1. doc.: IEEE 802.15-<doc#>
<month year>
Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)
Submission Title: Proposal for ISC/L-PD PHY mode Classification
Date Submitted: Mar. 16, 2016
Source: Soo-Young Chang (SYCA) and Jaesang Cha (SNUST)
Company: SYCA and SNUST
Address:
Voice: FAX:
Re: CFP of 15.7r1
Abstract: Some issues to add new PHYs to the existing 15.7 standard
Purpose: to suggest some critical issues to add new PHYs to the existing 15.7 standard
Notice: This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release: The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P
Slide 1
Soo-Young Chang (SYCA) and Jaesang Cha (SNUST)
<author>, <company>

2. Proposal for ISC/L-PD PHY mode Classification
Soo-Young Chang [SYCA]
AND
Jaesang Cha [SNUST]

3. INTRODUCTION
The authors’ understanding from 3/16/2016 PM2 informal discussion among members of ISC/L-PD subgroup
The subgroup ALMOST agreed to have three PHY categories in ISC/low PD area
Names of PHYs will not be stated in the standard while only detailed descriptions of these PHYs will be included which will be prepared later.
This document is prepared to help the group to classify all the proposed schemes into three PHYs – PHY A, PHY B, and PHY C.
Based on three contributions on this issue from Intel, Panasonic and Kookmin University

4. ISC/L-PD PHY MODE DESCRIPTIONS
This description is prepared only to help the 15.7r1 members to understand distinctions among three PHYs.
PHY
Intel’s
Panasonic’s
Kookmin’s
NEW proposal
PHY A
Rolling/Global Shutter Cameras and Low Rate PD
Discrete light source
Discrete Point source(s) transmitter
Discrete (or Single) source
PHY B
Rolling Shutter Cameras
Surface light source
LED panel transmitter
Surface source
PHY C
2 Dimensional Screen Codes
2-dimensional screen
Screen
2-dimensional /screen source

5. NEW PROPOSAL FOR ISC/L-PD PHY MODE CLASSIFICATION
Intel’s
Panasonic’s
Kookmin’s
NEW proposal
PHY A
1. Undersampled Frequency Shift ON-OFF Keying (UFSOOK)
2. Twinkle VPPM
1. UFSOOK (Intel, 16/0006r1)
2.Twinkle VPPM (Intel, 16/0006r1)
3.Spatial M-PSK (Kookmin U., 16/0015r1)
4.Offset VPPM (SNUST, 16/0026r2)
13.1 Under-sampled modulation (flicker-free mode)
1 Intel UFSOOK
2 Kookmin S2-PSK
13.2 (flicker mode) modulation
3 SNUST Offset-PPM
13.3 Twinkle VPPM
4 Intel twinkle (UFSOOK + VPPM)
5 Kookmin (S2-PSK + DSM-PSK)
13.4 Color Space Modulation
1. UFSOOK (Intel)
2.Twinkle VPPM (Intel)
3 Offset-VPWM (SNUST)
4. S2-PSK (Kookmin U)
5. S2+DMS-PSK (Kookmin U.)
6. CSM (SYCA)
PHY B
1. RS-FSK (rolling shutter frequency shift keying)
2. PPM 1
3. PPM 2
4. PPM 3
5. CM-FSK
6. C-OOK
1.CM-FSK/PSK (Kookmin U., 16/0014r1)
2.Compatible On-Off Keying (Kookmin U., 16/0013r2)
3.Surface PWM/PPM (Panasonic, 16/0027r1)
4.RS-FSK (NTU, 16/0018r0)
14.1 FSK
7 Kookmin CM-FSK (low symbol rate mode)
8 NTU RS-FSK (high symbol rate mode)
14.2 PWM/PPM
9 Panasonic PPM mode 1
10 Panasonic PPM mode 2
11 Panasonic PPM mode 3
14.3 OOK
12 Kookmin C-OOK mode 1 (low symbol rate mode)
13 Kookmin C-OOK mode 2 (frame rate drop error detection mode)
1.FSK (Kookmin U.)
2. 2 mode OOK (Kookmin U.)
3. 3 mode PWM/PPM (Panasonic)
PHY C
1. UCT-ISC
2. Invisible data embedded display
3. CSM (color space modulation)
4. SCAM
1.Compatible Color Shift Keying (Kookmin U., 16/0012r1)
2.VCAM (SNUST, 16/0024r3)
3.Invisible data-embedding (SNUST, 16/0025r1)
4.PAPM (China Telecom, 16/0229r1)
5.Kookmin 5 (KookminU., 16/????r0)
15.1 Visible 2D-sequential code
14 SNUST VCAM code
15 Kookmin color code
…….Intel 2D-sequential code
16 PAPM China Telecom
15.2 Invisible 2D-screen code
17 SNUST invisible code
18 Kookmin Invisible code ???
1. 2D-sequential color code (Kookmin U.)
2.VTASC (SNUST)
3.Invisible data-embedding (SNUST)
5 CSM
6.Kookmin Invisible code (KookminU.,)