1. Research performance in undergraduates receiving face to face versus online library instruction: A Citation Analysis Sarah Clark and Susan Chinburg Rogers State University Claremore, OK Fourteenth Off-Campus Library Services Conference, April 29, 2010

2. Academic Libraries & the rise of Online Education

3. Evolution of the Embedded Librarian: In the Literature Laying the groundwork Coining a phrase Case Studies of embedding Best Practices

4. Evolution of the Embedded Librarian: Rogers State University

5. Beyond the Launch: Quantitative Embedded Librarian Assessment

6. Citation Analysis in face-to-face instruction assessment Hovde Davis Robinson and Shlegl

7. Methodology Population Teaching methods Face-to-face Online Assignment requirements Data analysis Citations vs. Sources cited Citation Categories A: Textbooks, scholarly/technical books, and dictionaries B: Peer-reviewed journals, dissertations, and conference proceedings C: Publications/websites from educational orgs. D: Trade, technical, and industry publications/websites E: Corporate websites, ads, and whitepapers F: Non-scholarly, non industry specific publications (including general business publications, encyclopedias and websites not belonging to any other defined group) G: Primary sources and Personal communications, blogs, and social networking sites H: Government publications

8. Results: Per Citation

9. Results: Per source

10. Conclusions No statistically significant differences in citation patterns Citation behavior suggests embedded librarian program meets ACRL Standards Methodology can be useful for assessing Face-to-Face vs. online instruction, and is easily implemented by faculty and librarians

11. Limitations and Special Considerations Small Sample Size, only two semesters Unique citation patterns in MIS course (Current trade journals > peer-reviewed sources in business & technology) Narrow Research Question Does NOT explore instruction quality, simply whether students cite similar sources after receiving online vs. face-to- face library instruction

12. Further Study Expand Scope Timespan Additional courses Additional Institutions Expand Variables Currency of sources cited Average Bibliography size

13. Thank You! Sarah Clark, MLIS Access Services and Distance Learning Librarian Rogers State University Claremore, OK 918-343-7719 sclark@rsu.edu Twitter: @oklibrarian Susan Chinburg, Ph.D Assistant Professor School of Business and Technology Rogers State University Claremore, OK 918-343-7727 schinburg@rsu.edu