Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Allusions of Healing?: Poetry and bioethics Dr Trevor Stammers Programme Director in Bioethics and Medical Law St Mary’s University, London, UK.

Similar presentations


Presentation on theme: "Allusions of Healing?: Poetry and bioethics Dr Trevor Stammers Programme Director in Bioethics and Medical Law St Mary’s University, London, UK."— Presentation transcript:

1 Allusions of Healing?: Poetry and bioethics Dr Trevor Stammers Programme Director in Bioethics and Medical Law St Mary’s University, London, UK

2 Memorable verse “I wandered lonely as a cloud……”
“Water, water, everywhere, nor any drop to drink” “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?” “O, wad some Power the giftie gie us To see oursels as others see us!” “The Owl and the Pussy-cat went to sea In a beautiful pea green boat.”

3

4 Poet Physicians John Keats William Carlos Williams
Oliver Wendell Holmes Dannie Abse Rafael Campo 1986 White Coat Purple Coat

5 "Poetry contest reminds trainee medics that patients are people, not machines."  THE in reporting the competition

6

7 IVF by Kona MacPhee “I come home early, feel the pale house close around me as the pressure of my blood knocks at my temples, feel it clench me in its cramping grasp, the fierceness of its quiet sanctioning the small and listless hope that I might find it mercifully empty. Robert Frost “The ear is the reader”

8 IVF by Kona MacPhee Dazed, I turn the taps to fill the empty
tub, and draw the bathroom door to close behind me. I lie unmoving, feel all hope leaching from between my legs as blood tinges the water, staining it the quiet shade of a winter evening drifting in on sunset. Again no shoot of life sprouts in this crumbling womb that wrings itself to empty out the painfully planted seeds. The quiet …..

9 IVF by Kona MacPhee …………………………we go on living in the shadow of the cliffs now looming close: the blood that’s thick with traitorous clots of hope; the quiet knack we’ve lost, of giving in; the empty room whose door we cannot close.”

10 Advantages of Poetry Emotional intensity
Succinct, portable formulations Communication of encompassing ‘existential’ truths Diagnosis and picking up on subtle verbal cues Memorable and lasting effects on professional life Can bring healing to the wounded healer DR Caroline Welberry Assoc Prof of Family Medicine Georgetown

11 Disadvantages of Poetry
Prejudice Can induce unexpected and unpleasant emotion Lack of familiarity with medium and its methodology Negotiation of multiple complex meanings Different mind-set from that of scientific, logical inquiry Lack of systematic and extensive resource base Loss of meaning in translation “Poetry is of no use” Literature Medicine and Arts database POEMS

12 Analysing Poetry Metonymy and synecdoche
Iambic pentameter and alexandrine Trochee and dactyl Tenor and vehicle Explicit and implicit metaphors

13 Lithium by Robin Robertson
After the arc of ECT and the blunt concussion of pills, they gave him lithium to cling to- the psychiatrist's stone. A metal that floats on water, must be kept in kerosene, can be drawn into a wire. (He who had jumped into the harbour, burnt his hair off, been caught hanging from the light) He'd heard it was once used to make hydrogen bombs, but now was a coolant for nuclear reactors, so he broke out of hospital barefoot and walked ten miles to meet me in the snow.

14 References NYU Medical School Literature, Arts and Medicine Database Oliver, M Understanding Poetry San Diego: Harcourt Brace Reid, C A Scattering Oxford: Arete Books Stammers, T Poems in practice BJGP Wellbery, C On the use of poetry in medical education Journal for Learning through the Arts 2


Download ppt "Allusions of Healing?: Poetry and bioethics Dr Trevor Stammers Programme Director in Bioethics and Medical Law St Mary’s University, London, UK."

Similar presentations


Ads by Google