1. Human Rights
Classroom Resource

2. Lesson Objectives Human Rights Understand the nature of human rights.
Become familiar with the Human Rights Act 1998 and the rights contained within it.
Consider cases where there are competing human rights. 2
© Young Citizens

3. What are Human Rights? Human Rights 3
We are going to look in more detail at the different types of rights that people could or should have…
What rights should all people be entitled to?
Why are rights important? 3
© Young Citizens

4. Human Rights
Consider the following statements and place them into three categories: In every case , in most cases, in some cases.
A: Killing is wrong
B: Torture is wrong
C: It is wrong to keep someone as a slave
D: After a certain age people should be able to marry anyone they wish
E: People should be allowed to stop other people writing and saying what they wish
F: People should be allowed to travel within and leave their country if they wish
G: Private communications should not be intercepted
H: People should be allowed to criticise the government
I: People should be allowed to talk to and meet anyone they wish 4
© Young Citizens

5. Human Rights
Consider the following statements and place them into three categories: In every case , in most cases, in some cases.
J: A person accused of a crime should be tried by someone who has nothing to do with
the case
K: People should be allowed to have, or not have, whatever religious belief they wish
L: Everyone has the right to an education
M: Everyone over a certain age should have the right to vote
N: All people should be treated equally regardless of gender, sexuality, ethnicity or
religion
O: People should not be punished for something that wasn’t a crime when it was
committed 5
© Young Citizens

6. Human Rights Act 1998 Human Rights Why was it created? 6
Soon, the European Convention on Human Rights was drafted. Britain was one of the first countries to sign up, but the rights the Convention provides were not built into UK law until the creation of the Human Rights Act (HRA) 1998, which came into force in 2000.
Our human rights, as laid out in the Human Rights Act, can only be enforced against public bodies. Individuals cannot enforce their rights against other individuals.
Under the HRA, claimants can enforce their rights directly before UK courts instead of having to take their case to the European Court of Human Rights (based in Strasbourg). 6
© Young Citizens

7. Human Rights Act 1998 Human Rights What does it include? 7
Read through the list of rights included in the HRA on the handout.
Remember the difference between absolute and qualified rights.
Absolute
These rights can never be restricted.
These rights can be restricted in certain circumstances.
Qualified
You will now look at some scenarios. You will need to decide which right applies in each case. 7
© Young Citizens

8. Scenario A Human Rights 8
A baby is born with a very serious illness and is not expected to survive.
Doctors recommend that she be allowed to die, but the parents disagree and believe that as much as possible should be done to keep the little girl alive.
The parents challenge the doctors’ decision in court. 8
© Young Citizens

9. Scenario B Human Rights
A water company plans to build a sewage works 50 metres from a row of houses. 9
© Young Citizens

10. Scenario C Human Rights 10
An announcement is made that a hospital is due to close.
Many local people and hospital staff are against this. Staff are invited to a residents’ meeting to discuss the closure but are forbidden from doing so by senior staff who threaten to dismiss anyone who speaks in public about the closure. 10
© Young Citizens

11. Scenario D Human Rights 11 A man is charged with armed robbery.
At his trial, statements against him from two anonymous witnesses are read out in court.
The trial continues and there is no chance for the man to question these witnesses or challenge their evidence. 11
© Young Citizens

12. Scenario E Human Rights 12
The police arrest two men who they believe can give them valuable information about a recent terrorist attack.
Although the police do not think the men directly had anything to do with the attack, they hold the two men for questioning for 44 hours.
Everyone has the right to liberty (Article 5). 12
© Young Citizens

13. Scenario F Human Rights 13
A woman, who has no religious belief of any kind, teaches maths at a Roman Catholic school.
She applies for a promotion to become Head of Year, but is immediately turned down because she is not a Roman Catholic. 13
© Young Citizens

14. Competing Rights Human Rights
The last activity tried to identify the human rights that might apply in certain scenarios.
We are now going to look at situations where there is more than one human right involved, where different people’s human rights may conflict with each other. 14
© Young Citizens

15. Competing Rights Case One - Kelly’s Holiday Human Rights 15
Kelly, a popular, married celebrity, is on holiday in Greece with her secret boyfriend Paul. She has been having an affair with Paul for over a year and this is unknown to her soap-star husband, Ben. Kelly and Paul arrive back in London to see photos of their holiday all over the papers, including topless photos taken on her private beach. The story details the affair they have been having.
What rights are involved here? Who has which right?
Can this invasion of privacy be justified on the grounds of free speech?
Would it make a difference if Kelly wasn’t a celebrity? 15
© Young Citizens

16. Competing Rights Case Two - Civil Partnership Human Rights 16
A same-sex couple would like to have a civil partnership at their local town hall. The local registrar refuses to perform the ceremony as she feels that it would go against her religious beliefs.
What rights are involved here? Who has which right?
What potential solutions are there?
What would happen if no local registrars were willing to perform the ceremony? 16
© Young Citizens

17. Competing Rights Case Three - Refusing Treatment Human Rights 17
A baby is severely ill and in need of a blood transfusion. The parents belong to a religion which does not allow blood transfusions or medical intervention. The baby is too young to speak. The parents are adamant that the baby should not be treated, but the doctors are desperate to save the babies life.
What rights are involved here? Who has which right?
Should the law ever interfere with people’s family life?
What do you think should happen in this case?
Would your answer change if the child was older and able to talk?
At what age do you think someone can make the decision not to be treated? 17
© Young Citizens

18. Competing Rights Case Four – Disruptive Student Human Rights 18
A 16-year old is excluded several times from a school for disruptive behaviour. Another incident takes place two months before she and others are due to take their GCSEs. The parents of some of the other students call for the girl to be permanently excluded.
What rights are involved here? Who has which right?
Should the girl lose her right to education because she is interfering with someone else’s?
How might the situation be resolved without anyone losing their right to an education? 18
© Young Citizens

19. Plenary Human Rights 19 Q: Which three rights are ‘absolute’?
Q: What surprised you the most from today’s discussion?
Q: Is there anything we discussed today that you strongly
disagree with?
Q: Do you think there are any fundamental human rights that are
not covered by the Human Rights Act? Is so, what are they? 19
© Young Citizens

20. Human Rights
The motion:
Charlie Gard’s parents should be able to choose whether they want to keep their son alive. 20
© Young Citizens