,
11/02/07 William Horowitz Heavy Quark Workshop, LBNL 1 Falsifying AdS/CFT Drag or pQCD Heavy Quark Energy Loss with A+A at RHIC and LHC William Horowitz.

11/02/07 William Horowitz Heavy Quark Workshop, LBNL 1 Falsifying AdS/CFT Drag or pQCD Heavy Quark Energy Loss with A+A at RHIC and LHC William Horowitz.
Simon Wicks Columbia University Work done with William Horowitz, Magdalena Djordjevic and Miklos Gyulassy with input from Azfar Adil BNL Heavy Flavor Workshop,

Simon Wicks Columbia University Work done with William Horowitz, Magdalena Djordjevic and Miklos Gyulassy with input from Azfar Adil BNL Heavy Flavor Workshop,
Heavy Quark Energy Loss with Twist Expansion Approach Ben-Wei Zhang Institute of Particle Physics Central China Normal Univeristy CCAST, Beijing --- Augest.

Heavy Quark Energy Loss with Twist Expansion Approach Ben-Wei Zhang Institute of Particle Physics Central China Normal Univeristy CCAST, Beijing --- Augest.

Similar presentations

Ads by Google