1. CAPACITY AND LEGALITY CHAPTER 12
© 2010 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Prentice-Hall

2. Capacity
Law presumes that parties have contractual capacity to enter into the contract.
Certain persons do not have this capacity:
Minors
Insane persons
Intoxicated persons

3. Capacity (continued)
Common law and many state statutes protect persons who lack contractual capacity from having contracts forced on them.
Person asserting incapacity bears burden of proof.

4. Minors Common law defines minors as: Females under the age of 18; and
Many states have enacted statutes that specify the age of majority.
Generally 18 years of age for both males and females.

5. Parents’ Liability for Their Children’s Contracts
The Infancy Doctrine
Ratification
KEY ISSUES RELATING
TO MINORS AND
CONTRACTS
Parents’ Liability for Their Children’s Contracts
Necessaries of Life

6. Infancy Doctrine
Minors may disaffirm (cancel) most contracts they have entered into with adults.
Contract is voidable by minor.
Minor has choice to enforce or disaffirm contract.
Public policy of protecting minors from unscrupulous adults.

7. Infancy Doctrine (continued)
Disaffirmance – minor’s act of rescinding a contract under infancy doctrine.
May be done orally, in writing, or by conduct.
Must be done within reasonable time of reaching age of majority.

8. Infancy Doctrine (continued)
Parties’ Duties upon Disaffirmance
Minor must only return the goods or property received from the adult, in the condition it is in at the time of disaffirmance.
Adult has duty of restitution – If minor has transferred consideration before disaffirming the contract, adult must place minor in status quo.

9. Infancy Doctrine (continued)
Minor’s Duty of Restitution – Most states provide that the minor must place adult in status quo upon disaffirmance:
If minor’s intentional or grossly negligent conduct caused the loss of value to the adult’s property.
If minor misrepresented his or her age.

10. Ratification
If minor does not disaffirm during period of minority or within a reasonable time after reaching the age of majority:
Contract is ratified (accepted).
Minor (now an adult) is bound by contract.
Right to disaffirm is lost.

11. Parent’s Liability for Children’s Contracts
Parents owe a legal duty to provide food, clothing, shelter, and other necessaries of life for their minor children.
Parents liable for their children’s contracts for necessaries if they have not adequately provided such items.
Parental duty of support terminates if a minor becomes emancipated.

12. Minor’s Liability for Necessaries
Minors are obligated to pay for the necessaries of life.
Food, shelter, clothing, medical services
Based on quasi-contract.
Minor must pay only reasonable value of the goods or services.

13. Minors Cannot Disaffirm Certain Contracts
By state statutes
Typically:
Medical care
Health and life insurance
Educational loan agreements
Contracts to support children
Contracts to enlist in military
Certain sports and entertainment contracts

14. Mentally Incompetent Persons
Law protects people suffering from substantial mental incapacity from enforcement of contracts.
To be relieved of duties under a contract, law requires a person to have been legally insane at the time of entering contract.

15. Mentally Incompetent Persons (continued)
Legal Insanity – a state of contractual incapacity as determined by law.
Two standards concerning contracts of mentally incompetent persons:
Adjudged Insane
Insane, But Not Adjudged Insane

16. Mentally Incompetent Persons (continued)
Adjudged Insane
A person who has been adjudged insane by a proper court or administrative agency.
A contract entered into by such a person is void.
Neither party can enforce the contract.

17. Mentally Incompetent Persons (continued)
Insane, But Not Adjudged Insane
A person who is insane but has not been adjudged insane by a court or administrative agency.
A contract entered into by such a person is generally voidable.
The competent party cannot void the contract.

18. Intoxicated Person
A person who is so intoxicated that he or she cannot understand nature of transaction may disaffim.
Contract is voidable by intoxicated party.
Contract is not voidable by the other party if that party had contractual capacity.
Intoxicated party must return other party to status quo.

19. Illegality
Contracts with an illegal object are void and therefore unenforceable.
Two categories of illegality:
Contracts contrary to statutes
Contracts contrary to public policy

20. Contracts Contrary to Statutes
Federal and state statutes prohibit certain types of conduct.
Contracts to perform an activity that is prohibited by statute are void.
Usury Laws
Contracts to commit crime
Gambling Statutes
Licensing Statutes
Regulatory Statute
Revenue-Raising Statute

21. Contracts Contrary to Public Policy
Contracts that have a negative impact on society or that interfere with the public’s safety and welfare.
Such contracts are void.
Immoral Contracts
Contracts in Restraint of Trade
Exculpatory Clauses

22. Effect of Illegality Parties cannot sue for nonperformance.
Court will generally refuse to enforce or rescind an illegal contract.
Court will generally leave the parties where it finds them.

23. Exceptions to the General Rule
Court may assist:
Innocent persons justifiably ignorant of the law or fact that made the contract illegal.
E.g., person who bought insurance from unlicensed company.
Persons induced to enter into an illegal contract by fraud, duress, or undue influence.

24. Exceptions to the General Rule (continued)
Court may assist:
Persons who withdraw before the illegal act performed.
E.g., person who hires another to steal trade secret, but then tells person not to do it.
Persons less at fault than the other party for entering into the illegal contract.

25. Exculpatory Clauses
Contractual provision relieving a party from tort liability for ordinary negligence.
May be found in leases, sales contracts, service contracts, etc.
If in contract that affects public interest, involves essential service, or if protected party has superior bargaining power, clause is likely void.

26. Covenants Not to Compete
Lawful if ancillary to sale of a business or employment contract and if reasonable in three aspects:
The line of business protected.
Geographical area.
Duration of the restriction.

27. Unconscionability
Court may not enforce a contract that is so oppressive or manifestly unfair that it is unjust.
Called unconscionable contract, or contract of adhesion.
E.g., contract for loan with interest rate of 608%.

28. Unconscionability (continued)
Elements of unconscionable contract:
The parties possessed severely unequal bargaining power.
Dominant party unreasonably used its unequal bargaining power.
Adhering party had no reasonable alternative.