1. Adrian P Stephens Chair, FRCC adrian.p.stephens@intel.com
May 2004
TGn Functional Requirements and Comparison Criteria Special Committee (FRCC) May 2004 Report
Adrian P Stephens
Chair, FRCC
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

2. May 2004
Glossary
FRCC – Functional Requirements and Comparison Criteria special committee
FR – Functional Requirements
CC – Comparison Criteria
UM – Usage Model and Simulation Scenario document
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

3. May 2004
Charter of the FRCC
To produce FR and CC documents and have them approved by TGn
To maintain and complete the UM document and have it approved by TGn
Special Committee - Charter expires on completion of task
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

4. Status at end of last session
May 2004
Status at end of last session
r14 UM
r12 FR
r22 CC
r3 Comment Resolution Spreadsheet
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

5. Status at start of this session
May 2004
Status at start of this session
r19 UM
was r14
r19 only contains tracking changes from r18
r12 FR
unchanged
r26 CC
was r22
r26 only contains tracking changes from r25
r10 Comment Resolution Spreadsheet
was r3
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

6. Comment status at the end of the last session
May 2004
Comment status at the end of the last session
Status CC FR UM
Grand Total
Closed 79 11 18
108
Open 46
Withdrawn 4 1 5
Respectfully declined 10
Duplicate 3 96 12 64
172
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

7. Comment status at the start of this session
May 2004
Comment status at the start of this session
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

8. Goals of FRCC for this session
May 2004
Goals of FRCC for this session
To approve the CC and UM documents
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

9. FRCC Agenda ** Report by FRCC Chair ** = TGn agenda
May 2004
FRCC Agenda
** Report by FRCC Chair ** = TGn agenda
** Review FR, CC, UM documents
Highlight changes since last session
Q & A taken during review
Approve FRCC Agenda
Consider & Resolve CC comments
Consider & Resolve UM comments
(MI) Additional discussion on CC
(MI) Additional discussion on UM
Review changes to CC
Review changes to UM
Delay to allow for personal review prior to vote
10:30 Tuesday morning:
(Vote on Channel Model)
Vote on CC
Vote on UM
(FRCC dissolves at this point)
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

10. Documents to vote on Tuesday
May 2004
Documents to vote on Tuesday
r29 CC
r22 UM
r4 Channel Models
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

11. May 2004
Motion 1
Move to adopt document r29 as the Comparison Criteria document for TGn
Mover: Adrian Stephens, Chair FRCC
Seconder:
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation

12. May 2004
Motion 2
Move to adopt document r22 as the Usage Model document for TGn
Mover: Adrian Stephens, Chair FRCC
Seconder:
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation