Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

PRUDENT INVESTOR RULE ETHICS

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "PRUDENT INVESTOR RULE ETHICS"— Presentation transcript:

1 PRUDENT INVESTOR RULE ETHICS
8 FIDUCIARY QUESTIONS TO ASK YOUR FINANCIAL ADVISOR NATIONAL COLLEGE OF PROBATE JUDGES SPRING CONFERENCE May 2 – 5, 2018 Darryl J. Lynch, AIF ® Executive Director – Investments th Avenue NE, Suite 2100 Bellevue, WA // P: (425) Peter C. Palumbo, AIF ® Director - Investments One North Brentwood Blvd. Suite 600 St. Louis, MO // P: (314)

2 Working with Your Financial Advisor
History and Overview of the Prudent Person vs. Investor Rule Ways to Apply the Principles of the Uniform Prudent Investor Act to Guardians, Conservators and Estates Fiduciary Responsibilities vs. Liabilities: Eight questions to drive the conversation with your Financial Advisor Ethical objective decision making vs. subjective opinions Establishing and monitoring guardian investment accounts Blocking or Restricting Accounts to Reducing Bonding Costs 2

3 Uniform Prudent Investors Act of 1994
43 States have adopted the Uniform Prudent Investor Act of 1994 3 Source: uniformlaws.org

4 Source: National Guardianship Association
NATIONAL GUARDIANSHIP ASSOCIATION DEFINES FIDUCIARY AS… “Any person that has the responsibility to invest and manage the assets of another person is a fiduciary.” Source: National Guardianship Association This is not a legal definition nor an indication of the statue of Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. or any of its associates. This is provided for informational and education purposes only. 4

5 ORIGINS OF LEGAL LISTS Originated in the early 18th century
Started in the early 18th century British Government formed “legal lists” due to an investment scheme that altered the development of trust law.*90 Only investments on “legal list” allowed for fiduciary's. Government Debt and well-secured mortgage loans. “Legal List” were too constraining. Focused on preservation of capital at expense of income and growth.*94 Jurisdictions began adopting “Prudent Man – later Prudent Person – Rule” for more flexibility Harvard College v. Amory: “Such care and skill as a person of ordinary prudence would exercise in dealing with his own property,”*97 Negative to Prudent Person Rule was that it focused on individual investments without consideration of the broader investment strategy or portfolio and it stressed preservation of capital Originated in the early 18th century British Government Formed Legal Lists Government Debt and well-secured mortgage loans Source: Theories of Law 5

6 PROBLEMS WITH LEGAL LISTS
“Legal List” focused on preservation of capital which could be at the expense of income and growth. They were too constraining because they didn’t take into account other factors “Legal List” focused on preservation of capital at expense of income and growth.*94 They were too constraining : Government debt, Inflation, Term, excluded common stocks Investment Portfolio 6

7 Source: Harvard College v. Amory, 1830
PRUDENT MAN RULE “Such care and skill as a person of ordinary prudence would exercise in dealing with his own property.” Prudent Man Principle was founded on the idea that “….” So this is the idea that you would care and look over someone else’s to the same level of detail as you would your own. Source: Harvard College v. Amory, 1830 7

8 LIMITATIONS OF PRUDENT MAN (LATER PRUDENT PERSON) RULE
Focused on individual investments without consideration of the broader investment strategy or portfolio Allowed for hindsight evaluation of investment choices Diversification is not a requirement Stressed the preservation of capital without taking risk into account A major change was coming 8

9 DISTINCTION OF THE PRUDENT INVESTOR RULE
Total Portfolio Evaluation Risk Process Diversification Monitoring Delegation Documentation Modern Portfolio Theory Source: Uniform Prudent Investor Act of 1992 “The prudent investor rule is a test of conduct and not of resulting performance.” (760 ILCS 5/5) (from Ch. 17, par. 1675) 9

10 THE START OF THE PRUDENT INVESTOR RULE
Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) Cash CD’s Bonds Large Cap Stocks Emerging Markets RISK RETURN MPT is a discipline which seeks to maximize return and minimize risk by diversifying among different asset classes MPT Middle of the 20th century Consider risk and the compensation received for taking the risk But in doing so consider investments as a whole and not individually Asset Allocations come into effect when analyzing a portfolio investment* 104 Ex: CD’s vs Small Caps Diversification does not guarantee a profit or protect against a loss. 10

11 THE PRUDENT INVESTOR RULE
The Prudent Investor Rule of today is about a few key principles. Assessing Risk – Determining suitability and risk for each client on a case by case basis. Proper diversification among different assets Proper Diversification* TX Sec VA Sec NJ Sec 3B: Delegation of Investment Responsibilities CO Sec PA Sec. 7206 OH Sec Assessing Risk CO Sec TX Sec OH Sec * Diversification does not guarantee a profit or protect against a loss 11

12 THE PRUDENT INVESTOR RULE…continued
Documentation of the process is critical – Ongoing monitoring, don’t see and leave Minimizing investment costs Relying on qualified professionals, like CPA’s and Attorneys to help in the process Minimize Investment Costs NJ Sec. 3B: CO Sec CA Relying on Qualified Professionals Documentation Monitoring WA 409.8 NJ 3B: UT 12

13 Ethical Decision Making
Responsibility vs. Liability Fiduciary responsibilities can be shared but not abdicated. Fiduciary liability exposures exist where there are unfulfilled responsibilities. Fiduciaries can reduce liability by identifying and filling gaps in their practices. 13

14 Fiduciary Code of Ethics
Employ and provide the client information on the Prudent Practices when serving as an investment fiduciary. Act with honesty and integrity and avoid conflicts of interest, real or perceived. Ensure the timely and understandable disclosure of relevant information that is accurate, complete and objective. Be responsible when determining the value of services and form of compensation. 14

15 Fiduciary Code of Ethics…continued
Know your limits of expertise. Refer clients to colleagues and/or other professionals in connection with issues that go beyond your scope of knowledge and skill set. Respect the confidentiality of information acquired in the course of work, and not disclose such information to others, except when authorized or otherwise legally obligated to do so. Do not use confidential information acquired in the course of work for personal advantage. Not exploit any relationship or responsibility that has been entrusted. 15

16 As Guardian you are always responsible for the following:
Confirm investment goals and objectives Approve appropriate asset allocation strategy Establish or approve an explicit, written IPS/Investment Proposal Prudently select service providers Incur only reasonable expenses Monitor the activities of the overall investment program, including service providers Avoid conflicts of interest Documentation 16

17 Eight Questions to ask your Financial Advisor
Will the Advisor act as a fiduciary in all scenarios when managing portfolio assets? How long has the Financial Advisor been acting in this fiduciary capacity? Describe your experience acting as a fiduciary advisor. What fiduciary training has the Financial Advisor received? Any designations focused on fiduciary best practices? 17

18 Questions to Ask…continued
Provide at least three references of clients who are using your services in your capacity as a fiduciary advisor. Please disclose and describe any potential conflicts of interest. What safeguards and procedures do you have in place for blocked or restricted accounts? Describe your total compensation or fees received for your proposed services. What services do you provide to help fiduciaries meet their obligations? 18

19 Questions to Ask & Ethical Decision Making…continued
Creating and maintaining a comprehensive plan, strategy or policy statement / Investment proposal that documents the processes and procedures that will be used to manage the portfolio. IPS/Investment Proposal should have: Sufficient detail for a competent third party to implement; Not so detailed to require constant revisions and updates. 19

20 Questions to Ask & Ethical Decision Making…continued
Applying objective standards vs. subjective opinions for evaluation and recommending appropriate investment options. Monitoring and reporting portfolio performance. Understanding their important fiduciary roles, responsibilities and obligations. 20

21 How to Apply the Prudent Investor Rule for Guardians, Conservators and Trustees
Evaluation of Client’s Needs Investment Proposal for Court Approval & Investment Policy Statement Standardized Financial Decision-Making Process Industry Standard Evaluation of Investment Portfolio FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT PACKAGE Simple Fee Model Documentation of all Reviews and Ongoing Monitoring Cost-Effective Investment Management * Including Special Needs Trusts Proper Diversification and Periodic Rebalancing of Assets 21 Diversification does not guarantee a profit nor protect against a loss.

22 The Hierarchy of Decisions
Most Important Time Horizon-Investment Strategy Appropriate level of risk/return Asset Classes Considered Mix among Asset Classes Sub-Asset Classes Time Horizon-Investment Strategy Managers/Funds Least Important 22

23 Evaluate the Clients Needs
Time Horizon Age & Health Evaluation Total Investable Assets Income Sources Annual Expenses What is the short fall, if any? Anticipated large withdrawals? i.e. education Additional income from other sources? Limitations or restrictions on Investments? 23

24 Investment Policy Statement/Investment Proposal
Should Include… Statement of Fiduciary Relationship Purpose of the Investment Policy Statement / Proposal Rules and responsibilities of parties Involved i.e. Oversight monitoring: performance, advisor, allocation, conflict of interest, documentation, and manager selection Financial Advisor responsibilities Investment objectives 24

25 Investment Policy Statement/Investment Proposal…cont.
Investment Allocation Model Capital Preservation, Income, Balanced Income, Balanced Growth & Growth Investment Time Horizon Investment Selecting & Future Considerations Rebalancing Frequency Annual Costs Court Blocking or Restriction Requirements Adoption Agreements to be signed by Guardian & Financial Advisor 25

26 Investment Models MODEL FACTS: Low Cost Index Funds
Capital Preservation Income MODEL FACTS: Low Cost Index Funds No Load Actively Managed Mutual Funds Proper Diversification Among Asset Classes Optimize Number of Securities to Minimize Accounting Costs Most Clients Fall Within A Few Models 30% 100% 70% Balanced Income Balanced Growth 40% 50% 50% 60% Growth 25% 75% Fixed Income Equity The above allocation examples are for illustrative use only and are not intended as investment advice. Please consult with your Oppenheimer Financial Advisor with any specific questions you may have regarding your own situation. The suggestions here may help you choose an investment program appropriate for you. Keep in mind, though, these are only suggestions made for long-term, total-return-oriented investors without considering tax consequences. The use of an asset allocation suggestion does not guarantee a profit or protect against a loss in declining markets. You should discuss your individual situation with your investment professional to find the right balance between risk and potential reward. For more complete information about any of the funds that may be used including investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses, please obtain a prospectus and read it carefully before investing. 26

27 Sample Special Needs Trust
Investment Proposal Summary Sample Special Needs Trust Account Name Special Needs Trust Total Investable Assets $500,000 Type of Account Trust Monthly Withdrawal N/A Time Horizon 2 - 5 years Risk Tolerance Conservative - Moderate Allocation Model Income Benchmark Model 70% Barclays Aggregate Bond Index / 30% S&P Rebalancing Frequency Semi-Annual Blocked / Restrictions n/a Performance Reporting Quarterly in Person Reviews The cost benefits of a transfer to the Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. Guardianship and Trust program are:    Oppenheimer’s Annual Management Fee is 0.90% Provide opportunities for increased income for the client through proper asset allocation Oppenheimer will hold in the portfolio approximately 9 – 12 securities, thus reducing the annual accounting costs Maintain proper diversification & regular rebalancing Provide standardized performance reports quarterly Provide ongoing monitoring & risk evaluation to keep in compliance with the Uniform Prudent Investor Act (UPIA) 27 This proposal is for illustration purposes only and is not a representative of the performance of any specific investment, and there is no guarantee that the hypothetical rate of return can be achieved.

28 Investment Proposal Summary … continued
SHORT FIXED INCOME/CASH EQUIVALENT 20%  $100,000 HIGH YIELD FIXED INCOME 15%  $75,000 INTERMEDIATE FIXED INCOME 25%  $125,000 LONG-TERM FIXED INCOME 10%  $50,000 LARGE CAP VALUE LARGE CAP GROWTH 9%  $45,000 SMALL/MID CAP 6%  $30,000 INTERNATIONAL/GLOBAL EQUITIES 5% $25,000  SPECIALTY 0% TOTAL PORTFOLIO 100% $500,000 28 This proposal is for illustration purposes only and is not a representative of the performance of any specific investment, and there is no guarantee that the hypothetical rate of return can be achieved.

29 Establishing a New Account
Account Title Guardianship or Trust Total Investable Assets Age of Client Guardian Information Letters of Guardianship Allocation Model Beneficiary, Settlor & Trustee Information Source of Funds Bank Information Risk Tolerance Objectives Blocking Receipt Online Access *Note: Guardian must notify Advisor of an existing client’s death and provide a Death Certificate in a timely manner. 29

30 Cost of Managing an Investment Portfolio
Stock-picking and market-timing can be dangerous and counterproductive. Independent financial advisors (especially flat-fee or fee-for- service advisors) are valuable to the fiduciary (1% or less). Mutual funds are often an easy way to satisfy multiple fiduciary obligations, including diversification, lower management cost and built-in management. Index funds are more efficient to fiduciaries. Investment costs need to be considered. What is the importance of class shares of Mutual Funds in a portfolio and their internal costs. Actively managed funds charge higher administrative fees. 30

31 Cost and Fee Structure…continued
Do not forget to consider the tax effect. Generally speaking, mutual funds will have less capital gains tax consequences than actively managed accounts. Index funds will usually have less tax consequences then actively managed funds. But dwarfing all of that, will be the income tax effect of liquidation of all assets transferred to a fiduciary in order to permit the fiduciary to reinvest according to his, her or its investment strategy. Optimize number of securities to minimize actual costs. 31

32 Source: National Guardianship Association
Final Points “Delegation. For a fiduciary without substantial investment expertise, it is both a good plan and protective against liability, to select an investment advisor” Source: National Guardianship Association “The prudent investor rule is a test of conduct and not of resulting performance.” (760 ILCS 5/5) (from Ch. 17, para. 1675) 32

33 Final Points “The Prudent Investor Rule” (the Rule) is intended to give fiduciaries guidance on how to invest assets under their control and management. Fiduciaries… may use the Rule as a defense if challenged by the ward, families, courts and others. Wards… may use the Rule to protect from guardian mismanagement. 33 Source: National Guardianship Association

34 IMPORTANT INFORMATION
This Presentation is intended for informational purposes only and is subject to change without notice. For further information about the products/programs available and their suitability for your portfolio, please contact your Oppenheimer Financial Advisor. Any discussion of securities, should not be construed as a recommendation or an offer or solicitation to buy or sell interest in any securities. Securities products offered or sold by Oppenheimer will not be endorsed or guaranteed by Oppenheimer and will be subject to investment risks, including the possible loss of principal invested. Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. does not provide legal or tax advice. © 2018 Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. Transacts Business on All Principal Exchanges and Member SIPC. All rights reserved. No part of this presentation may be reproduced in any manner without written permission of Oppenheimer. 34


Download ppt "PRUDENT INVESTOR RULE ETHICS"

Similar presentations


Ads by Google